The Mathemateer blog has the hallmarks of the pupeteer – it presents an entertaining show by modeling well known characters and events from film, media, sport, music, and TV in order to illuminate GCSE questions and education matters. It also rsembles the musketeer and mutineer – it fights conventional wisdom about what an education blog should be.
Mostly for Maths, with a soupcon of Science, with the aim of helping parents to understand the type of question their children are faced with, and perhaps to risk a dinner table conversation around “could you answer this question?” Great expectations indeed – or should that be Great Equations? !
Introduction – method for choosing the best records
When “best single” polls are conducted these days they are packed with very recent records because people forget, or don’t know their pop history and focus on just one genre.
My own “three per year” method overcame these problems by including rock, pop and soul for a full half century of records and applying a weighting method to identify the best three each year.
I chose five criteria for “scoring” the “best three”: – Commercial worldwide sales, mainly BBC charts and U.S.A. Billboard Top 100 – Moving the genre forward, initiating a music style, summing up a musical period – Memorable lyrics – whether simply great poetry or wider impact on society – Critical acclaim, and awards such as Grammys and Brit awards – Readers’ polls, TV and Radio votes like Absolute, and artist’ fans top ten lists
I didn’t do precise Maths but broadly gave equal weighting to each. I limited the number of times an artist could appear.
I believe the Golden Age of Rock ‘n’ Roll – as defined by the rock, pop and soul genres – was from 1950 to 2000, which constitutes my main list.
In the Appendices you can see more on the methodology and the beginnings of the next half century.
I have tried to eliminate bias but if I were to state my personal preference these were the top ten from the 150 that I chose from 1950 – 2000:
Penny Lane/Strawberry Fields 2.Billie Jean 3.Like A Rolling Stone 4.Good Vibrations 5.I Can’t Get No Satisfaction 6.Heartbreak Hotel 7. I Feel Love. 8.Johnny B Goode . 9.London Calling. 10.No Woman No Cry
Here is my full “three per year” list:
2. The list of the best three records each year 1950 – 2000
And here is what I wrote ten years ago, when I began this process for my 60th birthday, now updated for some changes, with my justifications for each choice, and the story behind the records, researched and written by myself without AI !
3. My story of each of the records (click the links for the decades)
The USA Billboard chart of the early fifties was essentially still looking back – but my choices look forward. So, a typical chart then had Bing Crosby, Nat King Cole, Perry Como, Frank Sinatra and the Andrews Sisters. Some fine records and legendary performers but their style of music was about to be overturned. After the war years something optimistic and new was required, and modern pop music essentially began in 1950 with the birth of rock ‘n’ roll.
Although recorded late 1949 Rock The Joint makes our list as it was still around in 1950, and many cover versions, including Bill Haley’s early Rockabilly guitar version, emerged in the early 1950’s and later in Haley’s full on rock ‘n’ roll version. A Rhythm and Blues (R&B)song, there’s also jazz clarinet, but it’s essentially fast dance-worthy brass-based swing with raucous hollering. Rock The Joint followed on from the late 1940’s Good Rockin’ Tonight by Roy Brown (an electric guitar version) and Wynonie Harris’s more traditional horns. Both these songs move blues away from war and pre-war austerity and sadness on to a more optimistic post-war desire for enjoyment
Note that in the first half decade of the 50’s very few of my choices made much impact on the Billboard national pop charts – the Bible of chart success in the USA (which was essentially the one that counted in those days). Rather, they were hugely successful in the Country, or Rhythm and Blues (R&B) charts – before rock n roll changed everything, with Bill Haley and then Elvis to the fore. On the other hand, these early precursors of rock ‘n’ roll were all hugely influential in the revolution to come and their reputation endures to this day. As we will see the Radio Stations were still “segregated” but DJ’s like Alan Freed began to change that.
1950 Hot Rod Race Arkie Shibley
The first Rock ‘n’ Roll record? Not quite, but one of the first to recognise the importance of cars and for its use of guitars or at least the sound of electric guitars. Arkie was a cowboy hat wearing country singer so banjo, acoustic and upright bass are there, but the fast-driving base rhythm certainly sounds like guitar and suits the pace of the lyrics. The song is the story of a mythical hot rod car race through California between side to side Fords and a Mercury, eventually won by surprise 3rd party approaching from the rear. Another musical feature is the occasional short sharp high treble “lick” later made famous by among others Scotty Moore, George Harrison and Steve Cropper of Booker T fame. The “talking blues” vocal style gives it a slightly comical, novelty record feel, and with it mentioning carburettor Johnny Cash must surely have had this in mind with his One Piece at a Time record. The hot rod theme was hugely influential. The response song Hot Rod Lincoln was a hit for many artists. Chuck Berry and The Beach Boys developed the racing idea, Springsteen sang of the Pink Cadillac, The Clash of the Brand New Cadillac. Perhaps Eddie and Hot Rods paid homage. An while so many of the early rock ‘n’ roll records are rooted in R&B, this is one of the first showing the incorporation of country and western swing in to the rock’n’roll mix which eventually defined the genre and took it mainstream
Rollin and Tumblin Muddy Waters and the Baby Face Trio
An extraordinary record literally 15 years ahead of its time. Blues, electric guitar with an insistent beat, blues guitar riff and mouth organ, with lyrics descending into Banshee wail, and the B side dispensing with lyrics and becoming a persistent wail It was the precursor to the “rock” in rock n roll, arguably the beginning of heavy metal. Cream covered it in 1966, while Muddy himself updated in the late 1960s and with drums. Muddy Waters (born McKinley Morganfield in the Mississippi Delta ) went on to become a colossus of the electric blues scene in Chicago and of the genre as a whole, much admired by famous rock band musicians such as Eric Clapton and the Rolling Stones whose name comes from one of Muddy’s songs. Not just his records such as Hoochie Coochie Man, but also his live performances at clubs and festivals became legendary.
Led Zeppelin indirectly took the style to a new level with Immigrant Song and My Time of Dying, while Canned Heat covered Rollin and Tumblin and incorporated aspects of the rhythm into their hits Going Up The Country and On the Road Again. If rock ‘n’ roll is a meld of country acoustic guitar, rockabilly, brass based R&B and electric guitar-based blues this record is certainly the latter in this case.
Other Blues guitarists/singers have made a wider impact such as BB King with U2 on When Love Comes to Town, and also John Lee Hooker with Boom Boom. Perhaps not the greatest electric blues track or artist – surely that would be Muddy Waters, but the Boom Boom track from 1962 was perfectly placed in timing and style to play a crucial role in the development of rock then and with later success.
The origin of the Boom Boom lyrics are simple- John used to play at a restaurant and was often not on time. A waitress finally said “Boom boom you’re late again!* and the song was born. The song has the feel of a modern record, a faster blues sound, with a memorable riff, which seemed to perfectly fit the requirements of the burgeoning British Blues boom (excuse the pun!), No surprise that a for a young Eric Clapton, it was the first song he ever recorded, with the Yardbirds to be.
A gross simplification it may be but one can chart a path from the folk blues of Robert Johnson pre War to the electrified blues of Muddy Water, BB King and John Lee Hooker through to rock and then heavy rock. It seems me this record was at the very cusp of that transition and one of the few genuine original Blues records to fully cross over to the conventional popular charts.
Boom Boom has been covered by many artists, including the Animals, whose version was used in the Skyfall film; it featured in a Jeans advert; and I first picked up John Lee Hooker as the street musician playing live in a Chicago market in the Blues Brothers film – which helped re-launch interest in so many Soul and Blues artists. My original favourite music writer Charles Shaar Murray from the New Musical Express called it the “greatest pop song John Lee Hooker” ever made. It has won numerous awards.
Boom Boom has become the name of clubs as far and wide as San Francisco (John Lee Hookers’ Boom Boom room) and Sutton in South West London where my friend Graham recently took a group of us to the Boom Boom club, home of many a great medium-size rock concert.
But the major lasting Electric Blues Rock influence is surely Muddy not least for his later singles like Hoochie Coochie Man and iconic live appearances at the Rockpalast concert and Checkerboard Lounge with the Rolling Stones.
1951 Rocket 88 Jackie Brenston and the Delta cats
Is it a rocket? Is it a firework? No it’s a car! The Oldsmobile 88 was a beloved auto of its time, just right for cruising and dates.
With Ike Turner producing and playing (before his eventual downfall) this brought together R&B, Swing and Jump Blues into a wild boogie – woogie frenetic pace with driven base rhythm and horns including a killer saxophone solo. The lyrics about a “ride in style…all around town…convertible top ..don’t be late..pulling out at half past eight” tell the story of a great night out for the girls and boys. and sung in a joyously feel-good way, optimistic way, moving on from the inherent wartime austerity and sadness of the blues. And surrounding the recording is the legendary story of the damaged amplifier (dropped on the famous Highway 61 ) being fixed with paper cone, producing the distorted guitar sound which Sam Phillips later said he left in as it was ”more interesting”. Phillips took some royalties which paid for the opening of his Sun studios, to be used later by Elvis et alia. The distorted guitar sound became beloved of the Beatles, on for instance Revolution, and indirectly used in Tubular Bells (“Two slightly distorted guitars”).
Of all the records described as the first great rock ‘n’ roll record this has perhaps the highest claim with so many ingredients in place ; for both its music (fast and rhythmic) and lyrics (cars and girls – think Prefab Sprout ) its success (No. 1 on the R&B charts), and its transition from R&B to white radio stations. Released on the famous Chess record label it has an enduring reputation and influence and to this day is still collecting Hall of Fame awards. I dare you to listen to Rocket 88 and not feel good!
1951 Howlin Wolf How Many More Years
Following on from Rollin and Tunblin, another one from the electric blues end of the rock ‘n’ roll end of the spectrum – the beginning of the Riff and bringing base and drums up. A precursor to heavy rock – think Led Zeppelin’s How Many more Times. Born Chester Burnett, The Wolf’s voice was and remains unique – deep throaty howling. The song ticks so many boxes – released on Chess and recorded at Memphis Sam Phillips Sun Studios. – it was a big hit on the R&B charts . The Rolling Stones were big fans and years later recorded their version of the Wolf’s Little Red Rooster – their first big hit.
1951 Les Paul and Mary FordHow High the Moon
While many of the early 1950’s records (such as those above) which had a lasting influence on popular music going forward were hits mainly on the specialist country or R&B charts, two that were huge national No.1’s on Billboard were Johnnie Ray’s Cry (see below) and Les Paul and Mary Ford’s How High the Moon.
How High the Moon has hidden depth. On first listen it sounds a bit frothy, but listen again and you will understand the complex cleverness yet beautiful simplicity of the record. Some of the first multi tracked track, layered harmonies, later made famous by Phil Spector’s Wall of Sound, the Beatles (such as Because from Abbey Road), the Beachboys and Ten CC amongst others; and an intricate virtuoso guitar solo. Not surprising, since Les Paul was not just a great guitarist but also a studio technician and record producer – and his wife Mary was already an established Wester Swing Singer and Radio personality.
Les Paul additionally was one of the first designers and players of the solid body guitar along with Fender, Telecaster and Stratocaster. His Gibson Les Paul design has been played by all the great guitarists from Keith Richards to Peter Green , to Mark Knopfler on Money for Nothing; and George Harrison on the classic rotating guitar solo at the “End” of the Beatles Abbey Road, using the Guitar nicknamed Lucy, which Eric Clapton had earlier used on the Beales Guitar Gently Weeps and donated to Harrison.
The song How High the Moon was a huge national No 1 Hit and in fact in 1951 Les Paul and Mary Ford were the biggest selling artists in the USA. The track is certainly at the “pop” end of the spectrum – a kind of equivalent is the Carpenters and Abba – perfectly crafted pop with delightful female vocals. Though not rock ’n’ roll as such it certainly influenced the genre and in fact two events linked Les Paul to rock ‘n’ roll – he had a near fatal crash on Route 66, which meant he had to have his shattered arm set at 90 degrees to enable continued playing, and he was later electrocuted by his own gear in his studio, where as well as multi-tracking, Paul would develop innovative techniques like phasing and flanging which the Beatles and their engineers would use extensively.
1952Lloyd PriceLawdy Miss Clawdy . The record started life as an advert (for Maxwell House coffee) , was worked up by Fats Dominos the producer to a full record and with piano trills from the Fat Man himself. The backbeat is believed to have been invented on this record, and the backing singers echo to complement Lloyd’s exciting singing (he was nicknamed the “exciting Llyod Price”. Covered many times including by the King, Elvis Presley
1952 Ruth Brown Mama He Treats Your Daughter Mean. The Lady Sings the Blues – and more. Not the first protest song against misogyny and worse, but Ruth brings a bluesey soul voice a la Tina Turner, Janis Joplin, Elkie Brooks, Amy Whitehouse, Adele and PP Arnold’s First Cut is the Deepest. The lyrics started out as gospel music and a blues song by Blind Lemon Jefferson. Ruth was managed by Blanche Calloway (sister of Cab Calloway – think Blues Brothers Hi-di Hi-de Ho) but she crashed her car on her way to the recording session, A year later after hospital treatment Atlantic recorded the song but only after Ruth asked for a speed up and with her tambourine made the song. This was one of the first hit records (see below) on Atlantic which crossed over to the national charts the Queen of R&B was so successful that Atlantic was known as the House that Ruth built Throughout the 1950 s Ruth had hit records and even after that she received awards for Stage Show performances and was well known for pushing artistic rights especially for African Americans.
1952 Cry Johnnie Ray The early 1950s was a transition period – post war swing era, crooners’ ballads, not yet rock’n’roll. While the established singers such as Nat King Cole, Frank Sinatra, Perry Como, Bing Crosby were all great artists, their songs were somehow of the past whereas one similar sounding singer was of the future – Johnnie Ray. His heartfelt singing style – even though conventionally slow – and histrionic public performances emphasised soul and emotion with hints of jazz and blues, and radio listeners believed he was an R&B artist. Indeed he grew up visiting the African-American clubs. The song Cry and its live performance has echoes of the Righteous Brothers Unchained Melody, Sinead O’Connor’s Nothing Compares, and Duffy’s Warwick Avenue. Ray demonstrates male vulnerability and sadness. He influenced Elvis Presley and Bob Dylan; and also John Lennon greatly admired him and some of his slower solo songs reflect Ray’s style. Ray was a regular on the Ed Sullivan Show and the London Palladium. The song was a huge hit in America, topping the Billboard pop charts for 11 weeks and crossed over to the R&B charts.. His name appears in the lyrics for many songs, not least in Dexy’s Come on Eileen; “poor old Johnnie Ray sounded sad upon the radio, moved a million hearts in mono”. And in fact the song was one of the last 78 rpm singles.
1953 Hound Dog Big Mama (Willie Mae) Thornton Yes that one, that Elvis made famous and a great example of a white singer reinterpreting a R&B standard. The song was written specifically for Thornton by Lieber and Stoller (who went on to write extensively and produce records like Leader of the Pack and Stuck in the Middle with You) The lyrics came quickly, but the production was difficult and they had to persuade Thornton to up the tempo from a slow ballad blues to a storming, booming rock n roll classic, featuring guitars, base and drums at the expense of horns. It was a huge R&B hit and later became one of Elvis ‘s biggest ever hits.
1953 Shake Rattle and Roll Big Joe Turner Shake Rattle and Roll was a hit for Turner but like many such records was later a bigger hit for a white rock ‘n’ roll group, namely Bill Haley and the Comets. Big Joe Turner paid his dues as a performer from the 1920 s (and continued to the 1980s) so when Shake Rattle and Roll came along he was already 40 years old and already had played with the Jazz and Swing greats – Benny Goodman, Duke Ellington, Bill Holliday, Count Basie Dizzy Gillespie and had played Carnegie Hall.
Turner was initially a Blues shouter from Kansas. Budding music impresario Ahmet Ertugen (*) spotted him and signed him up for his new label Atlantic Records.
(*) Ahmet Ertugen , son of the Turkish Ambassador to USA , stayed in USA after his father returned home. Ahmet then qualified in Business Studies, but meanwhile collected thousands of records and co-founded the Atlantic label. He went on to introduce many associated labels most importantly Stax, which spawned Aretha Franklin, and then introduced Rock Acts like Yes and Cream and Led Zeppelin to Atlantic – so important did Robert Plant and Jimmy Page believe that Ertugen was to their success that the only reunion for Led Zeppelin was for Ertugen’s death in 2006.
1953 The Drifters Money Honey. Clyde McPhatter leads on this, his silky voice making its debut with the group, another early Atlantic classic. It’s a soul record but with unmistakable rock ,’n’ roll riffs, a bagpipe-like drone, some doo-wop backing, screams, saxophone solos so it crosses many genres. Eventually a multi-million seller for the Drifters , not surprisingly the covers have crossed the spectrum from Elvis to Eddie Cochran, the Jackson 5 to the Sensational Alex Harvey Band. The Drifters of course went on to major success in the later 1950’s and 1960’s with a variety of lead singers such as Ben E. King, and sometimes with re-releases in the 1970’s with hits such as Saturday Night at the Movies and Save The Last Dance For Me; but it all started here with Money Honey.
1954 That’s Alright Mama Elvis Presley
In a sense unremarkable in terms of immediate sales, this record nervertheless had enormous impact – the end of the old world, the beginning of the new, in musical and wider context.
19 year old Elvis had begun to try out recording with Sam Phillips at Sun Studios in Memphis. They could not quite find the right song but in a break in recording Elvis began jamming with his Band the Blue Moons (Scotty Moore on guitar and Bill Black on upright base, who along with Fontana on drums were to stay with Elvis through much of his career). They worked up a version of R&B singer Arthur Crudup’s That’s Alright Mama. Sam Phillips asked them to properly record it and while it’s not quite “the rest is history”, everything at least began to change after that. The records was a local hit in Tennessee – remarkably on both the back and also white radio stations. It wasn’t obvious whether Elvis was a black or white artist. But just a few weeks later on July 30th 1954 Elvis performed the song at the Overton Shell Park in Memphis Tennessee and began to try out his then revolutionary “moves “ – the wigglin’ and jiggling as it was called – and then again in October at the Louisiana Hayride tour.
The record had began life as an R&B song in the late 1940’s and in fact Crudup’s version has a shout at being the first rock n roll record, partly because of its guitar sound which Elvis and Scotty essentially are true to, but Elvis with a delightful tenor vocal transformed the sound and appeal; and the Band’s sound mixed in elements of bluegrass and country and rockabilly (including the B side Blue Moon of Kentucky) along with Elvis’ own acoustic rhythm guitar – already an accomplished player incidentally . It was the beginning of the melding of so many styles into what was to convert the largely American swing and jive style of the barely known idea of rock ’n’ roll in to the worldwide phenomenon it became. The Elvis version sounded fairly similar to Crudup’s but its impact of course took the song to another level
It was another two years before Elvis truly arrive worldwide but he had begun that process by covering an R&B record, much as the Beatles and Stones did before writing their own innovative material. The two-year transition from That’s Alright to Heartbreak Hotel was every bit as revolutionary as from Little Red Roster to Satisfaction, from Twist and Shout to I Feel Fine
1954 I Gotta Woman Ray Charles
Beginning of the transition to soul music from early R&B and the consequential acceptance into the national charts. A story of poor boy’s relationship with a well off lady, with Jerry Wexler’s production for the Atlantic label originating in Gospel music and mixed with hand claps and frenetic rhythm. The song has been covered many times not least by the Beatles and Johnnie Halliday.
1954 Rock Around The Clock Bill Haley and the Comets
A number 1 all over the world and remained the best selling single ever for many years after. Haley had started out in Western Swing as a cowboy yodeller and graduated through rockabilly to very early rock ‘n’ roll, with cover versions of some of our earlier records such as Shake Rattle Roll and Rocket 88. Also, an original song of his own Crazy Man Crazy in 1953 became the first purely rock n roll record to make the upper reaches of the Billboard national charts and the first to appear on TV and in film. . The real breakthrough came from Rock Around the Clock, recorded in 1954 as a B side then re-released as an A side when it featured in the movie the Blackboard Jungle a year later. The movie featured Glenn Ford and a debut for Sydney Poitier, and focused on teenage violence and juvenile delinquency surrounding a school, and its English teacher in particular. In English cinemas especially, the audience often followed suit, with teenagers, to become Teddy Boys, dancing in the aisles and ripping up seats in an Elephant and Castle showing. The song opened the film and featured several times in the movie.
It was a No.1 in both the UK and USA Billboard charts – the first rock ‘n’ roll record to achieve that and the record which moved rock n roll from a regional American significance to a worldwide genre. The song had longevity – returning to the charts many times in subsequent years but sadly Haley’s star waned somewhat as he had not the charisma of Elvis or Jerry Lee.
The significance of the song cannot be overstated. The song has sold 25 million copies – the majority by Haley – and equalled only by Bing Crosby’s White Christmas and it opened the way for many other artists.
1955 Ain’t That a Shame Fats Domino
Fats’ piano trills of course – but also a production and melody which made it suitable straight away for the cross-over from R&B (No.1 ) to national charts (no.10) . Pat Boone didn’t even wait to produce his own version – he ran it in parallel with Fats and reached no.1. Years later Cheap Trick included their own great version on the Live at Budakan “greatest live album of all time”
Alan Freed the disc jockey predominantly played white music but began to introduce black R&B music like this including the original R&B versions of covered versions on his Moondog Rock n roll show. If the fans were segregated at concerts this emergent radio station broke down those barriers. Note that John Lennon’s first group was called Johnny and the Moondogs.
1955 Maybelline Chuck Berry
Chuck Berry had been trying to hit the right style for a hit record for some time. Then his record company Chess suggested working up the rhythm of Ida Red, a country, fiddle based western swing song, via Maybelline the cosmetic, into a vehicle for Chuck to sing about cars (specifically Cadillacs), girls and dating along with his virtuoso guitar playing. This brought to the fore the new rock ‘n’ roll style including the first of many of Berry’s classic guitar solos; perhaps not the first rock ’n’ roll record but one the first to cross over in a big way from R&B to the national pop charts, and to really promote the transition from brass based R&B to guitar dominated rock.
The disc jockey Alan Freed had pioneered the inclusion of black artists in his Moondog show and concerts, and so helped make this a hit. So much so that he claimed a writing credit – much to Berry’s surprise which led to the first of Berry’s many legal disputes. And also contributed to the Payola scandal of DJ’s receiving backhanders for playing records. Nevertheless this was a barnstorming first hit for Check Berry, paving the way for some of the greatest of all rock’n’roll records, like Johnny B Goode, which the British invasion groups covered extensively in the early 1960s’
1955 Bo Didley / I’m a Man by Bo Didley
Not many artists can claim to have a hit record named after themselves. Bo Didley developed this rock ’n’ roll rhythm all by himself, a unique combination of African-Cuban rhythms and chopped staccato chord riffs played with distortion on his famous rectangular box electric guitar. It endured with the Stones’ version of Not Fade Away, which by bringing in the Bo Didley beat transformed a Buddy Holly B-side; and Eric Clapton’s Willy and the Hand Jive. The other double A side track I’m a Man is more traditional Blues and has been covered by Dr Feelgood on their Stupidity album – a candidate for best live album ever.
1956 Heartbreak Hotel Elvis Presley
“I put it to you m’Lord, that this was the record and year that truly launched rock’n’roll music rather than 1950”.
Let us look at the evidence for and against starting with the latter. Didn’t rock’n’roll start earlier, in 1950?
Early claims for the title of the first great rock’n’roll record include Jackie Brenston’s Rocket 88, from 1951 ; and Big Joe Turner’s “Shake Rattle and Roll” and of course Bill Haley and the Comets’ “Rock around the Clock”. Both released in 1954, but from the different wings of rock’n’roll. The former was a Bluesman, brought up on boogie-woogie, swing and the blues; the latter a country and western and yodel singer who gradually developed and rockabilly style and incorporating rhythm and blues. Rock Around the Clock was a huge hit especially when attached to the Sydney Poitier/Glenn Ford multi-racial school film “Blackboard Jungle”, which ran from 1955-1956 and promoted Teddy Boy riots inside the cinemas when shown in the UK. But I always felt growing up that Bill Haley was somehow from a bygone era, an older man in a bow tie playing a young man’s music. Elvis seemed to me a teenager playing teenage music. But even when Elvis’s Heartbreak Hotel came in 1956 was it fast enough to be rock’n’roll?
Now the case for the defence. Elvis Aaron Presley as a young man had followed country singers like and Hank Snow and was determined to be singer and musician of some sort. He also frequented the famous Beale Street in Memphis and begun to hear the Blues and R&B sounds. His break came when he wandered into Sam Phillips Sun studio on that fateful day in August 1953 and began a brief recording career on Sun label, producing some now iconic records like “That’s Alright Mama” originally an Arthur Crudup Blues number from way back in the 1940’s. This time Elvis was able to use Bill Black’s upright slap base as backing and Scotty Moore on lead guitar (to be become the Jordinaires) and crucially began to move and jump around in the studio. Over the next 2 years Elvis gradually built up a radio audience, developed his stage persona, and evolved his rockabilly sound which made listeners unsure of whether it was a black or white man they were hearing.
Still no international or even national breakthrough though. But Colon Tom Parker took over management of the increasingly popular Elvis, who switched to RCA records, and at age 20 in January 1956 recorded Heartbreak Hotel in his first session for the label in Nashville. Soon after his debut album was released, with the iconic cover later taken up by London Calling by the Clash. The cover is hugely significant – the wild look, and the emphasis on guitar, in contrast to the other great Rock ’n’ Roll record of late 1955/early 1956 Tutti Fruitti by Little Richard which was more piano and saxophone based.
Both Heartbreak Hotel and the album reached No.1 mid 1956. National TV appearances began to follow through 1956 including the all-important Ed Sullivan Show (when an astonishing 80% of the TV audience watched). A first film appearance in Love Me tender. Another huge number 1 with Hound Dog. Rounding off with the now famous “Million Dollar Quartet” jam session with Johnny Cash, Carl Perkins, and Jerry Lee Lewis. All in 1956 – an astonishing year. By the end, Wall Street Journal announced that Elvis had taken £22 million in merchandise sales on top of his records, which themselves had broken all records on the Billboard chart. Both the album and single were worldwide huge sellers. Presley “brought rock’n’roll into the mainstream of popular culture”, wrote historian Marty Jezer. Rock critic Dave Marsh wrote of the Sun and first RCA sessions that “these records, more than any others, contain the seeds of what rock & roll was, has been and most likely what it may foreseeably become.
The gyrations which TV producers tried to censor were of course exactly what the females in the audience were hoping to see and Elvis’s charisma was causing crazed crowd reactions like no other before. My comparison of Bill Haley to Elvis Presley is this. Great though “Rock Around the Clock” was there were two big differences to Elvis’s 1956 releases. First, Bill Haley to a certain extent soon faded whereas Elvis launched as a megastar. Second, Bill couldn’t be described as charismatic in the same way as Elvis’s sheer movement on stage made him irresistible. It is possible that if Elvis hadn’t emerged, Rock ’n’ Roll may have simply been a novelty lasting a few years without evolving into rock as a whole.
So if 1956 was the year that Rock’n’Roll truly emerged as a musical and cultural phenomenon which would last, was Heartbreak Hotel as opposed to Hound Dog the record which launched Rock’n’Roll?
Well one point is that as a young child growing up I always assumed that Heartbreak Hotel was the first great Rock ’n’ Roll record. Second listen to this rock royalty list of credits.
John Lennon: When I first heard “Heartbreak Hotel”, I could hardly make out what was being said. It was just the experience of hearing it and having my hair stand on end. We’d never heard American voices singing like that
George Harrison: described “Heartbreak Hotel” as a “rock n roll epiphany” in 1956
Keith Richard: described “Heartbreak Hotel” as having a huge effect “Then, “Since my baby left me”—it was just the sound” Keith, astute as ever, focused on the “silence”, the “gaps”.
Pau McCartney. “It’s the way [Presley] sings it as if he is singing from the depths of hell. His phrasing, use of echo, it’s all so beautiful. Musically, it’s perfect”.
Robert Plant of Led Zeppelin “It was so animal, so sexual, the first musical arousal I ever had. You could see a twitch in everybody my age. All we knew about the guy was that he was cool, handsome and looked wild.”
Heartbreak Hotel is a moody, relatively slow blues number, with hints of rock’n’roll per se in the instrumental break, about a broken man’s suicide. An unusual choice for a first RCA single, but Elvis himself insisted against the advice of the executives that it should be released. The opening lines of “Well Since My Baby Left Me” are now amongst the most famous in popular music – not so much for the words (Blues singers may have sung similar before) but for the way Elvis sang them, That voice! As he develops the song, echo is applied and his unique singing style and phrasing unfolds. He creates the atmosphere – “I feel so lonely I could die”. Then Scotty Moore’s short but electrifying guitar break seems to predict the importance of guitar in rock. (And watch how Elvis moves during this break). The record was years ahead of its time, seeming to reveal the full potential and variation of what rock’n’roll could become. Everything changed with Heartbreak Hotel.
A critic described the song as “catapulting Presley’s regional popularity into national hysteria”. After performances on TV, the song soon made No.1 and was the highest selling single in 1956 in the USA.
So summing up; difficult to get a majority verdict but I contend that the musical roots began in 1950 or even earlier, 1956 truly was the year that rock’n’roll and hence rock music as a genre became a global phenomenon rather than a passing fad, and it all centred around Elvis Aaron Presley. In particular the release in January 1956 of Heartbreak Hotel to an incredulous world. And a few months later yours truly was born in Carlisle. And 60 years later, who was top of the album charts in the UK in 2015/2016? Elvis Presley of course!
1956 Hound Dog Elvis Presley
Following soon after Heartbreak Hotel, Hound Dog was in many ways just as important as his debut. This time Elvis transformed a blues standard with a chequered history. An early Lieber and Stoller composition, it was first recorded by Willie Mae “Big Mama” Thornton in 1952 and was an R&B hit. As frequently happened in those days, several cover and “answer” versions were released which changed or responded to the lyrics, including one by Rufus “Bear Cat” Thomas for Sam Phillips Sun label. Another such was Las Vegas Lounge act Freddie Bell and the Bellboys, who added the “never caught a rabbit” refrain and who in their live act effectively parodied the original.
While visiting Vegas, Elvis saw this version and decided to develop his own approach. Before release, he performed the song on TV shows such as the Steve Allen Show and then on June 5 1956, the day after I was born in Carlisle, England, Elvis performed this seminal version, on the Milton Berle show, without guitar this time. “Let ‘em see you son”, said Milton, wisely. For one of the first times on TV, he gyrated with the “Elvis the Pelvis” technique. He slowed the song down to spoken word tempo. Conservative critics hated it, “unfit for family viewing” – and that was from Ed Sullivan even as he booked him on his show! All this only added to his popularity of course. Another early video reveals more truly the full version that would ultimately be recorded at RCA’s New York City studios, revealing Scotty Moore’s wonderful guitar solo, D.J. Fontana’s lightning fast drum break, the Jordanaires smooth background harmony vocals. Dominated of course by Elvis himself, who on the recording was not credited with production duties, but in fact insisted on 31 takes. He very much was in control, even at age 23.
This time the tempo was faster than Heartbreak Hotel, almost manic: Elvis had invented his own brand of rock’n’roll, which would never be the same again. The song along with double A-side Don’t Be Cruel, was No.1 for 11 weeks in the U.S.A. a longevity not repeated for over 30 years.
1956 Tutti Fruiti Little Richard
“A-wop-bom-a-loo-mop-a-lomp-bom-bom!” started life as a verbal expression of a drum pattern but Little Richard turned it into one of the most memorable phrases in rock ’n’ roll, especially as the accapella introduction to a record which changed the course of music history.
I was always intrigued by this singer because in the late 50’s early 60’s I literally was Little Richard. No I didn’t dress up as this icon, I was actually little and called Richard. I loved his music from the start – Long Tall Sally a favourite – but Tutti Fruiti as emerged over the years as his key release.
Little Richard has been singing for a few years on the RCA label when he sent a demo to Speciality Records of a song he had been singing casually on tour for a while. The lyrics had to be toned down for release- Tutti Fruiti – Aw Rooty was most definitely not the original chorus ! – but his new record company could see potential especially when he played around with his new piano style. He evolved boogie-woogie and shuffle into a new rock beat, and his playing style was new for a popular singer – one hand the rhythm, the other the trills, played in a flamboyant style, The charismatic singing style was loud and expressive, With this song he invented modern rock music – or at least the blues, soul and gospel wing of it also developed by such as Chuck Berry, James Brown and Ray Charles. Elvis with Bill Haley, Carl Perkins and Jerry Lee Lewis invented the country and rockabilly wing of course. As we will see later though, rock groups like the Beatles took up aspects of Little Richard’s style and merged them into European and conventional rock music for a white audience. Alison reminds me that music, movement and dance are inextricably linked. Little Richard instinctively understood this with both the way he moved at the Piano and the way his records brought everyone onto the dancefloor.
Little Richard was a bundle of contradictions, A very religious man, a devoted Christian, and yet also drug taker and an original wild man of rock’n’roll. Just check out his hairstyle and stance at the piano (for instance in the film, the Girl Can’t Help It) He was visionary in that he brought the races together. Though married, he appeared to be sexually ambiguous, long before Glam Rock. He was the first to use spotlights and flicker lights, he wore glittered shiny suits. The list goes on.
The list of people who have covered the song is a Who’s Who of rock’n’roll. Queen, Elvis, Pat Boone, Eric Clapton, Sting, and a Million Dollar trio of Mark Bolan, Elton John and Ringo Star. Let us develop the Beatles link further. The Beatles opened (yes opened) for Little Richard on a UK tour and also in their iconic Hamburg days, during which time they played the song many times but never recorded it. Little Richard is thought to have taught Paul on tour the high pitched “woo’s” made famous on “She.Loves You” and the style revisited on the closing “Judy-Judy” screams on” Hey Jude”. He played on the same bill as John Lennon at one of the Beatle’s last performances in Toronto (the rock’n’roll revival concert, and stole the show). George Harrison, The late lamented Bon Scott of ACDC, and more recently Bruno Mars are among many to acknowledge him.
The record was recorded late 1955 but did not peak in the U.S.A. until early 1956 and so joins with Elvis’s Heartbreak Hotel in claiming the honour of inventing and first popularising the genre called Rock’’n’Roll in 1956. The birth of rock’n’roll and of yours truly Little Richard indeed! The record has been voted #1 by Mojo magazine in their list of records which shaped modern music.
1957 Walk the Line Johnny Cash
John wrote this while on tour, being away from his new wife Vivian. It is a proclamation to stay faithful. As with many Johnny Cash records it is simplicity itself, with the “freight train” rhythm of “boom-chika-boom”. Released in 1956 and charting into 1957, it eventually sold 2 million copies in America and helped launch his 50 year career.
The record label is hugely significant – the Sun label run by Sam Phillips – the same of course as the early Elvis records. The release date of 1956 marks that cusp of passing the baton from country and blues to rock’n’roll and Johnny was right at that interface. The famous backward chord sequence started life on Johnny’s tape recorder in his Airforce days stationed in Germany. The final recording took place in the famous Sun Studios at Memphis, where Johnny also took part in the famous “Million Dollar Quartet” impromptu jam with Elvis, Carl Perkins and Jerry Lee Lewis, as if to confirm his rock’n’roll credentials.
Johnny did mot “walk the line” forever. By 1963 he was with country singer June Cash and together they wrote and recorded the memorable “Ring of Fire” which still today you can hear as a ringtone on your mobile. (Vivian later downplayed June’s role in writing the song)
Like many Brits. I first got to know Johnny’s music through “Boy Named Sue” from the memorable 1969 San Quentin prison concert and followed his career through the subsequent “Walk the Line” Joaquin Phoenix film, through to his comeback with “American Recordings” and eventual epitaph with “Hurt”. That famous deep – yet sad, quivering – voice remains unmistakable. The “Man in Black” was truly a legend and a measure of his contribution in so many genres is his presence in so many Halls of Fame: Nashville, Country, Rock ’n’ Roll, Rockabilly and Memphis.
Jailhouse Rock Elvis Presley 1957
I had thought that Jailhouse Rock was Elvis’s first film, but in fact he had already made two. Many people say that this electrifying dance sequence, in front of the scaffolding screen and fireman’s pole, wearing his iconic hooped jailbird outfit, was his finest moment on screen. Hard to disagree. I watched this again recently and you cannot take your eyes off Elvis, though surrounded by other inmates. Elvis suggested the dance style himself, and the choreographer readily concurred.
An early Lieber and Stoller production, the song featured that memorable two note intro, a particularly throaty Elvis voice (think John Lennon on Twist and Shout) and a delightful Scotty Moore solo, and generally is a dynamic rock’n’roll classic.
The lyrics are terrific and fascinating. From the list of wonderful criminal names (Shifty Henry, a real one, and Sad Sack, World War 2 name for a loser) to probably the first hint of a gay relationship (“Number 47 tells Number 3, you’re the cutest jailbird I ever did see” – like Morecambe and Wise’s two men in a bed scene, it is only later that you realise the significance). The “band was jumping and the joint began to swing” is perfectly played out in the film.
The song was one of the first of the string of connections between Rock and Jail. Johnny Cash’s San Quentin and Folsom prison performances, 10CC’s Rubber Bullets (“went to a party at the local county jail”), The Blues Brothers closing rendition of Jailhouse Rock, right through to One Direction’s recreation of some of the scenes for a video. Talking of which, Elvis’s film sequence is often described as the starting point for MTV style videos. True, right down to the poor lip synching! Oh, and John Lennon’s early group the Quarrymen included it in their set. That will do for me!
Arguably this was the creative peak of Elvis’s first great period, after that the films and records were never quite as good – until his re-emergence in the 1960’s with the Comeback concert and “in the Ghetto” and “Suspicious Minds” and then “You Were Always on My Mind”
Jailhouse Rock is truly a memorable visual delight and a musical assault on the senses, as any good rock’n’roll record should be.
1957 Buddy Holly and the Crickets That’’ll Be the Day
I first came across Buddy Holly as a child listening to the more recently released Rave On and Oh Boy and then caught up with “That’ll Be the Day” when the David Essex film That’ll Be The Day was a big hit. It seems it was also one of Alison’s favourites too! (The title of the song originated in a John Wayne line in a film)
After opening for Elvis and Bill Haley. Holly determined to have a musical career of his own and with the band the Crickets began recording with Decca on the Brunswick label. That’ll Be The day was a number 1, not just in America helped by the Ed Sullivan show , but all round the world including the UK. Hits like Peggy Sue followed, Holly’s guitar style using his Stradocaster was high stringed yet with a chunky rhythm – he was a fine innovative guitarist. He was clean cut, with famously old fashioned spectacles eventually replaced by horn-rims, His vocal style included staccato hiccups. Peggy Sue was dedicated to the girlfriend of drummer Jerry Allison. The inclusion of another great Holly single (Everyday) on the B-side of Peggy Sue makes this a double helping of Holly’s genius – the faster A side with the slower more sensitive B side.
Like (it seems) so many pop stars of the time, he died tragically – in a plane crash in the Winter Dance Party tour of 1959 on take-off from Clear Lake, Iowa. Fellow singers Richie Valens and the Big Bopper also perished. For years his famous glasses were lost till recovered years later in a police effects box.
Innovative, he used reverb and overdub and unusually wrote his own material. He was credited with developing the “2 guitars, bass and drums” format of rock groups, yet also combined orchestration with rock’n’roll and was at home with ballads like True Love Ways
Although his career was so short he laid down 50 quality tracks and his legacy is huge. Unlike Elvis, he toured outside America and John Lennon and Paul McCartney saw Holly at the London Palladium and Holly influenced their recording and performing style in the Beatles – in fact helped find a name for the group (crickets and beetles – both insects).
In fact the The Quarrymen – the predecessor of the Beatles – chose That’ll Be The Day as the recording for their first ever recorded demo in 1958, by which time the line-up had simplified to Lennon, McCartney and Harrison. Likewise Mick Jagger saw him live in Woolwich and the Rolling Stones later recorded Not Fade Away. And long after his death of course Don Mclean referred to that fateful day as the “day the music died” in American Pie.
Johnny B. Goode Chuck Berry 1958
The only rock’n’roll record to be included in the Voyager space capsule. Currently orbiting the heliosphere, and often voted as one of greatest records of any type in history. Chuck Berry (real name Anderson, excellent name) worked initially with Muddy Waters before launching his career on the famous Chess Record label, expanding blues into rock territory. The guitar solo is of course recognised as compulsory for any aspiring guitarist (my son Matthew plays it beautifully). Boogie –woogie style piano ( think Jools Holland) became a trade mark. The lyrics are partly autobiographical, with the story of a poor country boy trying to make good (Berry had been in jail, and was to spend two more spells there in future). And he lived on Goode Street at one point. Like many of the great radio songs, it paints an inspiring picture in your imagination: boy from Louisiana, sitting in the shade by the train track, strumming, he is noticed by passengers and encouraged by his mother to join a band.
The record took on a new lease of life in Back to the Future 1 and 2, in which Marty McFly plays rock’n’roll for the first time, and one of the band lets his cousin Chuck hear the sound over the phone. A great move scene continues with Marty trashing his guitar, anticipating Hendrix and the Who, but a step too far in 1955. Johnny B Goode continued to have a life beyond this single, featuring in many more for instance Bye Bye Johnny.
1958 Little Richard Good Golly Miss Molly
After the initial success of Tutti Fruitti in 1956, Little Richard’s 1958 Golly Miss Molly brought to an end an astonishing series of rock’n’roll classics including Long Tall Sally, Lucille, Ready Ready, The Girl and Can’t Help It.
Long Tall Sally, Girl Can’t Help It and Good Golly Miss Molly especially all share the hallmarks of Little Richard: I always was so excited by the vocal, so completely wild and seemingly out of control, screamed in that high register;12 bar blues made into the shuffle rhythm with the stop-restarts; the breakneck speed; the trill piano; the high note “woo” and the scream before the instrumental break which the Beatles would so memorably take up in Twist and Shout; the wonderful saxophone solo. The suggestive lyrics, double or triple entendres (how did they get away with them!) And the look, the pencil moustache, the stand up piano style, the exotic persona. Watch this video: what strikes me is the great combination of white all American teenagers clapping away to the black Little Richard and band – quite rare in those days – and the emphasis of saxophone and piano over guitar. With Little Richard “ducking back in the alley” and resting his leg a top the piano. Sensational stage performance.
The lyrics to Good Golly Miss Molly started life as a throwaway phrase by a Sothern DJ and Little Richard with producer Robert Bumps Blackwell developed the lyrics including “when you’re rocking and rolling you can’t hear your momma call”. Says it all really!
Good Golly Miss Molly and Long Tall Sally especially are regularly credited as songs that shaped popular music and have been covered and performed by countess rock acts from the Beatles to Credence Clearwater to the Swinging Blue Jeans.
1958 Eddie Cochran Summertime Blues
In his short life Eddie (who died in a car crash in Somerset, England, aged 21) made a huge contribution to popular music. Not only he did record at least three classic singes but also was a multi-instrumentalist, playing and singing on, and producing many other artists’ records, including that of Gene Vincent, who would play such as fateful part in his demise. Eddie also played a role in the early Jayne Mansfield / Little Richard movie “The Girl Can’t Help It” which would also be fateful – but for a good reason, When a young John Lennon saw Eddie performing Twenty Flight Rock in the film, he made it a staple of his pre Beatles group the Quarrymen.
Eddie is best known for three rockabilly style rock’n’roll singles employing his signature driving acoustic guitar. C’Mon Everbody – later covered part of a Levi jeans advert and covered by by Led Zeppelin; Somethin’ Else, memorably covered by Sid Vicious of the Sex Pistols for the Great Rock’n’Roll Swindle album and a big hit single. But it will be for Summertime Blues that he will be most remembered.
The lyric to Summertime Blues contrasts a frustrated, protesting feeling with an upbeat sound. I always thought of Eddie, with his sharp dressing, Hollywood looks, and expresser of teenage angst as a kind of musical James Dean. But he was more than just a teenage rebel, he knew exactly what he was doing and didn’t take himself too seriously. Listen to the lyrics on the song, a bored boy wanting a real summer vacation after working hard for low pay “take my problem to the United Nations” – to which the deep voice reply comes “Sorry, son you’re too young to vote” to which Eddie concludes – “there ain’t no cure for the summertime blues”. The song is beautifully simple, barely more than Eddie and his acoustic guitar and occasional base – but it sounds full and large and just oozes rhythm. It is a regular near the top of the “greatest rock songs ever” polls.
An even larger sound was heard on The Who’s Live at Leeds album, often described as the greatest Live Album ever. The Who’s cover version of Summertime Blues is a magnificent early heavy metal re-working of the song. In fact It has been covered by a who’s who (excuse the pun!) of royalty rock’n’roll, – Rush, the Rolling Stones, and Bruce Springsteen. And interestingly a high-charting version by the relatively obscure Blue Cheer – pre dating not only the Who’s version but also Born to Be Wild and Helter Skelter, other claimants to “first heavy metal” record. To be fair, the Who began singing the song in 1967/8 at concerts like the Monterey festival, and recorded at that time an unreleased version.
My closing feeling about Eddie’s version is just how cool the voce sounds – the type of American accent and phrasing which Paul Weller of the Jam grew up thinking he just had to use – until he realised that his own South London accent would be more authentic.
And it surely reminds us of student summer holidays. In my time there was no need to get a job as Eddie was forced to do. You could sign on the “dole”, place “astronaut” in the box marked “desired job”, and supplement your no-strings student grant with a summer of benefits. How times have changed!
Eddie had seen his hero Buddy Holly die while touring and was worried the same would happen to him. But needs must. he toured and he died in Bath hospital in Somerset after injuries in a taxi accident in Wiltshire – and Gene Vincent was in the car with him. Gene survived but never completely recovered.
1959 Buddy Holly True Love Ways
One of the most romantic songs ever recorded – apparently the most popular wedding reception bride and groom dance opener – it features lush strings. It was recorded for his wife. But this effectively brought the Rock’n’Roll era to an end in many ways. Holly recorded this song – along with “It Doesn’t Matter Anymore” and “Raining in My Heart” in what would be his last recording session and indicating perhaps for the time being was moving in a different direction from rock. The recording session was late 1958, “Raining” and “Doesn’t Matter” were released January 1959, but Holly’s his death in a plane crash in February 1959 meant “True Love” was not released until posthumously in 1960. I really believe it belongs to Buddy’s era of the 1950’s and in particular the year when he left us. Hence the inclusion in 1959. As Don Mclean memorably wrote in American Pie, Holly’s death was the “day the music died” – now quite well known but not so well known was the fact that “February made me shiver/with every paper I’d deliver” referred to McLean’s paper round – it is how he first found about his hero’s passing in February 1959. .
1959 Ray Charles What I’d Say Parts 1 and 2
Some say this was the record which invented Soul music. Ranked at No.10 in the Rolling Stone magazine’s list of 500 greatest songs. Ray had been a gospel, R&B and Rhumba style singer for some time and when the song was successfully played live at a concert – essentially an accident because he had 10 minutes to fill at the end – he determined to record the song including the now famous call and response with the audience and the Wurlitzer electric piano. To capture the full length yet be suitable for radio play, the song was split into part 1 and 2 A and B side.
The song controversially fused gospel and romance and importantly gospel and blues – being released on the Atlantic label it must surely have influenced Aretha and the gang. But it also hugely influenced rock artists like the Beatles who played it live in Hamburg. Mick Jagger sung it on his first session with the future Rolling Stones. For me, it took me time to discover and warm to it – as a young boy growing up it was Ray Charles’s subsequent ballads such as “I Can’t; Stop Loving You” that my father liked which at that time of course was counter to the Beatles revolution. So I grew up believing that Ray was just a balladeer, not realising that he had changed the course of music history (but then nor did Dad, because although he liked his 50’s music he wasn’t a muso obsessive like me!) But I picked the scent again when Ray made a memorable appearance as the grumpy record store owner in The Blues Brothers.
One of his album’s was called “the genius of Ray Charles” – not an overstatement in this case.
1959 Miles Davis All Blues
Also classed as a genius, the track All Blues by Miles Davis is the standout track from arguably the greatest jazz album of all time, Kind Of Blue.
Miles Davis had earned his stripes in the 1940’s by playing jazz and bebop with the likes of Charlie Parker and Dizzy Gillespie in Harlem and 52nd street in New York, evolving into Cool Jazz in the 1950’s. Heroin addiction forced him to move from the temptations of New York. However he continued his career with Blue Note label recordings, before returning at the Newport Jazz festival and recruiting John Coltrane to his quintet. In 1959 came his definitive work Kind of Blue. The track All Blues is a modal 12 bar blues featuring “head” improvisations by each of the sextet, particularly on trumpet. Its famous “Blue Notes” on the 3td 5th and 7th notes of the scale feature a flattened 7th note. With an unusual split tree beat rhythm there is a hint of waltz.
At 12 minutes it is unusual to include in this list as it was never a hit single; it is the epitome of Cool. The album however at 4 million sales is the biggest selling jazz album of all time. The influence was enormous, not just in jazz but in rock and ambient. Duane Allan of the Allman Brothers used Davis’s ideas while Richard Wright of Pink Floyd credits Kind of Blue with influencing Breathe on Dark Side of the Moon. Quincy Jones, Michael Jackson’s principal producer, was a bug fan and close friend of Davis. It was voted 10th in the all-time Rolling Stone’s list of top 500 albums of any type. .
I grew up being somewhat dismissive of jazz, unable to understand or appreciate its complexities. It took me around half a century to catch up, with the track All Blues appearing in my son’s GCSE music syllabus.
Decade 1960’s
1960 Sam Cooke Chain Gang
Sam Cooke began as a Gospel singer and gradually crossed over to popular music and soul. One of his first hits was You Send Me in 1957 and to a certain extent he treaded water till 1960 when first Wonderful World (“don’t know much about history…”) and then Chain Gang established him as the “Mr Soul” of the time I love both songs but have chosen the latter for the social significance which prefaced his increasing interest in Civil Rights which culminated in his posthumous “Change is Going to Come”.
A Chain Gang has huge significance in American history as it is a means of keeping prisoners together while out labouring, for instance while building the rail tracks. By 1960 it had mainly been phased out, but before that Sam and his brother had spotted and helped out a chain gang. They remembered it and wrote the song. The vocal sound effects Sam creates a memorable – re-creating in the listeners mind the sounds of the prisoner’s songs and perhaps even the sound of steel on rail track. And of course Sam’s unforgettable silky voice.
The track was a worldwide hit and re-established Sam for the latter part of his career.
1960 Chubby Checker the Twist
This track counts as the song with the oldest origins in our list. In 1844, Grape Vine Twist was a minstrel song, and then in 1938 Jelly Roll Morton’s song in “Wining’ Boy Blues” featured the line, “Mama, mama, look at sis, she’s out on the levee doing the double twist”. The evolution continued in the 50’s through a Drifters melody; a gospel group, the Sensational Nightingales’ original lyrics were developed by Hank Ballard and the Midnights, who recorded and released the song to modest success in 1958. Chubby Checker – so named because of slightly portly gait and because he was an impressionist of singers (a “checker”) – recorded his version for Dick Clark’s American bandstand. The song was an instant and enduring hit; reaching No.1 in two separate chart runs in the early 1960’s and by 1965 had sold 15 million copies, an incredible total for a single.
A standout feature is the saxophone – dirty base to open the song and then tenor sax solo mid track – my brother in law Chris a fine player himself could do worse than use this or other late fifties/early sixties saxophone examples to teach his music pupils! The other feature is the continuous “round and round” background refrain which sounds to me like a forerunner of 70’s dance and disco.
The dance itself brought not just teenagers but adults onto the dancefloor in numbers not seen before. Relatively easy and fun to perform (as I can vouch, even I could dance the Twist as a 6 or 7 year old). Just watch this video – Chubby shows us how but I always love the audiences in these early performances – going wild but told firmly to stay in their seats but itching to join in the twist.
The record has won numerous awards and was performed by Chubby with the rap group the Fat Boys at the Nelson Mandela 70th birthday tribute at Wembley (which I attended). The follow up record, “Twistin the Night Away” is if anything more well-known with memorable cover versions by Sam Cooke and Rod Stewart. Watch Chubby twist the night away like he did last summer. “Is it a bird, is it a plane? No it’s a twister!
1960 Every Brothers Cathy’s Clown
The song by Don and Phil every informs Cathy that “I don’t want your love anymore”, trying to “stand tall” after she has dumped him, resenting being called “Cathy’s Clown”. The double drums effect achieved with a tape loop combined with the brothers memorable harmonies made it their biggest hit single, spending several weeks atop both the American and UK charts. Inspired by the Grand Canyon suite by Ferde Grofe, the song influenced the Beatles harmonies on Please Please Me. In fact when John and Paul headed south for the first time to a talent contest, they described themselves as the “English Everlies”.
Don and Phil were country-based rock singers who had started mid-fifties with Walk Right Back Wake Up Little Suzie and Bye Bye Love. Their music influenced the Beachboys and Simon and Garfunkel and in fact they played with Paul on Graceland. And Don Everly was recognised by Keith Richards as one of the finest rhythm guitar players.
1961 Ben E King Stand By Me
Many versions of this inspiring song have been made (by Seal, Otis Redding etc) but Ben E King’s 1961 release remains the definitive track (except perhaps for one(*)). King, who left the Drifters in 1960 to pursue a solo career commencing with Spanish Harlem, wrote the song with producers Leiber and Stoller, inspired according to Sam Cooke by the spiritual Stand By Me Father. The music is very simple R&B and the Atlantic Records track comes to life with King’s soaring chorus. It is high in the “Songs of the Century” lists and charted high again on the release of the film of the same name in the 1980’s (and also a Jeans advert)
(*) The version of Stand By Me by John Lennon from his 1975 Rock ’n Roll covers album comes close to being the best. John completely reworks the accompaniment but stays absolutely loyal to the feel of the vocal. When John opens with “When the night…”, it is not what you call pure singing but oozes soul. It is one of his great vocal performances, almost up there with the historic Twist and Shout session. And the rhythm guitar is rightly brought forward, drums, dirty horns and electric guitar added. It was one of John’s last hits before his closing, brief revival in the fateful 1980, and one of my all-time favourites.
1961 Dion The Wanderer
“Well I’m the type of guy ..” is the memorable opening line from Dion, by now without his Belmonts with whom he had recorded “Teenager in Love”. His solo career had included Runaround Sue and took off with The Wanderer. “I roam from town to town and go through life without a care, I’m as happy as a clown with my two fists of iron, but I’m going nowhere” revealed a darker, edgier side to the carefree hero, who is so carefree he could answer the question his date asks – “which one do you like the best?” – by tearing off his shirt revealing “Rosie on my chest”. An early tattoo I guess.
Dion was an Italian American from the Bronx, New York. Initially a country singer, but he developed a harder city edge to his music. His early success won him a place on the ill fated Winter Garden tour, where he turned down a chance of a plane ride with Buddy Holly and the Big Bopper simply because he couldn’t quite afford it. It was the day on which “the music died”.
The Wanderer is a memorable song, covered by the likes of Bruce Springsteen, but is from that “in-between” period in music history– after the first flush of rock and roll but before the onset of the Beatles. Talking of which, Dion joined Bob Dylan as the only other musician on the front cover of “Sergeant Pepper”.
1961 Del Shannon Runaway
From a similar period and stable as Dion’s the Wanderer and Runaround Sue, “Runaway” was a No.1 record in both America and the U.K. having received its big break like so many on Dick Clark’s American Bandstand, the American equivalent of Top of the Pops. The record featured the famous Musitron electric organ high pitch break, performed by Max Crook, who had invented the instrument. The song was covered by many including the Travelling Wilburys and the Beatles sung it many times in Hamburg, almost certainly with harmonica replacing the Musitron.
As a very young boy I was drawn to songs like this with strange sounding electronic pianos – early synthesised music as it turned out. Other examples were Telstar by Joes Meek’s Tornadoes a year later, and of course the theme from Dr Who. The Moody Blues Mellotron (Knights in White Satin and the even better Tuesday Afternoon) and of course Pink Floyd (See Emily Play and Arnold Lane) took synthesised singles music forward. But it wasn’t till the early 1970’s that a true Moog synthesiser topped the UK pop charts with Chicory Tip’s Son of My Father. But we should never forget the early innovation linked to Del’s classic early 60’s voice that “Runaway” provided. Runaway like The Wanderer gained renewed traction in the U.K. as part of the “That’ll Be The Day” film and album.
1962 Sam Cooke Bring It on Home to Me
Sam Cooke had enjoyed great success with his crossover from Gospel to Pop with songs like Twistin the Night Away and Wonderful World. The recording session for Bring It On Home featured the almost equally popular Having a Party and the session was a very happy, carefree affair which comes across very obviously in the tracks. Bring it on Home contains references both on the lyrics and the vocalisations (call and response) to Sam’s Gospel roots and his early work with the Soul Stirrers.
The track has been covered countless time by artists such as the Animals and Rod Stewart, who is well known for crediting Sam as his favourite and most influential singer. Bring It on Home to Me is now a rock standard.
Sam subsequently recorded both Bring It on Home and Having a Party on his live album “Live at Harlem Square Club” in 1963, in a largely African American part of Florida – significant because by this stage the record company was pitching Cooke at more of a white audience. The album itself has a remarkable history. For this album, Sam’s voice seemed earthier and rougher than normal, and the crowd were raucous, wild almost at Sam’s amazing performance, and this comes across clearly on the record. The record company felt the overall effect was not suitable for release, with a more middle of the road sound and audience in mind. So the tapes lay in the vault until discovered years later, when it was realised that a gem had been discovered. The album was finally released in 1985 and quickly established itself as one of the greatest of all Live Albums, alongside such as the Who Live at Leeds, and James Brown at the Apollo Theatre. The album captures a time and a place and is a favourite in my collection. Sam’s relationship with his audience and especially female fans shines through, and reveals more of his true, original more gritty Soul voice.
Alas this was to be one of Sam’s last recordings as he died at the hand of a Hotel owner a year later, shot in mysterious circumstances. It brought to an end one of the great careers, and silenced one of the sweetest soul voices.
1962 Bob Dylan Blowin in the Wind
Written in 1962 and released a year later, q song about suffering, freedom, and war, the song matched the growing social unrest at the time, and has become a folk and civil rights anthem. Bob Dylan poses the questions about these issues but reflects that the elusive answer is “blowin’ in the wind”. The single was never a big seller per se. but the album “Freewheelin’” launched his career and Peter, Paul and Mary had a worldwide hit with their version of Blowin’ in the Wind.
The lyrics have their roots in the Old Testament (“ears to hear but hear not”) a Woody Guthrie song and a slave song/spiritual, which perhaps explains why Mavis Staples was astonished that a white man could write a song which seemed to indicate he understood African American problems. The sentiments also may have been influenced by his then girlfriend, the more radical Suze Roloto.
Bob began to play the song live at folk festivals and performed the song in England, believe it or not as part of a BBC “Sunday Night Play” Madhouse on Castle Street. During the visit he began to make contact with English folk musicians like Martin Carthy and the Beatles began to be influenced by Dylan.
The song continued to ripple through cultural and political fabric. Bob Dylan’s own career went from strength to strength. The song has become a staple of acoustic guitar lessons. Sam Cooke, in a kind of long distance call and response, issued his own follow up to the song, “A Change is Gonna Come”, which posthumously became one of his most compelling and famous songs..
And bizarrely the song played a prominent role in Douglas Adams’ Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy: after a computer’s 7 million year calculation to reveal the answer to the ultimate question about the Meaning of Life gives a rather unsatisfactory answer (“42”). A new computer called “planet earth” is programmed to come up with a better Ultimate Question, However, a few minutes before the question is revealed, the earth is destroyed to make way for an intergalactic bypass. Rather than re-programme, the Mice who are running it decide to simply go with this Ultimate Question:
“How many roads must a man go down?”
Which of course are the opening lines to “Blowin’ in the Wind”.
The song appears in the top twenty of Rolling Stone Magazine’s “500 Greatest Songs Ever” Bob Dylan was not even 21 years old when he wrote this song. The song and sentiment were game changers for Bob himself, and in music and society as a whole.
1962 Elvis Presley Can’t Help Falling In Love
The melody if this song is from 1784 (our earliest entry by some centuries) but the lyrics were written for the Blue Hawaii in 1961. Possibly the last great Elvis song of that first era, it made Number 1 in 1962 in the U.K. and America and is regularly voted near the top of his fans most favourite songs.
Can’t Help Falling in Love has taken forward a life of its own. UB 40 recorded a No. Hit cover version. Other covers range from the Stylistics to Andy Williams to Punk Band Leatherface whose version was used in bikers boxset TV series Sons of Anarchy. U2 often finished concerts with it A line from the song “wise men say, only fools rush in, but I can’t help falling…” has become the long lasting song of my football team Sunderland and indeed for a while “Wise Men Say” was the title of their fanzine before another musical title took over called “A Love Supreme” (in which I appeared one time wearing my Sunderland strip in front of Sydney Harbour Bridge).
This brought an end to Elvis’s first successful era. He resurfaced again at the top of the charts in the late sixties with great songs like In the Ghetto and Suspicious Minds, and even in the seventies with Way Down and Always on My Mind, but he was somehow playing catch-up rather than setting the pace.
Another key group in 1962 was the Four Seasons who were embarking on a career rather than completing it. It is worth spending some time on them because for me 1962 was the great “in between year”, namely before the Beatles revolution took hold, and after rock and roll. The Four Seasons had a foot in both eras.
I used to believe that the Four Seasons were somehow too middle of the road to belong to the rock family, but over the years the more I have learned about them and listened to their music the more I have come to appreciate them. As the Jersey Boys musical memorably recounts, there is an amazing story behind the band.
Founder members guitarist Tommy de Vito and singer Frankii Valli from New Jersey, NY, were working class Italian American boys flirting with petty crime when they formed the Four Lovers with composer Bob Gaudio and bass player Nick Massi. Their name changed after a failed audition at a Four Seasons bowling club. Producer Bob Crewe guided them to No.1 hits with Sherry, Big Girls Don’t Cry and Walk Like a Man and for the next few years in the U.S.A. they almost matched the Beatles for sales. The band were the first white act to sign for Vee-Jay records, John Lee Hookers label – indicating how they were seen in the USA and in fact with Vee Jay also releasing Beatles records in the USA, the label issued what is now a collector’s item, the combined “Beatles versus the Four Seasons” album.
Big Girls Don’t Cry started life as a line in a Ronald Reagan film, and features of course the irrresistable falsetto voice of Frank Valli. More hits like Beggin followed, and although the early 1970’s were a fallow period, Franki of course returned with My Eyes Adored You and Grease. Then a comeback for the group with Oh What a Night Late December (1963) and Who Loves You.
The group have now sold an astonishing 100 million records worldwide and to this day Frank still performs and the Jersey Boys is still selling out after 10 years on Broadway and almost that time in the West End. Our family can vouch that it is a great watch !
So as the great Elvis era began to fade – and those 6 years left an astonishing mark – the Four Seasons must have thought their time had come. But across the channel in Liverpool something was stirring.
She Loves You The Beatles 1963
Imagine you are on business travel, you arrive early and check in at the hotel. What do you do? The gym? A coffee? Or write a million single with your colleague? That’s what happened in 1963! The Beatles wrote “SHE LOVES YOU” in Newcastle’s Grey Street Turk’s Head Hotel while in the city for a Majestic Ballroom gig, not so far from the Newcastle Royal Grammar School I was to attend and which my brother Malcolm was just starting. Lennon and McCartney were beginning to experiment with lyrics and developed the unusual third person singular idea around “she” loves you. The piece de resistance of course was the “Yeah Yeah Yeah” chorus (which importantly translated in any country and language). The impact of this cannot be understated. Replacing Yes by Yeah may seem trivial now, but it summed up the Beatles perfectly – challenging tradition but in a way your Mum could still like. In fact it was at this time that Mum started a tradition in our family that lasted through most of the 1906’s. Mum bough every new Beatles single that came out – and we all just couldn’t wait to hear the latest direction they were taking. The price at 7 shillings and sixpence stayed pretty constant. My brother and I soon took possession of them – though somehow I have ended up still owning them to this day. With some classic 45 vinyl cover.
She Loves You was captured at the London Palladium on film. As well as the Yeah Yeah’s the Little Richard wooh’s were absolutely mesmerising for the mainly female audience. The screams and tears in the audience were unprecedented and this record kick-started Beatlemania, at least in Britain. It took another 6 months before the record went to No.1 in the USA in 1964. . The beauty of the Beatles was that although of course girls loved their cuteness, and high decibel screaming eventually helped cause the band to stop touring, they were equally popular with boys, for mainly different reasons of course.
The record introduced us to many of the signature Beatles features. Starts with Ringos’ drumming, then straight to chorus (not the usual verse-chorus: Paul describes this order as the shape of his songs often being “W” not “M”. Paul’s violin bass, George’s lead, John’s rhythm, and perfect voice harmonies. She Loves You is still the best selling Beatles single of all time in the U.K. and was the best selling single by anyone in the U.K. in the 1960’s. Lyrically and musically more sophisticated than at first hearing, the impact of this record round the world was incalculable both to launch Beatlemania and change popular culture for ever.
I Wanna Hold Your Hand The Beatles 1963
This was the song that broke the Beatles in America. It was composed “eyeball to eyeball” by Lennon McCartney close collaboration and though it sounds simple the chord structure is surprisingly complex and controversial. The vocals are joint Lennon McCartney, often with delightful harmonies and Harrison’s guitar establishes the early sound of the Beatles – short sharp “twangy” chords. When released it replaced She Loves You in the UK charts at Number 1 and in America it was the reverse. The February 9th 1964 performance on the Ed Sullivan show , set up by Brian Epstein, changed everything. The vocals sound a little weak (the microphone was turned down too low it seems) but the sheer attitude and stage presence – the way they stood – overcame that and more as you can see by the fan reaction. The No.1 status started a run (still a record) of seven Number ones by the same artist in the same Year.
The other early Lennon McCartney classic was Please Please Me, their first self penned top ten record (it reached No.2) which featured the famous Lennon throaty voice and McCartney Little Richard – like “woos” . There were many other outstanding early Beatles tracks available, and some of these were covers of R&B hits. One of these was Twist and Shout with perhaps the greatest rock vocal performance by a Beatle (or any one)
The band’s early Hamburg and Liverpool years were awash with cover versions of American Soul classics such as Please Mr Postman, Money and Rock’n’Roll classics like Chuck Berry’s “Rock’n’Roll Music”. Twist and Shout was originally by the Top Notes then the hit came with the Isley Brothers version, and Beatles had already been including it in their live sets.
It was decided to include Twist and Shout in the Beatles’ first LP, Please Please Me (the title track of which George Martin famously pronounced after finishing recording “gentleman you have your first No.! record – and they did, in the U.S.A –even though John can be heard, equally famously, forgetting some words). Martin wanted to bring an element of the Beatles’ live rougher feel to the recording session –and Twist and Shout achieved this beyond anyone’s expectations!
With John suffering from a cold, Martin kept this song to the very last, knowing it would test his voice. So the unforgettable throaty voice came partly by accident – but what followed was described by Ian MacDonald as “an intensity never before seen in British Rock’n’Roll”. The opening lines of “Shakin a Baby, Twist and Shout , C’mon C’mon Baby” starts big and just carries on getting bigger until into the astonishing crescendo of the rising “ah, ah”. Paul’s wonderful Little Richard style hollers and George and Ringo’s impeccable accompaniment complete the job. But John dominates with quite possibly the greatest 3-minute pop vocal ever – the ability of the great singers is to sound out of control – the shrieks – but still remain in control.
The Beatles played this on one of their famous Ed Sullivan appearances, and then memorably at the London Palladium Royal Variety Performance. I can remember to this day John’s wonderfully cheeky introduction to the song, “I need your help, can the people in the cheaper seats clap your hands, and the rest of you just rattle your jewellery.” Even the Queen Mother laughed at that one! John smiles sheepishly and the band launch into a raucous version of “Twist and Shout”. Looking back at the film of that momentous performance, John seems so happy, so healthy, so out front, so in control of the whole group – as indeed he was then. . Paul and George – famous left hand right hand pose – are great and Ringo does that “shakin’ his fringe” thing – but its’ John’s stage presence which totally dominates. He sounds big, the camera zooming in on his face makes him look big too. Utterly mesmerising, brings tears to your eyes, partly because of the performance, partly because of the innocence that would be lost. The four Beatles bow graciously together as one at the end.
At seven years old I was given the EP (remember them?) and the song was buried a little with the Taste of Honey/There’s a Place/Want to Know a Secret”. But Twist and Shout was always my favourite and it has grown in reputation to almost legendary status since then. A single in its own right in America, it was part of the famous “all the top 5 are Beatles” Billboard Chart
Much later the cult classic “Ferris Bueller Day Off” film featured a memorable Chicago parade scene in which Ferris mimes the song from his trailer and around a thousand ordinary citizens dance and sing to the song. You feel very little staged choreography was needed, the song is so infectious.
For me this is “roots” Beatles, before the psychedelic phase. Admittedly a cover, but it’s a song they truly made their own, and showcases John especially at his absolute explosive best as a vocalist. One of the all-time great vocal performances.
The Beatles learned their trade with R&B and Rock n Roll covers but from Hold Your Hand and She Loves You their confidence in their own abilities grew and importantly George Martin began to concur too.
1963 The Supremes – Where Did Our Love Go
The song was a hit in 1964 but was earlier offered to the Marvelettes of No.1 hit Please Mister Postman fame, but they turned it down. The Supremes eventually accepted it but there was initially disagreement about whether it was right for them and whether Diana Ross should take the lead vocal. She did and the rest is history.
The years 1963/1964 saw a breakthrough for the Supremes after several years of gradually leaning their trade, visiting the Motown Hitsville recording studios after school, recording backing vocals and handclaps for such as Marvin Gaye, and releasing some unsuccessful singles as the Primettes. A name change to the Supremes and increasing feature of Dianna Ross as lead singer seemed to do the trick, as they had a first minor hit with “Lovelight”.
Tamla Motown leaders Berry Gordy and Smokey Robinson were writing for them, but eventually it was a Holland Dozier Holland composition Where Did Our Love Go which made Number 1 for the first time. What followed was astonishing. Baby Love, Come See About Me (Alison’s favourite), Stop In the name of Love and Back in May Arms made it five number ones in a row.
You Can’t Hurry Love, I Hear a Symphony and the Happening were just some of the hits which followed, as was You Keep Me Hanging On, which incredibly was one of the first great Heavy Metal songs in 1967 – and I bought it. American psychedelic rock band Vanilla Fudge slowed the song right down and added electric guitar.
Dianna Ross especially went on to have a stellar career, whether a solo artists with Aint No Mountain High Enough, or the classic disco tracks Love Hangover or Nile Rogers produced Upside Down, or acting the part of Billie Holiday, or mentoring the young Michael Jackson.
When Where Did Our Love Go was released the Supremes were bottom of the bill on tour. By the time the record had finished its run they were top. The song perhaps doesn’t have the full range of melodies, harmonies and contributions from Mary Wilson and Florence Ballard (that would soon afterwards emerge on Come See About Me) but over the years it has achieved legendary status, perhaps because of its superbly simple, driving, classic Motown beat and rhythm provided by the Motown house band the Funk Brothers. It was part of the Soft Cell tainted Love medley, and It was on the legendary list (legendary to me anyway) of Motown and Stax records which dominated the NME of chart of “best records ever” which first alerted me to the significance of soul music to rock, and which all those years ago sowed the seed to plan this list. Yes, I have been planning my sixtieth birthday for around 40 years!
1964 The Kinks You Really Got Me
I began 1964 as a seven year old. 1964 was an important year for me musically. I owned my first single, on 45rpm vinyl. Well sort of. My cousin Suzanne bought “Would You Like to Swing on a Star” by Big Dee Irwin and Little Eva, and I immediately took ownership and have retained it to this day. (So, brother Malcolm, that’s where it went!) . My mother began to buy us records, mainly the Beatles, at 7 shillings and sixpence per single. My record collection began. I began to go the local cinema every Saturday morning where there was a terrific show with local groups playing pop for children.
Meanwhile, a steady stream of classic, enduring 1960’s records began to appear. Let us start with the Kinks.
The Kinks were at the Rolling Stones end of the spectrum from rebellious Stones to cute Beatles. I always remember that their hair was long, though not as long as the Pretty Things. “You Realy Got Me” was their first hit single, reaching No.1 in the U.K. and top ten U.S.A., making the Kinks part of the “British invasion”. The song is now famous as perhaps being the first heavy metal record, although if so the Kinks brothers Ray and Dave Davies would deny it,
The famous opening guitar riff came about because initially Ray planned for his song a slower, blues or jazz feel, with piano or saxophone as lead instrument, but Dave for his guitar break had the idea of cutting the front of his amp open with a razorblade and piercing it with a pin. This created the fuzzy guitar sound that the Kinks and many others were to use. The lyrics were as Ray said “a love song for street kids”. The song is regularly near the top of polls for greatest pop song or guitar riff.
Ray of course still performs regularly even today, though rarely with his brother, with whom his disagreements are legendary. The Kinks of course were to records several more classics, many of them much slower and innovative, such as Waterloo Sunset and Lola, but it was “You Really Got Me” which got the ball rolling.
1964 Righteous Brothers – You’ve Lost That Lovin Feeling
This was the first hit for Bill Medley (the low notes) and Bobby Hatfield (high notes) as the Righteous Brothers, so named because when playing before African American marines, the call came through from the audience, “You’re righteous, brothers”. Indeed, they were a soul group of sorts, Blue eyed Soul in fact.
This record almost didn’t make it in the U.K. Written by Barry Mann, Cynthia Weil and Phil Spector, our own Cilla Black recorded it first. Her version was climbing the charts when Phil Spector was advised to persuade the duo to come to England and perform the song: this they did and the rest is history.
Phil Spector had already achieved fame with his “wall of sound” on records with the Crystals and the Ronettes, and You’ve Lost That Lovin feeling is considered his finest production (though I would nominate Ike and Tina Turner’s River Deep Mountain High). The video reflects the song – revealing in the dark first Bill Medley’s bass-baritone opening, then Bobby Hatfield’s countertenor, then a back-up choir to emphasise the wall of sound feel.
The song was a worldwide number 1, is said to be the most played song on American radio in the 20th century, and is placed 3rd in the list of songs generating the most dollar royalties, helped for instance by an iconic inclusion in Tom Cruise’s Top Gun. The duo also hit gold with Unchained Melody, also aided by a soundtrack – this time in Patrick Swayze’s and Demi Moore’s Ghost. Bill Medley himself took part in a memorable soundtrack recording – The Time of Our Life from Dirty Dancing, this time with Jennifer Warnes.
1964 The Miracles Tracks of My Tears
A hit in 1965 but Marv Tarplin had earlier been composing the guitar parts for lead singer Smokey Robinson to compose the lyrics around. In fact the opening sultry guitar chords are almost as famous as the lyrics and vocals – which even before the chorus makes its mark begin with the famous opening line of “people say I’m the life of the party because I tell a joke or two…”
A slow song of regret, it has all the hallmarks of its Tamla Motown origin but somewhat unusually not the driving beat and baseline. Smokey’s voice was sublime and he really did get the hook-line by looking at himself in the mirror and wondering if extensive crying would leave tracks in the face.
the song was a big crossover hit in the USA but not initially in the UK until re-release under the full name of Smokey Robinson and the Miracles . The Miracles had been around since the late 1950’s but it became apparent that Smokey was the star attraction (think : “when Smokey sings” by ABC) and especially when they had a worldwide hit with Tears of a Clown.
Tracks of MY Tears has regularly been nominated as the best Motown Song of all , and one of the best songs of any type, ever.
1965 Bob Dylan Like a Rolling Stone
Where do we start with this classic Dylan record! Well, let’s start at the top. Like A Rolling Stone is frequently voted by critics as the best record ever, as in ever of any type. Including the Rolling Stone magazine (well they would wouldn’t they!).
For me, the lyrics are like the Shakespeare of pop, in that so many well-known pop phrases seem to have emerged from this song, or at least come to prominence, including:
. “How does it feel”…. .”to be on your own” …”a complete unknown”…”no direction home” …”like a rolling stone”
“No Direction Home” became the name of Martin Scorsese’s famous documentary about Dylan. The “feel” memorably is spitted out as “feel”. “A “Complete Unknown” was the bio-pic which helped launch Timothee Chalamet’s career.
Bob wrote the lyrics up at his Woodstock home (yes that one, kind of: Woodstock village is actually 20 miles from the actual concert site: the Anderson family has visited Woodstock and we can vouch that is still has that laid-back hippy feel that attracted artists like Dylan to live there). Originally a twenty page rant, Dylan refined the song to become a memorable warning and revenge message to a girl who at one stage had it all, but fell on hard times (“nobody taught you to live out on the street”). But finishes with a slight note of optimism (When you aren’t got nothing you go nothing’ to lose”). When recording the song, Bob was at the phase of switching from pure acoustic folk to elements of rock. So the electric guitar was added, and the famous electric organ break was added almost accidentally when a then young session guitarist Al Cooper offered a suggested organ refrain when his producer-boss happened to be out of the room and the rest is history.
When Dylan played this live at jazz festivals he was booed (as selling out) and in fact when in Manchester an audience member shouted “Judas”. Nevertheless the record launched Dylan to a wider rock audience, it was his biggest hit single even though radio stations were at first unwilling to play it, partly because of its 6 minutes length, partly because of it morose message.
Dylan has never looked back, still of course active today.
1965 The Rolling Stones – (I Can’t Get No) Satisfaction.
The Rolling Stones started their live-career in 1962 at the Marquee Club in Oxford Street, and then in earnest in 1963 with residencies in South West London at The Craw daddy Club in Richmond, and at Eel Pie Island in Twickenham, a “stone’s throw” (!) from where we live now. But until this release in May 1965, the Stones had mostly released cover versions of blues, rock’n’roll or soul standards as singles (check out this incredible early live video) In fact it was at one their Richmond gigs that the Beatles first met them, and helped inspire them to later write their own lyrics. Lennon and McCartney offered the Stones one of their partly finished songs “I Wanna Be Your Man” and when the Stones concurred, John and Paul sat in the corner of the club and soon came back with the finished article. The Stones hadn’t realised it could be that easy!
“Satisfaction” was arguably the first great Jagger and Richards composition (later they published under their pseudonym the Glimmer Twins). The famous opening guitar riff was generated by Keith Richards using the Gibson Maestro fuzzbox and the song recorded at the historic Blues-based studios of Chess Records in Chicago.
The lyrics for me in “Satisfaction” are a white man’s blues. While the genuine suffering of African Americans is well documented on Blues Records (and of course the Stones cut their teeth playing those records) how could a middle class boy like Jagger express his angst? Well, for possibly the first time in popular song, here was a lyric complaining about the very thing that made modern life so comfortable – the consumer society, commercialism and all its trappings. “Man on the radio….telling me more and more about some useless information…about how white my shirts should be…but he can’t be a man because he doesn’t smoke the same cigarettes as me” Still time for a bit of traditional blues, “Trying to make some girl…tells me better come back next week”
For me, I wasn’t sure about the Stones: you had to be a Stones or a Beatles fan: I was in the Beatles camp. But as a 9 year old, I was still fascinated by the unkempt look, Mick’s gyrations, lyrics about “white shirts and cigarettes”, the use in the title of brackets and a double negative (reasonably clever as I was, I didn’t learn till later this was a “negative concord”).
The track was initially censored because of suggestive and basically unsettling lyrics, but became a worldwide No.1 and perhaps the Stones best known record, which regularly appears in top tens of “best ever singles”. Two of it’s many covers include two completely different versions – Otis Redding’s electrifying Soul treatment, performed at the Monterey rock festival, and Devo’s post punk off-the wall version.
1965 The Who – My Generation.
Let’s deal with the question everyone asks, straight away. Should Pete Townshend have written that (in)famous lyric – “hope I die before I get old” – and yet still be singing the song at nearly 70 years of age, for instance at Glastonbury in 2015 as part of the “Who at 50” tour. Well the answer I believe is yes, it is fine. When Pete wrote the lyrics it was purely how he felt at the time – we all change our mind at some stage – and no doubt there was some calculation that it would cause a stir and be a “nod to the mods”. Pete has said at various stages it referred to “not getting rich” and was “searching for his place in society”.
Also, is 70 old “old” any more? If the Who could steal the show from young pups at Glastonbury are they truly old? Things have changed over the years. There is no way that I as a 16 year old in 1972 would wear a T shirt for a “group” from 50 years prior in 1922 (groups had only just begun to form, in the conventional sense): but my 16 year old son does indeed wear a Who T-shirt.
Pete, born in Chiswick, went to art school in Ealing alongside Ronnie Wood and Freddie Mercury, and now lives in Richmond. Very much a West London background. .
The song features the Roger Daltry stutter, the vocal call and response R&B style in the “talking ‘bout my generation” chorus, John Entwhistle’s “world’s best ever bass solo”, Keith Moon’s manic drums and Pete Townshend’s Rickenbacker guitar with his windmill arms. Occasionally accompanied by Pete breaking his guitar (a feature which in fact began when Pete, in anger at an audience laughing at his broken guitar string, smashed the instrument on stage.)
My Generation, when performed live, often segues into long versions of other songs, such as See Me Feel Me at “Live at Leeds”, one of the greatest of all Live rock albums. The Who also played My Generation at Woodstock. They weren’t as impressed as their American colleagues, and one of the reasons might be this. When I visited Woodstock itself on a USA visit, I realised how far out in the country the festival was (not actually in the town of Woodstock at all) and it occurred to me that the Who must have wondered, as they meandered through the countryside, what on earth they had let themselves in for.
Regularly voted in the top the of “best songs ever” lists, My Generation still has a universal message for any young generation, whatever the age of the singers!
1966 The Beachboys – Good Vibrations
The precise month-by-month chronology of Good Vibrations is crucial for context. Crucial for the history of rock music in fact. While the Beachboys had scored enormous commercial success with their Surfing sound and subsequent teen anthems like “I Get Around”, they hadn’t yet reached creative or critical acclaim. But their composer/arranger Brian Wilson heard the Beatles’ Rubber Soul in late 1965. He was struck by the continuity of the album and lack of filler tracks – all of them high quality. He vowed to aim for the same standard with his next album with the Beachboys which was to become Pet Sounds, which is now recognised as one of the greatest of all times in with tracks like “God Only Knows” and “Carline No” and the development of psychadelic rock, concept album and complex studio techniques. When Pet Sounds was released in May 1966, it was initially viewed as too radical for the band’s American record company, but was an immediate commercial and critical success in the U.K. Paul McCartney took note and was determined to respond too, and he did with Revolver in August 1966 and especially with Sergeant Pepper in June 1967. The Beachboys response should have come with the ill-fated unreleased classic Smile album in 1967, but Brian’s ill-health and increasing estrangement from the band and his record company meant the project was shelved for several decades. The battle with the Beatles was over.
So how does Good Vibrations fit in? Well, the track initially was an out-take from the Pet Sounds sessions, but was reworked in mid 1966 and released as a single to worldwide critical acclaim and commercial success. It was to be included on Smile and eventually included on Smiley Smile a watered down version of the hidden masterpiece Smile.
The song lyrics stretch from simple “good vibes” to extra sensory perception, while musically it was a highly complex “pocket symphony” recorded over several months and in several studios. One of the standout instruments was the electro- theremin, based on one of the first electronic instruments, which in fact could be played without physical contact. The instrument is frequently used where an eerie or ghostly sound is needed, hence its use in both Midsommer Murders theme tune and a Big Bang Theory “Sheldon-plays-instrument” episode as well as Good Vibrations (true!)
There are some similarities between Good Vibrations and Strawberry Fields. Both recorded at the creative peak of their composers, both a complex, highly produced patchwork of tempos and styles. Also partly drug induced. However, whereas John Lennon ‘s mind was able to recover within a few years, for Brian Wilson it was arguably decades. Thankfully, he recently played live the entire lost album of Smile.
At just 10 years old, I was unaware of most of the above, and my great interest was England’s World Cup bid. I created a scrapbook from newspapers cuttings (remember them?) about the tournament in general and England in particular. Of course I was pleased we won but will always regret that one of my footballing heroes Jimmy Montgomery being dropped from the final squad. (He was to gain legendary status 7 years later when I saw him make the double save at Wembley against Leeds)
Nevertheless I just loved the Good Vibrations record. It was bubbly, fun, thrilling, intriguing all at the same time – what did “I don’t where, but she sends me there” mean? How could so many jigsaw puzzle pieces of music all fit together so perfectly? All the while retaining the feel of California sunshine, and finally it added to me increasing fascination with electronic music a la Dr Who and Telstar.
1966 Wilson Pickett – Midnight Hour
This was recorded in 1965 and appeared on the album “Exciting Wilson Pikckett” in 1966. Wilson started as a gospel singer before joining Stax/Atlantic where with Steve Cropper, of Booker T fame, he wrote this song and recorded it with Donald Duck Dunn and Al Jackson, who with Steve Cropper were part of the classic Stax house band. (Later in the Blues Brothers this was the real band that Jake and Elwood Blues got “back together”). Producer Jerry Wexler added the off-beat and the end result is a classic Atllantic/Stax soul standard.
I first really began loving the slightly harsher than Motown Soul sound at Atlantic when Paul Rogers of Free expressed admiration for this style of music, and when I went up to Cambridge in 1974 I happened I to find a second hand record shop and saw the above Vinyl album on sale for 33 pence. I speculated and found I had a classic – Wilson Pickett, Aretha, Sam and Dave, Arthur Conley, Otis Redding et alia. Not Midnight Hour s it happens but other Pickett classics like Mustang Sally and a Thousand Dances. I still have the album. And finally, I do remember an NME “best ever record” poster and poll which included these kind of Stax records to my great surprise but huge fascination.
1966 Sounds of Silence Simon and Garfunkel
Simon and Garfunkel had performed many years before as teen duo Tom and Jerry with a little success with Hey Schoolgirl (Art was Tom, named after Tom Graph: he liked Maths: good!) This song was recorded a decade later in 1964, originally by the duo as a purely acoustic folk song on the subject of loneliness, but initially made no chart impact and they split up. Paul Simon in fact came to England. However producers back in America had the idea (after Dylan’s Rolling Stone) of electrifying folk and did the same with this song in 1965. It gradually gained radio plays and popularity and by January 1966 was vying with the Beatles “We Can Work It Out” for the U.S.A , No 1 position. Paul returned from England and with Art properly launched the group. The song was used in the Graduate film and has become one of the most performed songs of the last century. And exactly 50 years later in June 2016 Paul Simon finds himself back at the top of the UK album charts with his latest solo album. An astonishing career.
Cream Sunshine of Your Love 1967
Jimi Hendrix is playing the Lulu show live on TV (yes, it happened in those days). Jimi stops, announces that he wants to finish playing “this rubbish” (Hey Joe!)and launches into a Cream record to mark their split. It was Sunshine of Your Love. The impromptu song extended beyond the end of the programme. Lulu was fine with it (but the produces were not). In fact Jimi was returning a favour – Cream had been inspired to write the song after seeing Jimi in concert earlier.
Eric Clapton had formed the “supergroup” Cream with Jack Bruce, lead singer and bass guitarist, and drummer Ginger Baker. Their second album, Disraeli Gears, was being put together in America at the Atlantic Studios, home of many of the great Soul musicians at the time. The Band recorded Sunshine of Your Love and Atlantic luminaries such as Otis Redding, Booker T, and Jerry Wexler gave it their approval. And one more equally important man, Ahmet Ertegun, co-founder of Atlantic Records with Wexler. Ertegun brought in the producers, who were unused to the sheer decibels at which the band recorded, but the ensemble managed to infuse the Atlantic Blues sound into English rock and one would argue that the future sound ofAtlantic’s Led Zeppelin was born.
You may not know Sunshine of Your Love producer Ahmet Ertegun, but he is the Forest Gump of Rock and Soul music. He appears throughout it’s history. A Turkish immigrant to the U.S.A. , living the dream as they say. In the late 1940’s he co-founded Atlantic Record and produced records for Professor Longhair and Ray Charles. In the early 1950’s Ertegun wrote Blues standards s recorded for instance by Big Joe Turner and Pat Boone and was in the chorus for Turner’s seminal “Shake Rattle and Roll.”
In the 1960’s he was instrumental in developing the Atlantic/Stax Soul sound of Aretha, Wilson Pickett and Otis. Some of the greatest records ever. Ertegun then was instrumental in breaking Cream in America, and was thus predisposed to sign another upcoming British heavy rock band in the late 1960’s – Led Zeppelin ,with whom he formed a lifelong personal friendship and business bond.
When Ertegun sold his share in Atlantic, he invested in New York Cosmos soccer team and brought Pele and Beckenbauer to America. He was chairman of the American – Turkish society and promoted many joint causes for instance with Henry Kissinger.
Weill into his eighties he was still involved in the music business in 2006. Ertegun attended a Rolling Stones concert and unfortunately fell, and from the injuries died a few weeks later.
In 2007 the remaining members of Led Zeppelin reformed purely in honour of Ahmet Ertegun, their former producer,, and whose Jimmy Page had announced the death of Ahmet when Led Zeppelin were inducted to the Rock’n’Roll Hall of fame. The funds from the reunion concert (and there were a record 20 million applicants for this one concert at the O2) were for Ahmet’s Turkish American foundation. Led Zeppelin have never performed since.
The role of the record producer has fascinated me for years. I tried to be a producer myself, in my IT work, assembling teams, supervising work, generating ideas. With a little success, but ultimately not enough.
So back to the record. The significance of the tie-up with Ertegun and Wexler’s Atlantic is that it was a historic union of blues and rock – another example being Clapton’s reworking of Robert Johnson’s Crossroads. Ginger Baker’s complex drum patterns are a highlight of “Sunshine”, and Clapton’s “woman tone” guitar riff became one of all-time greats. It was a big top ten hit in America. I personally remember the song as an example of the summer of love, a hippy tune.
Eric Clapton, having started in John Mayall’s Bluesbreakers and the Yardbirds, then went on to become the ultimate guitar hero in Cream and Derek and the Dominoes, sometimes known as “God”. I remember talking to my bother about the group Cream and observed that Clapton was “only the guitarist, not the singer” (at the time I believed that the singer in a band was far more important, in this case the base player Jack Bruce). My brother Malcolm, older and wiser, looked at me and said wistfully, “Hmmm, only the guitarist you say…”.
The band only ran for 2 years and played Sunshine of Your Love at their famous farewell concert at the Royal Albert Hall (in those days a rare rock concert there). You can hear the enormous, full sound that the threesome makes, a feat repeated ten years later by the Jam.
Aretha Franklin Respect 1967 When Aretha recently sang “Natural Woman” to an audience at end 2015 including the Obamas and song writer Carole King, they were brought to tears because Aretha was so good. The wonderful voice from the Stax Atlantic years is absolutely still there and Aretha looked in good health. Alison would certainly not let me publish this1 list without an Aretha song – Say a Little Prayer perhaps? I have chosen Respect because of the multiple awards and recognitions (No.5 best ever song in Rolling Stone top 500) and huge sales: but more important because of its iconic status as a feminist anthem.
Although originally written by Otis Redding as a man’s demand for respect, Aretha turned it on its head to become a women’s rights call to arms, aided by the introduction of the famous R-E-S-P-E-C-T chorus. This truly launched Aretha as the Queen of Soul, a status she has held ever since. Not least because of her iconic appearance singing “Think” in the original Blues Brothers Film and “Respect” in the follow up Blues Brothers 2000.
The Beatles Penny Lane/ Strawberry Fields Forever 1967
The creative peak of Lennon, McCartney and the Beatles, therefore the creative peak of modern pop music as a whole and so my No.1 favourite of all time. The double A-Side is very relevant, Penny Lane being mainly Paul with help from John, George, Ringo and George Martin, and Strawberry Fields is John with help from Paul and the Gang.
Both songs were recorded in late 1966 and meant to be part of the Sergeant Pepper album. But because they were finished early and a single was due, the decision was taken to release the double A-side, early 1967, which in those days meant it could not be also included on the album. As Pepper was meant to be a concept album about memories of Liverpool, George Martin later felt it was a big mistake.
As it happens the record was a rare failure to reach No.1 (Englebert with Please Release Me bizarrely kept it off the top) but creatively the combination of John and Paul at their best on one 45 inch vinyl sends it to the top for me (any many others)
As an eleven year old I loved listening to the way Paul pronounced Customer in his still-Liverpool accent and wondered at image of the “fireman rushing in from the pouring rain”. Later I learned of the complex mock Baroque style piccolo trumpet in the horn section and the complex tonal chord changes to bridge the lyrics. The fish and finger pies, the line about “though she was in a Play, she is anyway” which was probably LSD induced. Penny Lane was a street in Liverpool on the local Bus route.
Strawberry Fields too finds a Beatle musing about his Liverpool childhood: it was a Salvation Army children’s home in whose garden John used to play. Too young to fully appreciate the scope of the song and music, I nevertheless came to the conclusion about the Beatle’s success. How could a song sound so weird and inscrutable and yet so attractively easy on the ear?
For a three minute single the song is astonishingly complicated – dissonances, Ringo’s’ wonderful drumming on the main track and its reprise after fade out, Paul’s early use of the Mellotron, Georges’s Indian zither, cellos, tape loops, reverse flutes, varispeeds, occupying an unprecedented 55 hours of studio time. Ringo Starr (the Ringo nickname came from the rings on his fingers, and a cowboy film character called Ringo ) sometimes became bored during these sessions but his drumming had certainly evolved from the Rory Storm days. The key lyric – one of the most important of John’s career – is “No one is in my tree”. John felt simultaneously that that no-one was near him creatively, and yet if true this worried him. “No I think I disagree”. Part impressionism and part psycho-analysis. With any other band this would be hidden on an LP but the genius of the Beatles was to create a memorable single from such complex, anarchic beginnings.
The “promotional film” for Fields – later on the “pop video” would be invented – featured reverse effects, piano’s in fields. Highly innovative as you would expect. And – I love the little extras – while filming it in Sevenoaks, John wandered into an antique shop and spotted the circus poster for Pablo Fanqie’s Fair that would become the inspiration for “The benefit of Mr Kite” on Sergeant Pepper. The Penny video shows features of Liverpool – the barber shop and famous “sheter in the middle of a roundabout” and the boys trying manfully to ride horses!
For me the Beatles had three key periods (which coincide with Ian MacDonald’s Revolution in the Head chapters of On The Up, At the Top, and Going Down): namely the early Liverpool years: the mid period of unsurpassed creativity from Rubber Soul through Revolver to Sergeant Pepper; and the later period of gradual wind-down starting with Magical Mystery Tour and the White Album and ending with Abbey Road and Let It Be. Penny Lane/Strawberry Fields lies at the zenith of the peak mid period. A natural bridge from the astonishing avant-garde closing track of Tomorrow Never Knows on Revolver to the beginnings of Pepper. It also meant the winning of the final battle in the war with Brian Wilson’s Beachboys over who could leapfrog the other’s creativity. Brian, perhaps sensing this, never quite recovered.
Consider this, in my opinion, on a scale of 1 to 10 the advance and technology and impact of Love Me Do, to Tomorrow Never Knows in only 3-4 years was 10/10. iPhone 3 to iPhone4 took the same time and the change was only 5 out of 10.
I make no apology for saying that on their own the individual tracks on this Double A Side Penny lane/Strawberry Fields may not be at the top of the tree. But the combination of the two tracks together – one Lennon, one McCartney – and George Martin pulling it together with George and Ringo, is simply unbeatable. But wasn’t that always the case with the Beatles, the secret of their success? The record sums up their whole career. It is the centrepoint of the Beatles phenomenon. Everything before was leading up to it, and everything after it and Pepper was not quite the same.
1968 Otis Redding – (Sittin’ On) The Dock of the Bay
I loved the song from the start but for many years I did not know what the title actually meant (how can you have a big Dock in a small bay?) until I learned that the song almost certainly refers to the San Francisco Bay. And the use of brackets intrigued me (and always has in song titles). Otis Redding was perhaps not the only person to be named “King of Soul” but he was right up there. An electric stage performer, sharp dresser, attractive, a wonderful throaty voice equally at home on up tempo numbers like his re-working of “Satisfaction” or slower songs like “Fa Fa Fa”. He was at the peak of his career, having triumphed at the Monterey rock festival – where he crossed over to a mainly white rock audience. Then he gave a few lines of a song to his collaborator Steve Cropper. They were Otis’s thoughts when staring across the bay from a rented houseboat and Steve extended the lines about “ships rolling in” to the full version that we know. Steve, being one of the world’s great guitarists (and still is), added his languid “less is more” guitar licks, the sound of the sea and the seagulls, recorded Otis and the rest is history. Except a very sad history it is of course. Soon after, Otis tragically dies in an accident – his place crashed into a lake. The song was rush released and was a huge hit.
The atmosphere on the song was wistful – surely Otis and Steve could not have foretold the events? Whatever, like so many artists the song they are best known for is not entirely typical of their output. Otis Blue or the Greatest Hits are great introductions to his marvellous Stax Atlantic years, the peak of which was also the end, the great “Dock of the Bay”.
Jimi Hendrix – All Along the Watchtower 1968
Jimi Hendrix’s career took off when he moved to London in 1966. Paul McCartney was living in central London and very much part of the social scene – actually unlike John Lennon who was having a difficult time out in Surrey. Paul and Ringo went to see Jimi early January 1967 at the Bag o’ Nails club in Soho, and again in summer ’67 in London where Jimi played the track Sergeant Pepper only three days after the Beatles release.
I used to think that of Jimi’s subsequent big hit singles, Hey Joe and especially Purple Haze were the best, with it memorable riff, and then I switched to Voodoo Chile, his posthumous No.1, with its famous guitar solo.
But finally – and not just because it features currently in a TV advert – All Along the Watchtower seems the most enduring and powerful. “There must be some kind of way outa here, said the Joker to the Thief” could only be Bob Dylan and indeed Bob wrote it at his home in Woodstock (where yours truly has visited) then recorded it at Nashville Tennessee, before Jimi transformed the song along with Traffic’s Dave Mason and the Stones’ Brian Jones in a recording session at Olympic Studio in London. (In those days great musicians, if hanging around the studios, were often invited to join in other rock stars’ sessions) What wasn’t a coincidence was the presence of Chas Chandler, future Slade Manager, who at the time was Jimi’s manager. Still they were not satisfied and final production was done at the Record Plant in New York.
Part of the Electric Ladyland album, “Watchtower” was released as a single and was very successful both in the UK and US. The combination of acoustic and Jimi’s now famous electric guitar solo is captivating, utterly dramatic. Jimi’s most famous Live performances were at Woodstock ( I subsequently visited the famous site, which in reality is 20 miles from the actual Woodstock village) and Monterey, where Jimi famously burned his guitar.
Just today, I saw an interview with the leading rock journalist/PR manager Keith Altham, who as a friend of my cousin Suzanne I have briefly met – he remains one of the great rock officianados: he explained that his PR client Jimi’s incendiary stunt was not in fact spontaneous but planned!. Keith was one of a group of mainly sixties and seventies PR representatives/managers/journalists who did so much to shape rock and soul music. Many revolved around the NME (New Musical Express) which I read avidly in the rock decades. My favourite editors and journalists from the NME were Keith Altham, Charles Sharr Murray and from the Punk era Paul Morely, Nick Kent, Danny Baker, Carline Coon, Tony Parsons, Julie Burchill. Keith Altham started with the cult pop magazine Fabulous and BBC pop show Scene and Heard, then as writer and editor of the NME carried out many famous interviews and concert reviews including with Peter Green, the Beachboys, the Animals and Jimi himself. Keith was PR manager to a who’s who of rock, from Paul Weller to Ray Davies to Rod Stewart. He famously took Jim Morrison of the Doors to see Status Quo.
Keith Altham conducted the very last interview with Jim Hendrix on September 11 1970. A little earlier in 1969, one of my first recollections of Jimi was on the Lulu show. This may seem incongruous but in those days there was less differentiation between the genres – it was all just pop music. This was the famous occasion when the Jimi Hendrix Experience were playing Hey Joe and half way through Jimi stopped abruptly and said he wanted to stop “playing this rubbish” and switched to Sunshine of Your Love by the recently demised Cream. A sign that Jimi already knew he need to move on and try new styles – which he was at the time of his tragic death. There was lots more to come.
1968 The Beatles – Hey Jude
A full 44 years after its release, Paul McCartney found himself as a spectator at the 2012 Olympics velodrome in London. The crowd spotted him. There began a spontaneous rendition of Hey Jude, in particular the “Na-Na-Na-Na-Na-Na-Na Na-Na-Na-Na-Na- Hey Jude chorus”. Now that’s star quality, that’s longevity for a song. AT the time as a 12 year old I was unaware that the song was written by Paul for John’s son Julien, in particular as encouragement to accept the break-up of his father’s marriage, and to accept John’s new girlfriend Yoko, to “let her in to your life”; and the “movement you need is on your shoulder” (a chip?). What I remember is the surprise at hearing such a long record on the radio, and a “record of two halves” with the long fading chorus, finished by Paul with a return to his Little Richard style “Judy-Judy”.
This was the biggest hit of the Beatles closing period. But visually for me the stand out images of that period were John and Yoko curiously in bed in Amsterdam pleading for peace as part of the “Ballad of John and Yoko”, and of course the last live concert in 1969 on the roof for “Get Back”, after which John said “Thanks you very much and I hope we passed the audition”. Get Back for me was also a standout record, beautifully simple back to basics, so much so that even our staid R.S. teacher Claude Dales admitted he liked the record (why aren’t teachers called “Claude” anymore?). The Get Back Rooftop concert has since achieved iconic status partly due to inclusion in the re-released Let It Be Film and Paul’s Glastonbury performance in which technology seemed to re-create his partner Lennon.
The Beatles very rarely did live studio performances like Top of the Pops – they didn’t have to – and their first and last live TOTP was for Paperback Writer in 1965 (there were videos like Strawberry Fields, but not in the studio). Then came the worldwide TV performance of All You Need is Love and finally the last live studio performance was actually for Hey Jude in the unlikely surroundings of the David Frost Show in 1968. The Beatles seemed underwhelmed at first – and take the micky out of David – just look at his face as Barry Davies might say ! But when the audience joined in with the closing chorus they seemed to warm to the memories of earlier small gigs. Its a remarkable under the radar appearance.
1969 The Rolling Stones – Gimme Shelter
The track wasn’t really an official major single release at the time – but has subsequently become one and in fact is recognised as one of the greatest rock songs of all time, featuring in countless films, TV series and computer games, and cover versions abound including one for the recent “Sons of Anarchy” biker-based TV series, which feels appropriate, and proves how enduring the song is (and always will be). The lyrics reflect the physical threat of flood and fire, but also the wider dark times of the Vietnam War period, (“war…just a shot away”); the music uses Keith Richards’ open string tuning guitar technique and a memorable, brutal guitar solo, and Mick’s harmonica. And the vocals are shared between Jagger and Merry Clayton, a wonderful soul/rock background singer who was also on Sweet Home Alabama. The overall feel is both claustrophobic and apocalyptic, yet simultaneously uplifting due to the closing “just a kiss away”.
The song comes from what to many is the Golden Age of the Stones, namely 1968-1972, in which their successive albums of Beggars Banquet, Let It Bleed, Sticky Fingers and Exile on Main Street showed an astonishing burst of creativity with a string of memorable singles including Honky Tonk Women, Jumping Jack Flash, Brown Sugar and Street Fighting Man. Arguably comparable to the Beatles foursome of Rubber Soul, Revolver, Sergeant Pepper and the White album. And all recorded during the difficult period of Brian Jones’ death, drugs busts and the beginning of Keith’s addictions, the Altamont Hell’s Angels concert tragedy, and tax exile.
Jump forward to the 2010’s and the bad are still active: Doom and Gloom a well-received single, Keith’s fascinating autobiography and now recognised as one of the great authorities on popular music, Mick’s co-producer role in Vinyl, the Sky TV New York rock and soul story of the 1970’s. And Gimme Shelter’s reputation just grows and grows. And after a 45 year misconception, I can finally clear up a personal “misheard lyric” mystery: it’s not “whoa Matilda it’s just a shout away” (which is plausible) but in fact its “War, children, it’s just a shot away”. Now I understand, now I no longer need to research Matilda after all this time. I can finally call time on a lifelong search.
1969 David Bowie – Space Oddity
In one sense this record was an oddity, what was seen at the time as a one-hit wonder, capitalising on the Moon landings that year. But we now know it was the beginning of a career, not an end. Bowie had released records before, like Laughing Gnome, but was yet to find his true muse. When I first heard the record at the age of 13 I believed it was indeed a novelty record, another Laughing Gnome. How wrong I was.
Consider this. Novelty records reveal less as you hear them more, you tire of them quickly. Space Oddity is the opposite. The more you listen the more depth is revealed. The combination of acoustic and electric guitars, and early synthesiser. The appreciation that astronauts have feelings too – “I miss my wife very much”. The eerie anticipation of Apollo 13 – “your circuit’s dead”. An extraordinary record for a 22 year old. And a sign of things to come.
My own recollection of the Moon landings was to create what is now I believe a thing of the past – the “Scrap Book”. Made up of newspaper cuttings before during and after the landings, this proved a worthy successor to my “1966 World Cup” collection. The record Space Oddity just seemed to add to the excitement.
Major Tom (as in “Ground Control to”) reappeared at least twice more in Bowie’s career, once in Ashes to Ashes and again in Blackstar, shortly before Bowie’s death. And of course the record became the first to be performed to video in Space when Chris Hadfield of the Space Station memorably sang Space Oddity to great approval from Bowie. Not a novelty record at all, it seems.
Jackson 5 I Want You Back 1969
I first began to take an interest in the group when their Jackson 5 Cartoon series was released, and when placed against teen rivals the Osmonds, I preferred the Jackson 5. One of the reasons was this record, the first of four consecutive USA number 1’s including the almost equally memorable ABC.
I Want You Back was written by the Motown writers and sung by Michael when he was only 11 years old. From the album Diana Ross Presents the Jackson 5, it is often described as the “greatest pop record ever”, has the “greatest chord sequence ever” or the “greatest dance floor filler ever”. It was the innocent start to a wonderful career, even if in later years Michael went through some difficult times.
Decade 1970’s
Marvin Gaye 1970 What’s Going On
Marvin began recording the song in 1970 after a hiatus following the death on stage of fellow singer Tammie Terrell. He began a new direction, moving on from his “Heard it Through the Grapevine” era, becoming more interested in the Civil Rights movements. Renaldo Benson, of the Four Tops, started the song after witnessing police brutality, and Marvin helped work up the lyrics into also an anti-Vietnam war song, a social commentary protest song. Recording as usual for Motown took place at Hitsville studios Detroit, and included the now famous but then novel multi-layered voice track. But when Marvin presented this to Motown Svengali Berry Gordy, he refused to release it, famously saying “it’s the worse thing I have ever heard”.
However, Marvin persisted and eventually a low key release in 1971 immediately lead to huge local then worldwide sales. The rest is history as they say. The accompanying equally successful eponymous album included early references to ecology and global warming. It launched a whole new chapter in Motown and Gaye’s career, which then included “Let’s Get It On” before a tragic death, at the hands of his own father, shot during an argument. (If you call it an assassination, only one other rockstar has died this way – John Lennon)
For me, this has been a slow burner. It is languid, haunting, sad. Marvin knows there’s a problem, but can’t quite understand it or solve it. Hence the title. Regularly appears in Rolling Stone’s “Top Ten songs ever” lists.
Elton John Your Song 1970
I first came across Elton when Noel Edmonds described how he “fell asleep” at an Elton John concert. To be fair, this was before Elton formed the Elton John Band and speeded things up.
What is not generally known about Elton is that he started as a professional musician as a young teenager in the early 1960s, playing as a pub pianist and at the age of 15 formed his own group Bluesology, which went on to back Long John Baldry’s band and, when touring, the Isely Brothers. In 1967 Reggie Dwight as he was then answered an advert to write songs with Bernie Taupin, and they have been partners ever since. He changed his name by combining Bluesology saxophone player with John Baldry. He and Taupin became house songwriters for a record label. Elton played backing piano on the Hollies He Aint Heavy He’s My Brother.
Elton began recording his own material and by the second album had released Your Song, which launched his career and the rest, as they say, is history.
For me it is slightly morose but I have grown to like it over the years. It also helped launch Ellie Golding’s career with her cover.
Free Allright Now 1970
When I went up to Cambridge in 1974, the type of music played at student Disco’s like the Grad Pad was rarely Soul music – it was Rock (in those days you danced to Rock). The DJ most frequently played “Can’t Get Enough” by Bad Company, whose lead singer was Paul Rogers and whose drummer was Simon Kirke. Both formerly of Free, who had broken up after the initial impetus of “Alright Now” had petered out.
All Right Now was written by Paul Rogers and Andy Fraser in Durham Students Union in 1970 (Paul was a Middlesborough boy). The band Free formed as teenagers and had worldwide success with Alright Now. The things which I remember at the time, were these. First, Paul Rogers said that all he ever wanted to do as a singer and musician was sound like the Stax Atlantic soul musicians – the gritty voices and driving bass lines with Steve Cropper’s delicious guitar. At that time as a rock fan I had not really heard of Stax but this made me curious and so began a lifetime love of all things Stax Soul. Second the guitar solo of Paul Kossoff – one of the greatest ever. Paul was the son of actor David, but alas was to live not much longer, succumbing to drugs in 1976. Third the bass line – at the time I hadn’t considered how important this was but this is so clearly obvious on this track. And lastly the line “let’s move before they raise the parking rate” is one of my favourites!
Although Free followed up with Little Bit Of Love, My Brother Jake and Wishing Well they could not repeat the success of All Right Now, which remains to this day a rock and guitar anthem. Paul Rogers is still singing today, for instance as a recent replacement for Freddie Mercury in Queen. His throaty voice defines the Rock Singer.
1971 Rod Stewart – Maggie Mae/Reason To Believe
When I first saw the record on Top of the Pops my first thought was this. “Doesn’t that look like John Peel, the disc jockey, on Mandolin?” And indeed it was he, perched on a stool.
Rod Stewart had been around the London music scene for many years before his breakthrough playing for instance with “Long” John Baldry – who hired Rod after hearing him play Harmonica on Twickenham Station: Brian Auger and Julie Driscol; the Jeff Beck group with Ronnie Wood; and Mick Fleetwood and Peter Green. He had released some singles, including Gasoline Alley and also lead for Python Lee Jackson on “In a Broken Dream”. But no great success, despite being featured in a half-hour TV documentary about Mod culture.
The breakthrough came with the album Every Picture Tells a Story. Although a solo album, it featured all the members of his then regular group the Faces, including his old mucker Ronnie Wood who would go on to replace Mick Taylor in the Rolling Stones.
The A-side single from album went on to be No.1 simultaneously in the UK and USA, as did the album, and astonishing rarely repeated feat. In the early to mid 1970’s, Rod and the Faces were absolutely everywhere, alternating between group and solo albums.
Rod is till as popular today as ever with astonishing longevity: his American song book albums in the 2000’s were huge American successes; and 37 years after Night on the Town hit No.1 in 1976, his album Time in 2013 also reached the top (the longest ever gap) and was one of the highest selling records in UK that year. His first single was Good Morning Little Schoolgirl in 1964 and 52 years later he still looks the part. Not quite Rod the Mod, but close enough! And still sounding like the great Sam Cooke, who provided the inspiration for Rod’s silky voice and many of his songs.
Oh, and that Mandolin on Maggie May. Although it was John Peel on TV, the real player on record was Ray Jackson of Lindisfarne, of “Fog on the Tyne” fame.
1971 Led Zeppelin – Stairway to Heaven
In 1971, a friend in my school class, the late lamented Paul Wellings said he had a spare ticket for an up and coming rock group, playing at Newcastle Mayfair ballroom, on March 18, 1971, and would I like to come?
I turned it down.
To be fair, I was only 15, and was not used to going out on the Toon. And the group had not had any hit singles, so I was only just aware of them. I thought they were obscure.
This was a huge mistake, because the group of course was Led Zeppelin, and the set list included one of the first plays of a new track, “Stairway to Heaven”.
That spring would be the last time they played small venues. Although their first three eponymous albums had established the group especially in America, they were not yet megastars and the band were determined to t play a “close to the fans” tour. All this was about to change, not least because their fourth album would have a different name to the group’s own – in fact no name at all on the sleeve, just four symbols.
I was about to enter the Newcastle Royal Grammar Sixth form , and of course in those days in the common room it was de rigeuer to bring in albums and their fantastic “arty” covers – King Crimson’s Court of the Crimson King, the Yes albums with Roger Dean’s futuristic covers. Led Zeppelin were seen in those days as somewhere between heavy metal and progressive (and their album covers did not disappoint).
Tracks on the fourth album – released later in 1971 – included “ Stairway”, Black Dog, and Rock’n’Roll and the record established the band once and for all as the biggest rock group of the seventies, possibly of all time. The album is in the top ten sellers of all time with close to 30 million sales.
Stairway to Heaven was written partly at Bron-Yr-Aur in the Welsh mountains, and the mystic feel of the slow tempo elements of the track perhaps come from this. The track builds pace of course and Jimmy Page’s guitar solo is now viewed as the greatest of all solos, played by many aspiring young guitar players including my son Matthew.
The track is the most played on F.M. radio in America, though never officially released as a single until years after release. I had tried to limit this list to headline singles, but for Stairway to Heaven, its legendary status elevates it above categorisation. Led Zeppelin’s policy was to release only albums, not singles.
Throughout the rest of the seventies I assiduously bought the band’s LP’s such as Physical Graffiti, and I did eventually manage to see them perform Stairway to Heaven, at Knebworth just before the end of their career together. But I often wonder what that night would have been like at Newcastle Mayfair ballroom. I wonder if my friend Paul remembers?
1971 – American Pie Don McLean
The major part of the record is now well understood. It is about the demise of Buddly Holly – “the day the music died”. Don had read about this while doing his paper round on winter’s morning in 1959. “February made me shiver, with every paper I’d deliver”….”Something touched me deep inside, the day the music died”. My feeling is that much of the song is about the passing the baton from one musical icon to the next, not just Buddy Holly, and significant events in their lives and careers. So the Court jester” is Bob Dylan, Eight Miles High the Byrds, and the “Marching Band” is Beatles’ Sergeant Pepper while “Helter Skelter” is from the White Album. Jack Flash is surely Mick Jagger, at infamous Altamont with the reference to an “angel born in hell”.
There are so many theories – not all of them conspiracy theories – about the lyrics so l recommend this insight. Don went on the record the beautiful Van Gogh tribute “Vincent”, with the memorable spoken introduction, ”Starry Starry Night”. (Which was my personal introduction at the time to the great artist and Impressionism in general).
American Pie has been described as the “song of the (last) century”. Very recently, the original penned lyrics were auctioned for $1.2 million (how many of today’s songs will achieve that sum?) Don Mclean declined to reveal any more insights – and why should he? Good on him, it is the right of every songwriter to withhold his explanations. For me, the best songs invite the imagination to paint pictures, to leave some gaps in a full understanding. “Took my Chevy to the levee, but the levee was dry” fascinated me from the start. It was only when I listened to Led Zeppelin’s “When the Levee Breaks” did I understand ! Words like “levee” and “bayou” are so much more fascinating than “flood defence”!
Stevie Wonder 1972 Superstition
Steve Wonder had begun his career with a No.1 single at the age of 12 (yes!) with Fingertips. As he matured he scored memorable hits with Signed Sealed Delivered and For Once in My Life. He became an accomplished writer for Motown – for instance Tears of a Clown was his. But nothing could really prepare us for the simply astonishing set of four albums he released in the early to mid 1970’s : Talking Book, Inner Visions, Fulfillingness First Finale and Songs in the Key of Life. With these Steve completely redefined what a Motown artist could be, both lyrically and in terms of introducing modern electronic sounds. Up there with the Stones Let it Bleed and Beatles Rubber Soul sequence of three or four classic albums on the spin.
Superstition was put together in conjunction with guitarist Jeff Beck, and features multi instrumentalist Stevie playing the distinctive opening drum sequence, the Moog synthesiser bass, and Calvichord riff. As a dance record at parties it became and still is a memorable floor filler. This and Sunshine of My Life, also from Talking Book, established the former “Little” Stevie Wonder as one of the major artists of the seventies and in fact of all time.
1972 – Get It On T Rex
T Rex is all about Marc Bolan (you knew that) and John Peel (perhaps not).
I followed the bond and then duel between the two from start to finish. Sadly neither is around to reminisce as I am sure they would.
I was an early listener to Tyrannosaurus Rex, who played in the late 1960’s a kind of folk or hippy rock, mostly acoustic. With mysterious lyrics with fairytale content. And the first of two Tom Tom Players in Steve Perriguine Took. Just that name drew me to the band. John Peel the cheerleader of “differentness” championed the band as an “underground” group and sometimes even appeared with them on stage. The band had some success with singles like Debora, King of the Rumbling Spires, and the album Beard Of Stars, helped by Peel’s playing on his shows.
But Steve was taking the alternative culture route while Marc in a sense wanted a quitter life but also sought stardom and increasingly wanted to introduce an electric rock sound to the band.
The turning point came with the release of Ride a White Swan, perfectly balanced between the old Tyrannosaurus Rex and the new T.Rex. Although only 2 minutes long, Ride a White Swan was brimming with mythology references but featured a gorgeous rock guitar riff. A slow burner, it reached No.2 after 11 weeks, to be denied the Top Spot by Clive Dunn’s Grandad (illustrating the wonderful diversity of the charts then). The band became T. Rex, glam rock was born, Steve Peregrine Took was replaced on Bongos by Mucky Finn, and soon Hot Love and the electric Warrior the album came out with lead single Get It On.
Get It On was Terex’s biggest hit in the U.S.A., peaking in early 1972, and a big No.1 in the U.K. Hot Love (Woman of gold, not very old) and Get It On proved the last straw and turning point for John Peel, who abandoned the group because of its commercial bent, and John and Marc barely spoke again. Unfair I think, because history has concluded I believe that Marc was well, a genius and the creator of some of the most memorable and enduring songs in pop history, and importantly sounding relevant to any generation.
Get It On (Bang a Gong) features a great base line from Steve Currie, and guest saxophone playing from King Crimson’s Ian McDonald of 21st century schizoid fame. Marc’s guitar playing and singing are spot on and the lyrics are intriguing (“teeth of the hydra upon you”). A couple of spots of glitter under his eyes and he and glam rock were made. And the closing mumble of “meanwhile I’m still thinking” is a reference to Chuck Berry’s Little Queenie. Watch this T Rex video which features Elton John on piano (it was Rick Wakeman who originally played keyboard)
Consider Marc’s legacy. His best songs like 20th Century Boy taken up by advertising campaigns years later, even his ordinary songs such I Love To Boogie featured in Billy Elliot. The creator you would argue of glam rock. An inspiration already to Punk Rock and New Wave (he hosted a Punk TV show), the Indie scene (Morrissey was a big fan), Britpop (Oasis Cigarettes and Alcohol clearly influenced by T Rex) and more recently My Chemical Romance, one of my daughters favourites.
Sadly he died in a car crash near Barnes Bridge, on route to his home in Upper Richmond Road in east Sheen. Both very near to where me and Alison have lived, You can still see the flowers where it happened. The car was driven by then girlfriend Gloria Jones, early singer of Tainted Love (yes that one).
Marc Bolan, a true hero of rock and roll, who came through the hard way, paid his dues on the circuit, dared to be different and left a memorable legacy.
1972 – Imagine John Lennon
The record was recorded as part of the Imagine album in 1971, but not released as a single in the UK till 1975 and did not reach No.1 until 1980 after Lennon’s assassination outside the Dakota buildings near Central Park, where a monument to the great man now rests. It is called Strawberry Fields and has Imagine at its centre.
It is not my personal favourite Lennon solo single; I prefer the rockier Instant Karma, or harrowing Cold Turkey, or classic soul cover Stand By Me. But the “one world” message and simple C-Major chord structure make it a classic that people round globe turn to in times of trouble. John said later he felt it was one of his best works, but knew he had to “sugar coat” the overall sound to get his radical message across.
1972 was a crucial year in this record’s history, on its path to becoming an anthem, regularly voted in the top five of “best records ever”. For that was when the iconic video was made with at his Tittenhurst Park home near Ascot. Let us explore this a little – it is part of Beatles mythology.
John and Yoko moved there from Weybridge and the video shows them walking through the fog towards the house. On entering, John plays the song on the to-be famous white piano, which Yoko opens the shutters to let the light in before they sit together and complete the song.
The significance to me is this. Throughout his career, John’s appearance changed quite dramatically, not just the length of his hair but the shape of his face, depending on well he was eating, and the substances he was taking, and the mood which befell him. In this video, John looks handsome and healthy once more, at peace at least for a time.
When the four Beatles spent their very last day recording together, at Abbey Road for “She’s So Heavy”, on August 20 1969, they spent some time talking about the now famous “continuous play” sequence of Abbey Road, and then decamped to John and Yoko’s Tittenhurst Park home on August 22nd for their very last publicity shoot as the Beatles. As you can see their appearance had (I would argue) deteriorated to the point of resembling renegades from the American civil war. One more recording session with three of the Beatles (minus Lennon) took place on January 3rd 1970, and one final one in April 1970 with just Ringo and Phil Spector, producer of Let It Be. And that was it. I remember the feeling of breakup of the Beatles – huge disappointment but we all knew it was coming. Meanwhile Lennon had fully launched his official solo career with Instant Karma early 1970, with both he and Yoko shaving their long locks. So contrast the photo above with how John looked just over two years later at his piano at the same location for the iconic Imagine video.
The record has been covered many times but one of my favourite uses of the record was a few years ago when Liverpool football club found themselves near the bottom of the English Premier League. Ever ones for dark humour, graffiti was created in Liverpool “above us only sky, below us only QPR and Reading”….. .
And the house itself? Soon after the video. John and Yoko took a trip to New York, not realising they would never come back to England, partly because of John’s “Green Card” worries about being denied access to USA if he ever left. And so he sold Tittenhurst Park to an old friend of his, one Richard Starkey.
1973 David Bowie – Life on Mars
Although released as a successful single in 1973, this was actually part of the 1971 album Changes, which was David Bowie’s comeback album after a break following Space Oddity. Changes was one of the very first albums I bought and to me it was all about the title track. Life on Mars did not really stand out. However, following Changes, Bowie released in quick succession Ziggy Stardust and Aladdin Sane, and following them Life On Mars suddenly seemed to fit much better – hence the single release.
Bowie composed the song himself on piano, but brought in Rick Wakeman of Strawbs, Yes and Six Wives of Henry 8th fame to embellish the piano. Mick Ronson put together the string and guitar pieces.
The lyrics are anyone’s guess, but it seems the “girl with the mousey hair” is unhappy and muses on whether life can be better elsewhere. I have great admiration for lyrics that I simply don’t understand – it encourages you to paint pictures in your mind. “The mice in their million hordes. From Ibitha to the Norfolk broads”. BBC Radio 2 described it very well – “between a Broadway Musical and a Salvador Dali painting”. The song has a certain majesty and in some critics lists tops the list of “best song ever”.
The song came to prominence again with the TV cop series Life on Mars. The show’s title track plays on an iPod in Sam Tyler’s car (played by John Sim) while he is run over, and on an 8-track tape when he wakes up in 1973 in Gene Hunt’s Manchester police department (Philip Gleinster). The song memorably plays again at the climax of the series where John Sim’s life (probably) comes to an end.
1973 Stevie Wonder – Livin for the City
Although the music is fascinating enough –the foreboding opening electronic bass line and more uplifting synthesiser breaks – it is the lyrics that are memorable. From his album Inner Visions, the song took political protest song to a new level. Although Marvin had lead the way with What’s Going On” it was still rare for a Motown based African American to so overtly and graphically to describe their plight. I always wondered how Stevie as a blind man could not only play so beautifully but also write such vivid lyrics.
The song tells the story of a Mississippi boy moving to New York where he and his family suffer from prejudice, urban pollution and unemployment. “To find a job is like the haystack needle, Because where he lives they don’t use coloured people” is so Stevie. Slightly awkward rhyming, but absolutely makes the point.
The other singles from Inner Visions were Misstra Know It All and Higher Ground, memorably covered by the Red Hot Chilli Peppers.
Elton John Bennie and the Jets/Candle in the Wind 1973
I really started following Elton when he formed his Band with Dee Murray (bass), Davey Johnstone (guitar) and Nigel Olsen (drums). Occasionally assisted by Ray Cooper percussionist. While Dee Murray sadly passed away, Davey and Nigel recently completed their 2000th show with Elton and long fair haired Davey was easily picked out during Elton’s performance of his latest record early 2016 on the Graham Norton show. And Elton and Ray did a solo tour just a couple of years ago. And of course Bernie Taupin still writes the lyrics to Elton’s tunes.
Bennie and Candle in the Wind were two of the standout tracks from Goodbye Yellow Brick Road, part of astonishing run of 8 albums in 5 years from “Elton John” (Your Song) in 1970 to “Captain Fantastic and the Brown Dirt Cowboy” (Someone saved my life tonight) in 1975. My own favourite was perhaps Honky Chateau (Rocket Man).
Bennie and Candle were released as a double A side single in Europe. Bennie was one of the oddest records that Elton released, but with the addition of crowd noises took on an unusual but alluring form, the story being about a mythical pop group. It was released alone in the USA and made Number 1. Elton reveals what a wonderfully innovative piano player he is with the off- beat tempo. Hints of all sorts of genres, whether its Ray Charles’ jazz piano of What I’d Say or Thunderclap Newman’s epic keyboard solo on Something In the Air, one of my personal favourites.
Candle in the Wind needs no explanation of course, the original being about Marilyn Monroe, and the re-recording as “Goodbye England’s Rose” about Princess Dianna, which is still the highest selling single in the U.K… Elton will not perform the song again, understandably, after his memorable performance at her funeral.
My all-time favourite Elton moment was when he performed live with John Lennon at what would be Lennon’s last major concert appearance, at Maddison Square Garden, where they sang “Saw Her Standing There” together. Lennon says “ thanks Elton and the band…let me sing this so I can get out of here and be sick…we chose one I wrote with an old fiancé of mine….Paul…..and we just about know it”. They also sang Whatever Gets You Through the Night (as a thanks to Lennon for contributing to it as a No.1 record) and Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds. After the concert an estranged Yoko was reunited with John. I still have “Saw her standing there” as B-side to Philadelphia Freedom on vinyl.
Oh, and the lyrics to Bennie and the Jets are, memorably “She’s Got Electric Boots, and Mohair Suits”, in case you misheard them.
Smoke on the Water. Deep Purple 1974
Smoke on the Water was the real story of Deep Purple’s ill fated recording experience in Montreux on the shores of Lake Geneva. A fire broke out in the Casino (“some stupid with a flare”) and the studio was destroyed.. But the subsequent recording in the alternative Pavilion has become one of the most influential metal records of all time, not least because of Richie Blackmore s epic guitar riff. With Ian Gillan on vocal and the remainder of the classic Purple line up (Glover Lord and Paice) the record also became part of perhaps the greatest Live Album of all time namely Made in Japan (*) The Swiss equivalent of a Blue Plaque has been placed on the shores of the \Lake (alongside a statue of Freddie Mercury) to commemorate the song. Along with Sabbath’s Paranoid and several other Purple releases it was one of the classic Metal 70’s singles paving the way for others to follow like Iron Maiden and AC DC. There is more subtlety thank you think in Deep Purple – Richie Blackmore gives credit to Beethoven for the riff and Deep Purple’s epic Child In Time demonstrates virtuoso organ playing suitable for choral music.
(*) The other greatest live albums include the early Fleetwood Mac made in Boston with Peter Green on guitar and lead vocals; Cheap Trick’s Live at the Budakon (what is it about Japan?!) ; the Stones Get Yer Yayas Our and the Who s Live at Leeds; Sam Cooke’s Live at the Harlem Square Club; James Brown’s Live at the Apollo; Thin Lizzy’s Live and Dangerous and my own favourite Dr Feelgood’s Stupidity. One of the greatest live recording versions of a single is Stevie Nicks; epic performance of Rhiannon. rivalling Bob Marley’s No Woman No Cry. And as many groups finish a concert with a cover check out Heart’s version of Led Zeppelin’s Rock N Roll in which Robert Plant is successfully out-sung by Ann Wilson in what sounds like the same key.
Bob Marley and the Wailers 1974 No Woman No Cry.
By the time this record came out the original Wailers Peter Tosh and Bunny Wailer had already left the group, perhaps despairing of achieving worldwide success. However this record changed everything. Originally from the 1974 Natty Dread album, which built on the success of Catch a Fire, the song No Woman No Cry was a respectable but not outstanding reggae tune. B but as part of the Live! album in 1975 recorded at Lyceum Theatre in London, it really sprung to life.
Bob’s reputation had been growing both in the black and white communities, among young and older, middle and working class. So when he played his triumphant concert, the adulation was something of a surprise to many in England, but not to his increasingly adoring fans. A superstar had snuck up on us.
Also included on the album was Trenchtown Rock and so Kingston Jamaica was brought to London. To his London fans it was something of a homecoming, and to them No Woman No Cry was already well known as you can hear from the vociferous sing-along. The I Threes, including Bob’s wife Rita, provide memorable backing. But it was Bob Marley himself who was the focus, reaching out to and unifying his audience, and although record itself was not a huge seller, it began to establish his sound and band as worldwide phenomena. And eventually the song – and specifically the Live version – was recognised as one of the greatest ever.
But why did Reggae need re- promoting at all? I had been a fan of reggae from the start, when it emerged from ska, rocksteady and R&B in the late 1960’s, slowed down and with an offbeat added, and my favourites included Desmond Decker (Israelites), Toots and The Maytals (Pressure Drop), who were early pioneers, as were the Pioneers themselves with Long Shot Kick the Bucket (in the other words the horse had died). The Beatles with Obla-di-Obla-Da was an early white-reggae attempt, as was Paul Simon’s Mother and Child reunion. Although Jimmy Cliff’s “The Harder They Come” kept things moving in the 1970’s, as did Eric Clapton’s version of Marley’s I Shot the Sherriff, Reggae had yet to achieve worldwide prominence, particularly in America.
I first began to realise that something special was happening in terms of recognition for Reggae in general and Marley in particular, in 1975 when the NME end of year polls had No Woman No Cry at best single, ahead of Bohemian Rhapsody, and the album at No.3 ahead of Led Zeppelin and David Bowie.
What Bob Marley brought that was different was the charisma, the dreadlocks, universal lyrics, the spirit of Rastafarianism, superb musicianship of course, and the ability to grow as an artist over a decade with a large roster of high quality songs. And let us not forget the role of Chris Blackwell and Island Records in bringing reggae to an international audience. Marley proved that Reggae , which had wrongly been seen by some to be lacking credibility as a genre, a commercial novelty, very much deserved it’s top place at the table of rock’n’roll. He retained the authenticity of Roots reggae, while making it commercial enough to appeal to a mass audience. A trick which only the greats such as Elvis with rock, the Beatles with pop and Michael Jackson with soul have achieved.
The concert at the Lyceum was a major step towards this transformation of reggae. I have often wondered why The Lyceum was chosen as the concert venue, rather than, say the Hammersmith Odeon, nearer at that time to Marley’s more natural London audience in Notting Hill. The Lyceum, built in the 1700’s in London’s West End, has had many phases and uses. From a first home for Madam Tussaud’s waxworks, to a showcase for Dickens’s works, to the creation there of Bram Stoker’s Dracula with help from actor Henry Irving who performed Shakespeare many times at the theatre with Ellen Terry. Then in 1939 it was due to close for a road improvement, with Sir John Gielgud, Ellen Terry’s great nephew, performing Hamlet on its closing night.
But campaigns against closure were successful and – here is the crucial clue – the theatre was converted into a giant ballroom. Post war dance bands played there, the Miss World annual contest was stationed there, and rock bands had just begun to play there when Bob Marley’s Live! was recorded there. Could it be that the ballroom acted in effect as a larger version of the “dancehalls” of Jamaica from where sounds systems and reggae music had emerged? It was an inspired choice, as the atmosphere created is akin to those other two classic Live albums, James Brown at the Apollo in Harlem and Sam Cook live at Harlem Square in Florida. The theatre is still well used, now back to a conventional theatre, with the Lion King having been in-situ since the end of the 1990’s to today.
I remember the concert but wasn’t there, though I wish I had at least been a fly on the wall, observing history in the making. And it is difficult to obtain videos of the concert – copyright correctly preserved. But here is the recording of occasion. My interpretation is this: the Lyceum was only a Ballroom for 10% of its life: this coincided with a lift off point in Bob Marley’s career which his audience were thrilled to share; the intersection of these two brief moments in time produced unique musical and social magic.
I used to think there was ambiguity in the lyrics – no need to cry if you don’t have a woman – but actually it is a reassuring message to a girlfriend that, in the words of the immortal chorus, “everything’s going to be all right”, sung beautifully by the audience. In a nutshell, that is why the song is so enduring. Almost a hymn, tremendously uplifting.
Band on the Run 1974 Wings
After the break up of the Beatles in April 1970, Paul McCartney’s solo career had a relatively slow start, with George Harrison’s All Things Must Pass and John Lennon’s Plastic Ono Band and Imagine albums giving them a lead. In 1972 Paul formed Wings with members including wife Linda and former Moody Blue Denny Laine. I was fascinated at the time by Paul’s decision to take Wings on the road to low profile University bars and Student Unions, including Newcastle University where my brother was studying at the time.
The album’s title came from a combination of a George Harrison comment about the closing days and interminable business meetings of the Beatles – “if we ever get out of here” – and Pau’s desire to “escape”, both literally from the UK to an international recording studio, and as a thread for the songs. Nigeria was chosen as the location for recording, but in many ways the venture was problematic – band members leaving, health problems, and lyrics stolen at knifepoint. Nevertheless, a classic set of songs emerged – the title track, Let Me Roll It, Bluebird. And Jet, the lead single, before Band on the Run itself was released on 45.This finally re-established Paul back at the top of the charts and truly launched the highly successful Wings career.
The song itself is composed of three distinct fragments, and is classic McCartney in that it manages to be both experimental and commercial at the same time. A trick later repeated on “Live and Let Die”, which along with Band on the Run and Maybe I’m Amazed is often considered his best post Beatle work.
And finally the famous album cover: Michael Parkinson, John Conteh, James Coburn, Clement Freud, Kenny Lynch and Christopher Lee join Paul, Linda and Denny under the spotlight.
Don’t Leave Me This Way Harold Melvin and the Bluenotes/Thelma Houston 1975
There were so many release dates for the two key versions of the Philly classic; let’s begin with the first inclusion of the song on Harold Melvin’s memorable 1975 album Wake Up Everybody, which also included their disco hit Bad Luck, and was the last to feature vocalist Teddy Pendergrass. The producers were Gamble and Huff, among the main writers and leaders of the Philadelphia International record label. If Motown and Stax were the key soul labels in the 60’s, one might argue that Philly took their place in the 70’s, most notably with the rise of Disco. Philly acts included the O’Jays, MFSB, The Trammps, Billy Paul and even briefly the Jacksons. Indeed one of my favourite Elton John records at the time was the Philly tribute, Philadelphia Freedom. The Trammps 45 “Disco Inferno” is one of my treasured vinyls. Don’t Leave Me This Way was not a hit single for Harold Melvin until 1977 is the U.K; it was released in response to the bigger selling (and worldwide No.1) version by Thelma Houston in 1977, hence my inclusion of both their versions in this list. Not (as some think) related to Whitney, Thelma was a Motown artist and her version was and remains a disco classic, often placed near the top of “best ever” disco lists. It took on a life of its own, becoming an Aids awareness anthem, taken back to No.1 by the Communards as an Eighties classic. It still pops up on the Reality TV music shows, either sung by Thelma herself or competitors. At the time, I like many rock fans was not keen on disco: that was to change in the coming years, with the impact of the Bee Gees and the recognition of the genre, including the smooth genius of the Philly productions.
Bohemian Rhapsody 1975 Queen
When I first heard this track, on the radio, I thought, yes, its Queen, but not as we know it, Freddie. A bit odd, I didn’t get it. And nor did the British pubic, because even after Kenny Everett wetted the public appetite by playing snippets of the song, because it was initially judged too long for radio, it first charted at a relatively low position. Then something changed, and it leapt to Number 1 and stayed there for 9 weeks. Yes, it was thatvideo.
Characters like Scaramouche, Bishmilla, Figaro and Beelzebub clearly add an operatic feel to the song, while the genres covered vary from heavy rock to progressive rock via classical and opera itself. Highly complex, recored with numerous “wall of sound” overdub, the most expensive single ever at that stage. The thrust of the lyrics are that a boy has accidentally killed a man, sells his soul to the devil and seeks redemption
Ironically the video was very quickly and cheaply made, but such was its impact that it is vewed as the precursor to MTV seven years before it happened. The song has gone on to become the 3rd best selling single ever in the UK (behind Band Aid and Elton’s Goodbye England’s Rose). It went to No.1 again in 1991. It was pivotal in Wayne’s World – the air guitar and hair shaking in the car.
Queen had earleir had success with my personal favourites Seven Seas of Rhye and Killer Queen, and later of course with We are the Champions and Another One Bites the Dust; and their epic Live Aid performance – in those trainers and that vest, Freddie opened with Bohemian Rhapsody and went on to deliver what is considered one of the best Live rock performances of all time, principally the crowd-clapping version of Radio Gaga.
And one more thing. Bohmemian Rhapsody is one of that select group of songs which intrigue me – great rock songs with no chorus (think about it) – like REM’s Drive. I must get out more!
Abba Dancing Queen 1975
Recorded in 1975 and released in 1976 as part of the breakthrough album Arrival, Dancing Queen has always seemed to me one of those ingenious records which sounds slow and yet is good to dance to. A genuine floor filler frequently near the top of “people’s favourite” lists. I feel that Mama Mia from the same era has ultimately had more impact – the show, the film, and now a restaurant opened by the band – but Dancing Queen is the song that would become a dance anthem and their only number 1 in the United States. It was one of 9 number 1’s in the U.K.
The song revolves around the joy of dancing itself, the musically draws on Euro disco, but the addition of classical piano among other production superlatives lifts it well above the 70s dance craze records.
Boys are back in town Thin Lizzy 1976
I first heard Thin Lizzy when they released Whiskey in the Jar, their interpretation of a traditional folk song. I thought “OK, good, but what next” – like most people I suspect. Well, soon after, the album Jailbreak was released containing the hit singles of the title track and the epic Boys are back in Town.
I saw Thin Lizzy in their prime at the Reading Festival in 1975 with my friend Chris Car, where we saw Joan Armatrading and Prog Rock band Yes as well, and at Bridlington Spa Hall with their classic line up of :
Phil Lynott – bass, vocals Gary Moore – guitar/Brian Robertson guitar Scott Gorham – guitar Brian Downey – drums
While working at Hull I visited the Spa quite often – so Lizzy could have been 1977 or 1979 – can’t work out which ! Or was it both! (Damn!.)Other groups I saw there were Darts and Madness, the latter of which remains one of my all-time favourite bands. But whatever happened to Darts!
Years later the song was made even more famous by its use in Toy Story 2.
“She was cool, she was red hot” was one of many classic lines on the record. Well, Phil himself was the coolest of cats. Phil, had you just lived longer, you would have seen your earlier son Macdargh and daughters by your wife Caroline Crowther (Leslie’s daughter) grow up. You may have persuaded your good friend George Best to look after himself. You might still have been living in your new house in Kew up the road from me. Most certain of all, you would have reformed the classic line up of Thin Lizzy and they would be the hottest ticket in town. I’d be there again.
Sex Pistols 1976 Anarchy in the UK
My family ask me why I like music played badly by badly behaved people. Well, you had to be there to understand. Of all the genres, Punk/New Wave is the one I felt most directly involved in – old enough to buy the records and go to gigs, but young enough to be about the same age as the participants. I wasn’t a Punk as such but I did dress up as one at a fancy dress party).
There have been many histories of punk but here is my principle chronology of the Punk experience.
On going up to Cambridge University in 1974 I began to read the New Musical express. Through 1975 the phenomenon of “pub rock” was featured heavily in the NME and I bought the Dr Feelgood Live album Stupidity in 1976, up there with The Who’s Live at Leeds as one of the great Live albums (and guitarist Wilko Johnson one of the greats too). “Back in the Night” and “Roxette” were Feelgood favourites. Also through the NME I became aware of the early American punk scene – principally in New York, the Ramones (“Blitzgried Bop”),early Iggy Pop, Blondie and Talking Heads and the New York Dolls – and also West Coast – the Flamin Groovies “Shake Some Action”.
Meanwhile Malcolm McLaren, having visited New York for himself, saw an opportunity to introduce New York punk rock to England. He and Vivienne Westwood at that time ran the rock’n’roll clothing shop on Kings Road, Chelsea (very near to where I would eventually live) called Let It Rock. (The shop supplied outfits to the That’ll Be the Day film and later Vivienne became fashion designer and Dame).They changed the name to SEX, changing the style of clothing to more avant garde. McLaren put together the Sex Pistols from his customers and their friends – Johnny Rotten, Steve Jones, Paul Cook, and Glen Matlock. MClaren was a student of the Situationist movement which inspired the French 1968 Left Bank rebellion and both he and Rotten (or Lydon as he was) used this as inspiration for the Punk ethos of the Pistols (and they wanted to make a few bob too!)
I began to read about the Sex Pistols in the NME and sure enough I walked into a Student Union bar in Cambridge in late 1976 and heard the famous words “I am an Anti Christ, I am an Anarchist” on the muffled juke vinyl box. At first I was a little puzzled – the music was slower than expected, compared to, say, the Ramones 100 m.p.h.style. Nevertheless, I was hooked after that.
My first (and only) punk gig was the Damned and the Adverts at Cambridge Corn Exchange in mid 1977. This was a rare occasion where town and gown met. The Corn Exchange was more used to gentle Folk Festival music, but here was a mixture of genuine local Punks, and students like me who just liked the music.
The Damned were actually, arguably the first UK Punk band to release a single – New Rose, championed by John Peel, was released fractionally before Anarchy. New Rose and Neat Neat Neat are still regarded as classics – certainly among my favourites.
Throughout 1977 and into 1978 there was an astonishing plethora of classic Punk and then New Wave records released. I bought many of them, singles and LP’s alike. The Clash (featuring former Pub Rocker in the 101ers Joe Strummer), White Riot and White Man in Hammersmith Palais; the Stranglers, Get a Grip, Peaches, No More Heroes and the ultimate Punk Album name Rattus Norvegicus; the Undertones, Teenage Kicks and My Perfect Cousin; Elvis Costello, I Don’t Want to Go to Chelsea and Watching the Detectives; the Jam, In the City and Down in The Tube Station at Midnight; Eddie and the Hotrods (Get Out of Denver, Do Anything You Wanna Do); and Ian Dory (former lead of pub rockers Bursal Fliers) Sex and Drugs and Rock’n’Roll and Hit Me With Your Rhythm Stick.
The list could go on – I bought them all and still have a great Punk and New Wave vinyl collection. That 1976-1980 period was hugely exciting – almost every month a new classic record would be released. Punk was famous for its anarchistic, rebellious attitude and its aggression (Rotten’s famous quote to a Pistol’s audience: “I bet we hate you more than you hate us”): but I just prefer to remember the great music.
A little known fact is the link from the Sex Pistols and Punk Rock to football; it seems Paul Cook the drummer was a keen Chelsea Fan, Stuart Pearce the fearsome England full back a Stranglers Fan and in general the anarchic, occasionally violent genres of Punk and 70’s football terraces, including the hooligans, do fit together; for instance on one of my favourite Punk Bands Sham 69 The Kids are United is sung in football style chanting.
So back to the group which kicked it all off – the Sex Pistols. If God Save the Queen – specially released in time for the Queen’s Jubilee in 1977 by Richard Branson’s Virgin label – was the record which exploded rock music as we knew it – then Anarchy in the UK was the record which lit the fuse.
This video version shows Anarchy played live with original writer Glen Matlock on bass. While here is a later video – the studio recording – with Sid Vicious now in the group. Matlock, a very competent musician, was infamously sacked for liking the Beatles too much, to be replaced by Sid Vicious, not a musician at all but whose all-round attitude suited the band’s image better at the time.
The Never Mind album followed and two more classic Singles (Pretty Vacant and Holidays in the Sun, which together with Anarchy and God Save the Queen make one of the great “sequence of four” consecutive singles). And then it was all over, at Winterland, California. Rotten walked off stage- “ever get the feeling you have been cheated”. Well, yes, Johnny but what a legacy: the Pistols influence was genuinely, somehow far greater than what they actually were. A band lasting two years only, but what a two years. Truly the spirit of Punk, after all.
Fleetwood Mac Go Your Own Way 1976
I first heard Fleetwood Mac in 1969, as most did with the No.1 single Albatross. I loved it but they never made another track like it. No matter, I have been following the band ever since, up to including reading drummer Mick Fleetwood’s autobiography and seeing the band live at the O2 with Alison in 2015 (no need then to see the tribute band, Fleetwood Bac, down at the Boom Boom Club).
More of the concert later, let us start with the truly original line up, built around guitarist Peter Green, Mick Fleetwood and bass player John McVie. (Peter Green, then leader, named the group graciously round his bass player and drummer). Mick Fleetwood had left school at 15 to start his drumming career in the London beat boom. His dyslexia led to a highly instinctive, unique drumming style. In the early to mid 1960’s he played in Shotgun Express with Rod Stewart, and in a group called the Cheynes, named after fashionable Cheyne Road, Chelsea, round the corner from where Alison and I would be married (see photo, the tall Mick Fleetwood apparent). He joined John Mayall’s Bluesbreakers, home to so many future rock stars. Including Peter Green. John McVie, with whom Mick helped form “Peter Green’s Fleetwood Mac”.
Oh Well, Green Manalishe and Man of the World followed Albatross to establish Fleetwood Mac not just as Britain’s top Blues group but also one of the highest record sellers – outselling the Beatles in 1969/1970. Peter Green was the focal point – if reluctantly – and is one of Britain’s greatest ever guitarists. Watch the Oh Well part 1 video, which with the slow atmospheric, acoustic Part 2 makes it one of my personal all-time favourite singles.
Meanwhile Christine Perfect had already made one of my favourite records, with Chicken Shack, called “I’d Rather Go Blind” (years later I was to bizarrely see Chicken Shack play a gig in a small Austrian ski resort). After she married John, to become Christine McVie, she joined the band as pianist/vocalist.
However, at the peak of their success, Fleetwood Mac lost their founder Peter Green, never the same after an acid trip in Germany. As luck would have it, in an American recording studio, Mick Fleetwood heard Lindsay Buckingham and Steve Nicks play and later invited them to join the group. The new sound of the second incarnation of Fleetwood Mac was born.
The rest, as they say, is history.
After the eponymous breakthrough album for the new group spawned hit singles like the epic Rhiannon (Stevie Nicks on vocals) and Say That You Love Me (Christine McVie), the album slow burned up to No. 1 in the U.S.A. and I certainly bought my copy. So the anticipation for Rumours was already huge and it did not disappoint. The various relationship problems in the band (the McVie’s were splitting up, Nicks left Buckingham, she had an affair with Fleetwood) if anything added to the quality and authenticity of the lyrics. As can be heard on the break-up songs Go Your Own Way, which has become what is generally viewed as the band’s best ever record, and Don’t Stop (later adopted by Bill Clinton for his inauguration). Dreams has emerged as one of the great songs too. The Chain of course became the sound of Formula 1, and the album as a whole with 40 million plus sales is in the top ten all time highest sellers.
Musically, Go Your Own Way is curious and all the better for that. I have always felt that the in first few bars, the band is reaching for rhythm but not quite making it. False starts if you like. A bit like Street Fighting Man. So I was pleased to hear recently that Lyndsey on acoustic and electric guitar, and Mick on drums, were aware of this, but kept the complex opening because they loved playing it. Today the awkwardness would be smoothed out by a cast of thousand focus groups and producers, but it actually emphasises the joy when the chorus kicks in. If joy is the right word, mind – you still feel that Stevie still hasn’t forgiven Lyndsey for writing the song about her. But the band has kept going – for two main reasons. They all love the music, and Mick has stayed true to his vision that they are band truly worth saving.
And so finally I achieved a lifelong ambition, in 2015, when Alison (who had already seen the band live in Germany) and I went to see their concert at the O2 London as part of their reunion tour with the classic line up of the 1970’s. What struck me was this: although Mick Fleetwood is the leader and manager of the band and a great technical drummer (who with John McVie forms one of the great rhythm sections) it is now Lyndsey Buckingham who is the creative genius and master live performer in the band, and a wonderful guitarist. Stevie Nicks retains that wonderfully mysterious but powerful voice and charismatic stage presence – her live performances of Rhiannon are very dramatic – and the happily un-retired Christine McVie booked her place on the Left Hand side of the stage behind keyboards (as we look) just like always. Her voice still sounded as it did all those years ago on Rather Go Blind and Over My Head, and she looked pretty much the same age too. Sadly she passed not many years after this concert.
One person was missing for me, though the group may not all agree. Peter Green long ago left the major music scene, but still occasionally plays low profile concerts and still plays beautifully. Is it too late for Mick and John to invite their old friend Peter on stage, perhaps for a one-or two song reunion? Perhaps they have, but sadly he declined? After all, he named the group after them all those years ago.
David Bowie Heroes 1977
Not a big hit at the time. But has crept up to be one of the all-time great and most popular songs. David Bowie recorded this in his Berlin period and indeed the song concerns a boy girl story either side of the Berlin Wall. Appropriate because years later the song supposedly played a part in the dismantling of the wall and the Soviet empire. The music was composed before the lyrics but was always meant to sound “heroic”. Brian Eno – of Roxy Music fame – was the producer and between his synthesisers, King Crimson’s Robert Fripp on guitar, and Toni Visconti produced a stirring synthesiser sound. Bowie’s singing style was unusual in that microphones were placed at 9inches, 20 feet and 50 feet, a “gating” technique, and this contributed to his occasional screeching, to reach the final microphone.
The B side always interested me, named V-2 Schneider. Showing just how much Bowie was absorbing Berlin influences at that time.
So, a wonderful, inspiring song ideal for sporting events like the Olympics. (But I still can’t understand the Dolphins bit). Bowie scholar David Buckley has written that “Heroes” “is perhaps pop’s definitive statement of the potential triumph of the human spirit over adversity”.[11]
I Feel Love Donna Summer 1977
If you took the average of all the “best dance/club” records ever this I believe would be come out top, even today, and deservedly so. Highly innovative, Giorgio Moroder, the Italian producer based in the famous Munich Musicland studio in Germany, and British producer Pete Bellotti, laid down one of the first purely synthesiser tracks using a soul singer aimed at the club scene. The usual strings were absent. I loved the synthesised Osinato bass lines, especially the piece in the middle where it slows down and appears to get louder. The Wharfdale speakers I had at the time – taking up large proportions of my room – were perfect to turn up the amplifier Bass and watch the speaker covers vibrate and casings thud.
Post-War music in the UK and Europe took a different direction to the USA in the 50’s and 60’s. Whereas in America the thread was the fusing of Country and Rhythm and Blues to form Rock’n’Roll, in Europe there were radical advancements in Electronic music, including the BBC’s Delia Derbyshire’s Radiophonic Workshop production of the Dr Who Theme, and in Germany and France classical musicians such as Stockhausen and Schoener were the fore-runners of Kraftwerk, Can and Jean Michelle Jarre’s ambient mood music and eventually into the Electronic Dance Music of the Orb and Orbital and Bronski Beat. Although the Moog Synthesiser had started life in the USA and its predecessor the Theramin was used by Brian Wilson on Good Vibrations, it was Europeans who seemed to sense extended synthesiser possibilities. The Beatles had used a Moog on Abbey Road Tracks such as Here Comes the Sun and in fact after use shipped their model back to Germany from which the same or similar model ended up being the core of the synthesised sound on I Feel Love.
The track influenced Brian Eno while producing Bowie’s Berlin trilogy, and was the forerunner of High Energy, Techno and EDM. Yes, Kraftwerk had begun to make electronic dance music by then, but while Autobahn was for the brain, I Feel Love was for the soul. It became a disco favourite and joined the 70’s American boom of Studio 54 and Saturday Night Fever
Some people feel that Donna got lucky to be picked to sing this, but consider this. She had a German husband. Her ethereal vocals were superb, she went on to make many more classics like Last Dance, MacArthur’s Park, Hot Stuff and Bad Girls. (Hers is one of my favourite Greatest Hits collections). The video shows her real stage presence too.
Hotel California The Eagles 1977
Hearing the Eagles talking about the song’s lyrics confirms that Hotel California is a simple metaphor, rather than a complex metaphor of a metaphor as some have suggested. In other words, the story is just what it sounds like: a critique of the American music business and its participants, and their excesses, and of the American dream itself. The Eagles describe it as a passage from “innocence to experience”. Implying it is not especially bitter, more observational, gently ironic. The theme continued on their next single from the Hotel California album, Life in the Fast Lane.
The melody was conceived by then guitarist Don Felder as a kind of Latino, Mexican reggae (unusual for a country rock band!). This inspired the writers Don Henley and the late great Glen Frey to imagine a Hotel (perhaps based on Beverley Hills) in Southern California or the New Mexico desert, at which a traveller stops and finds a variety of voices and stories (“some dance to remember, some dance to forget”…”we are all just prisoners here of our own device” ). Closing of course with the classic line “You can check out any time you like, but you can never leave!”
Check out the video, showing the “best ever guitar solo” fought out by Don Felder and Joe Walsh (of Rocky Mountain Way fame). Think Duelling Banjos. The two guitarists took many days to compose, rehearse and record this extended closing solo, made even more complex by Felder’s use of his double-fret 12 string guitar. For me, the introduction is equally memorable – this time multi-acoustic guitars, a wistful opening punctuated suddenly by the initially surprising, and now familiar, double drum beat lead into the reggae rhythm. The record won a Grammy for the record of the year and is in the Rolling Stone Magazine’s top fifty records of all time.
I missed the chance in 2006 to see the Eagles at my local venue – Twickenham stadium – at which they closed the show (before encore) with Hotel California. My guess is that with Glen Frey’s demise, we will never see the Eagles on tour again. Over the years they had several great lead guitarists, but Frey and Henley were the constant members who defined the Eagles. Talking of which, one of many reasons I love the Eagles is that Don Henley is one of a select club – the drummer/lead singer. Think Dave Clark, Karen Carpenter, Phil Collins in Genesis and Foo Fighter’s Dave Grohl. Details like that appeal to me. I must get out more!
If I never get to see the Eagles play live, the next best thing, well actually well down the list, may be to see a tribute band, And this I have done in fact, attending the “Alter Egos” concert at the Boom Boom Club in Sutton, West London. Invited by my friend Graham – such a spitting image for the band’s lead singer I though he was on stage – I hugely enjoyed hearing pretty well all the Eagles hits played and sung beautifully, right down to the epic duelling guitar solos of Hotel California.
Pink Floyd Another Brick in the Wall 1978 .
Pink Floyd were never a great singles band but with Another Brick in the Wall finally achieved worldwide number 1 single status including a long spell as Christmas number 1 in the UK. What started as another rock sung from the eponymous Album grew both musically and conceptually. The Band although arguably well educated themselves felt that schools were too domineering and pupils needed more freedom. Roger Waters especially was a burgeoning protest song writer and brough in a real school choir from Islington Green to emphasise the sentiment. The producer suggested that a disco beat be brought in to make the track more “of the times” and while sceptical the band accepted. The song has several parts and the single removes some but not all of the peculiarities such as “if you can’t eat your meat you cant have your pudding ” Another Brick in the Wall was from The Wall album which created a huge tour in which the Band gradually disappeared behind a slowly constructed wall on stage, and its operatic nature generated a film
The choir initially didn’t get paid Royalties – eventually corrected. Their style revealed the beginnings of the modern London accent and while the severity of punishments had to be eliminated this song was the beginning you could argue of the breakdown of school discipline.
Floyd earlier achieved Album success with Wish You Were here and particularly Dark Side of the Moon, an album which absolutely dominated the charts in the mid 1970’s. I first came across Pink Floyd in the 1960’s ’through their singles See Emily Play and Arnold Lane. My older friends preferred their albums, Piper at the Gates of Dawn, Umma Gumma, and Atom Heart Mother, especially as it looked great carrying the album sleeves into the Sixth Form common room. The band heralded from a mixture of North London and Cambridge (technical college) locations and were classed originally as Undergound, then as Progressive, or Psychedelic, Rock (and finally as just mega!)
The Progressive Rock movement of the early 1970’s – which later helped launch the Punk genre as a reaction against it – included bands such as Pink Floyd, Yes and King Crimson (again with memorable album covers) and also the Nice and Emerson Lake and Palmer, both featuring of course the now late lamented Keith Emerson. As an example of how experimental and inclusive progressive rock could be, it is worth mentioning some of Keith Emerson’s contributions: a version of Leonard Bernstein’s America from West Side Story spiced with elements of Dvorjak’s New World Symphony; the composition and recording of the Five Bridges Suite (referring to the bridges over Newcastle’s River Tyne); Fanfare for the Common Man adapted from Aaron Copleland’s piece; and the live recording at Newcastle City Hall of Muzorsky’s Pictures at an Exhibition.
One of the first signs of a backlash against Progressive rock was when underground and future champion of punk DJ John Peel described an ELP festival concert as a “waste of talent and electricity”; and the backlash became a flood when Johnny Rotten deployed his infamous “I hate Pink Floyd” T-shirt.
Rather unfairly, Prog Rock developed an “uncool” reputation, but for instance it gave rise to the great Peter Gabriel, and Roxy’s early Brian Eno-inspired tracks clearly incorporated some Prog Rock features. Keith Emerson, Rick Wakeman and Floyd’s Richard Wright especially developed the use of keyboard synthesisers: Emerson for instance took the Moog and Hammond organ to new heights. And think of this: so much of modern EDM (electronic dance music) is synthesiser or electronica based. The Orb, KLF, Can, Georgio Morooder and Kraftwerk were all exponents of early programmable dance music which eventually evolved into the techno, ambient, Ibiza and EDM genres.
The current progressive Deep House movement – of which one of the most Streamed tracks of all time, Clean Bandit’s Rather Be, is an example – owes a lot to progressive rock in terms of the spirit of experimentation and the use of electronica. Progressive Rock is known by some for it’s “ten minute guitar solos” but in fact it’s use of keyboards was the really innovative and enduring element. Just to complete the circle, two examples: Pink Floyd’s David Gilmour contributed to the Orb’s recent Metallic Spheres album, and my personal favourite Progressive record, King Crimson’s 21st Century Schizoid Man, has recently been covered by rapper Kanye West and the sample then used in the Pacco Rabanne after shave advert. Who’d have thunk it! (and I still call it after shave, I can’t abide the term “men’s fragrance”! )
So hands off Prog Rock! And was Dark Side of the Moon even truly Prog Rock at all? Well, let’s just say it was one of the greatest albums of all time and the third highest seller ever with 40 million plus units sold, and counting.
As the new decade arrived, Pink Floyd faced a dilemma. Syd Barret was forced to leave the band when his creative genius as a founder member was outweighed by his depression, instability and addictions. Guitarist David Gilmour replaced him. Should they leave behind Syd’s memory altogether, or somehow incorporate it? In fact Dark Side of the Moon, and the subsequent album, arguably even better, Wish You Were Here, both dealt extensively with Syd’s illness in the lyrics in tracks such as Brain Damage and Shine on You Crazy Diamond.
The album was recorded in Abbey Road studios from late 1972 to early 1973. It is said that recordings were sometimes interrupted because the band wished to watch Monty Python episodes, and Roger Waters took time off to see Arsenal F.C. Recording would have just finished by the time I travelled to Hillsboro in Sheffield with my brother Malcolm and his wife Susan, to see our football team Sunderland play and beat Arsenal in the semi-final of the F.A. Cup, before beating Leeds at Wembley. Perhaps Roger Waters was at that semi-final?
The recording used, as you might expect, very advanced recording techniques, and also an array of unusual sound effects, from simulated heartbeats on Breathe, alarm clocks on Time to cash registers on Money. And also the use of doormen and roadies to answer a series of Flash Card questions, to record their sometimes banal, sometimes amusing, answers. This is where the famous spoken phrase, “There is no dark side of the moon, really. As a matter of fact it’s all dark” came from. The band’s use of unusual effects didn’t always work. When I came up to Cambridge, a friend and I were listening to an earlier track, Grantchester Meadows (devotees of the current Detective Series will know this is near Cambridge). I highlighted the recorded sound of a fly buzzing from one speaker to another. My friend said “so what”. He had a point!
The single Time, released in 1974, was one of two official singles from the album, the other being Money. Neither reached the same chart status as Another Brick but it didn’t matter. The album was the thing. The clocks on Time were actually not recorded specifically for the track, rather they were sound checks by engineer Alan Parsons (of Project fame). But those rock stars were wacky in those days – “let’s get them on the track!”. The lyrics are of the Lennon “life is what happens while you are making other plans” type –seize the moment before it’s too late, or else “ten years have got behind you”, and “hanging on in quiet desperation is the English way”. The female vocalist who supplies the soaring chorus is not Clare Torry, who sings most of the non-lexical (words that are not words) vocals on the album. Rather, it was soul singer Doris Troy.
Pink Floyd were never really a singles band, so it’s difficult to say which is their best track. Comfortably Numb is often described as their best, but for me it is all about the guitar solo (David Gilmour is now recognised as one of the great guitarists, for instance with the solo on Comfortably Numb). . Wish You Were Here is probably my favourite, a simple, acoustic powerful song which it was great to hear Ed Sheeran play at the London Olympics ceremony with Floyd’s Nick Mason on drums.
While Another Brick in the Wall was the Group’s first and only worldwide hot single, Dark Side of the Moon for me encapsulates what Pink Floyd were all about. And finally – I have long owned the famous Dark Side of the Moon prism logo T-shirt, and this inspired me last year to pose the question “could you wear a Pink Floyd T-shirt in a GCSE Physics exam” on my Tutoring website.
Gloria Gaynor . I Will Survive 1978
Recently nominated for the Washington library of congress (*) along with the Supremes Where Did Our Love Go, it joins the Gutenberg Bible and Thomas Jefferson personal book collection. The reason is this; as well as being a great disco song, it’ a very affirmative, inspirational lyric. In one sense old fashioned compared to the electronic “I Feel Love”, nevertheless the song has itself survived down the years, to emerge near the top of “favourite dance tracks ever”. But I still cannot get the Roller Skater in the video!
(*) Sadly not the library in Washington County Durham where my father was born, but its namesake in the capitol city of America.
The Bee Gees . Stayin Alive 1978
In Hull where I was working at the time, The Waterfront Club was the coolest club, but Tiffany’s by the train station was the true disco. The Bee Gees Night Fever and Stayin Alive seemed to be on a permanent loop there for several years. These songs were part of the Robert Stigwood/John Travolta film Saturday Night Fever, with Stayin Alive being marginally the most well known and influential, partly because of its positioning at the beginning of the film. The lyrics reflect the struggle for survival on the tough streets of New York.
Sadly, the group won’t now play again, but Barry Gibb especially has his place as one of the greatest of pop composers. At one stage he was writer of four successive No.1 records for four different artists in the U.S.A., a feat never repeated.
I had followed the Bee Gees right from the start. Our family bought a copy of their very first UK hit in 1967 called New York Mining Disaster 1941. In one sense this was a very unlikely Bee Gees song – “I keep straining my ears to hear a sound, maybe someone is digging underground” – but it set the scene as clever writers and significantly, perhaps deliberately – had a Beatles feel about it. In fact some listeners on first play thought it was the Beatles. I always felt the spirit and sound of Eleanor Rigby was in there somewhere.
More hits followed like To Love Somebody and Massachusetts. However, by the early 1970’s the hits were drying up and ironically the band were reduced to playing the kind of small Northern variety nightclubs that in a few years’ time would become discos playing the Bee Gees songs. The turning point came with a move in 1975 to Miami, Florida, and with producer Arid Mardin they began to record more soul-oriented music, with Barry Gibb turning to falsetto style vocals. The singles Nights on Broadway, You Should be Dancing and Jive Talking were big hits. The rest, as they say, is history. The Bee Gees didn’t invent disco music but rode the wave and ended up in a sense defining the era. I often look back at that 1975-1979 period as one of the greatest in popular music, combining as it did two such influential (yet so different) genres – punk and disco.
London Calling The Clash 1979
The album London Calling is often described as The Clash’s best, and an all time great rock album, because of the sheer range of styles – post punk, roots reggae, ska, rockabilly. But still all with the “quickly made in a garage” style, and political lyrics, so attractive in punk. And of course, the iconic “like-Elvis” album cover with Mick Jones smashing the guitar.
The title track was still fairly close to the Punk sound – but much more polished. It tells the story of a “nuclear error” mimicking Three Mile Island, perhaps imagining that only a few people are left in the bunker; and despite living “by the river” (Thames) they are still able to send a radio signal out. The famous line about “phoney Beatlemania has bitten the dust” refers to the band’s worries post punk of retaining their own popularity. Apocalyptic and highly atmospheric, my own view is that song perhaps unconsciously was a call to arms to establish London as the cultural capital it was to become today, after the grey economic depression of the 1970’s. For instance an unlikely use of the song was in James Bond’s Die Another Day, when the song is played triumphantly as James (Pierce Brosnan) flies back to London on British Airways. Recognition: #15 on Rolling Stone magazines’s all time greatest 500 songs.
The sound of Punk growing up, the track established the Clash as greatest of all British Punk bands, achieving more longevity than the Pistols, and establishing the band in America. More classics were to come – “Should I Stay or Should I Go” and “Rockin the Casbah” before an eventual break up and Joe Strummer’s all too young passing away.
Blondie Heart of Glass 1979
Recorded in 1978 and released January 1979 his became a worldwide hit and arguably Blondie’s signature song. Some said that they jumped on the disco bandwagon, and “sold out”, but that’s not true. Yes, Blondie had emerged though the New York punk scene and along with the Ramones and New York Dolls had helped establish it, prior even to the British punk revolution. But when Debby Harry and Chris Stein played at a benefit gig for punk drummer Johnny Blitz at the famous CBGB’s club in 1978 in New York (he had been attacked, stabbed and hospitalised) they decided to play a version of Donna Summer’s I Feel Love, much to the crowd’s amazement. At that time rock versus disco was a major battle. Further, it was Chris and Debbie that invited Chic’s Nile Rogers to an early hip hop event which was eventually to lead to the famous bass line on Good Times and Rappers Delight. And Debbie had already expressed admiration in interviews for Georgio Moroeder and Kraftwerk.
So when producer Mike Chapman discussed a disco version of Heart Of Glass, for the Parallel Lines album, a song written by Chris and Debbie four years earlier, the group were happy to experiment. The drums and baseline make it: the sound actually combines a drum machine and real drums.
The iconic video features Debbie at her best, asymmetric dress and all, convincing hundreds of thousands of teenagers to keep a poster of Debbie on their walls. All of this makes Heart of Glass one of the greatest of all tracks in both a disco and new wave sense – an amazing feet to combine two such distinct genres.
Michael Jackson Don’t Stop Till You Get Enough 1979
Michael we knew was a supremely talented child star. The Jackson 5 had perhaps lost the battles against their rivals the Osmonds, but ultimately won the war of longevity and credibility. I Want You Back and ABC are bona fida classics. Michael’s solo work such as Got To Be There, and the Jackson’s “Dancing Machine”, “Show You the Way to Go” and “Shake Your Body” kept things moving upwards through the 1970’s, but nothing could prepare us for the impact of “Off The Wall” in 1979.
What struck me first was the album cover – the tuxedo ,the Afro haircut, set against the brickwall background – clearly something different was signalled. Indeed it was, Michael’s first solo record on Epic Records as opposed to Motown, and the first with producer Quincy Jones.
I bought the album immediately on release, and when I played Side 1 Track 1, Don’t Stop Till You Get Enough, the first few bars simply blew me away and still do. Michael mumbles at first, then announces his arrival as a superstar with the iconic falsetto holler, before Quincy’s intricate jazz/funk/disco arrangement kicks in, and Michael’s impossibly high vocal is then played alongside his own deeper response. Now known as the pair’s signature sound, but highly innovative at the time. After 4 minutes an unforgettable moment occurs when the synthesised brass sound simply explodes and we have a dance floor anthem of a sophisticated type only matched by Earth Wind and Fire’s Boogie Wonderland.
The video for the song reveals a number of things: the first showing of Michael’s new dance style, the rolling up of the sleeve, the long legs, the sheer charisma of the man: the video only features him and you cannot take your eyes off him. And the smile on his face. The sheer joy of entertaining. The world at his feet. Not a care Before the problems kicked in. But let’s remember innocent days when the child star became the hugely talented young man.
Decade 1980’s
Jam 1980 Going Underground
Last year I visited a memorable retrospective of the Jam’s career at Somerset House in London called “About a Young Idea” (the lyric from their first record, In the City). A number of things struck me. A poster showing the NME readers’ poll results reminded me just how amazingly popular the Jam were. Best band, best album, best single, best singer, best everything. And that Paul Weller’s school report contained no encouragement from his music teacher !
The Jam had launched with Punk Rock but had survived its gradual decline. I had followed the band from the very start The early singles, all seeming to include the word “World” (including News of the World” now famous as the title music of “Mock the Week”). Then what I’d call interesting singles – like “A Bomb in Wardour Street” and “Down in the Tube Station at Midnight”. Then the top twenty breakthrough singles, “When You’re Young” – “any guitar and any base drum” – and “Strange Town” – I just love the reference to A to Z guidebook. Then the classic top ten single “Eton Rifles” – “there’s a row going on, down in Slough” – which later David Cameron described as his favourite song while at the College, which Paul Weller did not particularly appreciate. As a Cambridge graduate, I understood the “town versus gown” problem, and as Royal Grammar School boy, I understood the “cadet force” context.
But all these songs were really leading up to the seismic breakthrough of Going Underground. Straight in at Number One, at the time almost unprecedented. For a Punk/New Wave group – incredible. The whole of the Jam’s back catalogue was rereleased and was all over the singles charts. The excitement at the time was incredible. Further Number One’s followed – Start, Beat Surrender and A Town Called Malice (of Billy Elliot fame). And That’s Entertainment, with their Five O’Clock Hero, are still the UK’s best-selling import singles – “wake up at 6am on a cool warm morning”. Watch this reat video for the softer side of the Jam. My view is that The Jam are one of Britain’s greatest ever groups – many critics concur. Paul Weller’s voice really came through once he realised he didn’t need to mimic American accents. Woking, South London was fine. And he has emerged as one of our greatest guitarists, lyricists and composers. And we shouldn’t forget Bruce Foxton on guitar and Rick Buckler on drums, superb musicians in their own right.
Going Underground itself has a memorable guitar-burst intro, then “some people might say my life is in a rut”, followed by “the public gets what the public wants”…”kidney machines replaced by rockets and bombs”. As ever Foxton’s bass does more than just provide the rhythm it’s a lead instrument in its own right. The overall feeling of the record is both disturbing and yet uplifting, highly commercial and danceable. The sequence of singles – Strange Town, When You’re Young, Eton Rifles, Going Underground, and Start surely being one of the greatest in music history.
Watch this video to witness the trademarks of the Jam Live – playing Going Underground – superb musicians, audience excitement (“this boy shouts, this boy screams!”), the enormous sound that the threesome makes. And the boys as ever immaculately dressed!
Abba Winner Takes It All 1980 Recorded in 1980, Winner Takes It All is frequently voted to be the “best Abba song”. Written by Bjorn Ulvaeus, sung by Agnetha Fältskog, the pair had just divorced. It is assumed the song reflects the personal reality of their break-up, and though the couple deny it, Agnetha’s faltering voice towards the song’s close suggests otherwise, as does the original working title “The story of my life”. The song is from the Super Trouper album, their last great L.P. and “Winner” was their second last UK No.1, the last being the title track. The beauty of the composition is that it is both simple yet complex at the same time. There is one key – F sharp major – and essentially only one melody throughout – perhaps two depending on definition – but the melody builds through the first three verses before slowing for the final heartbreak of the last verse.
Back in Black AC DC 1980 Being a Physics tutor I always like to think of Alternating Current and Direct Current as opposed to “swings both ways” ! The lead singer Brian Johnson replaced the sadly demised Bon Scott who sang on the early records like Highway to Hell. Brian is from Newcastle, and was lead singer of the group “Geordie”. In effect plucked from relative obscurity, he helped relaunch the Australian band, and their first new record was “Back in Black”, an album that on many counts is described as the 2nd highest album seller in history by anyone, behind only Thriller by Michael Jackson, showing the enormous world wide appeal of hard blues rock. The distinctive musical sound of ACDC is of course the lead guitar, played by the still school-uniform wearing Angus Young, one of the world’s great guitarists. The riff to the single from the album is one of the most played and learned – my son Matthew plays it near perfect. The more famous singles from the album are Rock N Roll Aint Noise Pollution and Shook Me All Night Long, but it is the title track that has gradually grown in status down the years. Like many “serious” rock fans it took me a while to warm to ACDC. At the time they were thought of as the “uncool” side of Heavy Metal. But the band’s inclusion in Hollywood Blockbusters soundtracks like Iron Man and Battlefield, and Computer game music, means that you simply can’t avoid hearing them, and the more I hear the more I like. Angus Young’s riffs are utter genius – and his playing technically superb, he effectively invented a style of playing – and Brian Johnson screeching vocals elevate the performance to breaking point. Will be interesting how Axl Rose from Guns N Roses gets on filling in for Brian Johnson in 2016 – Brian is taking time off, possibly permanently, because of deafness brought on I guess by years of standing by the amplifiers.
Vienna Ultravox 1981
The record that truly launched 1980’s music – at least the synthesised style that we now know as “eighties music”. Recorded in 1980, released January 1981, Vienna was recently voted as Britain’s favourite No.2 record on BBC Radio 2 – ahead of Fairytale of New York, Penny Lane and We Are The Champions – and famously kept off the top by Joe Dolce’s “Shaddup Your Face” Vienna is a synthpop record with several synthesisers including synthbass, although the distinctive mid-record faster instrumental break is a conventional viola completed by grand piano. The video invokes the film -noir spirit of Orson Welles famous 1948 film the Third Man, with Harry Lime as the anti-hero. Screenplay by Graeme Greene, the expressionist film famously features the dimly lit streets and shadowy doorways favoured in the Vienna video. It also features the famous “Swiss cuckoo clock” speech – think: what have the Romans ever done for us –and also the zither sound track, but that’s another story (or is it, I wonder if use of such a “different” instrument inspired the synthesiser sounds or the viola solo?) Actually there are several odd things about the video. First, strictly it isn’t a video at all, it is a collection of still photographs, mostly black and white to create the moody atmosphere, directed by Russel Mulcahy. Second, much of it is set not in Vienna, but in London’s Kilburn and Covent Garden (the band had to cut corners, funding the £6,000 video after the record company declined to pay!). Third, as well as the Third Man, the video also seems to invoke Austrian symbolist painter Gustav Klimit. Midge Ure later admitted that he made up the Klimit connection well afterwards !
And a strange fact about the lyric. When composing the music, group members Chris Cross and Billy Currie were discussing the comparison of the sound to composer Max Reger, the innovative, minimalist German composer principally of fuges. Midge Ure, walked in on the conversation, did not understand it, and turned away complaining “this means nothing to me”. The rest is history as they say, the phrase became a memorable, key part of the lyric. (Courtesy: SongFacts)
Ultravox had a chequered career till then. Formed mid 1970’s as a punk rock/new wave/art-rock outfit and lead by John Foxx, the band released several records which commercially failed. The band seemed finished, the Island record label dropped them, and Foxx left to have some minor solo hits such as Burning Car and Underpass (song titles very much of the time!
Meanwhile young Glaswegian Jim “Midge” Ure had spent time in teen-favourites Slik (remember their No.1 Forever and Ever?), and Sex Pistol Glen Matlock’s Rich Kids (remember power-pop?); in Viasge (Fade to Grey, co-written by Midge); contributed to fellow Scots group the Skids (of Into the Valley fame); and even briefly joined Thin Lizzy (touring with them as guitarist, taking over from Gary Moore no less). One of the reasons Midge left Rich Kids was because he had purchased a synthesiser and “musical differences” took him away from a purely guitar and drums sound. So when the chance came to replace Foxx in Ultravox it seemed a natural progression, especially as Mk1 Ultravox’s Billy Currie had already worked with Midge in Visage. The label Chrysalis picked up the group The reformed Ultravox’s first album Vienna was released in 1980, a slow burner which really took off after the single’s success, and eighties synth music was launched. There is an argument that Kraftwerk’s Autobahn in 1974, or Gary Numan with ground breaking and influential No.1’s, Are Friends Electric and Cars in 1979, or Human League Mark 1 with “Being Boiled” in 1978, invented 80’s music.
After all, didn’t the Undertones write and record this line in 1979 in one of my all-time favourite records, “My Perfect Cousin”: “His mother bought him a synthesiser / Got the Human League in to advise her / Now he’s making lots of noise / Playing along with the art school boys” (In fact my truly favourite line from the song about cousin Kevin is this: “he always beat me at Subbuteo, ‘cos he flicked the kick and I didn’t know”. (The “kick” being the ball, and for those unacquainted with Subbuteo rules (is there anyone?), touching it with your finger is illegal)
But the clue about eighties music is in the title. The mid-late 1970’s were still essentially the punk/new wave guitar years. Those early synthesiser records from the 1970’s were the exception not the rule. They didn’t quite fit. Continuing the Kevin theme, when Harry Enfield’s Kevin (from Kevin and Perry) turns 13 it is as if a switch (not a kick) is flicked and he instantaneously becomes a teenager. So when 1969 ticked over to 1970, things turned gloomy overnight. The Beatles split, Woodstock was over. Equally, when 1979 turned to 1980, truly a new decade launched as things seemed immediately brighter. Punk and disco were almost over, something new was needed in music. Although Vienna was a slow ballad record, it heralded the use the of synthesisers in what in many ways combined the spirit of punk and new wave with disco, namely fast joyous danceable music, but with simple synth riffs inspired by art rock. The glamour of new romantic outfits and hair do’s were added, replacing the harsher Mohican punk styles. And so eighties music became a genre – the last “genre of a decade” I believe. The nineties saw the fragmentation of music, then downloads kicked in. More of that later.
It is fascinating how Midge Ure, a canny Scot, hedged his bets and kept several different bands going until he hit the jackpot with Vienna and in doing so re-formed the failed group Ultravox from the Mark 1 version (One can imagine Simon Cowell advising him, “you want to do what?” ). Midge certainly paid his dues and was rewarded with success with more Ultravox hits (Dancing with Tears in my Eyes) and solo records (If I Was). And of course, immortally, he was the cofounder of Band Aid. Midge later said that it raised millions for charity, but did nothing for his bank balance! After returning to Ultravox, so much had happened and the band soon split up. But what a legacy, sometimes forgotten.
Don’t You Want Me Human League 1981
As noted in the Ultravox review above, the Human League had actually been releasing experimental synthesiser records since 1978. Their evolution into the famous threesome we recognise was tortuous: founded by Martyn Ware and Ian Craig Marsh, the group’s name comes from a science fiction fantasy war game, Starforce Alpha Centauri: they wanted Glen Gregory, future Heaven 17 lead singer, but instead added a friend, Phil Oakey, a hospital porter, essentially because he was good looking and dressed well. But Oakey contributed lyrics to one of their first releases, the highly unusual Being Boiled, which became a cult NME favourite. Philip Adrian Wright, a friend of Oakey’s was added to provide film and lighting effects : he took the name “Director of Visuals” (long before the dreaded “Director of Football” became popular at soccer clubs !) All seemed to be going well, with Empire State Human and Holiday 80 leading to an early Top of the Pops appearance, and the band were referenced as synthesiser purveyors in the Undertones’ “My Perfect Cousin” (see Ultravox above). However, two main problems emerged. First, genuine success eluded them, and the clue was in the Undertones’ dismissal of them as “art school boys”: they declined to sacrifice their artistic credibility for commercial breakthrough. When Gary Numan hit No.1 with “Are Friends Electric” with a similar type of music, this seemed to invoke disillusion rather than inspiration . And this in turn lead to a split, with Oakey keen to continue the band, while Ware and Marsh joined Glen Gregory at Heaven 17, who enjoyed some success with Temptation, but it was Oakey who had made the right choice.
At first though, things did not look promising. Without any other main members, Oakey had to recruit quickly to fulfil a tour commitment. And what happened next goes into the legend and folklore of rock music – but is true.
Oakey was in a nightclub in hometown Sheffield, the Crazy Daisy on High Street, and spotted two girls dancing together. Susan Ann Sully and Joanne Catherall. After a short conversation he invited them to tour with the band as back-up singers, which they did, after checking with their parents (they were 17 and 18 years old, still at school). They joined full-time as the group’s album “Dare!” was released and successful singles like Sound of the Crowd and Love Action followed. These were outstanding records but a “filler” track (Oakey’s dismissive word”) was lurking unloved at the end of Vinyl side 2. Against Oakey’s wishes the track “Don’t You Want Me” was released as 4th single from the Dare! album by the record company. To his surprise, it quickly reached number 1, stayed there over Christmas (remember when it didn’t have to be the X-Factor release?) and sold 1.5 million copies including a No.1 spot in America. The British invasion Mk 2 had begun.
The opening line is unforgettable: “You were working as a waitress in a cocktail bar, when I met you” seems to partially mirror co-lead singer Susan Sully’s experience, but essentially it’s about male-female power politics. The video helped establish the MTV video channel, with its’ clever, even creepy, murder mystery story.
“They don’t make haircuts like this anymore”
I had followed Human League periodically in the early days – especially after the Undertones’ reference in 1979 – and was as surprised as anyone at their success and the recruitment of Susan and Joanne. But there is something delightfully “punk” about Oakey and then the girls arriving from nowhere with no training, and very quickly producing such a classic album (OK with help). Dare! is a masterpiece. The position of “Don’t You Want Me” as last track seems appropriate, as it heralds the transition from the “art school boys” of “Sound of the Crowd” on Side 1, into the international pop stars the group became. With a string of further classic singles such as American No.1 “Human” they certainly won the battle with Heaven 17 and they are still touring to this day.
Dare! is still one of my favourite vinyl albums. It was made without any conventional instruments – Casio, Roland, Korg synthesisers instead – and yet it has “soul” and New Wave spirit. Martin Rushent, producer, was actually credited with the title “programmer”: now that was a new type of music!
Specials Ghost Town 1981 In one senses Ghost Town was absolutely of its time, the riots in Brixton, London and across the UK happening exactly at the time in June 1981 that this record climbed to its’s No.1 position in the charts. It seemed the record and the riots, while not exactly cause and effect, were somehow linked. On the other hand, the record feels more like the end of one era – the 1970’s punk/new wave and reggae era and economic depression – rather than the new 1980’s era of synthesiser, the revival of the entrepreneurial spirit and the “greed is good,” Loadsa money” mantra.
But as a UK protest song it is an enduring gem. The ghost town in question is Coventry. “Deindustrialisation” – that word from O-Level geography – taking its toll. Unemployment rising, number of nightclubs falling (“all the clubs have been closed down”). The combination of Terry Hall’s deadpan delivery and Neville’s rap hit the spot, and the slow ska rhythm and tacky Hammond organ with ghostly backing vocals are delightful. The mood is edgy and contradictory – is it edge of the seat murder mystery, snake-charmer, or angry?
The mid-record fairground-style trumpet/trombone solo deliberately lightens the mood (“Do you remember the good old days before the ghost town” ) – reminding me of O-Level English in that the drunken Porter’s soliloquy comes from nowhere to punctuate Macbeth and Lady Macbeth’s gloom with light relief.
“Fighting on the dancefloor” is a line that resonates through not just the social unrest but also the group itself. Jerry Dammers, the musical genius behind the Specials, had written and produced many of the band’s up tempo ska revival Two-Tone hits such as No.1.Too Much Too Young, but had difficulty persuading his colleagues of the need for such a radical departure with “Ghost Town”. Soon after the record was released, the band began to split. And the clubs really did close. The song refers to a club, the Locarno Mecca in Coventry – which has now been replaced by the central library (something ironic about that!). And bringing the story up to date, between 2005 and 2015 the number of U.K. nightclubs has almost halved from 3500 to 1700 – and in early 2016 nightclub entrance fees were taken out of the “basket of goods” used in the U.K. inflation R.P.I. index. The reasons for closure are less now to do with social problems than with much less drinking out by the young in entrance-fee establishments.
For the video the band actually shot it in London but it conveys the right effect, famously featuring the band tightly packed in the 1962 Vauxhall Cresta . An earlier video for Message to You Rudy reminds me that the Skinhead movement was actually attached to the ska revival in a very positive way. Clearly one thinks of racism amongst some skinheads but they loved West Indian ska and reggae music. I have never quite understood that. Whatever, multi-racial groups emerged from this strange mix and “that’s all good” as they say. I loved the ska genre, but Ghost Town more or less marks the peak of the ska revival which the Specials and among others Madness, the Beat and the Selector lead – I still have the best of 2 Tone on vinyl. And while the Specials really were special, it was Madness who were to adapt and be ultimately more enduring. But sad as I was when the ska revival petered out, at least I didn’t have to pretend to be able to do that fantastic jerky dance. Mind you, when Madness “One Step Beyond” is played, I can’t help twitching my feet to the rockinest rock steady beat…
But with Ghost Town itself the Specials left a legacy that still rings true today. The record was a No.1 in the U.K. and voted “best single” of the year by all of the then holy trinity of NME, Sounds and Melody Maker. However, it was a hit almost nowhere else in the world, because it was so peculiarly British. It did not chart in America, but the message seems still to be relevant there today, and absolutely fits with the spirit of the American political protest song. And even in the U.K., while there may not be “fighting on the dance floor”, some shop closures leave our town centres with a ghost town feel.
Grandmaster Flash and the Furious Five The Message 1982 “It’s like a jungle sometimes It makes me wonder how I keep from goin’ under”. So begins perhaps the first great hip hop and rap record. I loved this record so much that I managed to include the chorus in my Master Of Business Administration (MBA) dissertation on the indirect economic effect of BP Chemicals Hull on the rest of Humberside. “Don’t push me cause I’m close to the edge I’m trying not to lose my head It’s like a jungle sometimes It makes me wonder how I keep from goin’ under” Goodness knows how I weaved these words in, or what the examiners thought (but anyway I passed!). The group were a pioneering group of DJ’s, rappers and MC’s they were one of the first to popularise black urban protest through the then underground medium of rap and record deck scratching. But were they truly the first? The Sugarhill Gang’s Rappers Delight, with the epic Good Times/Another One Bites the Dust bass line, and “Hotel, Motel, Holiday Inn” refrain, a couple of years earlier, may claim that crown. Both The Message and Rappers Delight were part of the Sugarhill Records collective. Another similarity is the sheer volume of words. In one sense I admire rappers for writing such long poems and actually remembering the lyrics, but sometimes I feel that, like Stevie Wonder, Marvin Gaye, John Lennon or Paul Weller, a few high impact phrases do just as well. Weller’s “the smell of petrol on a cool warm morning” for instance paints a wonderfully simple picture of urban life, while Stevie’s “To find a job is like a haystack needle, Cause where he lives they don’t use coloured people” hits hard in just a couple of lines.
One of the differences between Rappers Delight and The Message was their degree of optimism. I always felt the former was an essentially happy record, whereas the latter was pretty gloomy and threatening – but a sign of things to come perhaps. Nevertheless one of my favourite records of all time and often described by critics as the greatest rap record ever, even after all this time.
Blue Monday New Order 1982 Some rock groups (think Rolling Stones with “Miss You” and U2 with the remix of “Real Thing”) have made creditable attempts to mimic dance music. But New Order the rock group simply are a dance group. No divide. New Order made it cool for young males to dance to club music in the discos. The Waterfront in Hull was simply saturated in New Order’s basslines in the same way that Donna Summer’s I Feel Love achieved. New Order emerged from the ashes of Joy Division after the untimely death of Ian Curtis at the time of his greatest triumph with Love Will Tear Us Apart, Faced with a decision of whether to carry on, Bernard Sumner took up the challenge of leading singing. Early hits Temptation and Ceremony were followed by Blue Monday which featured Gillian Gilbert’s Synth and Synthbass, and Peter Hooke’s memorable guitar bass line. Bernard Sumner deliberately sang deadpan, Recorded in 1982 and released in 1983 on the famous Indie label Factory, the single featured as B-Side and in the lyrics The Beach – a reference to a Manchester night club, which along with the Hacienda was very much part of the Madchester rave scene at the time. The song does not stick to conventional verse chorus structure and (like Bowie’s Sound and Vision) features long passages of instrumental music. The introductory “How Does It Feel” however is one of the most memorable spine chilling moments in any genre. The record was released on the at the time new format of 12 inch Vinyl – with suitably cool packaging – and is now the highest selling 12-inch record in history. Their Greatest Hits “Substance” is a wonderful CD and reveals just how many perfect dance tracks they made. And they are still recording, albeit without Peter Hooke – great shame. Blue Monday has been re-released countless times and is hugely influential. It regularly appears on both best pop single and best dance single votes and as I write is featured in an advert.
Many people think that as well as New Order and Joy Division , the Happy Mondays, Stone Roses and the Smiths were the great British bands of the 1980’s in the Manchester (Madchester scene). . The Smiths and Stone Roses had similarities, their North West background, inspirational guitarists (John Squire, Stone Roses, and Johnny Marr, the Smiths) but for me the Smiths have it because they simply were more productive, with a string of hit singles over several albums and achieved worldwide success with no less than four albums appearing in the mainly America Rolling Stone Magazine’s top 500 best ever albums. I first noticed them when John Peel began to feature them – at the time a huge mark of quality – and when Sandie Shaw had her first hit for a decade with their song Hand In Glove.
The song that broke the Smiths was This Charming Man, and Morrisey’s TV appearances with his gladioli. Further signature hits followed like Heaven Knowns I’m Miserable Now. But as Johnny Marr says, How Soon Is Now is “possibly our most enduring record. It’s most people’s favourite, I think.”
Like so many band’s standout or best-selling songs How Soon is Now is not typical of the band’s overall sound, and often slower (think Foreigner’s I Want to Know What Love Is). Whenever I hear How Soon is Now, for the first minute, I think, I know this is essentially the same slow pace and riff and chord F# for another five minutes, should I keep listening? But I do, it has a hypnotic effect which keeps you hooked to the end, and you are disappointed it has finished.
Johnny Marr’s guitar work on this track is one of the great electric guitar sounds – not a solo as such, but technically complex and yet riveting at the same time. Employing tremoic, tremolo guitar effect. Inspired by Bo Didley, and actually two of my favourite records I Want More by German techno band Can, and Hamilton Bohannon’s Disc Stomp, John Marr and producer John Porter used a series of feeback, reverb and bounce techniques to produce the now famous swirling sigma, slow vibrato sound on the record. The lyrics are classic “Miserable Now” Smiths/Morissey:
“I am the son, and the heir, of a shyness that is criminally vulgar I am the son and heir, of nothing in particular”
“…I am human and I need to be loved Just like everybody else does” Though not quite what they seem; the “nothing in particular” refers to TS Elliot’s Middlemarch.
Never a big hit (in fact few of the Smiths singles were) it nevertheless is a track which has gained in stature over the years to now been seen as one of the great guitar rock tracks, not just an indie anthem but in the rock pantheon as a whole. Such as cool title too, even cooler that the record doesn’t actually include the words “How soon is Now” !
But all in all the record I have chosen to represent the pre-Oasis Manchester scene is Blue Monday for its ground breaking legacy and worldwide enduring appeal, and almost first crossover from rock to electronic dance.
Soft Cell Tainted Love 1982 When American soul singer Gloria Jones recorded the original version of this song in 1964 to no great fanfare, she could not know the twists and turns her own life, and the life of this song, would take. In the early 1970’s Northern Soul arrived and her decade-old record was dusted off and became part of the Northern Soul scene around the Manchester clubs and Wigan Casino. I had followed Northern Soul for some time, and was amused to read that in one of my favourite pop music books, “Last Night A DJ Saved My Life, the history of the DJ”, the authors describe northern soul as “a genre built from failures”. I can see what they mean, because Northern soul records typically were not chart successes, their attraction was to be obscure, rare, hardly known except to a clique. Fast, simple Tamla style beats with a story in the song. Some of my favourites were R Dean Taylor’s There’s a Ghost in My House, and Robert Knight’s Love on a Mountain Top, and Al Wilson’s The Snake, which all climbed the charts after re-releases built on gradual Northern Soul success, fuelled by DJ’s who would search Vinyl records shops like Soul City in Covent garden or even fly to America themselves. Meanwhile, Gloria Jones’s Tainted Love, though newly successful in the clubs, still didn’t chart, even though she re-recorded it in 1976 with help from a producer, one Marc Bolan. She had become his girlfriend in the early 1970’s and they worked together musically on several tracks. On September 16 1977 she and Bolan were returning to their Richmond flat from central London in a Mini 1275 when their car left the road. She was injured, but Marc sadly died. The spot near Barnes station is place we regularly drive past and the memorial flowers are still there and refreshed. Four years later in 1981 embryonic synthpop duo Soft Cell were looking for a sure-fire hit to follow up their first, failed, record, Memorabilia. Tainted Love seemed a strange choice, but they completely changed the feel of the record by slowing right down and using synthesisers instead of guitar, bass and drums. They added a sequel of The Supremes Where Did Our Love Go onto the 12 inch and they were up and running, riding the wave of the new British Eighties synthesiser sound. It was a No.1 in the U.K. and although it didn’t reach that peak in the U.S.A.it still spent a then record 43 weeks on the Billboard Hot 100 in 1982. The video caused a stir on Top of the Pops, one of the first synthesiser duos, as opposed to groups, to appear. Meanwhile whatever happened to Northern Soul? Well it’s gone back to its obscure roots. My family and I attended a Soul disco in Corfu – us and just a few others! . Purple Rain Prince 1983 When Prince joined the list of 2016 casualties, this was a shocker. You get a vague impression from the BBC news – “Prince taken to hospital after emergency landing” – you think it’s an aircraft emergency. A day later he is released and everything’s fine. But it’s not. Found deceased in his own lift soon after, in Paisley Park – famed for his in-house recording studio where he lived in Minnesota. As readers know, younger than me. I had first started listening to and buying Prince singles in 1982, with the release of classic double A side Little Red Corvette/1999 (to become famous for the line Let’s Party Like Its…). In the fall of 1983 Prince recorded the track Purple Rain, along with I Would Die 4 U, live in concert in his hometown. Both were included intact on the album of the same name in 1984. “Purple” is both a reference to African American struggles – it is a derogatory slang word – and his (real) royal name Prince (Rogers Nelson, named after his father Prince Rogers. Rain is a play in both Purple senses, on the word “reign”. Along with other classic singles Lets Go Crazy and When Doves Cry, Purple Rain made the album one of the greatest ever as recognised in the Rolling Stone top 500. Difficult to categorise as rock, funk or soul, Prince was simply an astonishing multi instrumentalist, and wonderful writer and singer. The song, also the title of has film Purple Rain, was a staple of his tour dates, of which I was privileged to see one at London Earls Court in June 1992, soon after I had moved to nearby Chelsea. What struck me then was the sheer showmanship, and professionalism, as well as charisma of the man. Years later Lyndsay Buckingham of Fleetwood Mac at the London O2.struck me in the same way. Talking of the O2, Prince played an astonishing 22 date programme at the O2 in August to September 2007 to 351,000 people. The sheer length of the residency is testimony to his popularity well after his peak record selling period had passed. Almost to his very last day Prince was playing concerts. Why? Because he loved music and people loved him.
Michael Jackson Billie Jean 1983
This song ticks all the boxes. Dance floor filler, unique, innovative bass line, fascinating lyrics, outstanding vocal performance, iconic video. Quite simply one of the greatest records of all time. The Off the Wall album promoted Michael from child star to superstar, but nothing could prepare us what came next. The Thriller album, the title track and this single in particular catapulted Michael Jackson into the stratosphere. Fifteen years of progress seemed to lead to this song, and cemented Michael Jackson’s place at the very top table of rock and soul royalty. He completed the holy trinity of Elvis, the Beatles and now Michael Jackson. Only a handful of music acts even come close to this trinity – perhaps Dylan, the Stones, Zeppelin, Marley, Madonna, Prince, Beyonce, Adele. With Billie Jean, Michael Jackson began to reclaim the status of African American music, not just as a source of inspiration for 60’s and 70’s rock, but as a dominant force in itself, both global and multi-racial. The emerging MTV had been unwilling to feature soul and dance videos, but Billie Jean changed everything. Billie Jean showed Michael’s increasing confidence as a writer, and producer. The lyrics seem to describe a real life experience, a claim that Michael was the father of a fan’s child, but the “kid is not my son”. Later Michael claimed that it was a generic song about the “groupies” that hung around the Jacksons, but either way it is a gripping and unusual story, especially for a pop lyric. The musical sound of the track is Jones’s sparse “less is more” arrangement, but is perhaps best known for the extended instrumental introduction – the drum and synth bass setting the rhythm. Producer Quincy Jones was initially unhappy with this, but Michael’s instinct was to include this and he held sway. And the rest is history as they say.
The video features some odd sequences – the photographer, the tramp, the dustbins –but what people remember: is this: the dance steps, lighting up squares, the sheer coolness of his look, the timing of the movement.
Billie Jean’s legendary status enhanced by Michael’s iconic performance at the Motown 25th anniversary TV show in 1983. After performing with his brothers for the first time for many years – reminding us of his already huge body of work – the boys leave Michael alone to perform Billie Jean. What followed was astonishing – often describe as the greatest live TV musical performance of all time. Completely mesmerising, Michael uses the 27 second instrumental introduction to captivate the theatre audience of his peers with his look – the pose, the rhinestone glove, the discarded fedora, the dance steps – before launching into the vocal. And a little later, the famous Moonwalk for the first time. Michael shows what a great showman, entertainer, and dancer he is, over and above the music. Fred Astaire complemented him.
I can only think of three other Live TV performances with a similar impact as the Motown 25 performance. I’m told of Elvis on the Ed Sullivan show and you can see the combination of movement, charisma and great music has equivalent impact. The Beatles’ Twist and Shout on Sunday Night at the London Palladium. And Adele’s Someone Like You at the Brit Awards. The song was a No.1 simultaneously in the U.K. and U.S.A, winning several Grammy’s. The album Thriller went on to sell 60 million copies, likely to remain the highest of all time. For some, the title track is the centre piece of the album, but for me it is Billie Jean.
The follow up to Thriller, the Bad album is sometimes viewed as a poor man’s Thriller but consider this: nothing could outsell Thriller and Bad has sold a monumental 30 million albums: the consistently high quality of every track and the number of hit singles is 9, 5 of which reached number 1 in America, a record only Kate Perry with Teenage Dream has matched. Almost every track was written by Michael himself but Man in the Mirror the 4th single was not. Rather it was co-written by Siedha Garret (who sung Can’t Stop Lovin You with Michael) and Glenn Ballard, but the way Michael sings it, he seems to believe in the sentiment. “I’m starting with the man in the mirror, asking him to change his ways”. One of his most critically acclaimed songs, the addition of the gospel choir brings a hymn-like feel to the song. A number 1 in America, it has grown in stature over the years and regularly voted near the top of fan’s favourite Jackson songs. But I wonder if there is an element of Michael worrying about looking at himself in the Mirror?
The album was the last with producer Quincy Jones. Quincy is one of the all-time-great musical producers, still active and spanning all the decades of my life. When I was born in 1956 Quincy was already trumpeter and musical director with Dizzy Gillespie. His list of credits includes producing Leslie Gore’s “Its My Party”, performing on Miles Davis’s last album Live at Montreux, introducing Will Smith to the world on Fresh Prince of Belle Air, arranging We are the World the American Band Aid, produced the Frank Sinatra/ Count Basie collaboration, and had a hit himself with Ai No Carrida. He is a social activist, champion of civil rights, and works with Bono on civil rights projects.
But it is for his work with Michael Jackson that he will be remembered. Specifically the Off the Wall, Thriller and Bad albums. Three of the greatest of all time, with some of the greatest singles of all time. He brings his jazz heritage to play, combining with rock, soul funk and disco to set the stage for Michael to reveal his true talent. Although Michael recorded the creditable Dangerous later (featuring Black or White) in retrospect Bad was the last great Jackson album. What followed was a long slow decline both personally and musically.
An oft forgotten event at the peak of his fame in 1984 seemed to be the very first time that things started to go wrong. At a Pepsi commercial shoot, the special effects misfired and his hair was burned. Not his fault, but his invincibility was dented. And retrospectively considering the lyrics of Billie Jean -“People always told me be careful what you do….my mother always told me be careful who you love…the truth becomes the lie” the seeds of mistrust, misfortune and strange behaviour were perhaps apparent in early signs. When he died in 2009 Michael was just days away from commencing the This Is It comeback dates at the O2 arena. A phenomenal 50 dates, sold out. My feeling is that his poor health and prescription drug problems would have at some stage prevented him from completing the tour. But even if only a few gigs were completed, it would have answered the question, “has he still got it”. Looking at the rehearsal footage, I think the answer would have been “yes”. A sad end to perhaps the greatest career in popular music.
The Police Every Breath You Take 1983 The Police were a band I followed from the very start, not just the singles like Roxanne but all the early albums, Outlandos D’Amour, Reggatta de Blanc and Zenyatta Mondatta. Sting’s nickname (he was born Gordon Sumner in Wallsend, Newcastle, and was a teacher in nearby Cramlington) came from the yellow and black bumble bee – like sweater he used to wear; Andy Sumner was an established guitarist, ten years older; and Stewart Copeland was the drummer in Curved Air, son of Miles Copeland, an American CIA agent.
Initially singles like Roxanne and So Lonely were not hits in the U.K. but after some success in America, the singles were released here and charted. I distinctly remember Sting saying in an interview that although pleased with the recognition, he was frustrated because it was holding up release of some exciting new material. What could it be? It turned out to be Message In A Bottle, their first number 1. By the time the Police’s fifth (and last, as it turned out) studio album Synchronicity, they were on their way to being the biggest band in the world, and this album and the single
Every Breath You Take cemented that position. Just like with Simon and Garfunkel’s Bridge Over Troubled Water, their greatest success arose as tensions in the group caused a breakup. Every Breath was a story about suspicion and surveillance (“I’ll be watching you”) and not the love song that people first assumed. Further infused no doubt by Sting’s breakaway from wife Frances Tomalty to neighbour and friend Trudy Tyler. The song gained further popularity when Puff Daddy recorded a version called I’ll Be Missing You, a No.1. Even though the lyrics were substantially changed, Sting still received royalties, helping to make Every Breath You Take one of the top ten “richest” songs in history in terms of royalty generation (with Happy Birthday, White Christmas and You’ve Lost that Lovin Feeling being the top 3).
The record in a sense was un-Police like. As if to emphasise that, the video shows Sting playing upright double bass instead of his familiar bass guitar. (It often happens that a group’s biggest hit is not typical of their sound: think Pink Floyd’s “Another Brick in the Wall”). The record went on to be No.1 in the U.S.A. for 8 weeks, and is regularly voted among the best singles ever produced. For instance I was in as sense surprised that it was voted No.1 Eighties single in an ITV viewers poll – surprised because you can’t dance to it, it’s morose – but what it has got is enduring quality, and the personality of the group.
1984 U2 Pride (in the name of love) I first came across U2 when watching them perform I Will Follow and Sunday Bloody Sunday on The Tube, the classic post-punk Eighties Jools Holland/Paul Yates live rock programme filmed in Newcastle. (I recorded many episodes on my old Video 2000 recorder, alas unplayable now) I was instantly hooked and bought the album Boy. New Years’ Day remains one of my all-time favourite singles. The song which really broke the band internationally was Pride, part of the album Unforgettable Fire, which moved on the group from their punk origins to more arty, yet stadium friendly, rock.
And the key event at that time for the band was their “Bono in the crowd” performance at Live Aid (from about 7 – 9 minutes in the video). Hearing Bono sing elements from the Stones Ruby Tuesday and Sympathy from the Devil at the time reminded me of this thought: did the Edge and the boys wonder “what on earth is he up to now” just as Charlie and Keith did all those years ago when watching Mick Jagger from the back? Years later, I found out, yes they did! An interview with the Edge revealed they thought Bono had simply disappeared into the crowd, and were about to pack up and go, annoyed they had lost the time to sing “Pride”. But, along with Queen, it was one of the most talked about sets, even though musically it wasn’t great – and don’t forget U2 were relatively new at the time.
Pride itself refers to the assassination of the Reverend Martin Luther King – the famous lines “Early morning, April Four, A shot rings out in the Memphis sky, Free at last, they took your life, but they could not take your pride”.
Two facts you may not know: As Bono now acknowledges, the shot was in the evening not the morning. And the credited backing vocalist was Christine Kerr, whom you may know better as Chrissie Hynde – she was married to Jim Kerr of Simple Minds at the time.
Bruce Springsteen Born In The USA 1984
Bruce Springsteen had been a star for 10years already. His “Born to Run” debit prompted the infamous journalistic quote, “I have seen the future of rock and roll and it’s name is Bruce Springsteen”. Bruce spent much of the next ten years trying to live that down. By the early 1980’s he and the E-Street band were producing great albums like The River and Nebraska. His next, Born in the U.S.A. was more up-beat, more rock and roll. The lyrics, however, if you looked closely, were just as thoughtful and sometimes dark. Although the title track Born in the USA may have appeared to be nationalistic and celebratory, in fact the lyric “I had a brother at Khe San, fighting off the Viet Cong, They’re still there, He’s all gone” revealed a sadness about the friends he had lost in the Vietnam War and the problems Veterans faced upon return.
This single and the album propelled Bruce to superstardom. I remember that wherever you were in the world, whichever radio station you tuned in to, in 1984 you were bound to hear one of the seven hit singles from album or see the famous blue jean album cover. He was everywhere.
Today Springsteen is still popular, selling albums and selling out tours. But I wonder if there is a contradiction: he is a hero of the blue-collar American working class male: but so is Donald Trump. But Springsteen one would think is the opposite of a Trump supporter. He is a champion of LBGT rights and in 2016 declared his opposition to North Carolina’s “bathroom law” considering it to be prejudicial. How to square that circle?
The Eurythmics . Sweet Dreams Are Made Of This 1984 Annie Lennox, from Aberdeen, and Dave Stewart, from Sunderland, started out in the Tourists, whom I followed in their early days with Blind Among The Flowers in 1979. However, it’s an indication that there’s not much left in the tank when your second record is a cover, albeit successful – Dusty’s I Only Want to Be With You was a hit for the Tourists – and the band soon broke up.
However, something interesting and innovative then occurred. Annie and Dave became one of the first “power duos” in pop. Previously, in the 70’s, you were either solo, or in a 3 or 4 piece band. They formed the Eurythmics, with the idea of running it as a collective but with them very much in charge of writing and direction. Several other synthpop bands were emerging at the same time in the early eighties with two front persons – OMD, Tears for Fears, among others. I picked up on their first minor hit, Love is a Stranger, but it was Sweet Dreams Are Made Of This which made the band, reaching No.1 in the U.S.A., in fact succeeding The Police’s Every Breath You Take, showing just how successful the “second British invasion” was becoming. The video, with an androgynous looking, suited, Annie Lennox also used the increasing impact of early MTV to promote the record and the Eurthymics brand.
Do They Know Its Christmas Band Aid/Live Aid 1985
Sir Bob Geldof’s personal tragedies may have finally taken their toll but this does at least mean we see more of his co-conspirator Midge Ure when a comment is required for a Band Aid milestone, as it frequently is. Although I have tried to avoid overtly Christmas records in this list (good as War Is Over, Fairytale of New York and Merry Christmas Everybody are, all in my singles collection) this particular song is included for the following reason. Many records add social commentary to a political or social event which has already occurred. This record actually caused the event to occur – it changed the course of history, in a way that very few pop records have achieved,
It all started of course with Michael Buerk’s heartbreaking account of the famine in Ethiopia, Midge and Bob wrote the lyrics and quickly got together the gang to record the song . What is not generally known is this: how did Midge and Bob got together? Well, as a Geordie I am delighted to say that the Tube, one of my all time favourite programmes, was being filmed live as usual in Newcastle, in the old Tyne Tees studios. Paula Yates, co presenter with Jools Holland, was chatting to Midge Ure who was on the Tube that night, when Bob Geldoff happened to call. Bob and Midge got chatting about Buerk’s newscast and the rest is history.
It’s the little things I recall. The grainy film of the assembled singers arriving at the studio. Then why does the great Paul Weller of the Jam look so small? (Is he?) Paul Young sung the opening line (Its Christmas Time) though Bono sang memorable line the ironic “Well tonight thank God its them instead of you”. The Bananarama girls next to Spandau and Duran. . Basically a who’s who capturing a moment in time of great 80@s British pop. (But why were the excellent USA band Kool and the Gang there? Answer: same record label as Boomtown Rats). The argument with Mrs Thatcher over VAT.
A huge hit followed , reaching No.1 over late 1984 into 1985, keeping Wham’s Last Christmas off the No. 1 spot It is now the highest selling British single, approaching 4 million copies bar Elton’s Princess Dianna tribute. Over the years the lyrics have been criticised for being a little patronising (and in subsequent re-recordings have been changed for instance for the Ebola crisis) but the synth-based music is classic 80;s with an African feel, the lyrics were memorable and the record served its purpose more than Bob and Midge could have imagined.
Live Aid followed at Wembley 6 months later. I watched intently on TV all day. Again the little things are what I remember. Status Quo opening with Rocking all over the world. Queen’s and U2’s triumph, especially Freddie Mercury in his trainers and Bono in the crowd.. Phil Collins drumming at Live Aid, helicoptering to Heathrow and flying to America in time to drum for reunited Led Zeppelin (minus John Bonham) at the Philadelphia USA version (in fact Jimmy Page and Robert Plant unfairly felt he struggled, one of the reasons perhaps Phil’s career began to decline). Paul McCartney’s microphone failing. The closing Let It Be with Paul, Pete Townshend David Bowie and Alison Moyet the lifting of Bob Geldof on their shoulders.
I felt both the single and concert were more convincing than the USA “we are the world” and concert. Perhaps we discovered that we are “quite good at charity” that magical year. Since then countless Comic Reliefs and Sport Aides have carried on the tradition which Band Aid and Live Aid so memorably started. As I write, Sam Cam is winning celebrity bake-off for Sport Relief on TV. We discuss our Action Aid sponsorship of a young boy in Sierra Leone. Two small examples whose lineage perhaps traces back to the impact of Live Aid.
Bob and Midge may feel they would like to be remembered more for their music but they should be immensely proud of what they started that day at Tyne Tees Studio and continued at Notting Hill studio and Wembley Stadium. They truly changed the world.
Simple Minds Don’t You Forget About Me 1985
This song was offered to Bryan Ferry and Billy Idol, who turned it down, and eventually Simple Minds recorded it, without much enthusiasm for success. However, it’s inclusion in the film the Breakfast Clun launched it to No.1 in the United States and an amazing two year run in the U.K. charts. Retrospectively dubbed an enduring masterpiece, it’s one of the best from a great Scottish band still touring and recording today. I started following the band right from the start with Love Song, Promised You a Miracle and Waterfront. In one sense a quintessential eighties band but they transcended that. The Breakfast Club itself was a surprise hit given its plot. Although the idea of five teens forming a club is attractive enough, the setting was unusual – the five pupils are ordered to meet in their High School library one Saturday morning as an all-day detention for misbehaviour, and to each write an essay about “who I am”. (Could that kind of punishment happen nowadays?) The story follows their developing relationships and the film ends with them leaving the library. In the video you can see Emilio Estevez, son of Apocalypse Now’s Martin Sheen and brother of Charlie Sheen.
1985 Bob Marley and the Wailers One Love/People Get Ready.
Bob Marley’s status went stratospheric after “No Woman”, peaking with the album Exodus, the album recorded mid 1977 and charting for a whole year through to 1978 in the UK alone. The album was voted “album of the century” by Time Magazine and the song itself chosen as “song of the millennium” by the BBC.
A standout track from Exodus was One Love which has an amazing history covering half a century. Recorded for the first time by the Wailers in 1965 as a ska song it was not a big hit. Meanwhile after Bob Marley gained popularity through albums like Natty Dread and Rastaman Vibration in the mid 1970’s, the next album could not be recorded in Jamaica after an assassination attempt and Marley moved to England.
The album moves on from Roots reggae and incorporates other styles such as rock and funk. Side 1 is highly political in a religious sense – the standout title track for instance, Side 2 has more familiar themes of love, for instance Jamming, Waiting in Vain and One Love /People Get Ready. You will notice the song has gained a “People Get Ready” – this is because the Curtis Mayfield song of that name has been added into the lyrics
The re-recording of One Love on Exodus continued to be popular through 1977-78 but was not released as a single until 1984/5, after Bob Marley’s death in 1981 as part of the Legend greatest hits album. The song was finally a huge worldwide hit. A video was released featuring among others Paul McCartney and Madness. The BBC used the song with re-rerecording from Ziggy Marley as the standout featured song in their Millennium 2000 celebrations. The film ”Marley and Me” features the naming of Owen and Jennifer’s dog as Marley after listening to the song. The Jamaican Tourist Board and Virgin Atlantic frequently advertise with the song. The last Shrek film features an Antonio Banderas version.
The influence of Bob Marley on music and culture cannot be overstated. Before Bob Marley passed away he recorded one last classic, Redemption song, not a reggae song at all, hinting at new directions. A very sad loss, there was lots more to come from the great man, but he left a wonderful legacy. Although I never saw the band perform, Alison my wife did, in Munich Reitstadion on 1 June 1980, with Fleetwood Mac on the bill, where the Exodus songs were heavily featured, along with No Woman No Cry.
Walk This Way Run DMC/Aerosmith 1986 Aerosmith had already had a rock hit a decade earlier with Walk This Way when New York rap and hip hop group Run DMC were persuaded by their producer Rick Rubin to make a cover. Aerosmith’s singer Steve Tyler and guitarist Joe Perry joined the recording, which was revolutionary at the time in terms of linking classic guitar rock with rap and turntable scratching and indeed they created a new genre. What really sealed the deal was the video, one of the all-time greats. Starting on opposite sides of a wall in a real theatre in Union City, New Jersey, the two groups fought it out in competition before a hole was smashed in the wall with a guitar. Run DMC, one of the coolest of all groups with their bling, pork pie hats, sunglasses and unlaced Adidas trainers, and sound system amps, contrasted with the long haired rockers. Eventually reconciliation was reached in the video and in music too, with other cross genre artists like Eminem following.
For Run DMC further classic hits followed like “Tricky” and “It’s Like That” but the group finally finished when sadly one of the founder members Jam Master Jay was murdered at his recording studio in Queens, New York. The murder was unsolved like that of fellow hip hop stars Notorious B.I.G. and 2Pac.
1986 Running Up that Hill Kate Bush After Kate’s astonishing debut single the 1978 No.1 Wuthering Heights Running Up That Hill became her next big hit. From the Album Hounds of Love which featured several hit singles and an Abbey Road like continuous second side medley,
Running Up That Hill’s lyrics tell the intriguing story of a man and and woman swapping places in a deal with God. Musically it is built around a Fairlight synthesiser but features some unusual instruments such as drone like Horn, Balalaika and the Irish drum kit called the Lambeg producing the thunderous timbre to emphasise the “thunder in our hearts”. Promotion for the record included a famous appearance on Wogan, an interpretive dance video, and an appearance in Monty Python’s Secret Policeman’s Ball.
The record gained a new lease of life in 2022 when included in the TV series Stranger Things, and reached an amazing one billion Streams on Spotify and finally reached No.1 in the UK charts – it broke all sorts of records including the longest gap between an artist’s No.1’s (44 years) and vies with George Michael’s Last Christmas in taking the longest time to reach No.1 (around 38 years)
The record is regularly featured in “best record of all time” lists and is now Kate’s signature tune. It was recently described as “still sounding ahead of its time 40 years after release”.
West End Girls Pet Shop Boys 1986 Coming towards the end of the eighties synthpop genre, this record was a sleeper needing a rerecording and release before it crept to No.1 in both the U.K. and U.S.A. Singer Neil Tennant, from North Shields near Newcastle upon Tyne, went to Catholic Grammar School St. Cuthberts. He was a journalist for Marvel Comics and then Smash Hits and after being sent to New York to interview the Police, he met a producer Bobby Orlando who listened to and recorded some of Neil and Chris Lowe’s tracks, including West end Girls. They had met soon before on Kings Road Chelsea. The rest, as they say, is history. The lyrics for West End Girls include references to T.S. Eliot’s poem The Wasteland. The line “from lake Geneva to Finland Station” refers to a historic journey by Lenin. The record is influenced by the legendary rap pioneer protest song the Message by Grandmaster Flash. So not just an ordinary boy meets girl song!
Sign of the Times Prince 1987 Although by 1987 Prince was just passing the commercial peak of his Purple Reign years, this was possibly the peak in terms of cutting, socially aware lyrics combined with a dramatic, bluesy, hypnotic melody. Rightly voted the best single of the year by the NME in 1987, the song deals with current affairs – “the rocket ship explodes” referring to the Shuttle – and drug related issues – “In September my cousin tried a Reefer for the very first time, now he’s doing Horse, its June”. That classic line – and the way it is sung, the fractional pause between “Horse” and” Its June” – in a few words sums up what other songs take many verses to achieve. All accompanied by a sparse, staccato bass guitar synthesiser sound which so totally matches the dark lyrical themes, that it is utterly chilling.
From the album of the same name, the track was a worldwide success in the Singles charts. Almost unthinkable that such a track would be a hit today. Further success followed. With prolific writers like Lennon and McCartney, Cat Stevens, Madonna and Ed Sheeran, their music tends to pop up in all kinds of unusual places. Prince was the same. A film soundtrack here – for Batman; a donated single there – Manic Monday for the Bangles; a first UK No.1 with a ballad, “The Most Beautiful Girl”; and best of all Sinead O’Connor’s rework of Nothing Compares 2 U.
Although this century brought less commercial success, if anything his legend grew with his almost continuous touring to sell-out arena sized audiences. And right to the end he was his own man – one of the very few artists to decline to place his back catalogue on Spotify, to signal his unease at the loss of control and small revenues. For me that’s fine I’ll be glad to purchase the greatest hits CD to replace my worn out copy (who said you could spread marmalade on them!)
Prince Rogers Nelson. A sad loss.
Whitney Houston I Wanna Dance With Somebody (Who Loves Me) 1987 Whitney was born to Cissy Houston, herself a soul singer with work as back-up singer to none other than Jim Hendrix, Elvis Presley and Aretha Franklin, who was Whitney’s honorary aunt. With Dionne Warwick being Cissy’s niece, Whitney and Dionne were cousins. No surprise that she followed a singer career, though initially she was a celebrated model. One might argue her peak was in 1992 with her cover of Dolly Parton’s “I Will Always Love You” from the Bodyguard film, but “I Wanna Dance” five years earlier set up her career and is her second best-selling single after “Always Love You” I myself saw Whitney perform at the Nelson Mandela concert at Wembley in 1988. My own favourite Whitney album is the one I bought quite late in her career, in 1999, the edgier “My Love is Your Love”, arguably her last great record before her voice and health agonisingly began to deteriorate. Her legacy is astonishing. The most awarded female singer in music history, selling towards 200 million records.
Bon Jovi. Livin on a Prayer 1987
I was never quite sure what to make of Bon Jovi. Somewhere between pop and heavy rock. Over the years, tracks like Wanted Dead Or Alive, You Give Love a Bad Name and especially Livin On A Prayer have become rock anthems. It’s a song about a working class couple trying to make ends meet, released during the Reagan era of trickle-down economics. The song includes he phrase “Unions been on strike, he’s down on his luck”. Was this a pro labour or anti labour message? It’s never been clarified, but an interesting song of it’s time, which would not be out of place in today’s America.
Guns’N’Roses Sweet Child of Mine 1988 From Guns’N’Roses 1987 breakthrough album Appetite for Destruction, the single followed Welcome to the Jungle, and along with Paradise City and November Rain has become one of the band’s signature songs. The lyric is focused upon singer Axl Rose’s then girlfriend, Erin Everly, daughter of Don Everly, the singer. But the record is arguably more famous for Slash’s guitar solo. Initially just a warm up exercise, but he developed it into one of the world’s great solos, very popular with any teenage guitarist, including my own son Matthew who plays a very creditable version.
Black Box. Ride On Time 1988 House dance music peaked around this time. Having started in a Chicago warehouse mid 1980’s, the U.K. was at the centre of the genre, with MAARS Pump Up The Volume, Yazz The Only Way Its Up, Bomb The Bass Beat Dis, and S Express Theme From S Express being prime examples and among my favourite records of the time. But it was Italy’s Black Box who emerged with one of the most enduring records, Ride On Time, a U.K. No.1 and one of the first examples of Italian house club music to make an international impact. The emerging Ibitha club scene also helped promote the record. Interesting fact: though recorded in 1988 the 1989 UK hit remix featured the voice of Heather Small, one of the favourite singers of myself and Alison, who went on to record with M People (see 1993, Movin On Up)
Like a Prayer Madonna 1988 My personal preference is the earlier floor fillers like Holiday and Into the Groove but the record that regularly tops the “best ever Madonna” lists is Like a Prayer, recorded in 1988 and released Spring 1989. A chart topper round the world, the song and the video mix Catholic religion and human love. After the memorable opening of “life is a mystery”, It combines rock, dance and funk with the memorable gospel choir. A turning point in her career, it showed how astute a business woman she was (a contract with Pepsi followed) and that she was not afraid to address controversial topics in her lyrics. Shaded of KKK, black civil rights, and much like the early soul and gospel singers like Little Richard and Sam Cooke, she seemed to blur the line between faith and desire. Madonna has had an astonishing career and is still touring regularly and recording new music. She is the highest dollar grossing touring solo artist of all time, and the best-selling female artist of all time, behind only the Beatles, Elvis and Jacko, with sales of 250 million and counting. One of my first memories of Madonna was watching U.S.A. Live Aid in 1985 at JFK Philadelphia. It struck me that among the male rock-fest here was something brave and different: a confident performance, dancing while singing, enjoying herself clearly. A sign of things to come.
Fight the Power Public Enemy feat. James Brown 1989 1989 was surely the year of HipHop, when political rap and Gangster rap went mainstream. Public Enemy formed by Chuck D and Flavor Flor in Long Island New York had broken through with “Don’t Believe the Hype” on the iconic Def Jam label, which charted in the UK and was trumpeted by the NME . At the time the NME was till essentially in “rock” mode, and so when I read the “Don’t Believe the Hype” was their record of the year I really began to take note of Hiphop. Then “Fight the Power” from the album “Fear of a Black Planet” cemented the group’s place in history. More hit singles followed like Welcome to the Terrordome as the group challenged prejudice against the Black African American community. “Fight the Power” is an astonishing record – samples from no less than 20 artists including James Brown, Afrika Bambata and the Isley Brothers. In fact James Brown features so heavily with his Funky Drummer, Funky President and Say It Loud, that rather naughtily I have included his name in the artist credit. Recorded for a Spike Lee film, the lyrics were the most controversial and hard hitting yet in the genre. Accusations of racism against Elvis and John Wayne were difficult to accept but thought provoking. All this with infectious dance beats and rhythms. Not for the feint hearted but often voted as one of the most important records ever made.
Meanwhile also in 1989, this time across the coast in a suburb of California, a father watched his children intently at play. He spotted a talent which he wished to nurture. His children faced an uphill struggle to overcome prejudice in their chosen field, but it was clear they were outstanding and talent prevailed. Venus and Serena – for it was the Williams sisters – became two of the greatest players in Tennis history, wining Grand Slams aplenty at a young age, then overcoming a whole new set of problems in their late twenties due to physical and emotional issues. But the girls were tough and Serena has come back to win many more Majors and Venus has been close. The girls got “Straight Outta Compton” – for Compton was their home town – because they had to, to succeed in Tennis. Hip Hop band N.W,A. also came Straight Outta Compton in 1989 with a ground breaking Gangster Rap album pulled together by Dr Dre and Ice Cube. Later they became successful solo artists and Dr Dre became rich through his Beats headphones company. “Straight Outta Compton” was recently a major film release, controversially winning a screen-writer Oscar for the all-white team behind it.
So 1989 was a turning point in in converting rap into political statement. More than just social comment, a call to arms, sometimes controversial in terms of language used and an association with violence. Public Enemy and N.W.A. have had a huge influence upon African American conscious nous in a battle that, judging by the Ferguson incident and reactions, is still ongoing. Beyoncé at Superbowl has carried on the fight in 2016, albeit through a more mainstream vehicle. Not my personal favourites – too much swearing – but both groups Public Enemy and N.W.A. And their records are well recognised in the Rock’n’Roll Hall of Fame and the Rolling Stone Top 500. Sinead O’Connor. 1989
The song, recorded in 1989, and written by Prince, was a worldwide hit for Sinead in 1990. She was asked in an interview if she had met Prince, and replied “not often, we didn’t get on very well together. In fact we had a punch up”. Prince denied this. Sinead later downplayed it. Sadly we can never now know both sides of the truth. The video was an iconic performance, set in Paris. Mostly showing just Sinead’s face, and ending with tears. A similar video was made many years later by Welsh singer Duffy, for her Warwick Avenue hit.
Adamaski/Seal 1989 The song, recorded in 1989, was released in 1990 by Adamski with Seal on vocals and released by Seal alone in 1991, this time with Trevor Horn of Frankie and Buggles fame producing. The baseline and synthesiser riff made it. Seal was the one who had enduring success. The record was covered successfully by George Michael, combining it with Papa Was A Rolling Stone.
Decade 1990’s
Dee Lite. Groove Is In The Heart 1990
The record is often voted one of the greatest dance records ever. Dee Lite were an American dance band who on Groove Is In the Heart incorporated Bootsy Collins, the Parliament/Funkadelic bass guitarist. It was top ten in America and only kept from No. 1 in the U.K. by a quirk of chart methodology by Steve Millers’ The Joker: both had equal sales in the week in question, but a rule said that if a song’s increase from the week before was higher, it would take presidence, and indeed the Joker climbed from a lower position. This has never occurred since.
Vogue Madonna 1990
“Strike a pose” begins Madonna and proceeds to combine 70’s disco with an underground New York City dance craze called “vogueing” and set the scene for 1990’s dance music. No.1 in 30 countries, the highest selling record worldwide of 1990. The spoken middle section makes name checks of the style, dance and Hollywood icons she admires, such as Grace Kelly and Fred Astaire.
Madonna’s early records were released on Sire, which to me as a punk fan is fascinating. Sire was the home of Talking Heads, the Undertones and the Ramones and confirms Madonna Louise Ciccone’s origin in the independent scene, initially at least. Vogue was by no means Madonna’s last classic – Frozen, Ray of Light and Hung Up were to follow. Just in May 2016 Madonna gave a wonderful rendition of Prince/Sinead’s Nothing Compares 2 U at the Billboard awards.. Why does she go on, when she does not need the money? Answer. Like all the great artists, she simply loves the music and performing.
Back to Life (However do you want me) . Soul 2 Soul 1990
I finally moved to London in 1990, and have lived here ever since. I lived in the Chelsea/Earls Court area, not far from Chelsea and Westminster Hospital where Alison would give birth to Matthew and Ellie. At the time I moved to London, Jazzie B of Soul to Soul was beginning to establish himself in the same area of London, Cromwell Road though Kensington up to Notting Hill, as a Sound System pioneer and record producer. He revolutionised and reinvented British soul music. I was a fan from the start, fascinated by the name of his album “Club Classics Volume 1” (how could they already be classics?) and by the way he brought singers like Caron Wheeler in and out of the group.
Is Back to Life, Jazzie B and the group, and associated video, one of the coolest records ever made? Judge for yourself! “Back to life, back to reality, back to the here and now”. Number 1 in the UK, a Grammy award in America, Jazzie B combined so many genres in his music from the Beatles and Bowie to reggae and hiphop, and developed a uniquely British style of urban soul music. He and the group had many more big hits and Jazzie B is still highly influential: a recent Ivor Novello award and OBE; he still presents a weekly radio show showcasing new music. A true hero of the U.K. black music scene.
Smells Like Teen Spirit Nirvana 1991
For me the Grunge rock style of the early 1990’s was possibly the last great rock movement which had a distinct new style and major cultural and musical impact. Although lead singer Kurt Cobain downplayed it, he represented the voice of the generation, Generation X, or the “slack generation”. The musical style was a sludgy guitar sound, with distortion, feedback and fuzz pedals typically common. The dynamics often switched several time mid song soft to loud and back, with the louder sections typified by angry sounding complaints of alienation and apathy. Hints of punk – certainly the spirit – but mostly slower. Pearl Jam and Soundgarden were other purveyors but it was Nirvana which lead the way with their Seattle sound in one of the first examples of “Alt-Rock”.
The lyrics for “Smells Like Teen Spirit” were said to have come from graffiti written on the wall by Bikini Kill, the Riot Grrrls singer (sic). (Only after the teen anthem was written, did the suggestion arise that Teen Spirit was actually a deodorant!) Kurt Cobain built a lyric around this and worked up the unusual guitar sound with drummer Dave Groll, bass player Kris Novoslelic and Kurt playing lead guitar and of course singing that now famous disinterested yet angry style of his. Butch Vig produced. The video features a high school concert featuring both apathy and then chaos; in a dark and blurred style – similar to the grunge sound.
“I feel stupid and contagious”…”I’m worse at what I do best”….finishing with the epic, repeated “a denial”. Classic grunge lyrics. The song went on to achieve immense sales (close to 2 million in the U.S.A alone ) and is often voted into the higher echelons of “best record ever” by critics. The album Nevermind is now one of the highest selling of all time and features of course the famous “swimming baby” – who, as I saw in an interview, has grown up just fine.
Enter Sandman Metallica 1991
I love this record. And so do tens of millions of others too. Enter Sandman was the stand out single along with Nothing else Matters, from the eponymous album Metallica, their fifth ( I am always puzzled why groups use the eponymous name well into their career, as if they cannot think of anything else – the Beatles and Fleetwood Mac did this too).
The album was a calmer and hence more commercial sound than their thrash metal beginnings. Enter Sandman itself features the famous riff, a wall of sound of guitars, a frightening vocal, and very odd yet compelling lyrics. The song is a lullaby/fairytale/nightmare : “exit light/enter night…off to never never land”. With the sandman as “bogie-man”. The feel of Roald Dahl and the Brothers Grimm I think. Except more terrifying.
The release year was the same as Nirvana’s grunge peak – and although Metallica were seen as heavy metal the overall sound on Metallica has similarities to grunge I believe (the opening base line for instance) It is like heavy metal and Punk – some similarities but it is clear which groups belong in each camp.
When you see Metallica being interviewed these days they seem more like smart businessmen that rockers – but still at the top of their game. The album has gone on to become one of the biggest selling of all time with 30 million sales and counting, and a trophy cabinet full of awards.
REM . Losing My Religion 1991
Consider this. That’s me in the corner: one of the greatest of all pop lyrics? For 25 years I have tried to figure out why that simple line is so intriguing. Is Michael Stipe looking at a photograph of himself, or having an out of body experience? There is something of the Blair Witch Project about the line. The song as a whole has so many memorable lines. “Losing my religion” itself is in fact probably the American Southern expression for “losing one’s cool”; “I think I thought I saw you try” adds to the dream like quality of the song; “Oh no I’ve said too much, I havn’t said enough” is a familiar feeling. Michael Stipe, when interviewed wisely doesn’t reveal all the meanings, but hints that it’s a song about unrequited love, a similar paranoia described in the Police’s Every Breath You Take.
The lead musical instrument is the mandolin. A rare appearance for the instrument in popular music: think Mike Oldfield’s announcement in Tubular Bells (…two slightly distorted guitars, mandolin!) and John Peel playing mandolin for Rod Stewart’s Maggie May on TOTP. In fact it was Ray Jackson of Lindisfarne playing mandolin on Rod’s record. Wallsend, Newcastle born Ray was both lead singer and Mandolin player with Lindisfarne (memorably on Lady Eleanor, one of the inspirations for my daughter’s name). Lindisfarne’s other biggest hit, Meet Me on the Corner, brings us neatly back to “Corner”. Along with George Michael’s “Turn a different corner”,” Meet me on the Corner” is one of my favourite “corner” songs, but the best of all is REM’s “That’s me in the corner” in Losing My Religion. I’m obsessive about such connections: I must get out more!
Come As You Are Nirvana 1992
I remember having just come down to London and being in a dance hall with my much better looking fiend Nick, when this track was played. It struck me then very few rock tracks were played at dances but here it was – must be something special. Indeed it was. Like Teen Spirit it was from the multi-million selling album Nevermind. The watery, slippery feel of the opening guitar riff is matched by the feel of the video. The dominating image from the video, and line from the song, was Kurt Cobain imploring “I don’t have a gun”. Unfortunately Kurt did, and only a few years later, after deteriorating health and drug problems, he took his own life almost certainly at the hands of his own gun.
While not quite of the same impact as the anthemic Teen Spirit, Come As You are is nevertheless at the zenith of the band’s legacy. It reminds us what a fine guitarist Kurt was as well as a visionary songwriter and distinctive vocalist. Following his death a number of things occurred. Arguments about royalties already begun continued. Drummer Dave Groll went on to form the almost equally successful Foo Fighters – and continued his fantastic drumming on generally faster and more commercial songs. Kurt’s wife Courtney Love of Alt-Rock group Hole has branched into politics, art and advertising for YSL, but still to this day sings, records and tours and for instance shared vocals on my daughter Ellie’s fave band Fall Out Boy CD.
Meanwhile the song and Kurt himself are honoured in his birthplace of Aberdeen (not that one, the one in Washington)
So 25 years on, Teen Spirit and Come As You are still sound as powerful, ground breaking and fresh as ever.
Boys 2 Men. End of the Road 1992
Boys 2 Men are among only 4 artists (themselves, the Beatles, Elvis and Maria Carey) to spend over 50 weeks at the top of the American charts (in fact they jointly released with Maria the song One Sweet Day which accounted for 16 of those weeks). End of the Road shows the group at their best, four lead harmony vocals over gentle hip hop beats. Their first hit, it spent a continuous 11 weeks at the top of the Billboard Hot 100 and hit No.1 in the U.K. too.
U2. One 1992
By now U2 were perhaps the world’s greatest rock band. Their live performances Under a Blood Red Sky, then on an L.A. rooftop a la Beatles, performing Streets Have No Name from the epic Joshua Tree, were for me better than their Live Aid show.
So I was thrilled to see the band perform at Wembley in August 1993 as part of the “giant screen” Zoo TV tour. (I had been to Wembley many times, not least for Sunderland’s famous 1973 Cup Final win, but this was the first time I got to stand on the pitch)
The song “One” – on the Wembley set list – was from the Achtung Baby album, one of my favourite U2 L.P.’s. Mysterious Ways is perhaps is a more typical track, as the band had gone to Berlin to record on the eve of unification, perhaps wishing to pick up the electronic vibe just as earlier David Bowie had, but now also hoping to absorb the “freedom” feeling. It didn’t turn out that way initially, as a surprisingly gloomy atmosphere seemed to pervade the album’s fractious recording. When eventually One was developed, initially as a few chords on the Edge’s acoustic guitar, things looked up. Even then, fascinatingly, the track took many many takes and remixes by producers Daniel Lanois and Eno (formerly of Roxy Music of course) before the track finally was ready. I didn’t realise at the time, that it would become a classic. Not surprising, because nor did the band! The song is about reconciliation and unity, yes, but also the difficulties in achieving it. “We’re one, but we’re not the same”. “We get to carry each other”: the “get to” is emphasised as a privilege not a right. These are inspiring lyrics, along with “One life, sisters, brothers”; but like many of the great songs there is ambiguity and a dark side too. Nevertheless, most people take the positive and are inspired by the simple but memorable melody, the ultimately optimistic lyrics and one of the great guitar solos by the Edge.
Years later, one of the band’s heroes, Johnny Cash, recorded One, and I know the band were thrilled. It reminds me of the film I saw of U2’s recording of “When Love Comes to Town” with BB King, in which Bono behaves like a fan – he’s clearly in thrall to the great blue guitarist.
The song “One” crept up on us all but is now generally acknowledged as one of the best, if not the best, of U2’s prodigious output, and near the top of many “greatest songs of all time” lists.
REM . Everybody Hurts 1993
REM released Automatic for the People as an equally popular follow up to 1991’s Out of Time, and Losing My Religion. The key single was Everybody Hurts, a song with such sad lyrics, and a sad vibe, that it became associated with suicide charities. The song regularly used to be in the top ten of Absolute Radio’s listeners all-time favourite singles – long after its release, always a good sign. The Absolute Radio annual poll was one of the things which inspired the list you are reading . But the problem with it was that it was a little too narrowly focused on a particular period and genre; hence my idea of top 3 of each year.
REM (“Rapid Eye Movement”) were from Athens Georgia, home also to the B52’s. The city was named after the home of Plato and Aristotle, because one of the first buildings was a University. The state of Georgia is home to Augusta and the Master’s Golf, and – surprising considering the course’s spectacular azaleas – a speciality Chemicals Factory, on my list of regular visits in my BP Chemicals years.
REM were perhaps the most popular of all alternative rock groups: with both the public and their peers (Nirvana and Radiohead were big fans). Their 30 year career came to an end in 2011 when the band sensibly decided they had come to the end of the road, were struggling to say something new. After all, after naming a big hit single “What’s the Frequency Kenneth?”, (one of my personal favourites) what more can you compose?
M People. Movin On Up 1993
This was the year when German electronic group Snap achieved a No. 1 worldwide rap/dance hit, Rhythm is a Dancer. But a British dance group was emerging which would have a more enduring legacy, namely M People. Formed by Mike Pickering and acid jazz pioneer Paul Heard, part of the Manchester clubs scene. Pickering was DJ at the famous Hacienda night club. Percussionist Shovel was recruited as was Heather Small, from the soul group Hot House, who had contributed the studio vocal to Black Box’s Ride On Time. How Can I Love You More was their first hit, but the group really secured international success with the album Elegant Slumming and singles One Night In Heaven, and Movin On Up, which was hit not just in the U.K. but America too.
I first came across M People when they won the prestigious Mercury Music prize, which is not renowned for awarding prizes to commercial groups. What was attractive about M People was their home grown, build up from the base, northern club beginnings. And they tapped into a variety of genres – acid house, northern soul, house and disco – yet a made a unique sound. Also of course that voice. Heather Small was and is one of the greatest soul singers, and brought sincerity to the songs with inspirational lyrics that some purely electronic dance music does not.
Alison and I, with our friends John and Theresa, went to see an early show of the band at Brixton Academy. What I remember is this: the band announced a new song, Open Your Heart, and I could tell after just a few bars it would be a major hit. It was, and it’s not often a song so immediately makes its mark. The album Bizarre Fruit revealed further hit singles like Sight For Sore Eyes and the enduring Search for a Hero.
Heather Small herself produced a major sold record, Proud, which has featured in TV shows as diverse as the theme to Oprah Winfrey’s show, and UK TV comedy Miranda, in which she appeared as herself in the last episode.
Alison and I saw M People play once more recently, with Niles Rogers and Chic, on a glorious summers’ evening in Kew Gardens, London and Heather’s memorable voice is absolutely still there.
Robin S . Show Me Love 1993
Robin Stone, American singer songwriter, had a wordwide hit with this House anthem that has been regularly voted as one of the best Dance records ever, sampled many times since. It’s a very strong soul vocal as well. In 2016, Robin is once more at the top of the Billboard Dance charts with Shout It Loud.
Blur 1994 Girls and Boys
This is remembered as their first hit, but is actually the comeback from a fallow period after their massive “There’s no other way”. That was seen as Indie, whereas Girls and Boys was one of the first Brit Pop record and arguably the beginning of their rivalry with Oasis, in which Blur won the battle with Country House, but Oasis won the war with the album What’s the Story Morning Glory.
Girls and Boys has a number of plus points. NME single of the year (at a time when it was still a major honour), an ingenious combination of rock and dance beats, and lyrics which seemed to anticipate both the Trans-gender agenda these days (“girls who are boys”) , and also the rise of the TOWIE Essex phenomenon. More important though, the lyrics summed up the “following the herd down to Greece” mentality (of which I was part). Damon Albarn claims to have written the song after a holiday in Magaluf, and this was an observation on the rampant immorality he discovered (of which I wasn’t a part!) Check out the video, a Wham Club Tropicana look alike (by Kevin Godley of 10 cc fame) but with irony.
Damon Albarn deserves his place in the list because of this song, which broke America for the band and paved the way for the worldwide hit “Song 2”, and for a continuing contribution to pop music in all its forms, including the Gorillaz cartoon band, and various Musicals, and a reformed Blur at Glastonbury recently.
Oasis. Live Forever 1994
Noel, Liam, Guigsy and Bonehead burst on the scene in Manchester in 1991 to 1992, Noel having actually joined after Liam. They signed to Creation Records and Live Forever was their first top 10 UK hit just as the first album Definitely Maybe was released. At first it was the charismatic Liam who garnered the attention. The Indie, arrogant hands-behind-back pose and nasal Lennon-like voice meant you couldn’t take your eyes off Liam. We didn’t realise that Noel was the chief songwriter and composer. Oasis were full of contradictions. I couldn’t decide if the music was retro or fresh, if the clothes were thrown together or deliberately, casually fashionable. Live Forever was intentionally upbeat, a reposte to American Grunge. The guitar work was great, the key “we see things we never see” verse and “you and I we’re gonna live forever” chorus are memorable. Regularly voted the greatest Oasis song, it’s become a rock anthem, growing in stature over the years.
Radiohead Street Spirit Fade Out 1994
Radiohead’s breakthrough album “The Bends” has often been recognised as one of the greatest Rock albums of all time and although not the first single, Street Spirit was arguably the most successful and well known track on the album. Bends elevated Radiohead from indie-rock to the Premier League as one critic said, and especially in America they have never looked back. Radiohead and in 2016 are selling out shows instantaneously.
Street Spirit has an ethereal, almost hymn like quality, which builds through the record. The lyrics are inspired by Ben Okri’s Famished Road. The phrase “terrible beauty” spring to mind, especially in this year of the Irish Easter Rising anniversary.
Radiohead’s debut single Creep a couple of years before almost didn’t see light of day, partly because of censorship of bad language and because the band were reluctant to compromise on re-recording, and partly because it’s first release had disappointing sales. But gradual positive sales on West Coast America and a sanitised Top of the Pops appearance meant successful re-release. The record went on to become the band’s most popular song on tour – so popular that the band tired of playing it.
The words in Creep are about trying to get noticed by the opposite sex – probably at a disco at Thom Yorke’s Exeter University -and trying to be so very special, which is a problem when you see yourself as a creep. Actually for me, this is the heir apparent to Jilted John from the punk era. “I was so upset that I cried all the way to the chip shop”.
Oasis. Wonderwall 1995
By the time this record was released, the Britpop rivalry was well underway. While Blur won the battle with Country House’s No.1 position versus Roll With It, Oasis clearly won the war with the album What’s the Story Morning Glory. This became one of biggest selling albums of all time in the U.K.. Strangely, though I was already a fan, when a disc jockey played the record for the first time without announcing the artist, I didn’t recognise it. However it was obvious to me this was an intriguing, alluring record with a very unusual sound and I was delighted to find it was Oasis.
The meaning of Wonderwall is open to question. Possibly a prison cell poster, or associated with the 1968 arthouse film for which George Harrison wrote the soundtrack (the first such Beatles solo outing) in which a hole in a wall is created for viewing. (I am always reminded of the famous Shawshank Redemption scene when Tim Robins has been hiding his escape route behind a poster). Noel himself says it is concerns an “imaginary friend” who saves you. Even then, there’s doubt about whether it is about Meg Matthews, Noel’s one-time wife.
Whatever (to coin another Oasis favourite) Wonderwall is about as near to a love song as Noel will get:
I don’t believe that anybody feels The way I do about you now
The song was Oasis’s biggest worldwide hit (top ten on the Billboard Top 100) and is one of the most covered songs in history. The minimalist black and white video has become a classic.
I never saw Oasis live – I had a chance to see them at Earls Court but the show was sold out, as most Oasis gigs were then. Still, I had something called a VHS video – live at their “beloved” (*) Manchester City’s ground, then Maine Road. In those days the Maine Road ground was somewhat in decline (as were the club, after the heady days of Colin Bell and Francis Lee – “Just look at his face”) and so in 1996 Old Trafford was the chosen Manchester ground for Euro 1996.
20 years later and its Euros time again, at time of writing. No football song this time! But in 1996, at the peak of “Lads/Britpop” culture, The Lightning Seeds, with Frank Skinner and David Abdiel, recorded the equal best England football song, Three Lions on Your Shirt (thirty years of hurt is now fifty); equal with the 1990 World Cup’s New Order World In Motion, featuring lyrics by Lilly Allen’s father Keith, the John Barnes rap and back-up vocals by Paul Gascoyne and Chris Waddle. These two of course had actual hits respectively with Fog on the Tyne and (with Glenn Hoddle) Diamond Lights, mullets and all.
(*) The use of the word beloved annoys me. It is written by people who don’t understand football fans. Unless you support one of the top teams (and I support Sunderland) then you actually hate your football team most of the time because of the frustrations and misery they bring you (for instance their seemingly annual fight to achieve relegation), interspersed with occasional flowerings of joy (their failure somehow to achieve it).
Pulp Common People 1995
Incredibly, Jarvis Cocker’s Pulp had been recording and performing for over 15 years before achieving significant chart success. He founded the band in Sheffield at the age of 15 and with a little help from John Peel along the way just kept going through the 80’s synth-pop decade and into the Brit-pop era in the 1990’s. The release of albums His’n’Hers and Different Class, along with singles like Common People and Disco 2000, propelled the band eventually to fame, helped by a Glastonbury appearance and Jarvis’s infamous invasion of the stage a Michael Jackson performance of “Earth Song”.
Common People the song is based upon real life experience while Jarvis was studying film at St Martin’s College of art and design. He met a fellow student – a Greek girl – whom he claimed told him that she “wanted to move to Hackney and live like ‘the common people””. Jarvis developed the theme into a rant about the hypocrisy of social-class swapping. “Pretend you never went to school….because you “think that poor is cool”.
The identity of the Greek girl is not completely established but here is a clue. “She told me that her Dad was loaded”…”watching roaches climb the wall, if you called your Dad he could stop it all”. Danae Stratou, studying at the college at the time, now a well-established artist, was the daughter of a wealthy textiles businessman, and is considered the most likely candidate. Intriguingly, Danae is married to Yanis Varoufakis, a name you may know: he’s the left wing firebrand former Greek finance minister who tried to negotiate Greece’s debt reduction in the 2014 Euro crisis.
The record is now considered one of the cornerstones of the Britpop era, placing Pulp among the top four along with Oasis, Blur, and Suede.
Alanis Morisette. You Oughta Know 1995
Canadian Alanis had a strict Catholic upbringing, was a child TV star and an early Teen singer with some success. She moved to Los Angeles when her career stalled and began writing the album Jagged Little Pill. The first single You Oughta Know was picked up by LA alternative rock stations and became a Grammy Winner and worldwide hit – albeit not everywhere. Back in Canada there was some resistance to her new persona. The contribution of guitar and base by two of the Red Hot Chilli Peppers surely added edge and street credibility. The subject of Alanis’s annoyance is not exactly of Carly Simon “You’re So Vain” proportions, but has been the subject of much speculation without resolution.
Singles like Head Over Feet, Hand In My Pocket and Ironic (sparking a debate about the true meaning of the word) followed making Jagged Little Pill one of the highest selling ever by a female solo artist with sales of over 30 million.
Alanis could never possibly repeat the success of this album but has had a very creditable and successful career since then. I always felt her brand of Alt-Angst Rock revealed an angry as well as independent woman, but it seems she is happy now with marriage and motherhood
Underworld . Born Slippy 1996
The official name is Born Slippy.NUXX a reference to file names on the band’s computer, and because the original Born Slippy from the year before was a different track altogether, albeit also by Underworld. When the film Trainspotting came out, for which Born Slippy.NUXX was the closing soundtrack, the single was re-released and everyone just calls it Born Slippy now anyway. Even though the lyrics do not mention the Title. (Got that?) The lyrics do however mention “lager, lager, lager” and “chemicals” which makes it particularly suitable for Trainspotting, the cult Danny Boyle (of Olympics fame) film about the Irvine Welsh book of low life and the drug scene in Edinburgh. Trainspotting made the name of Ewan McGregor and Robert Carlisle, and while the group never quite reached this peak again, and the record is recognised as one of the greatest dance tracks ever.
And the name Trainspotting? It refers to station at Leith, as in Sunshine Over by the great Proclaimers.
Prodigy. Firestarter 1996
I’d been following Prodigy for a few years through their Charly, Everybody in the Place, and Outa Space phase and couldn’t work out what sort of group they were – rave, techno, yes but with a hint of reggae, jungle breakbeat and ragga. So when Keith Flint transitioned from dancer to Mohican punk lead singer to accompany main men Liam Howlett and Maxim Reality I was as surprised as anyone.
Firestarter was a U.K. number 1 for 3 weeks and the album Fat of the Land was a worldwide Number 1 including in the U.S.A. This brand of fierce, firebrand hardcore techno dance music has rarely been repeated since, but to this day sound exciting and refreshing, if a little disturbing.
Fugees. Killing Me Softly. 1996
One of the greatest cover versions ever, at least of the type which completely reworks the original song, like Joe Cocker with A Little Help and Sinead O’Connor with Nothing Compares 2 U. Roberta Flack had recorded the wonderful original version in 1972, then in 1996 the Fugees, the hip hop/soul group, comprising Wyclef Jean, Pras Michel and Lauryn Hill, released the album The Score. At the time I remember Lauryn being called the “coolest girl on the planet” and for a while the cap fitted. Their version starts memorably – is it guitar or synthesiser? – and includes the iconic “one time” background refrain.
Robbie Williams . Angels 1997
The first great Robbie single almost never made it to release. I remember when Robbie left Take That, there were health problems, booze rather than drugs, and we assumed that he would simply fade away. The release of Life Thru a Lens initially dispelled the worry, but as the first three singles, Old Before I Die, Lazy days and South of the Border charted at successively lower positions, not just the public but the record company began to lose faith. As a last resort, Robbie suggested Angels as a final single. Written by new co-writer Guy Chambers and initially with Dublin songwriter Ray Heffernan, the song relates to Robbie’s family. Although not a No.1 the song has gradually reached a million sales and become one of Robbie’s signature songs, and a classic Live show finale. During the classic Virgin / Absolute Radio annual New Year “best ever singles” votes and playbacks in the early 2000’s, Robbie’s Angels always vied with Bohemian Rhapsody and Imagine for the Top Three slot. Deservedly so. Robbie never really made it in the U.S.A but consider this: he is not just best-selling British solo artist ever in the U.K. but the highest selling Non-Latino artist in Latin America. One reason why at 75 million worldwide sales he is one of the most successful artists of all time.
The Beastie Boys . (You Gotta) Fight for Your Right (To Party) 1997
The band emerged from the punk scene in New York City – they supported the Dead Kennedy’s and the Misfits – and recruited Adam Horiwitz from his group the Young and Useless. They switched to hip hop after working with iconic DJ Rick Rubi, who formed Def Jam Records, and were part of the ground breaking Raising Hell tour with Run DMC (one of my favourite rap groups). The Beastie Boys first album Licensed to Ill was one of the label’s first releases and went on to sell 10 million copies. The chief singles were No Sleep Till Brooklyn (named after Motorhead’s “No Sleep Till Hammersmith”) and Fight For Your Right (to party). The video features a “party while your parents are away” and pays homage to Zombie movie Dawn of the Dead.
Radiohead Paranoid Android 1997
My personal introduction to Radiohead, like many others, came by purchasing their 3rd album OK Computer. The NME described it as the first great album of the 21st century (a Maths problem, surely, but I know what they meant!) Indeed since then the album s been described as the greatest album not just of the 20th or 21st century, but of all time. Including by REM’s Michael Stipe (not surprising since Radiohead often reference him as an influence).
Thom York describes how Bitches Brew by Miles Davis in 1970 was a major influence on OK Computer. “It was building something up and watching it fall apart, that’s the beauty of it. It was at the core of what we were trying to do with OK Computer.”.The Beatles Day in the Life was another. Krautrock band Can and film score producer Enio Moricone of Spaghetti Western fame are further influences.
Radiohead’s music has influences but the blend is unique. It is not always easy to listen to (and in the albums after Bends and Computer this was even more of an issue). The lyrical themes of alienation and anti-consumerism are fairly familiar but the electronic sounds are not, especially when they are mixed with quieter moments of beauty.
My personal favourite single from the album is Karma Police but the most successful and enduring is Paranoid Android. I know what you are thinking, you are thinking I know where that name comes from, and you would be right. Douglas Adams’ Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy of course features Marvin the Paranoid Android and the record’s title is a tribute to him.
Marvin of course memorably had a “brain the size of the universe”, but was depressed because he was never challenged to use it (we all know the feeling !). He had a difficult upbringing. “The first ten million years were the worst. The second ten million years were the worst too…after that I went into decline”. References for Marvin the Paranoid Android include A.A. Milne’s Eeyore and Shakespeare’s Jacques from As You Like It, and Marvin has become one of the great tragi-comedy characters.
But back to Radiohead’s Paranoid Android. There is an element of paranoia – “voices in my head” and “when I am king you will be first against the wall”. In fact the iyrical inspiration was observation of a woman’s meltdown after a drink was spilt upon her. And yet some of the lyrics seem unconnected to anything else in the song. “God Loves his children…”. As a mathematician that both annoys me and fascinates me. The Bowie technique of taking scissors to a song, scattering the lyrics and rearranging them, seems crazy on the face of it. And yet, I have always been absorbed by and admired lyrics that I don’t understand, that challenge you to paint pictures and interpret.
Musically, Paranoid Android, is both memorable and disturbing. When I think of the track I think “Heavy Metal” but in fact only small parts are metal. Some parts are acoustic, some almost choir-like. Some parts seem to echo King Crimson’s Court of the Crimson King. The record is a computer-age, digital successor to the great “epic” rock tracks of the seventies, Stairway to Heaven and Bohemian Rhapsody spring to mind, Or even Pink Floyd’s Syd Barret tracks – written by him or later inspired by him – such as “Several Species of Small Furry Animals…”. There are several distinct phases of different tempo, and which don’t always seem to connect easily together. And yet they do. And at the end of the day it’s pure, unique, Radiohead, not (directly) at all the songs which influenced it.
Radiohead’s music was never designed to be danced to, that’s for sure. The enduring popularity – now, incredibly, almost twenty five years on from their debut Creep – must, it seems to me, be because of the ongoing tradition associated with early Dylan and the Beatles’ Norwegian Wood, of students huddling around warm coffee in freezing lodgings, listening to challenging rock music. Does that really still happen? It must!
The Verve . Bittersweet Symphony 1998
The song has a complicated past. The group had permission to use a short section of Rolling Stones manager Andrew Loog Oldham’s orchestral arrangement of the Stones “The Last Time” (watch this classic video and compare) However when the song Bittersweet Symphony became a hit as part of the classic Urban Hymns album release, the Stones’ former financial manager Allen Klein (he infamously of Beatles notoriety) claimed royalty rights. Although the lyrics were entirely written by the Verve’s Richard Ashcroft, the credits were changed to Ashcroft/Jagger/Richards, and the royalties assigned to Klein’s ABKCO publishing company.
The song’s key lyric is “you’re a slave to money and then you die” (a bit harsh?) and the video has become a classic: Richard Ashcroft walks down a “so 90’s England” North London shopping street, appearing to bump into people deliberately. I saw Richard just in May 2016 on BBC breakfast TV describing how, with the video being shot live, passers-by thought he really was like that: rude, aggressive. Not the case!
Bittersweet Symphony was released in 1997 and is seen as part of the Britpop era, albeit near the end of it: it gradually became a big hit in America through 1998, helping to bring it to the attention of one Beyonce Knowles, who later sampled it as part of the “Mrs Carter” world tour.
It is strange how some songs take on a life of their own, over and above the original composition and lyrics, and Bitter Sweet Symphony is an example. It keeps popping up everywhere. The ITV coverage of England soccer matches for many years has begun with the orchestral arrangement of the song.
The Manic Street Preachers . If you tolerate this, then your children will be next. 1998
The Manics first came to my attention when I bought the 45 rpm single “Suicide is Painless” in 1992, their rock cover of the Theme from M*A*S*H*. An early “to become a classic” was Motorcycle Emptiness. Their peak years commercially were the mid 1990’s, first with the iconic “Design for Life”, written following the tragic disappearance – still unexplained – of band member Richey Edwards; and next with “If you tolerate this….” (confirmed by the Guinness Book of Records as the longest title (without brackets) of a No. 1 record in the U.K. – I love statistcs like that!).
The Manics are a highly political left leaning group – and James Dean Bradfield’s lyrics generally confirm that. (What a name! His real name!). I remember noting the grouped pulled out of a high profile charity gig because Royalty would be present and that was against their principles. I admired that. They are also firmly Welsh, are still going strong, and have recorded the Wales football team’s song for the 2016 Euro tournament.
The song draws its inspiration from the Spanish Civil war, where Welsh volunteers joined in the International Brigade’s fight with the fascists. The title is taken from a real Republican poster. There are echoes of the Clash’s Spanish Bombs and George Orwell’s Homage to Catalonia.
One of the most famous lyrics from the song is “if I can shoot rabbits so I can shoot fascists”. But for me “and on the streets tonight an old man plays, with newspaper cuttings of his glory days” does what the great songwriters achieve: introduce a picture in your mind, and the rest you invent yourself.
The lyrics are made all the more poignant by the gorgeous guitar intro, and James’s wonderful tenor vocal which is both angry yet touching at the same time. Sad yet inspiring. The record is regularly voted as one of the great British No.1 records.
The Manics Greatest Hits is one of my favourite type of albums: by a “just below the top” rock group who have nevertheless had such a stream of hits, not necessarily all No.1’s – that the group creeps up on you as in fact one of the great British bands. Think the Undertones, the Stranglers.
You’re Still The One Shania Twain 1998
From the album Come on Over, which went on to sell more than 40 million copies worldwide and spent a phenomenal 2 years in the Billboard Top 20. The sales are in the top ten of any album in history and the most by any female artist ever . Canadian born Shania was well established country artist before she evolved with producer Mutt Lange a country-pop cross over style. Single after single was released from the album over an incredible stretch from 1997 to 2000 and the two which I recall with fondness and which were the most successful in the UK were “Man, I feel like a woman” and “That Don’t’ Impress Me Much”. These were perhaps overly commercial – Euro Disco almost – but the one which stayed closest to her Country roots and still stands up today was “You’re still the one”, a sensitive love song for her producer/partner Lange, a reposte to critics who said the relationship would not last. Well, it did for some time but Shania and Mutt divorced some ten years later and the break up caused such trauma to Shania that she withdrew from touring and lost her voice altogether, but happily returned to form very recently with a successful world tour named after the song: “Still the One”..
The song won two Grammy awards and was her first top ten hit in the UK. Country in the UK has never been as popular as in America but it has clearly had a huge influence on pope and rock music (Hank Williams on Elvis Costello, country rock with the Eagles, Johnny Cash on rock’n’roll for instance ). There was a period in the 1970’s and 1980’s when Country was a major chart force in the U.K. (Blanket on the Ground, Billie Joe Spears, The Gambler and Lucille by Kenny Rogers for instance and I have a soft spot for these type of records). Garth Brooks is a huge seller in the USA but not so impactful in the UK. It tends to take a cross over artist like Shania or Taylor Swift these days to make a mark in the U.K.
Goo Goo Dolls Iris 1999
This one crept up to become a classic. I first heard this some years after release, near the top of the then-annual Virgin/Absolute Radio “greatest ever” tracks in the early 2000’s. Suddenly tracks like this and “Chasing Cars” were right up there with the usual suspects of “Angels” and “Bohemian Rhapsody”. Definitely worth investigating. The name Goo Goo Dolls emerged when an as yet un-named young American garage band from Buffalo NY got their first gig and needed a name. Quickly they saw a toy, and the rest is history. Founder John Rzeznic commented, “if we had more time we would have come up with something better”. But the name stuck and the rest is history. “Iris” is not the group’s first hit but certainly their most well known and popular, eventually reaching a reasonable UK chart position in 1999. It appeared in almost all variations of the Billboard Chart – alternate rock, Hot 100, Radio, Adult and so-on – and was part of the soundtrack for City of Angels starring Meg Ryan and Nicolas Cage. It won the Grammy for best record and also best song (no I don’t know the difference either!) It is regularly performed by X-Factor entrants, and generally charts again straight afterwards. Difficult to describe – powerful folk rock, perhaps – listen to it here – you’ll know it!
Moby Why Does My Heart Feel So Bad 1999
There is a wonderful story behind Moby’s rise to fame with singles like this from his breakthrough album Play. He had produced a first, dark, electronica album Animal Rights with a little success. Opening for Soundgarden on tour, the audience through things at him. He considered quitting but was encouraged by praise from Bono, Terence Trent Derby and Axl Rose (Moby commented, if you are going to get three pieces of fan mail, that’s the fan mail to get”). For his next album he took the unusual step of mixing his ambient electronica and techno music with samples from American folk and gospel (such as Run On, a version of God’s Gonna Cut You Down which Johnny cash recorded) and African music (such as the Banks Brothers on Why Does My Heart). The album Play gradually climbed the charts week by week in the U.K. until a year after release it hit No.1. Moby was as surprised as anyone to get the call about U.K. success, especially as he was still almost unknown in his home of America, playing well down the bill on tour.
The album carried on selling for another year or more eventually selling 12 million copies despite only reaching No.38 on the Hot 100 album chart. How did this happen? Well here’s my story. I resisted buying the album but eventually relented when I heard this incredible statistic: there are 18 tracks on the album and every one of them has either been a hit single with radio play (such as Porcelain, Southside and Where Does my Heart); or had been part of a film soundtrack such as Danny Boyle’s the Beach; or in TV series like the X-files; or in adverts such as Bailey’s Cream; or in new ballet. For a couple of years you couldn’t avoid Moby if you wished.
The album’s legacy is this: it brought original world and roots music to more prominence, and developed a subtle but commercial brand of electronic and ambient music. Fatboy Slim (a.k.a Norma Cook of the Housemartins) with Praise You was going in the same direction with big success too, but Moby’s music somehow seems more long lasting.
And as a footnote, years later, Alison and I helped our son Matthew with his GCSE music syllabus revision, which featured none other than Moby’s “Why Does My Heart”, up there with Mozart and Handel and Miles Davis. I learned about the record’s “layered textures and loops”! There is even a GCSE BBC Bitesize section devoted to it. (As a tutor I have become very familiar with Bitesize)
Baby One More Time Britney Spears 1999
Incudes the line “hit me baby” so I hoped at the time she meant Hit On Me, or whatever is the modern translation for “Step out” (OK I’m not that old) or “Go out” with me. In fact years later I learned that the Swedish writers has believed “hit me” meant “call me” in American. Phew, relief. Although one may have thought Britney would disappear like many teen sensations, in fact she has had a stellar career, with many hits like Oops I Did It Again, and Toxic, still highly successful especially in the U.S.A.
Appendix 1 – More on Methodology
Ten years ago for my 60th birthday in 2016 I selected three Singles from each of the sixty years which had passed since what I considered the birthday of rock’n’roll namely Elvis’s Heartbreak Hotel in 1956 – also , the year I was born. This made 180 singles in all, (based on year of release) But how to choose the way to select three records per year?
Weighting is a method of giving priority to certain items in a list for ranking or averaging. For instance the atomic mass of chlorine is shown as 35.5 because its isotopes are 75% 35.0 and 25% 37.0. In economics the Consumer Prices Inflation index (CPI) is calculated from a “basket of goods” in which for instance Housing is given a higher weighting than alcohol or communication. I needed a weighting method for my records and chose five criteria.
When polls are conducted these days they are packed with very recent records because people forget, or don’t know their pop history, or are genre specific. My “three per year” method for rock pop and soul weighted by my five criteria (summarised below) to ensure enduring legacy overcame these problems.
I chose five criteria for “scoring”: – Commercial worldwide sales – Moving the genre forward – Memorable lyrics – Critical acclaim – Fan polls
Years after my 60th birthday list, my favourite rock critic, Neil McCormick, produce a list of the 50 greatest albums, ranked, with the Beatles’ Abbey Road emerging at the top. His methodology to narrow down the list from numerous possibilities was to choose albums of an “enduring legacy” – in effect his weighting method. Also to focus on particular genres (namely rock, soul and pop as opposed to , say, classical). And to limit each artist to one or two entries (except the Beatles with three) in order to spread the recognition.
So I knew I was on the right track.
When I updated my list for my 70th birthday I made a few fractional changes in retrospect to the list and one significant change. I initially thought 1956 – the year of Elvis’s breakthrough and my own birth year was the beginning of modern pop rock and soul, but I now believe 1950 was the true beginning of the golden age of rock n’ roll and that by the year 2000 the momentum was drawing to a close. Hence I have focused on the neat half century 1950 – 2000.
Appendix 2. Beginning of the next 50 years
I have gone part way to using the same approach for 2000 onwards and there have been some fine records but I feel that it is now a new era.
Decade 2000’s
Stan. Eminem feat. Dido 2000
This record still has the power to enthral and disturb in equal measure 25 years after release, and deservedly recognised as one of the greatest rap records, and records in general, ever. There are so many things to say about it, where to begin? Well, first how come Dido is on a rap record?
Dido (whose full name was Dido Florian Cloud de Bounevialle O’Malley Armstrong, now shortened by the singer herself to just Dido) was born on Christmas Day and so in common with Paddington Bear has another birthday in June. She went to school in Islington and Westminster school and studied music, Her first album No Angel and single Here With Me, were already beginning to sell well, and Thank You had featured on the Gwyneth Paltrow Sliding Doors film. Eminem sought to include the gentle Thank You on Stan as contrast to the harsher rap and brutal storyline. The success of Eminem’s record brought Dido to fame in America and No Angel was the top selling album worldwide in 2001. Life for Rent and White Flag followed as further huge successes. I bought them all.
Dido also appeared in the video, at first reluctantly because of the violent nature of the story. Stan is of course an obsessive fan, who feels he is being ignored by rapper Eminem/Slim Shady, and eventually kills himself and his girlfriend in a car crash, and records the event for posterity on something called “a cassette”. Eminem meanwhile is in the process of finally writing back to Stan when he realises it is too late. Stan recalls hearing about some dude on the news, they “found a tape but did not say who it was to” and utters the killer line:
“Come to think about it, his name was, it was you, Damn”
The memorable thing for me about the way he sings the last line is this: no name between “was” and “it”, and in fact no delay at all between the thought and the terrible realisation of what this means, or between “you” and the reaction, “damn”.
Eminem of course is now one of the world’s biggest stars (his duet with Rhianna of “Love the Way You Lie” for instance was a recent worldwide best seller). Dido lives a quieter life these days, as a mother, but is still recording and touring. In fact I thought she was appearing at our local theatre recently in “Dido and Aeneas”. (Yes, it’s the Purcell opera, of course. But there is a connection: Dido the queen of Carthage was absolutely the basis of the singer’s parents’ choice of name).
Daft Punk. One More Time 2000
You may think that Edith Piaf, Charles Aznavour, Vanessa Paradi and Johnnie Halliday are the most famous singers. But no, Daft Punk surely are now. The robot helmeted pair of Guy-Manuel de Homem-Christo and Thomas Bangalter first scored a hit with “Around the World” and this worldwide electronic synthpop dance floor filler followed soon after. No.2 in the U.K., One More Time – seen here on the soundtrack of a Japanese cartoon film – is sometimes described as the greatest dance record ever and features in the Rolling Stone magazine’s top 500 tracks in history. More success of course was to follow some 15 years later with their Chic collaboration on Get Lucky. The compressed, auto tuned vocals are the most distinctive feature.
U2 Beautiful Day 2000
The song is about finding your way after “you’ve got no destination”; and finding solace in the beautiful day and sights you can see from space, including the “world in green and blue”. Also the “oilfields at first light” and I can relate to that, after working so long in the oil, gas and chemicals industry. Terrible beauty is a phrase U2 will know from their Irish back ground, and indeed there can be a terrible beauty about industrial scenes such as refineries, lit up at night, flares booming.
The Grammy winning, No.1 song took on a further significance when ITV used it as part of their “Premiership” programme, Desmond Lynam switching from BBC to present the early days of the Premier League. The show was initially shown at 7 p.m., but this was not popular and even when switched to later, soon the writing was on the wall: only Match of the Day could present a Saturday night football highlights show.
U2 have made some good records since then including Vertigo and The Saints Are Coming (with Green Day) but I wonder if history will judge Beautiful Day as the last U2 classic? When U2 recently released a promising album, their most recent, Songs of Innocence, and a storming punk inspired single “The Miracle of Joey Ramone”, I was about to buy the album. However the group, with Apple, decided to release it free of charge on iTunes. I thought, if it is free it has no value. If it is of no value, it cannot be that good. So from the point of being prepared to purchase for £10, I never did get the album, because it was too cheap, and ignored the free downloads.
Notwithstanding Bono’s serious injuries sustained in a cycling accident, U2 remain one of the great touring groups, but it would be great if they could release just one more chart topping rock single! Paul Hewson (Bono Vox, meaning good voice); David Evans (the Edge, nicknamed because of his angular looks and sharp instincts); Larry Mullen Jr; and Adam Clayton make up one of the greatest of all rock groups, having formed over 30 years ago as school mates at Mount Temple School in Dublin. They all answered an advert on a school noticeboard, looking for band members. An epic way to start. Keep going, boys!
Destiny’s Child Survivor 2001
The group’s three lead singers, Beyoncé Knowles, Kelly Rowland and Michelle Williams all went on to have solo success, especially Beyoncé, but this is where it all started. After scoring a big No.1 with What’s My Name, the album Survivor delivered three more hits, Independent Woman (from Charlie’s Angels), Bootylicious, and the title track I’m a Survivor, which went straight in at No.1 in the UK charts. The group were reinventing soul music in terms both of singing style, assertive lyrics, and an urban style which saw them jump in and out of double time. The group had initially been Girl Tyme, with a fourth member LaToya Tuckett, but after becoming a threesome a la Supremes, they settled on Destiny’s Child by referencing the Book of Isiah.
Missy “Misdemeanor” Elliot . Get Ur Freak On 2001
I first really caught on to this record when it became the NME’s single of the year in 2001. (Just ahead of Kylie’s Can’t Get You Out of My Head – how times had changed since the NME championed punk). The record has the distinctive Bhangra style and tumbi instrument from India. An astonishing combination of world music and hip-hop, the producer was Timbaland with whom Missy has frequently collaborated down the years. She has had a stellar career since then both as a producer and solo artist, and the record hit the charts again in 2015 when she performed it at the half time Superbowl concert.
Kylie Minogue. Can’t Get You Outa My Head 2001
Kylie had moved on from early Neighbour’s acting roles to filming Shakespeare’s the Tempest in Barbados (she played Miranda); and from Stock Aitken and Waterman’s I Should Be So Lucky to the disco track Spinning Around, a U.K. No.1. So the scene was set for her greatest commercial and critical achievement, Can’t Get You Outa My Head. The track was co-written by Cathy Dennis (disco solo artist turned successful writer) and Rob Davis. If you recognise the name, yes it’s the guy from Mud, with the long curly hair and earrings. Initially the track was offered to S Club 7 – who turned it down – and then to Sophie Ellis Bextor, whom Rob had worked with on the classic Spiller track Goovejet (If this aint love). Sophie also turned it down. However Kylie knew it was for her within a minute of hearing the demo.
The song has a classic New Order type robotic dance bass line, and 124 bpm synthpop drum loop. But there are oddities which make it so appealing. The structure is not typical Verse Chorus Verse Chorus. Rather, it begins with the Chorus (just as some Beatles tracks did) but then has several “misplaced sections”. The lyrics at first sound fairly basic, but close listening reveals quite an obsessive feel, al la The Police’s Every Breath You Take.
The song entered the U.K. Chart at No.1, a position it reached in an astonishing 40 countries. It is one of the highest selling singles of all time with 7 million copies. It won several “single of the year” accolades and an Ivor Novello award. The song and video are considered Kylie’s “signature” performances. A footnote: at the time there was considerable hype of the “Blur/Oasis” type, for whether Kylie, or Victoria Beckham with “Not such an Innocent Girl” would hit the top spot first. It was Kylie of course.
Robbie Williams Feel 2002
Arguably the last great Robbie single, Feel was released from the Escapology album, and was a worldwide hit, though not in America. It is now seen as his third great signature tune, along with Let Me Entertain You and Angels. The classic line from the song is “before I’ve arrived I can see myself coming” and this was a line I kept humming years later when I popped his Greatest Hits album in the CD player while driving across France and Belgium through the long flat countryside on route to Brussels for one of my last ever appointments with BP Chemicals. This lyric – along with “not sure I understand this road I’ve been given” – seemed to be telling me something was wrong; and indeed, while I was there in Brussels, 7/7 was happening back in London. A scary moment. I was glad to get back to my family.
The other famous line in the song was “I want to feel real love, in the home that I live in”. I always sensed that Robbie found it a little awkward to sing this line. Mind you, the more grammatically correct “in the home in which I live” would be even more awkward! Shades of Paul McCartney’s “ever changing world in which we live in”.
Soon after Robbie played to an astonishing 375,000 fans over three consecutive nights at Knebworth. Arguably the biggest single live music event in Britain ever. I remember looking at the show on TV, and there was a moment when he stopped singing and just looked out at his adoring fans. I suspect he was wise enough to know, this will never happen again, enjoy the moment.
Coldplay . The Scientist 2002
The members of Coldplay are Chris Martin, Johnny Buckland, Guy Berryman and Will Champion. The band have continued unchanged since the start, apart from one brief firing and reinstatement of drummer Will, and a brief offer – turned down – for Tim Rice-Oxley of Keane to join. Most of the boys have a University College London background. There are mathematicians among them (hooray!) but Chris himself is a classicist (hooray from my brother!).
Chris had the decency to complete his studies even though the band had started releasing records. He gained a First Class Honours in Latin and Greek (not your average artists from the “street”!).
The band’s breakthrough was with “Yellow” and their rise to international stardom really gathered pace with “Rush of Blood to the Head” and the singles Clocks, In My Place and The Scientist.
The Scientist is a slow song, but seems to me to pull off the trick of having an insistent, pulsing rhythm. The video for the Scientist is shot in reverse motion – for which Chris had to spend a month learning the song backwards. Was it worth it? Yes, watch the video to the end it’s a fascinating, clever, story with a twist. And it makes sense of one of the key lines “I’m going back to the start”. The most important line, though is, “Questions of science, science and progress, do not speak as loud as my heart”.
Hurt . Johnny Cash 2002
I wouldn’t normally feature a record right at the end of an artist’s career – but with this record that is the whole point. Hurt was recorded just before the great Man in Black’s death, a fact which plays a significant part in the record’s story. And as well as being one his best ever records musically and lyrically, it features what is now recognised by many as the best pop video ever, by anyone, in history, period.
In a sense this record has nothing to do with the 21st century, in other senses it has everything to do with it because this century is a product of the last. And because the record is a beacon of “real” music amongst much of today’s homogenised, “produced by committee”, fare.
Hurt, along with B-side Personal Jesus written by Depeche Mode, comes from the album American IV, the last in a series of albums recorded in the 1990’s and early 2000’s, in which Johnny revisited and re-interpreted many mostly American classic folk and country songs, some well –known, some not. It would be wrong to say these albums were wholly responsible for relaunching his career – he never really went away – but they helped. His peers certainly recognised him as one of the greats – Bono was delighted when Johnny recorded U2’s “One” for instance.
Musically Hurt starts slowly and acoustically and builds to a memorable guitar and piano climax. But it is the video and lyrics which make this performance.
Johnny didn’t write the lyrics, but since almost every line seems to apply to him, one imagines he did, while looking back at his life. “I hurt myself today, to see if I still feel” he begins in now crackling voice, and continues.….”the needle tears a hole”. He may or may not have been a heroin user but he certainly faced drug and alcohol demons. “Everyone I know, goes away in the end”. As he ages his friends pass away (and in 2016 the demise of the great sixties generation of stars that survived is accelerating).
And then the central line of the song, “You could have it all, my empire of dirt”.
“Empire of dirt”, written by Nine Inch Nails’ Trent Raiznor, is one of the great evocative, “try and picture this” lyrics of rock’n’roll. Johnny looks back on his life, dismisses it (wrongly, you feel) – as tainted and corrupted. He’s achieved so much, but how much is it worth?
And Johnny continues, “I will let you down”. His first wife, certainly felt that way, as he spent so much time away on tour and eventually was unfaithful. And talking of faith, Johnny sings about the “crown of thorns” in reference to his own Christian faith. This was the only line in the whole song that he re-wrote, indicating both how much that faith meant to him, and yet that so much of the song’s darker sentiment really did fit with him.
And then at the end (one suspects at the real end of his life too); some reconciliation, happily, a compromise. “If I could start again, a million miles away, I would keep myself, I would find a way”. Not such a bad person, after all.
And then, on top of all that, the video. That video. Johnny sings “I remember everything” and producer Rick Rubin (of cult hip hop label Def Jam fame) indeed enables Johnny to do just that in the video.
Set in Cash’s own house and the House of Cash museum – but long since closed down, almost derelict, the victim of floods – we can see memorabilia, but faded: the cracked glass on a gold record. A banquet is laid out, but beginning to decay, perhaps for the emperor of dirt. We see Christ’s crown of thorns. Cash is still the main in black, but the handsome face a little blotched. Shots of Johnny playing guitar and piano, singing “Hurt” with the still deep and powerful voice, now a little cracked. Interspersed with footage of his earlier career, concerts: mostly happier times. Johnny living the American dream, jumping onto a railway wagon, guitar on his back.
Then as Johnny sings “What have I become, my sweetest friend” we see his wife June Carter Cash – a wonderful country singer herself – looking on from the stairs; worried, helpless, still adorable, still adoring.
The video closes symbolically with Johnny closing the piano lid, and stroking it tenderly, as if to say, “goodbye old friend”.
Three months later June passed away, and four months after that, Johnny too. And some time later the Cash’s house where the video was partly filmed, burned down.
The song and the video cast (self) doubt on the value of Johnny’s career. But he should not have worried – he achieved so much, his legacy is recognised more than ever.
Seven Nation Army White Stripes 2003
The song that shows why Jack White is a songwriter and I am not. He describes how “everyone” knows the story, and I would have been happy with that. But he goes on to embellish it with one of the great lines of modern rock music, “from the Queen of England to the Hounds of Hell”. That’s a pretty wide spread, and almost as good as the line I have just heard, that Jordan Speith, the golfer, makes a very rare double bogey at the Masters, and discovers his “inner Ernie Else”(Ernie had just taken 10 at a par 4).
And talking of sport, this record has become a favourite of England football fans. The guitar riff is played by the horn section (yes there is one) at England football matches.
I could never work out whether the drummer was Jack’s sister. Whatever, they were ahead of Royal Blood in creating very loud rock music from minimal instrumentation.
Jack has made many great records since then (including an off the wall Bond theme) but like it or not this is the one he’ll be remembered for, at least in the U.K.
Crazy In Love. Beyoncé feat. Jay-Z 2003
Crazy in Love brings two genres together, first 1970’s soul/funk with the French horn sample from a Chi-Lites minor hit Are You My Woman(Tell Me So); and second, the hip hop beats, and rap from Beyonce Knowles’ husband to be Jay-Z. And of course there’s Beyonce’s electrifying vocal performance and iconic video. All adding up to a dance floor classic.
While Beyoncé was just starting her solo career, after Destiny’s Child went their separate ways, Jay-Z was well established by then as a hugely successful rapper. He had grown up as Shawn Carter in Brooklyn New York, and had a difficult up-bringing. His father had left the family, he moved from school to school and at an early stage seemed to be exposed to drugs and violence (he would later be charged with knifing a record producer).An early school friend was the Notorious B.I.G. , future rapper and murder victim of a drive-by shooting. Carter’s mother noticed him banging out drum beats on the kitchen table, bought him a beat-box, and the rest as they say is history. Shawn Carter became Jay-Z in honour of his nickname Jazzy and fellow rapper Jaz-O. He began by selling CD’s from the boot of his car before signing a distribution deal with iconic Hip-Hop label Def Jam, of which in years to come he would be president.
It is sometimes difficult in the U.K. to realise just how popular and successful rap and hip-hop is in America and how mainstream its artists have become. Jay-Z alone has sold more than 100 million records worldwide and received 22 Grammy awards. His business empire grew alongside his music career. He owns 40 40 sports bar in New York, he founded the Roc Nation Sports Agency, he is part owner of Brooklyn Nets NBA team and at once stage was a possible investor in Arsenal F.C. He co-founded urban clothing brand Rocawear and recently heavily invested in Private Jet booking app JetSmarter. He co-owns the music streaming service Tidal. The list could go on. He is also a philanthropist and active supporter of President Obama.
Meanwhile that record. While Beyoncé is the lead, Jay-Z’s contribution tops it off. Crazy In Love was No.1 in both the U.K. and America and has become one of the biggest selling records of all time with 8 million plus sales. And the ultimate accolade? It was officially voted the track of the (2000’s) decade by the NME staff. Bear in mind that award went to the Sex Pistols with God Save the Queen in the 1970’s. Hip hop and rap have come a long way.
Arctic Monkeys. Bet You Look Good on the Dancefloor 2003
From Sheffield, Alex Turner’s band have taken on Indie and Punk rock music to the 21s century and achieved spectacular popularity both in the U.K. and, perhaps surprisingly, the U.S.A. as well. Their first hit is not easy on the ear, but then at the time it was very different to anything you were hearing on the radio. More recently their A.M. album with singles R U Mine and Do I Wanna Know has become one of my personal favourites not least because of its album cover – a nice oscilloscope style sin wave.
The Killers. All the Things I’ve Done 2004
Otherwise known by its famous refrain and chorus “I’ve got soul but I’m not a soldier”. The Killers are from Las Vegas, Nevada, home to Andre Agassi. I visited Las Vegas after skiing in Aspen, and saw not the Killers but the Temptations, in a cabaret style show. In Las Vegas the point to note is that you don’t walk anywhere; like the toy-store owner in Toy Story 2 you take the car even to cross the road.
Mr Brightside, was one of their other great hits from the album Hot Fuss, and a rousing rendition was reported on the BBC in 2016 after an attendee at an Irish Wake spontaneously sang the song in a pub and (inevitably) the YouTube video went viral (it is very funny) .
Hot Fuss and the singles quickly established the Killers as the commercial, acceptable face of indie alternative rock and many Grammy nominations were to follow. The band were named after seeing a logo in a New Order video and Brandon Flowers was inspired to form a band after seeing Oasis live. So they have a British connection, which comes through in their music. Another thing I like is their annual release of a Christmas single in aid of African charities.
2004 Maroon 5 She Will Be Loved
Maroon 5, from Los Angeles, broke through with their Songs About Jane album and Harder to Breathe single, and This Love and She Will be Loved followed, both nominated for Grammies. Maroon 5, aided by singer Adam Levine’s Holywood looks, have never looked back, touring extensively and achieving phenomenal sales more recently with Payphone, and dance anthem Moves Like Jagger, featuring Christine Aquilera.
Green Day Boulevard of Broken Dreams 2004
Billie Joe Armstrong’s California based group had a big hot with Dookie, a full decade before, but success was fading. The release of the classic American Idiot, a punk rock opera, changed all that. Five big hot singles resulted, the title track, Wake Me Up When September Comes, Holiday Jesus of Surburbia, and arguably the standout track, Boulevard of Broken Dreams. The song is based around a poster for a James Dean poster and describes the loneliness of walking the streets of New York, after the initial euphoria of the Holiday. The album is overtly political. I am not sure Donald Trump would like it: “I am not part of the redneck agenda” Billie Joe famously sings on the title track American Idiot.
The song reached top 5 in both U.K. and USA and won a Grammy for Record of the Year. The album, which became a Broadway and West End musical, is one of my personal all-time favourites and shows how British Punk and New Wave could have developed had we persevered.
Colplay . Fix You 2005
This was about the time that, after 28 years, I was leaving BP and specifically the ill-fated Chemicals spin-off Innovene, taken over by Ineos. As I often walked up from my office at the time in Staines to its town centre at lunchtime, I felt somewhat sad. I hummed this tune, with its optimistic message around “fix you”. I remember at the time that Chris Martin described the song as the “centrepiece” of the album X&Y. I checked my copy and found that, no, Speed of Sound was 7th of 13, Fix You was 4th. As a data scientist this bothered me. But thinking about it, I realised what he meant. Some songs are so important that all the rest fit around it. And of course, “Questions of science, science and progress, do not speak as loud as my heart”.
Fix You was written in tribute to Gwyneth Paltro’s recently deceased father, and fact features an organ that he had bought but not had the chance to play. This gives it a feel of both gospel and Jimmy Cliff’s Many Rivers To Cross. The song is both sad (dedicated to the 7/7 bombings) yet inspirational (the central guitar break is played at American Hockey games). The lyrics “Lights will guide you home” refer to the way the BT Tower used to guide the guys home to UCL lodgings after a night out. (For me, BT Tower will forever be the Post Office Tower, just as the Rendezvous Café in my hometown of Whitley Bay will always the Venetian café, even though the name in reality changed around 40 years ago. I’m reminded of this every time I visit or it appears on TV series such as detective series Vera.)
The video to Fix You begins in London Bridge’s Tooley Street. This seemed appropriate, as soon after leaving BP, my next full time job was indeed at London Bridge, in Seacontainer’s offices, right underneath the Shard as it grew each day to eventually dwarf the Post Office Tower.
I Predict a Riot. Kaiser Chiefs 2005
The last great Punk record. Fast, attacking guitar sound, memorable chorus with shades of the Clash’s White Riot, and inner city angst lyrics.
The Kaiser Chiefs were named after the South African football team and arrived on the scene around the same time as their fellow Austro-German WW1 protagonist named group, Franz Ferdinand.
Ricky Wilson’s song describes a dismal, violent night out in his home town Leeds, which includes what reads like a police beating, which “would never have happened to Smeaton, an old Leodensian”. A memorable line.
I am ashamed to say that for many years I had assumed “Smeaton” was a Dickensian character (he does sound like one). But in fact John Smeaton was a civil engineer from Leeds (a Leodensian) and a very interesting one too. He contributed to the famous debate within the Royal Society scientists on whether Liebnitz’s conservation of energy theory contradicted Newton’s Laws. He designed the Eddystone Lighthouse (not, not quite Eddison Lighthouse of Love Grows fame). He designed the Portland tower for which Portland cement was developed, which became Smeaton Tower at Plymouth. He built many bridges including the Hexham and Coldstream bridges, and built the Spital Tounges chimney at Newcastle upon Tyne.He devised a water engine for Kew Gardens, and even found time to invent “Smeaton’s coefficient” and formula L = kV² AC1 which would be used a hundred years later by the Wright Brothers to help design the first successful aeroplane. What a man, a true British hero of the industrial revolution. No wonder he is credited with invention of the term “Civil Engineer”.
I have followed the band since that first hit. Excellent works like “Ruby, Ruby, Ruby”, but I always regret that “I Predict a Riot” was the end of a Punk revival rather than the beginning. The Kaiser Chiefs are still going strong, with Ricky Wilson branching out into ventures such as judge for the Voice and a small part in Harry Potter. Not especially a worldwide hit, but as an observation on inner city Britain and an attempt to keep punk rock music in the charts, it is spot on.
Foo Fighters. Best of You 2005
After the untimely death of Nirvana’s Kurt Cobain, drummer Dave Grohl was at a loss how to proceed. A multi instrumentalist and songwriter, Dave put together his new group The Foo Fighters, which have become one of the most successful rock bands in the world, with Dave switching frequently to guitar as well as lead vocal. The song Best of You was written after working with politician John Kerry and is the band’s biggest single. Dave Grohl recently gained respect for carrying on playing with a broken leg after falling off the stage!
Crazy Gnarls Barclay 2006
I have a theory that if you want a hit record, then simply use a song with “Crazy” in the title. For instance Crazy For You, Crazy Little Thing Called Love, Crazy in Love, and “Crazy” itself (a different song) originally by Willie Nelson. This record took its inspiration from the Sergio Leone/Clint Eastwood Dollars trilogy, with its Ennio Morricone score, and another Spaghetti Wester, Django Prepare a Coffin. The song received critical acclaim and spent nine weeks at the top of the U.K. charts, also becoming the first song to achieve the No.1 spot on the basis of downloads alone.
Chasing Cars Snow Patrol 2006
I began to realise just how good this was when it was voted Number 1 song of all time in the annual Virgin/Absolute poll, pushing the usual suspects of Bohemian Rhapsody, Angels, Let It Be and Imagine downwards. However, this actually was the inspiration partly for this 60 years of rock’n’roll list. Good as the song was, and still is, and as fascinating as these polls are, this type of vote is heavily influenced by what people have heard recently. So if the poll was repeated in 2016, would Chasing Cars still be No.1? Probably not, so the answer, as I have done, is to force the issue, ensuring three songs from each of my 60 years are chosen, across a wide spread of genres.
The song by Northern Irish band Snow Patrol – who had already released one classic, Run – starts slowly and builds beautifully and dramatically; in one sense it is romantic but is not quite what you think. The phrase “Chasing Cars” originates in an infatuation, yes, but comparing it to a dog relentlessly chasing a car, and ether not catching it or not knowing what to do when it catches up. Nevertheless, a timeless classic. The song was one of the early records to benefit from Download (I Tunes essentially in those days) and inclusion in the Grey’s Anatomy box-set seasons hugely boosted its American sales, such that it was nominated for a Grammy. It also brought the final curtain down on Top of The Pops, being the last song played live on the show.
Dani California 2006 Red Hot Chilli Peppers
I first took great interest in this song when fans in a Radio Poll voted it their favourite Chilli Peppers song. What, no “Under the Bridge”, or Higher Ground? Those early Peppers records from the 1990’s had put me on their case from the start But something strange had happened, It was the start of I Tunes, and the listeners had been greatly influenced by the new phenomenon called the “download” . But that’s not all. Dani California turned out to be the third in a trilogy of songs about “Dani”. “Californication” had introduced the as yet un-named “teenage bride with a baby inside”, and “By the Way” had proceeded with “Dani the girl” before Dani California told more of the unfortunate girl’s life story before eventual sad demise.
Anthony Keidis,songwriter and singer possessed of a powerful yet haunting voice, explained that Dani was a combination of all the girls he had been with. The Peppers have had a tortured life but are still at the top of their game, and are headlining Festivals in the UK in 2016. Keidis, guitarist Fruscianate, and Flea have both taken drugs and argued about usage. In “under the Bridge” Keidis is “lonely in the City of Angles” because his bandmates have disowned him for too little drug-taking. But their musical pedigree is assured. Flea is often voted amongst the top three bass players of all time (Paul McCartney and John Entwhistle being the others)
I watched the Peppers on TV at Knebworth and they were outstanding. The Dani song is the band’s usual unique combination of rock and funk and the story of Dani’s travels though America reminds me how cool American place-names like Minisota, Mississippi, Alabama, Louisiana and California sound – much better than Yorkshire, Sussex, Norfork perhaps. The song features in “Rock Band”; and the “Sons of Anarchy” Cable TV series – an early indication of how popular rock songs would be in gritty American TV dramas of the Sky Atlantic/Netflix age.
2007 Mark Ronson and Amy Winehouse Valerie
Although Rehab and the album title track Back to Black are probably of more substance lyrically and ultimately more prophetic for poor Amy, let us remember her for this up tempo dance track which I think in years to come will be the one that actually gets played most on the radio. Originally a hit for Liverpool band the Zutons, long time Amy collaborator and producer Mark Ronson recorded Amy’s version by completely reworking the song. Mark went on to produce Uptown Funk and Amy recorded with Tony Bennet no less. I remember having dinner with our friends Gerry and Denise, who mentioned they had seen a headline about one of their favourite singers, Amy Winehouse. They thought it seemed like bad news. I checked the internet and confirmed the worst. They were devastated, as we so many when she passed away.
Rihanna and Jay-Z Umbrella 2007
It’s is easy to forget that by 2007 Rihanna, born in Barbados to a Guyanan mother, and attending school with future England cricketer Chris Jordan, had already scored top 10 hits in the UK and U.S.A. with singles Pon de Replay, S.O.S. and Unfaithful. Rapper and music mogul Jay Z had signed Rihanna to his Def Jam label, and Umbrella eventually as a song came to Rihanna after almost being taken up by Britney Spears and Mary J. Blige. The thing which clinched it for Rihanna was the Ella, Ella hook, and the unusual hip hop hi-hat beat. The song was a No.1 worldwide including 10 weeks at the top in the U.K.
Take That Patience 2007
During the late 1990’s and early 2000’s shares in Gary Barlow collapsed while Robbie William’s stock went stratospheric. Gary was a million miles from being the nation’s treasure that he would become. So it was a surprise and a risk when after a ten year absence he reformed Take That as a foursome. But the Beautiful World album was high quality and two singles in particular stood out. Shine was one – featuring an up temp rhythm and rare Mark Owen lead vocal – which rather irritatingly became the signature tune for Morrison’s supermarket. The lyric was rumoured to be about Robbie prior to his return. The other singe was Patience, a more traditional ballad, featuring Gary Barlow falsetto. The song was No.1 for 4 weeks in the U.K. and went on to win the Brit Award for best British single. It was in the top sellers lists in the U.K.in both 2006 and 2007. Take That were well and truly “back for good”- now there’s an idea for a song!
A few years later in 20010 Robbie Williams re-joined for the Progress album from which The Flood – one of my own personal favourites – was released. Take That’s national tour was sensationally successful – I watched on TV as Robbie was given some solo time mid concert to do his three signatures, Angles, Feel, and Entertain You. Then the five members performed many of their number 1’s reminding you that they have had an astonishing 12 U.K. No.1’s over a 25 year career.
Sex on Fire. Kings of Leon 2008
As a fan of Southern Rock, of the Lynyrd Skynyrd type, I was already fascinated by this band from the Nashville and Tennessee areas, before their breakthrough. I also loved the fact that all four members of the band were related – three brothers and a cousin – all called Followill. As youngsters, the band has hit the road in an Oldsmobile, touring with their Preacher father at churches and tent revivals. The band achieved success in the U.K. before America, but scored worldwide success with their Only By The Night album, and singles Sex on Fire and Use Somebody.
One Day Like this Elbow 2008
I was well of the song by the time the 2012 Olympics came along, having bought the album already, the wonderfully titled Seldom Seen Kid. But I was unprepared for what happened when Guy Garvey and the band played live at the London Olympic ceremony – the whole crowd seemed to rise as one and join in in a Hey Jude style rendition of the chorus. (Guy Garvey later said this wasn’t a total coincidence – just for once he wanted to record an anthemic song). “Throw those curtains wide, one day like this a year would see me right” is one of the great feel-good lines in rock and “Its looking like a beautiful day” with staccato strings is equally memorable. Every one of the 80,000 people at the Olympic stadium seemed to know the song, whatever their age and background.
I also recall a wonderful re-playing of the whole Seldom Seen Kid album by the band with the BBC Concert Orchestra recorded at the “Beatles studio” Abbey Road. A “rock music as art” cultural event of the highest order. Although the track was not a big worldwide seller, it won the coveted “Ivor Novello” award for best song of the year musically and lyrically.
Lady Gaga Poker Face 2008
Stefani Joanne Angelina Germanotta seemed to appear from nowhere but she didn’t – she came up the hard way, learning her trade in theatre, in musicals, as a songwriter, as a method actor, small part TV actor, and performance artist. 75% Italian, she grew up in New York’s Manhattan, and went to school there in the Convent of the Sacred heart, She suffered some knock backs – dropped from Def Jam record label – before breaking through with her album “Fame”. The name Lady Gaga came by accident. Her boyfriend texted Radio Gaga, but autocorrected to Lady Gaga. The rest is history.
Relocating to Los Angeles, Lady Gaga scored worldwide success with Poker Face. A synthpop EDM song, it became the best welling single of 2009 worldwide, and launched Lady Gaga onto an unsuspecting public.
Lady Gaga proved she was by no means a two album wonder (Fame and Fame Monster) and with Born This Way in 2011 became one of the highest selling artists of all time. I had thought that Born This Way was an autobiographical life story, but in fact it pays homage to the gay and LBGT community that she resonates with. Unusual fact: the dance anthem was part recorded at iconic rock studio, Abbey Road.
Alecia Keys and Jay Z Empire State of Mind 2009
This is a record where I really get Rap. While Alecia rerecorded a version and video on her own, the much edgier original with rapper Jay Z really makes sense as you can see on this classic video. “Concrete jungle, where dreams are made of” sums up the New York I know. It’s a wonderful city, from Times Square all the way uptown to Harlem and beyond. When Jay Z was presented with the song for his Roc nation label, he wisely chose Alecia Keys, the classically trained pianist, for the vocal because of the epic sweep of the song which suited a major piano contribution.
Black Eyed Peas Gotta Feeling 2009
The Black Eyed Peas, featuring singer Fergie (Stacey Ferguson) and the now Voice host will.I.am (William Adams), had their first major number 1 in 2003 with Where Is the Love, and the dance floor filler followed with a 14 week spell at No.1 in the U.S.A in 2009. Adams has formed the group as early as 1988 in High School in Los Angeles, and at one stage approached future Pussycat Doll and Reality TV judge Nicole Scherzinger to join the group before settling on children’s TV star Fergie.
Single Ladies (Put a Ring on it). Beyoncé 2009
The record begins with classic soul and gospel call and response. “All the Single Ladies”. “Single Ladies!”. Beyoncé is on the prowl in a club with her single girlfriends. She spots an ex-boyfriend, and scolds him for not “putting a ring on it”. Not committing. The song follows in the great line of female empowerment anthems, from Aretha’s Respect to Gloria Gaynor’s I Will Survive. But there is an irony, that having got a $5 million Lorraine Schwartz designed ring herself from husband Jay Z, Beyoncé seemed to hide it. The power couple are famous for not especially appearing married in public, if I read the celebrity magazines and social media right (but then I don’t read them so I am probably wrong). However, Beyoncé was then criticised by some for naming her 2013 tour the Mrs Carter tour (Jay-Z is Shawn Carter). The poor lady cannot win!. Too complicated for me, as is the debate about who is the most powerful power couple, Jay-Z and Beyoncé or Kanye West and Kim Kardashian. Again, I am unaware of this rivalry as I don’t own a Mobile phone with which to keep up with events.
The song was released from the I Am Sasha Fierce album, which la Rod Stewart had a fast side and slow side. So Single Ladies was released simultaneously with If I Were a Boy, an equally fine track. Musically, its principally rap with some Double Dutch staccato clapping rhythm, and a crooner break mid track, and the vocals are particularly strident to get the message across. The record has sold upwards of 6 million copies pushing it into the list of worldwide best-selling singles, and has been nominated for a multitude of awards; and interestingly Rock Magazine Rolling Stone made it their single of the year at the time.
The video, a very simple black and white, fast and furious dance routine with similar choreography to the “internet sensation” Mexican breakfast, has become iconic and further enhances the song’s legend. The song is very much part of her Live set list.
it is clear, all joking aside, that the Beyoncé is now the most influential and talented female star on the planet. I began to realise this, when listening to Rock Journalist BBC Radio’s Jo Whiley talking about Glastonbury. When asked what was the best live performance she had seen at the festival (and she has seen a few) she replied without hesitation, “Beyoncé”. She explained that she had started with her two best known songs (Crazy in Love and Single Ladies) and Jo had thought, where does she go from here? But in fact Jo recalled, she just got better and better, the hit songs just kept on coming.
And not averse to making a political statement, Beyoncé supported the Black Lives Matter campaign with her Formation performance at this year’s Superbowl.
She is one remarkable woman. Many of the vocal and musical styles we take for granted these days were initiated by her. She essentially reinvented soul music for this century.
Decade 2010’s
2010 Katy Perry Firework
Kathryn Hudson as she is really named released her first album under that name. Initially a gospel singer she transitioned to dance pop and transitioned to Katy Perry, her mother’s maiden name, to avoid confusion with actress Kate Hudson. She first came to prominence with I Kissed A Girl. The song is about self-confidence (“You’re a firework, show them what you’re worth”) and has become one of her signature songs along with California Girls and Roar. The recent Taylor Swift song Bad Blood is rumoured to reflect strained relations between the girls. Time will tell of that is true.
2010 Adele Rolling in the Deep
Adele Laurie Blue Adkins grew up with a single mother in Tottenham and Brighton. Most people like myself first became aware of Adele through her Chasing Pavements single and album “19”, but Hometown Glory was her first hit, written about West Norwood (they had moved back to London, and Adele was a graduate of the Brit Performing Arts School in Croydon along with classmates Jessie J and Leona Lewis).
Rolling in the Deep, from “21”, set Adele on the road to superstardom. Written with co-songwriter Paul Epworth, who seems to me to perform the same kind of role that Guy Chambers did with Robbie Williams, the song was No.1 on the Billboard Hot 100 chart for seven weeks. It topped the year end Billboard sales charts, and was both Grammy song of the year and record of the year: a triumvirate achieved by very few – the only others being Bridge Over Troubled Water, First Time I Ever saw Your face, and Bettie Davies Eyes.
The other important thing it revealed was Adele’s ability to vary her genre and pace – this up-tempo, Bluesy foot stomper provided an edge to her credibility. By no means just a balladeer, I concluded.
2010 Mumford and Sons The Cave
Mumford and Sons became world superstars the proper way. Starting with small, then medium then large gigs, touring as support act, breaking America with radio play, then major success with debut album Sigh No More and the single “Little Lion Man”. Next came “The Cave”, which on first hearing sounds like an inspiring call to return to help your fellow prisoners on escape from confinement – “I will hold on hope, won’t let you choke”. Indeed it is, but it is much, much deeper than that. The lyrics are based in fact on the Greek philosopher Plato, the allegory of “Plato’s Cave”, in which prisoners are in chains from birth with only a wall to look at, and occasionally the shadows cast by humans by a fire. The allegory and the song are about disoriented feelings on release. “So come out of your cave walking on your hands, And see the world hanging upside down” And “call to the sirens” references Homer’s Odyssey too. Not your average “boy meets girl” song then! (And yet, is there a hint of relationship breakup in the lyrics? I love songs which on first hearing I haven’t a clue what they mean, then even revealing hidden depths lave an element of uncertainty. Many of the great songs – and this is one – are like that). And the Cave is probably the only part of my son Mathew’s A-Level Philosophy and Ethics syllabus which also appears in this “best song” list!. Mind you, daughter Ellie may well study a Shakespeare play which the Mumford reference in other songs.
The musical sound of the song – like “I will wait” from their even more successful album Babel, has the feel of all of the traditions of British and Irish Folk and American Bluegrass combined and yet sounds fresh and unique. Not often is a banjo, ukulele or mandolin heard in the Charts! (unless you count John Peel’s famous appearance on Top of the Pops to accompany on mandolin Rod Stewart’s Maggie Mae)
A few years ago I watched several episodes of the “Transatlantic sessions” on BBC4, a remarkable programme which paired country and folk musicians from both sides of the Atlantic and which explored the shared heritage of these two great musical genres in live relatively unrehearsed sessions.. One featured Transatlantic artist was country great Emmylou Harris, who performed a memorable version of “The Cave” with the Mumfords on the American country crossover programme “CMT Crossroads”.
The Mumfords are named after Marcus Mumford, the only Mumford but the chief organiser, and deliberately sound like an old small business. They organise small concerts in faraway villages in their “Gentlemen of the Road” programme which has the feel of the Travelling Wilburys concept. The band are from West London, which of course has a rich folk tradition, including the Strawbs, originally called the Strawberry Hill Boys, named after my current hometown village near Twickenham. Marcus, although American born, lived most of his life in nearby Wimbledon. He is married to actress Carey Mulligan, whom he met as a pen-pal. He has a voice to die for. Rather than categorise his music as folk-rock, too narrow a boundary, let me just call it quality music which happens to include folk and rock among other genres.
The Cave is multi award-winning and achieved no less than 4 Grammy nominations, the American music industry equivalent of the Oscars. The band have achieved Brit Award “Group of the Year” status. But for me the lasting legacy will have been to bring refreshing variety back to the increasingly formulated Charts, through the genre of folk music which only periodically goes mainstream. It is a cliché, but “authentic” defines the Mumfords. One of the great enjoyments of this journey through the ages is to rediscover records like the Cave which I had bought early on, but didn’t realise quite how critically acclaimed and popular worldwide it had become, and how much depth it possessed.
2011 Adele Someone Like You
Although Adele briefly showcased this song from “21” live on Jools Holland’s Later, for most people, including myself, the first viewing of Adele singing this was at the 2011 Brit Awards. Very simple, piano backing only, the lights from the audience tables shimmering, I knew before the end that I was a watching a classic live performance and so it proved. After the show the record shot to number 1 in the UK and America.
Here was a case where the live performance added something extra to the original recording. Bob Marley achieved this with No Woman No Cry, by changing the pace and drawing strength from the audience. Adele lived the story on stage, of rejection by a boyfriend, fighting to hold back the tears. What must that boy be thinking?
2011 Lana Del Ray Video Games
Elizabeth Woolridge Grant changed her name to Lana Del Ray because it reminded her of the seaside, Miami, Cuba – and the 50’s style glamour she so successfully brings to her persona. Born in New York City and with a catholic upbringing (as do so many female stars it seems to me) Lana’s second album Born to Die featured the unforgettable Video Games.
Awash with lavish strings, dramatic, sad, atmospheric it tells the story of her relationship with a boy, who seems to enjoy his beer and video games. Does she think he plays too much? Not clear but it raises the issue of whether modern the male youth is addicted to them. Gone are the days when boys carried LP covers of King Crimson under their arms as a sign of street credibility, or bought their favourite guitar band the Jam’s latest single immediately on release. Computer games and Box Sets have replaced rock music as the item of choice to spend pocket money on. Also gone are the days when boys outshone girls at school – while girls admittedly spend more time on social media, it is not as addictive as computer games.
The song was a worldwide hit and in many polls song of the year.
2011 We Found Love Calvin Harris and Rhianna
Calvin Harris (actually born Adam Wiles, in Dumfries) is a Scottish producer and DJ specialising in electronic and techno dance music. His album 18 Months surpassed Michael Jackson by producing no less than 10 hit singles. But given that he uses guest vocalists is it really “his” album. Rhianna performance on “We Found Love” (in a hopeless pace) generated a worldwide hit, staying at No.1 in the Billboard Hot 100 in the U.S.A for 8 consecutive weeks.
2012 Coldplay Paradise
Round about Viva La Vida is 2008 and continuing with Mylo Xoto in 2011 something strange happened. Though Coldplay were most certainly an alternative rock band, and arguably an album band, they began to court favour with celebrities from the dance and rap world and made singles which seemed deliberately commercial, for the charts. Were they selling out? Consider this: very few rock bands have Number 1’s or even Top Ten Singles anymore, and I feel Coldplay sensed there was a gap to be filled, that Singles success really mattered. The trend continued even further with Ghost Stories in 2014 with Sky Full of Stars, an out and out electronic dance music track a la Calvin Harris from Ghost Stories. Plus, their U2 sounding of Speed of Sound was beginning to sound a bit too, well, U2-like. Something had to change, to keep the band fresh and successful, and credit to Coldplay they have pulled it off, while still maintaining credibility. A constant of these most recent albums is the producer, one Brian Eno of Roxy Music fame, and sure to keep the band honest.
It is interesting though that following the usual success of 2014-5’s Head Full of Dreams, the band are hinting that this 7th album brings to an end a cycle of albums, and a break is imminent. Hopefully it is temporary.
Paradise live holds a special place in the memories of the Anderson family in 2012. Coldplay closed the Paralympic closing ceremony, bringing to an end one of the most memorable 4 weeks that any Londoner will ever experience. We watched two of the cycle events from the bottom of our road, we saw the Gloriana on the river, I saw the triathlon live at Hyde Park, sneaking out from work on a long lunchtime. My son Matthew visited Olympic park. The opening and closing of the Olympic and Paralympics showcased British rock music at its very best, and Coldplay did a magnificent job playing a full set, including joining with Rhianna on Princess of China and Jay-Z on Paradise.
Paradise became one few the few rock bands to achieve a number 1 in recent years, gradually rising week by week to hot the top spot in the first week of 2012. I often feel the slow burners are a sign of quality and longevity.
2012 Adele Skyfall
There have been some genuinely great Bond songs which transcend the movie, such as Live and Let Die and the Shirley Bassey songs, and this is one. The ending to this Bond film is not, as usual, in some giant structure, with hundreds of enemy agents. Rather, it takes place in the gloomy surrounds of the Skyfall country house, in Scotland where Bond grew up. Or was it? Although the car journey up through the Scottish mountains on the scenic valley road was real, the route was the A82 via Loch Lomond rather than Bond’s description of nearby the A9; and at the end of the journey they reach the house itself which is in fact in…Surrey. No matter, the song brilliantly captures both the traditional Bond theme drama, and the specific feel of the closing scenes, in which of course Judy Dench bows out of the series.
Imagine Dragons Radioactive 2012
Las Vegas based Imagine Dragons are famed for blending genres and that is just what they did with this combination of dubstep, electronica and rock. The disturbing, fuzzy sound matches the lyrics – apocalyptic. Making it perfectly suited to computer games such as Assassin’s Creed. The song was a sleeper, eventually reaching No.3 in the States and holding the record at 87 weeks for the most consecutive weeks on the Hot 100.
Rather Be. Clean Bandit feat. Jess Glynne 2013
Jess Glynne did the hard yards, pulling out of X-factor because of musical differences at the age of 15 in 2005, before completing A-Levels in London and building up her musical experience by networking in the music business, and taking a year-long music course at an East London college. She signed a deal with Atlantic Records – now there is a label with a pedigree, going all the way back to Aretha and Led Zeppelin – and a House group Route 94 asked her to sing lead on their My Love record (which would later become a No.1 for Jess) .
Meanwhile EDM producers and musicians Clean Bandit heard My Love, and asked Jess to take the lead on “Rather Be”. Recorded late 2013 the record immediately hit No.1 in January 2014 in the UK and became a worldwide hit, including in America. “Rather Be” is now officially one of the ten most streamed songs in Spotify history, at 400 million and counting, no doubt helped by the rather irritating M&S advert “Adventures in Imagination” (you know the one).
I liked Jess Glynne from the start. She has a voice that is suitable for the EDM age, yet is soulful and has a deep power (no doubt Atlantic were encouraged by that). Let us hope a recent operation on her vocal chords is successful. Plus, having come through the hard way, she will last the course, and in interviews she clearly has a strong focus on what she wants to achieve.
As a song you might argue that it’s good but not great. But what brings it into this list is the video. At time of writing we are approaching 2.5 billion views on YouTube. That is two thousand five hundred million. It is difficult to get one’s head around that. Like a score of 8-0 has to be spelled out (that’s eight) It caused YouTube to redesign their rules for storage from 23 to 64 bit integers. The video of course featured the dance style which took off round the world, bringing K-Pop to an international audience. Presidents, Prime Ministers, Movie Stars and Royal Family were happy to be seen trying the “horse trot” dance move. As a dance craze, it’s not quite on a par with the “Twist” in 1962 to 1963 but it is up there.
Psy is not an overnight sensation, the single being from his 6th album, recorded and released in 2012 and charting through 2012/2013. He admits though it will be impossible to surpass the impact. He is a very nice fellow in fact. Paul Lester of The Guardian labelled it as “generic ravey Euro dance with guitars”, and as “Pump Up the Jam meets the Macarena with a dash of Cotton Eye Joe”
Gangnam style refers to a lifestyle in fashionable Seoul in South Korea, the equivalent of Chelsea or Beverley Hills. Additional private education is almost taken, with children cramming to get into the best cramming schools. The café culture is hip and trendy.
What does it say about the quality of music compared let us say to the 1960’s? Well the originality clearly is not there, but the worldwide impact is almost beyond imagination, and the means by which we measure impact (YouTube sensation, going viral, downloads etc) moved to a whole new level with this record. And culturally brought Asia and the West much closer.
2013 Daft Punk ft. Pharrell Williams and Nile Rodgers Get Lucky
Nile Rodgers of Chic was asked to contribute to this Daft Punk disco track and in the end dominated with the kind of wonderful guitar riff we remember so well from his 70’s and 80’s dance anthems like Good Times. For me Nile Rogers is right up there with some of the great guitarists showing you don’t have to be out and out rock to be a great lead electric guitarist. As Alison I found out at Kew Gardens that summer when we saw an outdoor concert featuring Chic (sadly without bass player Bernard Edwards who had passed away earlier) and another favourite Heather Small with M People. Nile has composed or produced so many classics from his own material like Le Freak to Bowie’s Lets Dance, Diana Ross’s Upside Down, Duran Duran’s the Reflex, Sister Sledge’s We Are Family and Madonna’s Like a Virgin.
Get Lucky – seen here in the video of perhaps the coolest super-group ever – once released was an instance success, No.1 round the world and selling 9 million copies. Bringing French enigmatic electronic duo Daft Punk a return to the upper chart echelons for the first time since their Around the World/One More Time era, and more success for Pharrell to add to Happy, originally from the closing credits of Despicable Me 2.
2014 Hozier Take Me To Church
Andrew Hozier-Byrne is a singer songwriter from County Wicklow in Ireland. I began tracking the progress of Take Me To Church when my sister-in-law bought the record before it was famous, and when it first hit the outer reaches of the top 40, first as a stand-alone E.P. and then as part of the album, supported by the “going viral” video. Each week over a period of almost a year it seemed to rise a couple of places, until eventually it made top ten and then eventually peaked at No.2.
The song and follow the tradition of mixing Catholic angst with human love (think Madonna’s Like a Prayer) except in this case there’s a protest against homophobia on behalf of the gay community.
It is a wonderful record in many respects – it is so different from the “design by committee” R&B hip hop which dominates the charts: essentially home-made a la Ed Sheeran; an intriguing song which passes my test of painting a picture about which you are not quite sure of the meaning. Also a No.2 in America, it was nominated for a Grammy award for song of the year.
The challenge for Hozier is to follow it up. Another standout track from the album, namely Angel of Small Death and the Codeine Scene, suggests there is plenty more to come.
2014 Meghan Trainor All About That Bass
The return of Bubblegum music, albeit with a flavour of hip hop and doo-wop. Reminiscent of the Archies Sugar Sugar, Tiffany’s I think We’re Alone Now, and Aqua’s Barbie Girl. But what makes it more interesting is this: the lyrics are about body image, specifically comparing it to the shape of a bass guitar (with no treble), and an infectious video to boot. Also, the phenomenally successful sales, No.1 in America for 8 weeks, reached No.1 in 19 countries including the UK and has sold over 10 million records. And Meghan is from Nantuckett, Masechusetts one of the earliest English settlements
2014 Taylor Swift Blank Space
In which Taylor Swift truly makes the break away from her country and western beginnings, into sophisticated pop. Clever, catchy lyrics poking fun at herself and the media obsession with her dating arrangements. “I’m a nightmare dressed as a daydream”, “I’ve got a Blank Space baby, I’ll write your name”. But one of the most discussed lyrics is this:
Got a long list of ex-lovers / they’ll tell you I’m insane” WHAT IT SOUNDS LIKE: “Got a lot of Starbucks lovers / they’ll tell you I’m insane (It really does, listen to the video)
And this so has joined that list of famous misheard lyrics, creating a “highstreet retail” pairing with Abba’s “Called you last night from Tesco”.
The song was a huge success, spending seven weeks at the top of the Billboard Hot 100, becoming the first woman to succeed herself at the top, following Shake It Off, an even more un-country like record.
2015 Ed Sheeran Thinking Out Loud
While first hit A-team was more simple and spontaneous than this, Thinking Out Loud was the record that finally made Ed a world superstar. Showing a hint of inspiration from Ed’s hero Van Morrison, it was recorded in a small Surrey studio in the village near Windsor Great Park, of Windlesham, which must have the highest ratio of celebrity to resident: Agatha Christies, Glen Hoddle, Brian May, Nick Faldo and Andrew Ridgely have all lived there. Released in late-2014 Thinking Out Loud was still in the charts a full 12 months later and helped Ed become the most downloaded Spotify artist of all time with 860 million streams. Unusually it took a record 19 weeks to reach U.K. No.1 while it peaked at No.2 in the Billboard Hot 100 – for 8 weeks in a row – before eventually selling 4 million copies there. The video features Ed in a ball room dance and the song is about his (now ex) girlfriend. The song has been viewed a billion (a 1000 million) times on U-tube. It has a full set of awards, from Ivor Novello to Brit to Grammy.
While his music is neither rock, soul, reggae or dance and doesn’t therefore fit my favourite genres, this very fact makes it appealing, as it breaks up the “designed b committee” Eurovision style EDM and hip hop that so seems to dominate the charts. Ed Sheeran is unique not just for his musical style but for the way he self-started his early career. While he is happy to appear on the X-Factor, his propulsion to stardom owed nothing to that popular route.
Ed is from Yorkshire and then Suffolk, and he began playing guitar and writing songs at a ridiculously early age. I remember him saying, “I started playing solo shows to a few people, and the audiences simply grew as I played more shows”. (Shades of Gary Player’s the “the more I practice the luckier I get”) He caught the attention of Elton John and American actor Jamie Foxx who mentored him: Ed booked a one way ticket to America with just a one night booking, and simply carried on. He joined Taylor Swift’s tour, and was soon playing sold out solo shows at Maddison Square Gardens. He played A-Team and a memorable, impeccable-choice version of Pink Floyd’s Wish You Were Here at the 2012 Olympic Opening ceremony. He pops up on other records too – One Direction’s Little Things is his composition, while No.1 single maker Jamie Lawson is signed to Ed’s own record label.
Ed Sheeran is now one of the most influential musicians in the music business world – and this will surely continue even if his own releases eventually fade – but he remains the bloke next door. What’s not to like about a guy who names one of his videos for a Wembley stadium concert “Jumpers for Goalposts”? Marvellous!
2015 Mark Ronson and Bruno Mars Uptown Funk
The best record that Prince never made (I’ve been aching to write a line like that!).
Mark Ronson, a U.K. born producer brought up in Masorti Judaism who moved to New York, has a stellar collection of direct or indirect family relations – businessman Gerald Ronson of Guiness Four fame, politicians Malcolm Rifkind and Leon Brittan, Odeon Cinemas founder Oscar Deutch, and Foreigner guitarist Mick Jones. Then as a child and student at New York University he befriended the Lennon’s son Sean, and Quincey Jones daughter Rashida. After graduating from DJ’ing to producer, his breakthrough with a Smiths song “Stop Me” was followed by his major work as producer of Amy Winehouse’s Back to Black.
Meanwhle Bruno Mars – real name Peter Gene Hernandez, of Hawaiian and Philippine parents, but nicknamed after a wrestler called Bruno – was coming up the hard way as a writer of songs for many artists including Brits the Sugarbabes and Alexander Burke. His break eventually came when he recorded his own songs such as Just The Way You Are, Grenade, and Locked Out of Heaven. I used to think he was purely a commercial artist but took notice when seeing his “showmanship” stage performance and musical proficiency on TV, with his ultra-professional backing band known variously as the Smeezingtons and Hooligans.
So it was no surprise when Mark Ronson and Bruno Mars collaborated on 70’s style dance anthem Uptown Funk. The track received some unwelcome notoriety, first when Fleur East on the X-Factor covered the song before it had even been released, and the real version’s release date had to be rushed forward. Second, the similarity to the Gap Band’s “Oops Upside Yourself” required credits and a royalty share to be granted to the “rowing” song’s writers. Nothing to worry about though, it reached No.1 in the U.K. and around the world and achieved Grammy status. Bruno’s voice seemed to develop into a true, gritty, Stax-style soul voice as can be seen on this video. Will be interesting to see his next move.
Weeknd I Cant Feel My Face 2015
Canadian produces a stunning dance classic which gained critical recognition all round an a huge Number 1 around the world. There are so many hooks and choruses here. But let us also finish on another 2015 record. Not a number 1 or Grammy winner, but a good one to end on may have been instead “Four five seconds to wildin” – by Paul McCartney, Rihanna and Kanye West. I thought at first it was a “24 hours to Tulsa” kind of record. However it seems “wildin” refers to losing one’s temper. This is a minimalist straight forward acoustic guitar folk song, with a touch of gospel organ, which rather neatly bookends the rock’n’roll era – Paul who was there almost at the beginning and Rhianna and Kanye current hip-hop stars. The song showcases Rhianna’s voice. The good choice is that Paul didn’t attempt to sing rap – he was never a soul or dance record maker – but the trio met on neutral territory. And so rap and hip hop stars of today still feel comfortable singing with a star who was there almost at the very start of my 60 years of rock’n’roll
What I have learned, what has changed and what will come next
At the end of my last IT contract in 2015 I decided with my wife for a change of career direction into Maths tutoring – a gentle wind-down to retirement – or so it seemed. Ten years later, in 2025, I have reached the apparent required number of hours in a role to be an expert (ten thousand) and the business is thriving with my work essentially full time.
It is time to reflect on learnings and changes
When I started, the new 9-1 Maths GCSE syllabus and grading had just come in. So although I had expertise from school days and work, it seemed like a good opportunity to learn the syllabus from scratch and create my own teaching materials. I designed imaginative slide-packs and interactive quizzes for each topic (by myself before any fancy AI help – see below!) By offering these on TES as well as using them with pupils this compels you to really understand the syllabus in great depth and create high-class materials. I still frequently update them to reflect the latest exam questions, or with a new real life example from the news, or a new video such as a science core practical. This also means my own lifelong learning continues.
To get started in tutoring you have to be willing to practice with some free or low cost work perhaps with your own or friend’s children to get a feel for what works or doesn’t. But once you get a few paid lessons under your belt, your experience and reputation develops, perhaps with a bit of advertising to launch your business.
But you soon realise that just local Maths tutoring at purely GCSE level is not enough to earn a living, So I chose to diversify – using my own knowledge of real entrepreneurial business strategies. Broadening horizontally across to the three Sciences – Physics, Chemistry and Biology; and to Business Studies and Economics; and to non-core qualifications; and introducing depth, vertically up and down the age groups from junior to A-Level and University entrance. And internationally too. Approaches from non-UK individuals and companies could only have come from having a good website – this doesn’t have to expensive, pay for a server but develop the pages yourself. And pupils in different time zones helps you to expand your working day capacity.
The Coronavirus Years
Covid from 2020-22 was a game changer. Parents wanted educational continuity for their children so demand expanded and for the first time I used Zoom. So successful was it that post-Covid, on-line is still 90% of my work – even for fairly local pupils – it saves the bus-journey! Students got comfortable with using on line access to materials and being able to share their homework and write on screen. And Maths web-sites like BBC Bitesize and Dr. Frost came into their own. Also, for the first time as a U.K. tutor I could receive and accept requests from anywhere in the world.
The tutoring process.
Administration is important. It is helpful to separate out this from the actual teaching. A spouse or partner can create the schedules and invoices and even do most of the accounting. Payment in advance helps tutors and parents alike – it creates certainty, trust and expectation.
Parents of course want improved results but also need to be assured of the process. A follow up email after each lesson is essential to record progress and set specific homework and announce what comes next. A weekly lesson at the same day and time works best to create the routine which students need. Parents appreciate you going the extra mile, offering them advice born from your experience, or accepting reasonable change requests.
Reputation within schools and with Parents is important – word travels fast if you are good. Siblings provide great continuity – in some cases the younger and older family members have been with me almost the whole ten years.
A good tutor works hard – 5 hours a day, 25 hours a week, for 40 weeks direct paid tutoring a year makes the 1000 hours a year (and my ten thousand hours after ten years!) And as well as the 5 hours a day with pupils, another 5 hours following up with emails and homework; and developing new materials, expanding the business. So 10 a.m. to 8 p.m. is a typical day.
Embrace variety. I have tutored over 200 pupils. At any given time I am tutoring around 20 different ones with a large variety of topics and levels – at handover time you have to switch instantly between them so have to be well organised. Further, I am able if needed to teach two completely different topics – perhaps Maths then Science – in the same one hour lesson.
Because I have created such a well organised data base of high quality materials I don’t have to spend much time preparing before the lesson – although I start with a default plan, like a D.J. I can respond quickly to requests for help in topics or for a test. In fact, strangely, I prepare after the lesson more than before it. I pick out specific pieces of homework – on-line links to quizzes, and packs of relevant past paper questions where I have taken the time to put the worked answers the very next page. The examiner’s model answers are very useful but I often add my own extra explanatory notes.
I tend to follow the syllabus – either what the student is doing now; or what I predict they will do next – when correct I feel smug! My philosophy is to teach to the test – if pupils feel its super-relevant there is much more chance of retaining attention and absorbing content. Occasionally I will amplify the syllabus with real life news items such as the Science of greenhouse gases and climate change, or the Economics of balancing interest rates versus inflation, or the Maths of sports statistics; or my own real life Business experience in the chemicals industry.
As a tutor you have to enjoy and be fascinated by your subject. As an example I will bring my Cambridge recollections of atomic theory and also DNA structure – which had only recently been discovered in the very laboratories in which I worked – up to date with the latest sub-atomic particle or photosynthesis-generated chemicals discovered on far away-planets. In doing so, realise the same laws of science can be applied from the smallest entity up through hierarchies to ever more complex systems such as humans and the Universe. The benefit of teaching and remaining curious about so many STEM topics at so many levels is that I can pitch the tuition at just the right level to challenge the pupil, yet without losing sight of the syllabus.
For those tutors without much experience of working in schools it is important to take opportunities to learn about the management of education, such as by being a school governor, or taking on a marking or moderating role for a qualification. And understanding the subtle differences between Exam Boards, and how their marking criteria and grade boundaries work, and between Higher and Foundation.
So in 2025 what do I predict for the next ten years in the world of tutoring?
Artificial Intelligence (AI) . The first wave of on-line Learning Management Systems, language translation Apps and past paper websites especially for Maths is well established and will continue to grow and thrive.
But AI takes us into new possibilities. It works through machine learning with Large Language Models (LLM’s). It is able to provide a reasonable answer to almost any question, including sometimes maths problems, by very quickly synthesising relevant information from its databases to present answers in a neat, summarised form. The answers are increasingly – but not 100% – correct. Much of it is free but sometimes a fee is charged. Personalised Learning platforms which automatically tailor the programme to a student’s responses and needs are emerging. There may even be roles for tutors to orchestrate “compare the market” advice and train pupils to use the best platforms.
And don’t forget the benefits of AI in helping tutors and teachers alike with creation and update of teaching materials – this is called Generative AI. To create a new slide you can use a mixture of syllabus Specification, old-school search engines and AI summaries (Co Pilot is fine for this). But be very careful with copyright – use your creations internally – but never publish anything externally over and above your own material without credits or permissions.
Some of a tutors work will be automated or be phased out, but not all; a pupil still has to know what questions to ask of AI, whether to trust the answer, and be motivated to use the internet for uses other than gaming and social media. And if a pupil relies too much on AI to generate answers they will not benefit from thinking through problems and be found out eventually in coursework and especially in exams. Also, there are well publicised AI downsides around veracity, security and data privacy.
So the weekly face to face routine with a tutor still very much counts.
National framework changes. We are likely to see two changes at national level. The addition of VAT to the Independent Sector fees could mean that some parents may choose a middle way path – leave or don’t start Private Schools, use State Schools instead, but use the money saved to top up their child’s education with a private tutor. Secondly, syllabuses and exam structures are being reviewed and this may lead to changes. Both of these developments may lead to more requests for additional help at least in the short term.
Beyond GCSE’s, A-Levels and Entrance Exams. Those are my core qualifications in Maths, Science and Business/Economics, but some of my work is now in extra-curricular stand-alone qualifications, both at school age and also lifelong-learning and Continued Professional Development. l. Initially I did none of these below but now I tutor in all of the following “non-core” areas – demand has grown and is likely to grow more;
EPQ’s So Extended Qualification Project are taken by students in the middle holiday of sixth form and involve the research for, project management of, and execution of a 5000 word dissertation on any subject at all – as long as its outside or over and above their A-Levels. A tutor can offer anything from weekly help to an essay-review before handing in. Personally I have learned so much from students fantastic essays on topics both within and outside my STEM and Business spheres.
Technical. As AI replaces paper-based service jobs and heavy industry winds down, students may want to take specialist Technical qualifications such as Apprenticeships, B-Tech or the new T-Levels. These are qualifications leading to jobs in hands-on service areas like hospitality or hairdressing, or light industry areas like composite plastic manufacture, or the newer high-tech and green industries, or Trades such as Electrical, which are never going to disappear especially with the demand for housing. With the expansion of qualifications comes the creation of roles for moderators, markers and quality controllers as well as direct topic teaching, and often Technical Colleges top up with roles with contractors with tutoring experience.
Maths Challenges. Many schools suggest their top sets enter national Maths Challenges (typically organised by the UKMT) at primary, junior, intermediate and senior level, and parents take these seriously enough to ask for some help. The questions require a good understanding of basic maths techniques of course – but two more things are needed, First the ability to work fast and manage the exam, secondly to think out of the box for the end-of-paper problem solving questions. Numerical reasoning is another growth area with many public and private sector roles fitting this into job application interviews.
The above three avenues have proved very successful and are ongoing, but some other non-cores have run their course quickly – in business you sometimes have to speculate to accumulate.
The organisation of tutoring. Many large tutoring companies have sprung up and we could see a consolidation in the market with smaller ones swallowed up and independent tutors encouraged to come under their wing. So tutors don’t have to find their own candidates but lose a share of the revenue. More regulation of the sector is possible. We see tutoring “shops” in the high street, or in supermarkets – where parents can leave their children while they do the shopping.
Ten Years After
It’s ten years after the start. I never thought my tutoring would become so diverse and full-time. With offering so many topics I have not only picked up where I left off at University but have also progressed my Lifelong Learning. Satisfaction comes in two respects – running your own business and adding that bit of value to students’ education.
I often finish my blogs with a song – so here of course you will find the great British Blues Rock Band, Alvin Lee’s Ten Years After. Known as an album band – but this was their hit single on video and Live. .
Business marketing mix and operational case studies
The Marketing Mix covered in GCSE and A Level Business includes the 4 P’s – Product, Price, Place and Promotion. As well as marketing, a business entrepreneur needs effective and efficient operations , employing the four factors of production namely land, labour, capital and ingenuity.
I have followed the fortunes of two businesses in my local Twickenham streets during their five years to date – a high street butcher and a park café.
I will describe the success and failures of these two businesses through the lenses of marketing and operations.
Brown’s Artisan Butchers.
Just before the Pandemic started in the UK in 2020, an independent butcher opened in the High Street of Twickenham, London. The business, then called Brown’s Artisan Butchers, is run by a butcher of 50 years’ experience, who had for many years run a butcher in nearby Hounslow and knew Twickenham well. He located his shop on the High Street, next to a Marks and Spencer’s Food Shop, an independent greengrocer, and a highly successful Fishmongers, which sold some meat, though meat is not their main product.
Mr. Brown emphasized in his promotion material his speciality cuts, locally sourced foods from free range farms. He has written books on the subject and does training for anyone from home-cooks to upcoming butchers to top Chefs. He displays carcasses drying, but discreetly at the back of the shop. He justifies slightly higher prices with a quality reputations and his artisan approach to unusual cuts and quality flavoured sausages.
This butcher survived the Pandemic lock down well, with queues often to be seen wanting access, and by Autumn 2021 was well established post-lockdown.
A competitor for Mr. Brown.
A competitor called The Meat Room, was opened by a businessman at around the same time as Brown’s. The location was close to Brown’s but crucially a different section of the High Street.
The Meat Room owner ran two successful butchers shops in the Midlands and wanted to try and expand in London. He had a reasonable amount of butcher trade experience. He chose Twickenham and located his shop on the busy High Street, but next to no other food shops, for instance his neighbours included a Furniture Shop, which subsequently closed. The window of his shop was unusual in that it displayed giant meat carcases, drying. The range of meats were varied and the prices though slightly higher than supermarkets were reasonable. However the trade was not enough to sustain the business and it closed after about a year.
So Brown’s saw off the competition and more recently in 2025 Brown’s has changed its name to the “Honest Butcher”. A slight change of Branding but the actual shop has remained the same and continues to be successful even as other independent supermarkets have opened nearby. Mr. Brown continues to be a welcome, well respected presence in his shop and his young well trained and knowledgeable staff support him well.
A café in the park.
Radnor Gardens in Twickenham is an ideal place for an outdoor cafe, near the river Thames, some popular gardens, and a playground and some schools, in a relatively affluent area, with no nearby competitors. A new owner refurbished an existing basic café with some simple improvements and at first was successful. The offer was simple, essentially coffee and croissants. But problems started occurring such as being unable to serve coffee because the supplies of beans ran out, and customers reporting that the café was often closed even on hot summer days. Eventually the business failed in about 2020..
Another new owner emerged in the early 2020’s with a very different approach. Antipodea already ran successful branches in nearby Kew and Richmond and the owners wished to expand and diversify from evening to daytime hospitality. They invested quite heavily in creating a new look with much more seating than before and a delightful “green” plant image with plant-covered green walls and doors The food included Australian style breakfasts and brunches, and a good variety of cooked lunches. Prices were relatively high for a café but the quality of food was good, as was customer satisfaction, which included waitress service. The business ran successfully for a while, with the café generally full with its targeted customer segment of mothers and children, dog walkers, families, river walkers ; fairly up market.
However, after a break in and difficulty in getting staff, and a natural slowdown in winter, the café began to struggle, perhaps because of the meal selection being just too ambitious and hence expensive. And eventually it closed.
But within a year, a replacement opened up, again run by a nearby parent company, this time Parsons from nearby Teddington. It appears some capital has been invested, with a slightly different style of seating; and a less ambitious but fit for purpose menu is offered, but the overall feel of the garden – plant vista has been nicely retained and in the hot summer of 2025 it looked to be successful.
Marketing Mix and Operational efficiency; observations and conclusion
For the butcher’s business it is clear that the Product and its Brand (artisan, good quality, unusual cuts, Brown’s personal reputation, good customer service) are important in its success. In contrast the Meat Room’s branding was poor. But there was more than that – Place was important. Brown’s is in the “Central Business District” for independent food retail on the High Street – even if competitors are close by, customers know where to look for meat and related complementary products. In contrast the Meat Room although only a few hundred yards away was isolated from other food shops – it simply didn’t fit – and a bit further from the car park.
Looking at the café, the first incarnation got its Operations wrong – running out of supplies, unpredictable opening hours and the product offering too limited. The second, Antipodea, ran excellently for a while with attractive green branding . But I think it suffered operationally from staff shortages and while its pricing and product offering may have improved margins and profitability, actually prices may have been slightly too high-end for a simple park café and sales volumes suffered.
So far in 2025 and through the winter into 2026, the new Parsons café seems to have retained the Brand – an environment- friendly image – but improved the interior and has got the Menu offering about right in terms of middle range price and realistic product variety. The capacity utilisation seems good. And as a local dog walker I was delighted it offered free dog biscuits during refurbishment – sometimes the little things are a good part of the promotional aspect of marketing mix. In fact walking past the cafe almost every day has enabled me to spot a demographic trend – in fact . Customers fall into two main groups – young families with playground-age children – and, perhaps surprisingly – the “grey market” of groups of pensioners enjoying a chat and a coffee, even when it is raining outside.
But perhaps the test has yet to arrive – how does a park café thrive in winter or in the rain? Does it accept losses in low periods – or shut down for the winter months? Full time or temporary staff?
A message for Business Studies students.
Wherever you live – Twickenham or anywhere – think about your local high street and shops and consider how you would describe them in terms of the marketing mix and operations. You could easily get this type of case study in the exam and you can see above how to use the technical terms from your syllabus to analyse businesses.
The recent discovery of a life-signature chemical far out in space has created great interest in the scientific community and news media alike and resonates for GCSE and A- Level students not just of Chemistry but Physics and Biology too.
A signature chemical detected on a far-away planet
Cambridge University astronomers have detected the presence of a compound dimethyl sulphide (DMS) in the atmosphere of an exoplanet called K2-18 b. It is situated 124 Light Years away from earth (meaning it would take light travelling at 300 million meters per second about a hundred and twenty four years to travel the 700 trillion miles to reach it – so don’t plan a holiday there!)
The planet is 2.6 times the radius of earth, but because it is fairly close to the star that it orbits (a Red Dwarf), it only takes 33 days to complete the orbit, meaning its Year is only 33 days as opposed to our 365 days.
But why is this biosignature of DMS (CH3SCH3) so interesting? It is because we have this compound in our earth’s atmosphere too and it is produced by the billions of phytoplankton in our oceans, so an explanation could be that the remote planet’s surface also contains warm water “teeming with life”. And the compound contains three of the CHNOPS elements considered to be the building blocks of life. Methane and Carbon Dioxide have also been detected using the infra-red spectrum of the James Webb telescope which itself orbits the Sun..
If the DMS does indeed come from phytoplankton, the significance is that these microorganisms are called the “lungs of the earth” and perform photosynthesis in our oceans, absorbing carbon dioxide and producing oxygen for our atmosphere and glucose for the food chain – for instance whales consume them..
These plankton may not have been the very first photosynthesisers – that accolade belongs to cyanobacteria – but they may have been the second group and indeed many plankton are eukaryotic cells with a nucleus and chloroplasts making them plant-like.
So in summary, the link is that if Dimethyl Sulphide (and also Dimethyl Disulphide) have been detected on planet K2-18b, this indicates the presence of phytoplankton, which in turn suggests the process of photosynthesis, which is the fundamental biological process on our own earth – and so why not also on Planet K2-18 b?
But there’s always a however…
But hold on – there are some doubts, even amongst the astronomers. First, the probability of the detection being pure chance is low at 0.3% but not yet low enough. A-Level Maths and Biology students will be familiar with the 5% confidence limit in Hypothesis testing but in this instance a much stricter and lower confidence limit is apparently needed, namely 0.00006% or five standard deviations, and more observations are needed to reach such a tiny probability of the detection being merely a “false flag”.
Additionally, Biology students will be familiar with the concept of Biotic and Abiotic factors. In theory the only way DMS can be produced is through a Biotic process, namely a Biological life-confirming reaction such as photosynthesis. But we can’t entirely discount the possibility of DMS simply being produced by an obscure Abiotic (non-biological) process) on a planet whose conditions, after all, we know relatively little about. Also, DMS is a chemical which breaks down very quickly in an atmosphere and the products of that breakdown such as hydrogen sulphide have not been definitively detected at K2-18b.
Further, to what extent does plankton actually constitute “life”? There is a multi billion year route with many hurdles to overcome which makes the transition from plankton to humans far from inevitable.
Always end with a song…
So it is fair to say that the jury is “still out”, but nevertheless this is an exciting development in the quest to answer the famous question, is there alien life out there? Not perhaps, as David Bowie might say, Life on Mars, but probably plankton on Planet K2-18 b.
In the style of an EPQ (Extended Project Qualification) Dissertation By Rick Anderson
Table of Contents
Abstract Introduction Research Review
Difference Engine No.1 Analytical Engine / Lady Lovelace Difference Engine No.2 Finally, a complete build Natural Philosophy Influencers The Lunar Society Three Herschels, two Darwins, one Babbage
Discussion/Development
Mathematician Engineer Computer Pioneer Author Philosopher – Natural and Traditional Science society networker
Conclusion Evaluation Bibliography Appendix – assessment of Bibliography references
Charles Babbage – more than a computer pioneer?
Abstract
Charles Babbage was a 19th century English mathematician and polymath, a natural philosopher best known for his designs of the Difference and Analytical calculating Engines, considered to be the forerunners of the modern computer. This paper describes Babbage’s many other areas of expertise across science, philosophy and economics, including as an author. It also considers his many memberships of 19th century Societies in London and Cambridge and to what extent he was naturally influenced by the 18th century Lunar Society of Birmingham. Pulling these various strands together the paper concludes with an answer to the question of whether he was more than a computing pioneer, and if so in which areas in particular.
Introduction
Charles Babbage (1791 – 1871) is seen by many as the Godfather of the modern computer. In the early 1800’s he went up to Cambridge University to study Maths. He attended Trinity and Peterhouse Colleges, both well established, in contrast to my own Fitzwilliam, yet to be invented.
But at least I graduated with Honours, in Natural Sciences; whereas he was sent down before graduating in Mathematics, because in those days you had to present a thesis for debate and he chose a controversial subject ; his disdain for authority became a trademark.
Despite this unfortunate ending he had already found a crucial lifelong colleague at Cambridge, future astronomer John Herschel, and they were founders of the alternative mathematical Analytical Society. Babbage used Cambridge to launch his career in Natural Philosophy and quite soon after into his Engine design.
Whereas my career post Cambridge took me straight to Industrial Chemistry and eventually I.T., now with this paper and as a Tutor I am finally returning to the option I never took up at Cambridge – the History and Philosophy of Science.
So my first objective is to use Babbage as a way of understanding a great period of 18th and 19th century British Science. Within that my second objective is to discover if there is a link between Babbage and his numerous societies and the Birmingham Lunar Society, just before Babbage’s time .
My third objective is to try for myself the art of writing an EPQ, an Extended Project Qualification dissertation. As a Maths, Science and Business tutor, of course I should be comfortable answering exam questions on these topics; and having supervised scores of EPQ’s I will now write one and within this really understand the practicalities of research techniques.
My overall and fourth objective is to answer the question of the title, namely was Babbage more than “just” a computer pioneer, and if so to what extent and in what fields.
My primary research is to visit the Science Museum and see for myself some old and new versions of Babbage’s famous calculating engines. My secondary research involves reading in full three books. Two full traditional paperback books, written about periods before and after his lifetime, namely “The Lunar Men” (Uglow, 2003) and “The Cogwheel Brain” (Swade, 2000); and one scanned version written by Babbage himself, effectively his autobiography , “Passages from the Life of a Philosopher” (Babbage, 1862). Also of course numerous internet links.
If we now pick now up Babbage, post Cambridge, he soon founded or helped form several more mathematical or scientific societies and joined the prestigious Royal Society of Science. In fact he also became the Chair of the famous Lucasian Mathematical Society of Cambridge.
His early Maths specialism was in “Tables” – of logarithms, trigonometry, and so on – in particular spotting errors in them. He wished he could automate out these errors mechanically, powered by “steam” he mused – and this joke developed into a lifelong project, using not steam but with thousands of finely manufactured metal alloy Cogwheels – driven by an initial crank shaft but thereafter, on each calculation, automatically.
Basic mechanical calculators had been around for some time – for instance a hundred years before, Leibnitz (of calculus fame, along with Sir Isaac Newton) had developed a simple machine, but more for domestic drawing room novelty. But Babbage’s “Engine” design and vision was far beyond that.
In this paper we will review the three Engines that he designed – but did not complete, at least not himself. However, his second was finally built recently under the supervision of Doran Swade, the author of Cogwheel Brain; while his Analytical Engine design was interpreted in his famous collaboration with Lady Ada Lovelace.
But what of his interests outside pure mathematics? We will focus initially on one aspect namely Natural Philosophy, which effectively was “Science” before scientists were so called and covered not just traditional aspects like religion and ethics but also the natural world of the earth and its’ species, and the Universe and their Laws.
In rounding up the Research we will outline Babbage’s influencers, to see where he was coming from, in order to see in the Discussion section where he was going to and how as a mathematician, he could absorb so much else. To that end we will summarise his expertise in and influence upon various roles in his career – computer pioneer, engineer, philosopher, networker, author before finally drawing a conclusion as to the extent that Babbage really was more than the Godfather of computing.
Research Review
Difference Engine No.1
Babbage began by developing “Difference Engine No.1” so called because it relies on the method of finite differences, as illustrated below with some polynomials for the first few values:
You will see that the power of the polynomial determines the point at which the differences become constant – 1st difference for a linear equation, 2nd difference for a quadratic and 3rd difference for a cubic. Note for GCSE Maths students – yes, this is related to Sequences: replace the “x” by “n” and you see the familiar constant “difference of differences” of a quadratic sequence. Note also that by adding back the differences you can reverse to the original numbers, which meant for Babbage he could utilise simple addition and subtraction – instead of the more complicated multiplication and division – even for generating numerous values of complex polynomials. And since logarithms and trigonometric ratios could be approximated to polynomials this extended its further use.
The crucial use of “differences” gave its name to the difference engine, yet also limited it to addition and subtraction – so it was a special purpose rather than a general purpose calculation machine capable of more analysis, which Babbage developed later. The genius of Babbage was to reproduce the calculations described with rotating mechanical cogs and gears with numbers inscribed according to the degrees of rotation, which, once set in motion, would achieve results automatically including coping with “carrying” of units like “tens”.
After building a small prototype of the Engine (now lost) in 1822, Babbage formally began the project soon after. Babbage employed an Engineer, Clement, to construct and assembled the 24,000 parts needed for the fully completed Engine. Funding came from the British Government Treasury, who supported the idea of automatic tabulation. Clement delivered a working model, in 1832, around a seventh of the full size, and Babbage used this to demonstrate to visitors to his house in London. The model survives in working order today, in the London Science Museum, along with detailed notes even if the drawings and remaining parts are lost.
Even this incomplete model is now recognised as a major feat of precision engineering which was the first calculating machine to incorporate a mathematical rule in order to automate the calculation of successive results. For instance, in demonstrating his model at his soirees, Babbage repeatedly generated results with a difference of 2, then the machine surprised his audience with another difference altogether without any physical intervention – Babbage had set the machine up to do this. Just this little snippet is proof the model was in good working order and that a form of “programming” was in place.
Following the promise of the 1832 demonstration model, the fact that Babbage did not go on to complete the engine was due to many factors, some within his control, some not. He suffered family tragedies. He fell out with Clement. He forever tampered with designs, including working on a different Engine. He did not market it professionally. The project drifted for another ten years until the Treasury, after funding close to £1 million in today’s money, finally “pulled the plug” in 1842. Note also that 1832 was the year of publication of Babbage’s magnum opus the Economy of Manufacturers and Machinery, the writing of which must have surely distracted him, but for genuinely beneficial reasons.
Although Babbage did not complete his Engine, it should be noted that after reading about it the Scheutz brothers from Sweden did make a Difference Engine – at least a simpler version of it – three machines in fact. They attempted to market them, with one of the customers being the UK Government who ironically bought it in the late 1850’s after years of frustration with Babbage himself. The machine did actually help a little with production of some official Tables but was not deemed sufficiently useful to warrant further roll-out. The machine was retired, but has been preserved in the Science Museum and in the Smithsonian National Museum of American History in the USA where it is regularly demonstrated. As a final note Babbage did finally get to demonstrate the small model of his machine one more time at an Exhibition in London in 1862, which created some interest for the audience.
The Analytical Engine and collaboration with Ada Lovelace.
Meanwhile, let us go back to 1834, by which time Babbage cleared the decks to begin work on his follow-up to the Difference Engine, namely the Analytical Engine. Although he published little himself externally, more recent analysis of his thousands of sketches, notes and diagrams revealed the astonishing conclusion that this Engine truly did lay the foundations for the modern general purpose computer, having almost all the necessary design principles and major components we would recognise today. He developed the cog-wheel design to allow values from one results column to be fed back into the beginning. He called it the “locomotive which lays down its own railway”, “engine eating its own tail” ; we call it a “loop”. Other circular features included the design principle of sub-operations on the periphery of a central calculator (echoes of the modern Business Warehouse Star Schema) and a cylindrical barrel with studs which determined the operations needed for calculation – a “micro programme” now. He improved speed and the carrying of tens with successive carrying carriages, and a series of latches , which if set in a “warned sate” and then “polled” to carry a digit, imitated in Babbage’s’ words “knowing”, “memory” and “recollection”
Babbage introduced the idea of the “Store” for containing fixed and variable values – in today’s computers the “hard drive” and “memory” ; and the “Mill” for executing calculations having selected the starting values and returning results to the Store on completion – equivalent to the central processor today. But it was 100 years before Von Neuman published similar ideas in his seminal work on the “architecture” of computers. Babbage also introduced the idea of “pipelining” – what we would call today “parallel processing” to save total processing time. Some of his numbers carried an extraordinary accuracy of 40 decimal points.
With the type of calculations now extended to include the operations of multiplication and division as well as addition and subtraction, Babbage proposed two further developments. First the output of results would include a printer on to paper and plates for publishing. Second he introduced the idea of punch cards and a card reader for determining which calculations should take place in which order . (As a student in the 1970’s I myself used punch cards on the Cambridge University computers)
The idea of the cards was not entirely new, with the Jacquard loom for textile production using them. In fact when the Duke of Wellington and Prince Albert came to discuss the Engine (indicating the importance and recognition of Babbage’s work) the Prince impressed Babbage with his understanding of the Loom-Engine connection.
There were also cards for repeating a sequence of operations with the final value being fed back to the beginning and the calculation repeated and improved– GCSE students will recognise this as “iteration”. The Engine could also perform “conditional branching” where a second event depends on the outcome of the previous event – and this mirrors the GCSE Probability Tree .
To convey the motion and positions of his parts at different stages of rotation Babbage hit upon the new nomenclature of Mechanical Notation, a feature of which was to sketch these various views in the same way that Walt Disney was to use in establishing his cartoon company.
It should be noted that although Babbage employed a full-time draughtsman and had help from assistants including his sons, again like its predecessor the Analytical Engine was never fully built. This was partly because Babbage continued to fall out with potential Government sponsors in particular his lifetime nemesis Sir George Airy, Astronomer Royal, but also because by that time he seemed to prefer the intellectual challenge of design rather than physical challenge of production – perhaps just as well because the complete Analytical Engine would have been huge – filling a large room, and would literally have needed steam to power it.
During this period Babbage famously collaborated with Lady Ada Lovelace, estranged daughter of the poet Lord Byron. A mathematician herself, at age 17 she met Babbage at one of his soirees in 1833 – accompanied by her Maths tutor Mary Sommerville, known to all the Herschels and who would become one of the most famous Victorian female scientists. Babbage subsequently demonstrated his original Difference Engine model to Ada, and they began to exchange ideas in writing about the Analytical Engine.
Eventually as her family commitments eased , ten years later Ada completed a translation of an Italian review (written in French) of Babbage’s work on the Analytical Engine in 1843 . Baggage encouraged her to write her own notes and her input culminated in writing a series of sequential operations necessary to generate Bernoulli’s numbers on Babbage’s engine and as such she claims the title of the first “programmer” – certainly the first female one. Her programme – known as Note G – was only an appendix – but is one of the most substantial appendices ever published – the first “computer programme”
The Bernoulli formula function is complicated and for the first time she showed that a complex mathematical function could generate a series of numbers with sequential operations on the Analytical Engine and then repeated in a loop. She also introduced the idea of using the engine for non-numerical purposes such as generation of musical notes – did she anticipate the Moog Synthesiser ? ; and use of symbols instead of numbers and speculated on “weaving algebraic patterns just as Jacquard’s Loom weaves flowers and leaves”. Because Her “Sketch on an analytical engine” was the only Paper of substance she published, some argue her importance is over-rated, but when a hundred or more years later experts began to read that document they realised what a visionary she was – or could have become if ill health had not sadly taken her early.
Babbage eventually created a fragment of the Engine, and later his son Henry completed a model of the Mill for demonstration and it still exists today in the London Science Museum A hundred years later Alan Turing described the Engine as “Turing complete” as a general purpose computer in principle capable of dealing with any algorithm and in doing so referenced Lady Lovelace.
In summary Wilkes (1992) recently argued that although, perhaps surprisingly, there is no direct physical line from Babbages’s Engines to modern day computers, nevertheless he described Babbage’s work – particularly the Analytical Engine – as “vision verging on genius” because he had identified so many of the design aspects that we take for granted in modern computer architecture. He continued “It was only when the first digital computers had come into action that the extent of Babbage’s genius became fully appreciated”.
One of the reasons there was no real follow up was because Babbage published so little of the design details in singe formal coherent papers. Which brings us to Difference Engine No. 2 and its eventual reincarnation.
Difference Engine No.2
After completing most of the work on the Analytical Engine, Babbage returned to consideration of the original Difference Engine. This time the No.2 machine carried only a third of the parts with no loss of efficiency and with more emphasis on output to printer paper and engraving. Amazingly, his printer design allowed for modern days ideas about “portrait” and ” landscape”, and font choice and options around rows and columns.
Unlike the first Engine, whose drawings suffered by real use and exposure in workshops, the 20 drawings for the second Engine were conceptual only and have survived in pristine condition. This was to prove crucial in eventual construction – but many years after Babbage’s death in 1871. He died with parts for all three of his unfinished Engines scattered in his workshops. But in his will he left these and his drawings to his son, Henry, who from these later produced a fragments of the machines which ended up for instance in the Science Museum and in the Whipple Museum of calculators in Cambridge University – back where Babbage started. A similar fragment many years later have inspired the Harvard electro mechanical calculator used in the World War 2 Manhattan project.
Finally, a complete Build.
Fast forward a hundred years, and Dr Allan Bromley from the Computer Science department in Sydney Australia, with Doran Swade, the curator of Computer Science at the Science museum in South Kensington, London, begin a project in 1985 to complete a full working construction of the complete Difference Engine No.2 by the 200th anniversary of Babbage’s birth which would occur in 1991.
Using his drawings and most of the same 19th century manufacturing techniques and standards of precision as much as possible, they embarked (Swade 1993 and 2000) on a journey which would prove every bit as troublesome as Babbage’s -funding requirements, marketing the project, engineering issues . At some stages they came across some design issues that would prevent the machine working – should they solve themselves – was that valid ? They had to assume Babbage would have solved them with similar tinkering – after all he spent his whole life doing that ! The difference this time that a deadline approached whereas Babbage let time drift .
A working trial piece demonstration created momentum with the media but sponsors like IBM come and went and manufacturing supplier – so vital to the production of identical components – went bust. But eventually the final build took place – amazingly on the Ground Floor of the Science Museum in full view of the visiting public. The two engineers were encouraged to explain what they were doing.
By the time of the launch the full machine was ready – almost. In full calculation mode it occasionally jammed so for the launch to the media in June 1991 the machine was set with rotating wheels as expected – but only with Zeros. But just the sight of the machine coming to life with beautiful helical movement of the wheels and columns with pristine shiny gears was enough and progress was then made to get it full working by the time of Babbage’s exact 200th anniversary in December. The jamming was reduced and occasional carry errors eliminate – by making sure that all parts were made to precision just as Babbage had foreseen. By end of November 1991 the machine was certified to be in full working order, repeatedly and accurately performing full, complex calculations . The project team had done it with a few days to spare before Babbage’s centenary on 27 December. Subsequently they added the Printer. In building the complete Engine they proved that Babbage’s failures were not due to faults in his vision or design, rather simply practical difficulties of production.
The newly built No.2 machine still remains in the Science Museum in South Kensington. I went to see it as part of “Primary Research”, along with The Scheutz model and Henry Babbages’s portion of the Analytical Engine Mill. While there, I observed a series of visitors fascinated by the fully rebuilt model, and video of it working – typically parents with children..and parents explaining. Also, the location was interesting – in the Mathematics department, not the adjacent information Age section. But there also is a fourth Engine portion– Clement’s original fragment – in the “Making of the Modern World” section. A project to build the Analytical Engine in full is being run by Doran Swade – Plan 28 – though after ten years it has not come to fruition.
Here are my photos from the Science Museum – not the best but they are mine!
Various models or portions of the Babbage Engines exist in America for instance at the Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History. Another build of Difference Engine No.2 took place in Mountain View, California. Sponsored by a Microsoft Executive, the machine was then moved from Silicon Valley to Seattle. (CHM)
Babbage and philosophy
Now let us look at Babbage’s interests outside his Engines. Towards the end of his life Babbage looked back with his self-penned “autobiography”“Passages from the Life of a Philosopher”. The reasons he viewed himself as such were that as a “polymath” he had broad interests and expertise in many subjects; from Maths to Engineering and Astronomy ; but further, to Economics and Manufacturing (he published a successful book “Economy of Manufacturers and Machinery”). He invented well-known items like the Ophthalmoscope for eye-testing and, incredibly, the “Cow-catcher” – well known to us in films on the front of American steam-trains. He proposed the “black-box” recorder for every moment of a train’s journey. He was a code-breaker – he cracked a cipher which had a defied unlocking for 300 years.
Babbage at his peak moved in intellectual circles, in fact was at the centre of them with his regular hosting at his home in London of “scientific soirees”, popular in the 1830’s both within the scientific community – such as Faraday, Charles Darwin and Wheatstone – and outside – such as the Duke of Wellington and Charles Dickens . And crucially as we shall see later, astronomer Mary Sommerville chaperoning a young Debutante called Ada Byron, whom Mary tutored in Maths. He wished both to promote Science in general, and mathematical calculation in particular, as a central force for good and means of societal advancement; but also to improve the way it was run (as a campaigner for reform he criticised the Royal Society).
It is important to note that before the 19th century the idea of the “scientist” as a whole, never mind the scientific specialist roles, was not well established. What we might now call scientists, were often referred to as “natural philosophers”, principally the philosophical study of Physics, but also aspects of nature like botany and anthropology.
Natural Philosophy is not inherently mathematics, but they intersect. For instance Babbage himself contributed an article to the publication “Philosophical Transactions” of the Royal Society just as Sir Isac Newton has done 150 years earlier. And before that 16th century Mathematicians who studied Astronomy and circular motion such as Galileo and Kepler were often described as Natural Philosophers. It should be noted however that Koyré (Ungureanu 2014) maintained that unlike Babbage “the great minds of the past, such as Galileo or Newton, were not engineers or craftsmen. Technological improvement was incidental, a mere by-product of the progress of science.” So Babbage was a new kind of scientist and natural philosopher who combined great intellectual insight with practical engineering skills who saw the combination of science and technology as a force for national advancement and collective good
Another extraordinary example of Babbage’s work in the philosophy genre was his 1837 “Ninth Bridgewater Treatise”, an unauthorised addition to Reverend Willaim Whewell’s series of papers which aimed to position Science within the traditional religious view of the world and the universe. (Unauthorised because Babbage, no stranger to picking arguments, was responding to Whewell’s criticism of mathematical philosophers)
Babbage proposed that every motion, word and breath is somehow stored and remembered by the particles of air in the atmosphere. In echoes of the Science Museum recreation of the Difference Engine, the Manchester Science and Industry museum in 2019 hosted an event called Atmospheric Memory in which Babbage’s ideas from the Treatise were interpreted by the artist digital artist Rafael Lozano-Hemmer. Babbage said “The air itself is one vast library on whose pages are for ever written all that man has ever said or woman whispered.”
Babbageargued that unusual occurrences such as geological faults and miracles were in fact pre-ordained adaptations of natural laws and drew parallels with his Engines’ ability to be instructed – in a sense pre-programmed, though the phrase did not exist at the time. He links his Engine to discussions around fatalism and determinism on the one hand, and free will on the other. It is an immense tour-de-force of original intellectual thinking. He moves into the same arena, albeit from a different direction, occupied by Emile Zola’s work involving the Experimental Novel and Naturalism.
The Treatise is said to have inspired authors Edgar Alan Poe; and Charles Dickens, who attended Babbage’s soirees. Also note that the Treatise drew inevitably on work by John Herschel, Babbage’s lifelong collaborator.
(Steven Leech, 2019)
Babbage’s machines began to “think” like humans – they could be given instructions, one solution became the input for the next stage. Although a physical crank of a handle was needed to start the machine, thereafter many calculations were achieved at speed, automatically without further human intervention and the idea of machine intelligence was born. The debate into the connection between psychology, the human brain and machines had truly begun, and even though it took a hundred years to come to fruition the end point was electronic computing, robotics and artificial intelligence.
Some of Babbage’s philosophical views drew from Francis Bacon, a philosopher himself from the earlier Age of Enlightenment, who promoted an empirical view of the importance of evidence and facts in induction. Which brings us to the question, who else influenced Babbage to become the all round polymath across mathematical, scientific and philosophical areas?
Babbage’s influencers
Babbage was largely self-taught in Mathematics before going up to Cambridge. His early interest in Mathematical tables was spurred by a brief connection with an insurance company and actuarial tables, and a French project to assign specific roles to the production of tables by “computers” which in those days were people not machines. Gaspard de Prony published Logarithms and Trigonometry Tables after describing the three levels in his “division of labour” – categories of senior theorem mathematicians, calculating mathematicians, then the quickly trained “computers”.
This would later inform his Difference and Analytical Engine designs to mirror the four aspects of Table production – calculation, checking, printing and proof reading, all of which he felt would be more reliable if automated. This also links to him being an early proponent of “division of labour” as outlined in his book “Economy of Manufacturers and Machinery”
As a pure mathematician he was highly advanced although not at the very leading edge. He was an expert on functions including calculus and was part of the movement to use “d” instead of “delta” in differentiation, to introduce “infinitesimal differences”.
Babbage’s early 19th century work was a natural succession to the late 18th century advances in British science and industry – the beginning of the Industrial Revolution – and the role of scientific clubs to facilitate this. One such example lies In the Lunar Society as described in “The Lunar Men: The Friends Who Made the Future 1730-1810” . (Uglow, 2003). Let us look at them as a detailed case study to illustrate this.
The Lunar Society
We find a group of experimenters, tradesmen, artisans, entrepreneurs such as Erasmus Darwin (yes, an ancestor of Charles and fellow Botanist), Joseph Priestley (electricity and gases), Wedgewood (pottery and minerals), James Watt (Condensing Cylinder Steam Engine) and his business partner Matthew Boulton . Together from their Birmingham Lunar Society (which met monthly on the full moon) they developed or improved many facets of the industrial revolution such as canals, steam engines, pottery, ceramics, mineral extraction, electricity, soda water, balloons, medical heart-drugs; and perhaps interesting for Babbage, copying machines.
They were not called scientists, but knew science. They were also campaigners. They promoted scientific cooperation. They were sometimes described as natural philosophers, particularly Joseph Priestley, famous for his early views on the nature of “matter” not just from a chemical point of view, such as involving analysis of air and water, but from a philosophical and religious angle as well. The founder, William Small was a Professor of Mathematics and Philosophy.
James Watt, before his work on steam engines, developed an expertise in the harmonics of church organs and on mathematical instrument manufacture – such as compasses and scales. He later developed the ideas around workflow in manufacture with his business associate Matthew Boulton, and developed the Soho factory in Birmingham, and established the requirement for precision, engineering which makes me believe that Babbage’s development of the Difference Engine has a natural connection to and progression from the Lunar Society. In fact the beginning of Babbage’s career in the 1820’s almost overlaps with the end of the Lunar Society (1765 to 1813) . He probably never met their core members directly (although he definitely did meet their lineage) but both their spirit of British natural inventiveness and their engineering achievements must surely have influenced him.
Three Hershels, two Darwins, one Babbage
One other direct connection from Babbage to the Lunar society is through William and Caroline Herschel, famous astronomers and members of the Royal Society like Babbage; Caroline was “part of the Lunar Men’s wider circle” and as William’s sister she recorded William’s observations, making and publishing standardised for time calculations before becoming a famous astronomer herself.
William’s son was John Herschel, whom Caroline looked after and mentored following her brothers’ death. John Heschel was pivotal throughout Babbage’s career, first at Cambridge together, and then John was there at the start of Babbage’s Astronomical Society and at the famous conversation where Babbage expressed his desire to use “steam” for calculation of Tables. John accompanied Babbage on his visits to factories. John Heschel continued as a supporter and friend of Babbage for the rest of their lives.
There are many connections from John Herschel’s father Willaim to the Lunar society. Sir William Watson, a close scientific associate of William Herschel, was linked with some members of the Lunar Society of Birmingham. In 1785 he published “A Treatise on Time”, a philosophical essay dedicated to William Herschel and heavily indebted to Joseph Priestley, a member of the Lunar Society
Erasmus Darwin, fulcrum of the Lunar Society, while working on Botanic Linnaeus nomenclature, sought advice from Sir Joseph Banks, as did William Heschel while striving for a naming system for planets. Many of the members of the Lunar Society were also members of the Royal Society of Scientists as were Babbage and John Herschel.
Erasmus Darwin collaborated extensively with Wiilliam Herschel on the similarity between the order of natural botany and the cosmology of the Universe. In due course Wiliam’s son John became the lifelong friend and mentor of Babbage, and Babbage knew Erasmus’s grandson, Charles Darwin, well enough to invite him to his soirees. Darwin and Babbage were good friends. As Darwin acknowledged in his autobiography, “I used to call pretty often on Babbage and regularly attended his famous evening parties.” (Francesco Cassata, Roberto Marchionatti, 2011) The Economist Alfred Marshall even argues that Babbage’s work on mechanism of the mind and Darwin’s theory of evolution in the “Original of the Species” are closely interwoven. Note that the Lunar Men book’s timeline Appendix starts with Erasmus Darwin and concludes with a very last entry – his grandson Chales Darwin, friend and associate of Babbage.
There is a symmetry in that Erasmus Darwin and William Herschel were keen collaborators in the late 1700’s (JP Daly, 2020) – “(Erasmus) Darwin later visited (Willaim) Herschel’s observatory at Slough. What is beyond doubt is that Darwin enthusiastically embraced Herschel’s natural historical cosmology”, while in the early 1800’s William’s son John and Erasmus’s grandson Charles Darwinmet, incredibly, in South Africa, coincidentally, on Darwin’s famous HMS Beagle voyage on route to the Galapagos Islands, while docked near Herschel’s observatory in Cape Town. And were reunited in Westminster Abbey – their bodies buried next to each other. That Babbage mixed with these two giants of 19th century science speaks volumes to his connections, influence and influences, as seen below in my Tree.
So in summary there was a natural if indirect link from the Lunar Society of Birmingham to Babbage and his associates in London and Cambridge, both in terms of personnel, family trees and also their specialisms. Babbage must have been aware of and influenced by the Lunar Society and its members. Although he was less entrepreneurial than many Lunar members – Babbage rarely commercialised or took patents on his inventions – nevertheless his goal of mechanisation for the wider good was shared by the Lunar Society; but he then saw the additional benefit of progressing mechanisation into calculation and automation. He was more mathematical than the Lunar Society but as a Polymath natural philosopher his wider science interests like Engineering definitely coincided, as did his general belief in the value of Science “clubs”.
Discussion/Development
In the light of the above research let us examine and summarise the various roles which Babbage undertook. To what extent did he excel, did he leave a legacy, when was he acknowledged, how did he compare to equivalent figures before, during and after his lifetime?
Mathematician
As a Mathematician Babbage was in the Premier League, but not a Champion. He was at the forefront of the debate about the versions of calculus originated by Newton and Leibnitz, but he was not a Newton or Leibniz himself. Although a Chair for ten years of Lucian Maths back at Cambridge University, he fulfilled his duties rather than excelling (he never returned to live there). His special expertise was in the areas of Tables, statistics, functions including calculus, and probability. But he had a wider role – to promote the use of Maths in everyday life, the use of measurement, accuracy, precision, empirical judgement; he believed that everything could be expressed numerically and recorded as such (he frequently stopped to measure animal heartbeats) And he linked Maths to other specialisms like philosophy and astronomy.
Engineer
He understood the need for precise design and manufacture, which is why he hired Clement for Engine No. 1 and draughtsman Godfrey for Engine No.2 He understood metallurgy, gearing ratio, cogs, leverage, springs, shafts, connecting rods, tolerances. Also wider civil engineering aspects such as railway track gauges and factory design. He was an inventor of mechanical devices. With some skill in making and using tools he was able to run his own workshop. He created a very small prototype of the Engine himself, even before Clement’s model.
With that array of theoretical engineering knowledge and practical skills, two questions emerge. First where did they come from since Babbage wasn’t formally trained in Engineering at school or University? I believe the answer is partly self-taught – he designed water-walking shoes as a school boy – and also by liaison with his Society colleagues. Secondly, why did it take so long (almost ten years) to get even part of the Engine No.1 built? Especially since as you will see from the photos, the Engine is big but not that big. The reason is partly because of his poor Project Management skills – no timeline milestones, his tinkering with design, running over budget, falling out with Clement. And partly, because of the sheer complexity of the interlocking cog wheels and columns – and the need to avoid jamming and calculation errors – and the large number (20,000) of small parts requiring very fine tolerance production. Some would argue that Clement deliberately over complicated production to extend his contract, but remember even the Science Museum project took seven years to complete. And even Clement’s incomplete model is now recognised as a shining example of advanced early 19th century engineering.
Computer Pioneer
After Babbage died, he and his work were almost forgotten, as was Ada Lovelace. Although his son Henry’s noble efforts to publicise and occasionally build some designs just about extended his legacy to the 1900’s, there was a gap of almost 50 more years to the invention of the modern computer and even then only one major designer, Aitken (Harvard Mark 1) significantly recognised his work. So when and why has Babbage become recognised as the Godfather of computing, after falling out of favour?
There is an argument that in choosing mechanical cogwheel design, rather than the as yet unavailable electronic option, and preferring base 10 rather than the Base 2 of Boolean logic, which paved the way years later for digital age, that Babbage had created a dead-end. And his failure to find large scale uses, and failure to complete his complex Engines, and his alienating of important potential sponsors, also contributed to his diminished reputation.
Arguably the reinvention of Babbage started with the “Babbage Papers” held in the London Science Museum Archives containing three main types of material; his notebooks, engineering drawings and also notations which “describe the way parts are intended to act” and can be thought of as ‘walk throughs’ or ‘traces’ of micro-programs for various models or plans of the engines” (Reference: Science Museum)
In this Bibliography reference you can follow in extraordinary detail scans of many of the thousands of original drawings, formulae, plans, explanations, instructions that Babbage had created, even if not published. It’s a beautifully constructed digital retrospective by the way. My guess is that when Dr Allan Bromley, already an expert on computing history, began in 1979 to research and put together this archive he must have thought, “wow, Babbage got there first! And no-one knew!) It was he who persuaded Doran Swade to commence the project to build Engine No.2 in 1985.
In terms of the towering figures of mathematical computing machines, Babbage is now considered up there with the greats. Pascal and Leibniz from the 1700’s; monumental mathematicians who produced the arithmetic machine and reckoner, early mechanical small desktop mechanical calculators but very limited compared to Babbage’s machines. Then in the 1800’s, as well as Babbage, Colman’s arithmometer – the first reliable office mechanical calculator; and George Boole, developer of Boolean logic which permutates digital “1 or zero” digital computer design. In the 1900’s , Aitken’s Harvard Mark 1 referencing Babbage, and of course Turing’s famous papers before and after WW2, bookending his literal Colossus to crack the Enigma code.
It should be noted Turing was more of a theoretical computer scientist, relying on his Engineer Tommy Flowers for the build, which now featured Thermionic valves, driven by early electronics not mechanics or steam. And in the 2000’s one might argue that Steve Jobs (Apple hardware including the Mac and I Pad) and Bill Gates (Microsoft software and Windows operating system) are the most recent key figures, unless a name becomes attached to Quantum computing or AI.
My take on this is that Babbage combined both of Turing’s theoretical and Flowers’s practical roles; but unlike them (they had a War to urgently win) he lacked the discipline of a deadline. And likewise he combined aspects of Gates and Jobs, but lacked their commercial impetus. I think Babbage, had he lived today, may have invented programming languages, but would be bored to churn out individual coding. He may have been a solutions architect, but outsourced the grind of implementation.
Author
Babbage wrote six significant books in his lifetime as follows (links in Bibliography):
Note that at the time of his death in 1871, Charles Babbage was beginning to pull together descriptions of his various Engines to be formally published. His son, Henry, having inherited much of his father’s materials, did finally publish a full Engines description in 1889. He also built several small versions of the Difference Engine, and at the end of his life in 1910, completed the portion of the Analytical Mill now in the Science Museum. In terms of computing, there was a brief flurry of references in the 1930’s and 40’s as the modern computer’s invention began, then a lull until aided by the Science Museum’s Build project; a flurry of books about Babbage’ s Engines followed from the 1980’s onwards.
In terms of the above six books it’s instructive to describe them to help answer our central question, was Babbage more than (just) a computer pioneer?
Babbage’s lifelong development of his Engines started, and to some extent continued, from the standpoint of calculating, checking, proof reading and printing mathematical tables so it is no surprise his first major publication was the logarithms of the first 108,000 numbers.
The Decline of Science begins to reveal both Babbage’s wider interests in Science as a whole, but also his lifelong fight with his perceived detractors, in this case the Royal Society.
Of all Babbage’s publications, On theEconomy of Machinery and Manufactures is perhaps his most influential (OEMM as it is called). It is an extraordinary intellectual achievement, some would argue on a par with his physical Engines. OEMM was a consequence of his visits to workshops and the new industrial factories, often with frequent collaborator John Herschel, in England and also continental Europe. The type of factories that Lunar Men Watt and Boulton had established in Soho, Birmingham.
In this book Babbage describes his “Babbage principle” relating to advantages of specialisation and division of labour accordingly leading to lower overall production costs, along with the benefits of machinery over labour.
He also introduces the concept of economies of scale from larger factories; the “transactional cost” method including cost of each part of a process including conformance to quality specifications; the benefits of incremental improvements through observing and hence refining manufacturing processes; standardisation techniques for producing identical parts; the idea of measuring performance of management tasks and factory workflow; the importance of supply chains; and the effect of taxation on manufacturing.
In short, he describes the transition from simply “making” to manufacturing (Ozgur, 2010), and perhaps invents many aspects of microeconomics.
The influence of OEMM cannot be overstated. Arguably the two most famous publications in economic history are Karl Marx’s “Das Kapital” and Adam Smith’s “Wealth of Nations” – in simple terms the Communist and Capitalist views of political economy. Marx referenced Babbage directly, and although Smith’s first edition didn’t, subsequent editions leaned heavily on the fact that initially Smith’s view was that agriculture laid the foundations for Britain’s increasing wealth, but now Babbage was explaining that Britian’s role in the Industrial Revolution, in particular manufacturing, was the major factor.
Later in the 1800’s, the influence of Babbage can be seen John Stewart Mill’s seminal works like “Principles of Political Economy” and into the 1900’s, in Frederik Taylor’s theories on work study, operational research, factory design and piecework payment systems (and Babbage even predicted the issue that workers, if studied, would behave particularly productively); and in Japan and America, the ideas of Quality Assurance, Total Quality and even Quality Circles seemed to refer back to OEMM. (Note ; as an industrialist myself, with practical expertise on Quality and Operational Research, and as Business and Economics tutor, I was astonished to discover Babbage’s influence)
Then just five years after OEMM came the Bridgewater Treatise, described earlier under philosophy; proving that Babbage could switch very quickly from Engineering and Manufacturing to Religion and Philosophy. It is an extraordinary demonstration of his broad range of “polymath” natural philosophy knowledge. Apparently Engineering and Philosophy seem disconnected, but Babbage’s common ground was the influence of empirical observation, measurement and the relation of human ingenuity and thought to mechanical operation.
The Exposition of 1851 coincides with the great Crystal Palace exhibition of the same year, and as well as offering his views on the building design, entry prices and prizes, Babbage takes the opportunity to talk more generally about the roles of science, government and technology. The fact he was not invited to exhibit indicates the beginning of his fall from grace.
Passages from the Life of a Philosopher, referred to earlier, looks back autobiographically on his life, beginning surprisingly perhaps by dedicating it to the King of Italy. I believe that this not only reveals how important he feels his travels were, but also some indication of not being fully accepted or acknowledged in his own country.
The book illustrates the range and progression of his priorities and it is instructive to group his chapters broadly to these categories: his early life and upbringing; the Difference and Analytical Engines and his demonstration in 1862; his recollections of meetings with famous people: Prince Albert, the Duke of Wellington, Humphrey Davey; stories of his various experiences, for instance with the Courts, Theatre, Fire, and Water; his work on railways, effectively as a management consultant, combining recommendations on information (the “black box” equivalent, infrastructure (the gauge) and engineering invention (the cow catcher); religion and miracles; his contribution to Science and human knowledge.
The book reveals both his genius but also his foibles, his insistence on recording “who said what when” in his meetings, and his cantankerous aspects. For instance, after surprisingly not being asked to participate in the great 1852 Exhibition at Crystal Palace – and that must have hurt – he finally gets to demonstrate the Engine fragment formally for the first (and last) time in 1862 at the London follow up, an Exposition in South Kensington. It was going well but he complains about the small space, falls out with some audience members who were complaining about his latest grievance – street organists – and promptly leaves early in annoyance.
But let us focus on his crowning achievements. In describing his later Engines, Babbage talks of “The whole of arithmetic now appeared within the grasp of mechanism”….”I concluded also that nothing but teaching the Engine to foresee and then to act upon that foresight could ever lead me to the object I desired, namely, to make the whole of any unlimited number of carriages in one unit of time”….”it formed the first great step towards reducing the whole science of number to the absolute control of mechanism”
Two of his most important quotes are these, first the core philosophy of his life:
“I think one of the most important guiding principles has been this:—that every moment of my waking hours has always been occupied by some train of inquiry. In far the largest number of instances the subject might be simple or even trivial, but still work of inquiry, of some kind or other, was always going on.”
Second, his acknowledgment of the difficulties of his Engine work, and the hope and expectation that someone in future will pick up the reins and run with it.
“Half a century may probably elapse before anyone without those aids which I leave behind me, will attempt so unpromising a task. If, unwarned by my example, any man shall undertake and shall succeed in really constructing an engine embodying in itself the whole of the executive department of mathematical analysis upon different principles or by simpler mechanical means, I have no fear of leaving my reputation in his charge, for he alone will be fully able to appreciate the nature of my efforts and the value of their results”.
At the end of the Life of a Philosopher book, Babbage then lists in chronological order some eighty published papers either directly in his name, or others publishing for him, or extracting his work.
They begin with a paper in 1813 on the Analytical Society with his Cambridge colleague John Herschel.
Then continue with many mathematical papers such as on Calculus and Functions; on mechanical calculators, his own Engines; water related devices like diving bells, submarines and lighthouses; printing methods; the geology of the earth’s surfaces; the astronomy of Neptune and the Sun; the bones of extinct animals; gun arrangements in an army’s battery; observations on awarding peerages; and extracts from most of his books, including his second last paper in 1864 derived from his “Passages” book.
Then more than fifty years after his first paper comes the eightieth and last, sometime after 1864, intriguingly it is the beginnings of his unfinished account of the history of the Analytical Engine, in which he includes a reprint of the earlier translation of “Sketch of the Analytical Engine” and acknowledges translation by none other than “the late Countess of Lovelace, with extensive Notes by the Translator.”
In summary the large range of topics in his papers and books spanning half a century indicates that yes, Babbage truly was a polymath and all-round natural philosopher.
Philosopher – natural and traditional
We have covered Babbage’s philosophical links extensively so let us summarise his role, first as a natural philosopher.
Babbage was a new kind of scientist and natural philosopher who combined great intellectual insight with practical engineering skills who saw the combination of science and technology as a force for national advancement and collective good.
A true Polymath, his range and depth of his expertise was astonishing – from his mathematical calculating engines of course, but also to the other sciences of physics, engineering , geology and astronomy; and into business and economics. In the National Portrait Gallery, London you can find Babbage’s portrait, painted by Samuel Laurence in 1844, and the Gallery describes Babbage as a “Mathematician, mechanical engineer, philosopher and computer pioneer.” Note also his ability to link many of these areas of expertise – for instance he pinpointed the role of factory machinery and engineering in generating economic efficiency and economies of scale.
Babbage’s knowledge of more traditional areas of philosophy such as religion, ethics and the human mind came to light particularly in his Ninth Bridgewater Treatise. As ever he was able to link this area back to his Engine work, noting that his Analytical Engine would have “foresight” and suggesting that the Universe perhaps had pre-programmed, deterministic aspect.
In Babbage’s last book, he calls himself a “philosopher”. His title “passages from the life of…” indicates to me a whimsical look back, and its varied contents seem as if to say, “yes, I’ve seen and done everything, just as a natural philosopher should”.
Science society networker
Babbage also carried on the tradition of late Georgian/early Victorian English Science Societies as a means of networking and promoting sciences – he belonged to many and founded some, such as the Cambridge Mathematics Practitioners, the Analytical Society, the British Association for Advancement of Science, The Statistical Society, The Royal Astronomical Society, and the Royal Society.
Perhaps his “clubs” were the London versions of the Lunar Society, the Birmingham based group. There was only a few years between them and meetings and conversations must surely have overlapped. Perhaps Babbage should have paid them more attention – but were the philosophical intelligentsia of London and Cambridge too far removed from industrial Birmingham? Perhaps, but it has been claimed that “(John) Herschel and Babbage spent a great deal of time visiting factories and viewed themselves as the philosophical equivalents of great industrialists such as James Watt, Matthew Boulton…”. (Ashworth, 1996)
We have noted several indirect connections between Babbage and the Lunar Society. , such as Watt and Darwin. Another is through the famous English scientist Sir Humprey Davy, pioneer in electrochemistry and gases like nitrous oxide. Let us use his example to see how science society networking worked. Davy was well known to a founder of the Lunar Society, steam engineer James Watt (Lacy, 2023).
Also, Davy was president of the Royal Society (of Science) while Babbage was an active member. In fact the somewhat Machiavellian side of Babbage is shown during Davy’s accession to and time as President of the Royal Society ; Babbage and John Herschel and others from the “Cambridge group” frequently corresponded – overtly and covertly – about how to get their preferred candidate voted in as President – and it wasn’t Davy. Despite this Babbage helped Davy with vacuum tube calculations and Davy supported Babbage in his request for Engine funding from the Board of Longitude, and later Davy was on a sub-committee in Government looking as they often did at Treasury Engine funding.
Babbage and Herschel in the Royal Society moved away from Maths a little but “continued to hold up mathematical skills of the highest order as thesine qua non of the true natural philosopher” . Their extra research enabled “Cambridge Network members to a claim to superiority over mathematically illiterate philosophers”.
Babbage fell foul of and fell out with the Royal Society for a number of reasons – his failure to win a medal, and his perceived attack in “Decline of Science”. In many senses Babbage was a superb member and founder of Science and Maths societies, but on the other hand his personal grievances and thin-skin ease of taking offence were sometimes his own worst enemy.
Conclusion
Yes, Babbage really was more than a computer pioneer. In fact, in the period either side of his death, namely the 2nd half of the 19th century, one might argue that his influence in subjects outside of mechanical calculation was the greater. But we need to distinguish between just strong expertise, and expertise so outstanding as to leave a lasting legacy.
As a mathematician he clearly outstanding – many papers published, ten years a Lucasian chair of Mathematics at Cambridge – but ultimately, he was a follower not a leader. For instance, he didn’t invent calculus but helped to resolve the different versions. What he began to achieve was recognition of the importance of practical, applied mathematics for instance in measurement, quantification, requirement of empirical evidence.
As an engineer, he had excellent design skills – such as in his Engines – and reasonable practical skills – he had his own workshop. He and Clement were some of the first to recognise and implement the idea of repeatable production of small machine parts to very tight tolerances. Babbage was a very good engineering manager – except in one crucial respect namely Project Management in which he allowed drift of specification scope and time. He was also a visionary who promoted the importance of technology including mechanical engineering in the advancement of Great Britain in the industrial revolution.
As a natural philosopher was one the last of the breed and one of the best – such a large range of specialisms in both the sciences – physics, engineering, industry, mathematics, astronomy, even stretching to botany and geology – and also traditional philosophy as evidenced by his epic Ninth Bridgewater Treatise. After Babbage’s period, the roles of specialist scientists began to emerge, and to separate from traditional philosophy, and rarely again would an all-rounder of Babbage’s expertise and stature come forth.
Babbage’s belief in and enjoyment of formal clubs and societies, was proved by his numerous memberships and founding leaderships. Some of which were natural successors to the Lunar Society which finished just as he was starting his career. Although he seemingly didn’t physically meet its members his associations with them and the wider Lunar network were numerous through his close relationships with for instance the Herschels, the Darwins, and Humphrey Davy. Babbage was also a great informal networker as well, proved by his very popular for a time soirees for the great and the good. But ultimately Babbage let his own eccentricities and overt criticisms, for instance of the Royal Society, and civil servants like Airey, diminish his reputation.
We shall close by comparing and contrasting his two greatest expertises and influences – computer science obviously – but starting with his role in examining and influencing, in his actual and near lifetime, the development of the United Kingdom as a world leading manufacturing powerhouse. His epic Economy of Machinery and Manufactures is of course less well known than his Engine designs but it laid the foundation of many operational strategies which were actually implemented in real manufacturing businesses. For instance his “Babbage principle” of division of labour, the benefit of economies of scale, transactional cost efficiencies, vertical integration of supply chains, quality control and assurance, to name but a few. As such he was hugely influential in early Microeconomics, Operational Research and eventually Management Consultancy. One of his recommendations was on the transition from invention to innovation in processes, leading to mass marketable products – which leads us finally to his Engines, because sadly Babbage could not achieve that himself.
Babbage’s Difference Engines were the first to make the transition from rudimentary mechanical calculators – with very little application beyond drawing room curiosities – to sophisticated automatic calculators with a high degree of accuracy and precision and real purpose (in Table production and generating polynomial results). Although he never had them fully built, his working models were enough to demonstrate potential – which was proved by the recent full build of Engine No.2 at the Science Museum.
The Analytical Engine was even less complete in his lifetime, but its potential was a step above the Difference Engine as it was more of a programmable all-purpose machine capable of more extensive calculations. As we now know, Ada Lovelace’s interpretation of his designs opened up the possibility of computer programmes.
Babbage did achieve a lot of recognition in his lifetime for his Machines – which other mathematician could be welcome to demonstrate their product to Prime Ministers and Chancellors of The Exchequer as well as such a range of celebrities and scientists? So why did his machines fall out of sight for almost a hundred years? Partly because his use of cogwheels – while ingenious – was ultimately less sophisticated than electronics. Partly because although he was a great networker, he had a habit of falling out with colleagues like Engineer Clement and sponsors in Government – which with his own tendency to tinker lead to him never fully completing his machines. And partly the need for computers hadn’t really arrived – or he couldn’t sell the need or see it (Tables were too narrow an application). It seemed that simple early office mechanical calculators were all that was needed.
So if there was no really direct line from Babbage to modern computers why and when did he become so famous as the Father of Computing? Was there something in the sheer size of his Machines, similar to early mainframe computers? Actually, I conclude that the work of Bromley and Swade in the 1980s’s played a huge role in uncovering his designs, from for example his Notebooks and the collection of Babbage Papers, and on turning that into a finished Engine project. With that came widespread publicity in both the scientific and crucially the non-scientific media. As people began to use computers themselves, they began to wonder, where did all this come from? Add in Ada Lovelace’s contribution and all-told it was a great story; but more than a story. Babbage had correctly and astonishingly predicted a hundred years in advance the solutions architecture of much of today’s computing – the separation of hardware and software, of programming and data store, the idea of loops, iterations and subroutines. This only truly became apparent in the full examination of his designs; and so, his elevation to “father of the computer” was retrospective.
Some analogies I can think of are these; on TV on Long Lost Families or Who Do you Think You Are, people learn about their long-lost relatives’ activities. When fans in America heard the Rolling Stones interpretation of Rhythm and Blues for the first time in the early 1960s’s many didn’t know that the songs’ origin was actually in African American Blues in their own country. Consider Columbus being viewed as the first European to discover America – later it was discovered the Vikings were there much earlier. Or (ironically) the recent discovery of the 2000-year-old ancient Greek Antikythera machine with gears for predicting navigational and astronomical events. Also consider Vincent Van Gogh, the impressionist painter, unloved in his lifetime. Which leads to a final analysis of Babbage.
A Dr Who episode brought Van Gogh forward in time to a modern art gallery displaying his paintings. The Doctor asked him to listen to what the visitors were saying. Of course, they were gushing in praise and Vincent was astonished but delighted. Babbage and Lovelace also appeared in a Dr Who episode – but nearer to their own time period. I bet that Babbage would love to be transported forward to finally realise the recognition he craved . In today’s terminology he would be described as “insecure”. All sorts of recognition has emerged in the end – a crater on the Moon named Babbage, a computer language called Ada, a road in Cambridge called Babbage Road to name a few.
So, in final conclusion, the large majority of people who have heard of Babbage would know him in popular culture as the father of computing only; but a significant minority of specialists would know him as the extraordinary polymath.
Evaluation (of my project, required in EPQ)
As most EPQ students do, I aimed to run the project in the summer holidays. My time plan worked successfully. The start was slow – writing the first few paragraphs is always the most difficult. But once the fascination of the topic took hold, it was easy to keep going. In fact, I doubled the minimum length required.
I achieved my objectives. I reached a conclusion and answered the question, namely that Babbage certainly was just more than a computer pioneer. Those with just a slight recognition of Babbage would be surprised, but experts would not. What might be controversial are my assertions that Babbage’s work was a natural succession to Lunar Society; and that his work on factory economics as described in his epic book OEMM is in my view almost as important as his purely Difference and Analytical Engine work. This may reflect some bias on my part – as a factory economist myself I was astonished and impressed to discover his influence in that area.
Another objective was to complete a project to learn lessons on students’ behalf including research techniques. Here is what I found and hence can provide recommendations.
I vowed at the outset not to rely purely on the internet. Spending time reading a couple of proper paper books was invaluable because you see the whole picture not just fragments. My primary research visit to the Science Museum was useful in a number of ways – you get to see the physicality of the Machines, and visitors’ reactions to them. Also discover little surprises like the Herschels’ telescope.
‘
But inevitably the internet plays a big part. Here are some thoughts. Google Scholar and JSTOR provide reliable references. You have to join JSTOR but its free up to a hundred articles. Google Scholar seems unlimited access and I recommend searching on some key words, then after selecting a document use “Control-F” to highlight particular words you are looking for – this makes potentially long and intimidating documents much easier to navigate. Then either take short word for word extracts into your dissertation – but remember to acknowledge with quotation marks and use italics. Or try to summarise in your own words a short paragraph to insert into your project. Note that if “PDF” is mentioned to the right of the Google Scholar screen you get the full download – better than just an abstract.
Make sure that if you use a Reference that you immediately record it – full references in Bibliography, author name and date in the dissertation itself. Otherwise you will forget.
Occasionally I used Copilot a Google Artificial Intelligence Add-In. It generally gives a nice summary of a topic with reasonable accuracy. Typically I used it to answer a linkage question like “did A ever meet B”? I feel it sometimes gave me the answer it thought I wanted to read; and sometimes gave exactly the same answer to two slightly different questions. Sometimes the wrong answer (it confused the different Herschels). So I used “critical thinking” to not always totally believe what it told me. One thing is certain – never copy exactly what it says – you will be found out!
I frequently looked at the marking grid to make sure that as well as I enjoyed the project, I was also fulfilling what examiners want. For instance, trying to link phrases and also present alternative arguments; such as “Babbage sought recognition so gained a lot of publicity from his soirees and was a great networker, on the other hand he frequently fell out with potential sponsors”.
Also to consider what were my limitations and so what further work might I do: increasingly I found such a huge amount of material available that it became difficult to choose and difficult to be sure I was finding something new; I think my angles on the Lunar Society and the super-importance of OEMM potentially were new so I would like to follow up more on those aspects.
Also, I’d like to solve the puzzle of where in the world all the remaining fragments or complete Engines are located. Did I miss one at the Science Museum? Yes I did – Clement’s part-build – a good example of primary follow up research is that the Science Museum did identify my missing Engine after I emailed them. Which reminds me, the official guidance is to use technical academic language so exclamation marks are no doubt frowned upon and I have probably over used them in my project (!).
In terms of what I might have done differently, the eventual length at 10,000 words was twice the minimum, so I should have been more disciplined in scope (but I became fascinated). Also I found in the structure of the dissertation a little difficult to decide what to put in Research, or Discussion, or Conclusion and could have resolved that from the start. My basic advice is this: in Research use more fact-based paragraphs without your own opinion and most of your references should be here. Save just a few references for discussion where you will be more writing your own interpretation and opinion on what the Research showed and develop some themes of your own. Then in Conclusion bring it all together, referring back to the title, answering its question, using justifying evidence with a little bit of counterbalance argument.
But all in all I am pleased and proud to have completed this work.
A transdisciplinary perspective on economic complexity. Marshall’s problem revisited Francesco Cassata, Roberto Marchionatti∗ Department of Economics, University of Turin, Italy
Appendix: Assessment of sample of References (required for EPQ)
Reference
Relevance to Paper
Reliability of author
The Cogwheel Brain, Doran Swade
Tells the story of Babbage as a computer pioneer and beyond and of the rebuild of Difference Engines No.2
Swade is regarded as one of the experts on Babbage and as Science Museum computer science curator was the co-leader of the project to rebuild Difference Engine No. 2. He is not biased, as he lists the pros and cons of the argument that Babbage was a computer pioneer. Swade both publishes a book and features in an article in the well respected Scientific American Magazine
Charels Babbage the Great Uncle of Computing ? , Maurice Wilkes
Discusses Babbage’s life, connections and impact on computing
Part of a wider magazine on Computing Perspectives, Communications of the Age, Wilkes worked very closely with Swade and Dr Bromley, the other leader of the Difference Engine No. 2 rebuild who helped to digitalise the Babbage Papers at the Science Museum. Wilkes lists the pros and cons of the argument that Babbage was a computer pioneer. He won a Turing award.
CHARLES BABBAGE: AN INADVERTENT DEVELOPMENT ECONOMIST, Erdem Ozgur
Describes Babbage’s contributions in areas beyond calculations Engines namely as an early developer of Microeconomic ideas and promoter of manufacturing
The paper is from JSTOR’s respected academic paper library and is part of a wider series of papers on economic theory in “Quaderni di storia dell’economia politica”
The Lunar Men: The Friends Who Made the Future 1730-1810 Paperback – 4 Sept. 2003 Jennifer Uglow
Tells the story of the Lunar Society a crucial account of the club and its members which influenced Babbage
Jenny Uglow has received several literary prizes for this book and as an author has witten several Biographies of other historical English figures. She has featured as an expert in the BBC’s In Our time on the Discovery of Oxygen and the Lunar Society itself and as consultant to period dramas like Pride and Prejudice.
In this week’s Economist magazine, a description of Lithium and Sodium ion batteries could easily have come straight from the GCSE Chemistry syllabus, particularly the atomic structure section.
The article describes the fact that with both metals being in Group 1 of the Periodic Table, they have a single electron in the outer shell, which is easily lost to form the positive ion. And this electron, rather than let us say being transferred to a chlorine atom to form sodium chloride, instead forms the electric current generated by the cell, which has a good “energy density”.
The context is that part of the push for transition from fossil fuels involves moving to electric vehicles (EV’s) which generally have a lithium ion battery. These typically use nickel and cobalt lithium oxides as the cathode, and lithium carbon (graphite) as the anode. (The reason that Lithium alone is not used is that as we know from our GCSE, Lithium is very reactive, too reactive in fact)
The problem with this design is that Lithium is scarce and like the Nickel and Cobalt requires mining which itself can damage the environment.
So the Economist argues that sodium ion cells, in alliance this time with iron and manganese, involve metals which in all cases are much more easily and abundantly available. But the magazine highlights the problem, again using the Chemistry syllabus, that because sodium is one further down in Group 1, it has more protons and hence is heavier and so may not be used in EV’s (already creaking under the weight of Lithium batteries) – but sodium ion batteries can however be used in heavy duty applications like power grid storage or even at home, when weight does not matter so much.
All of which goes to show just how important is the GCSE Chemistry syllabus!
Numerical reasoning – what is it, what type of questions?
Working in the Maths tutoring arena, I’m hearing more about the topic of numerical reasoning and therefore so will pupils and parents. This blogpost helps you understand it and try lots of examples yourself. Numerical reasoning is more than addition, multiplication, and division. But equally it’s not about quadratic equations or calculus.
In general, its more about real-life problem-solving and in particular about interpretation of numerical charts, graphs, tables, data sets, trends and series. Leading to a conclusion often requiring choosing an answer to a multiple choice question, and the wording of the question often needs careful attention.
The specific underlying maths skills needed are quite limited in their topic-scope and are mostly KS3 level. Principally:
accurate, quick mental arithmetic backed up with calculator if allowed
BIDMAS order of operations and execution thereof
fractions decimals, percents including operations with percents
ratios
pie charts, bar charts, line graphs
two way tables of data
money calculations from simple pounds and pennies to basic sales units, value, costs and profit, and currency conversion
series, sequences and patterns
speed time and distance formula triangle
units of measure, conversions, multiples of 10
In fact, it’s the generic skill requirements which differentiate numerical reasoning questions. Interpreting data involves understanding the data, regardless of the various presentation formats, or sometimes column-headings not seen before. Then being able to manipulate the data, perhaps involving combinations of the maths techniques above, or realising a two-step process is needed to calculate missing information to finally answer the question.
Comprehension of the data, deciphering patterns, performing estimates and determining relevant information are other requirements – for instance quickly realising the question is pointing you to just one bar in a bar chart or just one row and column in a table.
Because the actual maths topics, like percentages, are fairly basic, then the surprising result is that you could find the same numerical reasoning question in almost any age-group test. In theory at least these questions should be accessible to anyone who’s been to school, not necessarily a high performing school or top maths set. So it is an “equalising” method. All you need is generic maths intuition, rather than specific difficult techniques, or so it is claimed! (I have my doubts – if you struggle with percents and ratios you will probably struggle with interpretational maths skills too). Which leads us to the question, where could you come across these questions?
Which tests and exams feature particular types of numerical reasoning questions?
Let us start with 11-plus entrance exams.
Most selective independent or grammar schools will have some kind of Maths test as part of the admissions process. And most of these tests will contain at least a few numerical reasoning questions to back up the basic numbers-only questions.
An example would be this:
Q1. A purely numerical “fractions” question might be, what is ½ plus ¼? (Ans. ¾ )
Q2. A version of this, shall we say on its way to numerical reasoning style, might be: if I have £10 to spend, and spend a quarter on sweets and a half on drinks, how much change do I get? (Ans. £2.50)
Selective schools typically use exam Boards such as ISEB, GL, CEM and Ukiset for admissions testing. All of these will contain numerical reasoning to a certain extent, but two stand out.
First CEM, which has a specific paper called “Numerical Reasoning”. A typical question might be:
Rick is 1.8m tall and John is the same as Rick. Peter is taller than Rick. Carol is 57cm shorter than Peter. John is 45cm taller than Carol. What height is Peter?
Ans. Carol must be 1m 80cm less 45 cm = 1m 35 cm. So Peter must be 1m 35cm plus 57 cm = 1m 92 cm
Or a sequence question like:
Q3. This picture represents a sequence of triangle numbers. How many blocks would be in the next pattern? Ans. 10
Second, Ukiset, the UK Independent Schools’ Entry Test, (particularly for international students) This is a test nearest to what the purists would regard as classic numerical reasoning. (Like many exam Boards, it also contains verbal and non-verbal reasoning, but we’ll not cover those here). A score is generated after the test which can be benchmarked to indicate potential.
Here are some examples of typical style of Ukiset questions
Q4. From the graph above, what is the percentage increase in Hare population between 1970 and 1980? Choose from A 10% B 20% C 25% D 30% Ans C 25%. (10,000 – 8,000) / 8,000 x 100%
Q5. The total attendance for three South Coast football teams was 1,200,000 in 2018 and 1,000,000 in 2019. Using the Pie charts above how much greater was the attendance for Portsmouth in 2019 than 2018
Choose from A 25,000 B 50,000 C 75,000 D 100,000
Ans B 50,000 2018 = 60/360 x 1,200,000 = 1/6 x 1,200,000 = 200,000 2019 = ¼ x 1,000,000 = 250,000 Difference = 50,000
Q6a. From the table below, showing which sports 100 male and female pupils play at school. What is the ratio of male to female pupils at the school, expressed in its simplest form? A 4:6 B 6:4 C 2:3 D 3:2
Ans. C 2:3. Male total = 40, female total = 60 so ratio = 40:60 = 2:3
Q6b. Amongst the males only, what percentage of them play soccer? A 25% B 40% C 50% C 75%
Ans C 50%. 20/40 x 100% = 50%
Q7.
A business sells two products and the units sold in thousands are shown above by year. Some financial details for 1980 are shown below.
Profit is calculated as sales value (sales price per unit x number of units sold), less total costs.
How much more profit was made in $ in 1980 for product 1 than product 2? A $ 20,000 B $40,000 C $60,000 D $80,000
Ans. C $60,000
Product 1 Sales value = 10,000 x £10 = £100,000 so profit after deducting £20,000 costs = £80,000. Product 2 Sales value = 1,000 x £50 = £50,000 so profit after deducting £10,000 costs = £40,000 Difference = £40,000 x 1.5 = $ 60.000
The UKMT U.K. Maths Challenge from Junior to Senior provides a good source of numerical reasoning practice. Here is an example:
Q8. To paint a room, half of a 3 litre can of paint was used for the first coat then 2/3 of the remainder was used for the 2nd coat. How much paint remained?
Ans 0.5 litre = 500 ml. ½ of 3 = 1.5 and 2/3 of 1.5 – 1.0 so 0.5 left.
Let us move on to GCSE Maths exams.
In the O-Level years we had Pure Maths and Applied Maths, with numerical reasoning very much in the latter category. While it is clear that in recent years examiners have aspired to introduce more “real-world” and “wordy” Maths questions to GCSE 9-1 graded exams, we can be a bit nore specific and identify certain questions in the style of some of the above numerical reasoning questions. All of the below are based on actual recent questions.
Q9. A firm has a total of 160 vehicles. They are cars and lorries. The number of cars : the number of lorries = 3 : 7 Each car and each lorry uses electricity or diesel or petrol. 1/8 of the cars use electricity. 25% of the cars use diesel. The rest of the cars use petrol.
How many cars use petrol?You must show all your working.
Ans 30. 160 vehicles = 10 shares so 1 share = 16 Cars = 3 x 16 = 48 so electricity = 1/8 x 48 = 6 Diesel = ¼ of 48 = 12 so petrol = 48 – 6 – 12 = 30
Q10. In Europe, Rick pays 27 euros for 18 litres of petrol. In the U.K., Malcolm pays £40 for 8 gallons of the same type of petrol. 1 euro = £0.85 and 4.5 litres = 1 gallon Rick thinks that petrol is cheaper in Spain than in U.K. Is he correct? You must show how you get your answer
Ans.No: Many ways to prove it for instance: in Europe 1.5 Euros = 1 litre =£1.275 In U.K. £5 = 1 gallon = 4.5 litres so 1 litre = £1.11 So cheaper in U.K.
Q11. Ellie makes cakes in a restaurant using potato, cheese and onion so that weight of potato : weight of cheese : weight of onion = 9 : 2 : 1 Ellie needs to make 6000 g of cakes. Cheese costs £2.25 for 175 g.
Work out the cost of the cheese needed to make 6000 g of cakes.
Ans.£12.86 12 shares = 6000 so 1 share = 500 g so cheese = 2 x 500 = 1000g So cheese = 1000 / 175 x 2.25 = £12.86
Q12. A sign on a motorway says the time to reach a junction 30 miles way is 26 minutes. The driver thinks they would have to drive faster than the speed limit of 70 miles per hour to do that. Are they right?
Ans. No . Speed = distance / time = 30 / (26/60) = 1800 /26 = 69.2 mph
Q13. In a survey of 10 people their fruit preferences are shown in the table below
In a second survey of more people the preferences are shown in the pie chart below. Explain how the second survey shows a lower preference for bananas.
Ans. First survey: 5/10 is a half. Second survey: yellow slice is less than 1/2
A-level
Many questions at Maths A-Level feature “real world” scenarios but do not qualify as classic numerical reasoning questions because they require high level mathematical techiques such as calculus and standard deviation, not accessible to most people. However, there is a set question each year which contains the spirit of numerical reasoning, namely the large data set.
Typically the data set and graph questions at GCSE and earlier contain rolled up summaries of accumulated data. But this annual A-Level question pre-releases a large data set of original detail in Microsoft Excel from which the student can make summaries themselves and draw conclusions. An example is shown.
Original data
Question Q14: does the data and graph prove that the amount of salt consumed reduced greatly in the period shown:Ans:not completely because “greatly” is ill- defined and purchasing does not necessarily correlate with consumption
Numerical reasoning skills can help your career
In the new worlld of AI, programming, algorithms, information technology and even socila media, the use of Maths in general and numerical reasoning in particular is becoming a more important skill. Even the Prime Minister says so! And the use of graphs and statistics in the pandemic encourged non-mathemticians to evaluate data.
So it is not surprising that numerical reasoning is becoming part of the job application process – not just in the technical sector but also in a variety of other areas such as private companies like Amazon and many banks, consultancies and energy companies. Also the public sector such as Civil Service, Police and to focus upon one, the Military. Officer applications must undertake Aptitude tests including spatial awareness, verbal, non-verbal and numerical reasoning, for which some typical questions are shown below:
Q15. A worker who has to work for 8 hours a day is entitled to three 20-minute breaks, and an hour for lunch during the working day. If they work for 5 days per week for 4 weeks, how many hours will they have actually worked? Ans 120 hours. Working day = 8 – 1 – 1 = 6 hours x 5 x 4 = 120
Q16a. Below is a table listing the percentage changes in profit from 2014 to 2016 for five different companies.
Using the above table, if company Q earned £412,500 in 2014, how much profit did they make in 2016?
Ans: £485,100 412,500 x 1.12 = 462,000 x 1.05 = 485,100
Q16b
The table shows journeys from factory to depot and cost per hour to travel. If a driver from company R drives at 50 km/hr what is the cost?
Ans: £40 100 km at 50 km/hr = 2 hr x 20 = 40
Q16c. If a driver from company T leaves at 09.00 and arrives at 11.00 am what is their average speed in km/hr?
Ans: 60 km/hr 2 hours to drive 120 km = 60 km/hr
Q17a
A service’s costs are shown in total for the hours a customer uses. How much would the customer pay for 8 hours?
Ans: £24 . Double £12 : or £12 = 4 hours so £3 = 1 hour so 8 hours = 8 x 3 = £24
Q17b
In fact the customer uses 2 hour of the service. The bus stop to the service is exactly at their home but on reaching the terminus a half hour walk is needed to the service and then half hour back to the terminus. Using the timetables, what is the latest bus the customer can catch from home to be sure of getting home after the service for 3.45 pm?
Ans: 10 am bus . This would reach terminus at 11 am, arrive at service at 11.30, take 2 hour service to 1.30 pm, walk back to Terminus by 2pm, catch 2.30 pm bus back and arrive at home at 3.30 pm. This is 15 minutes in hand but later bus would be 45 minutes late. The 9am bus would be unnecessarily early.
Edexcel’s Pearson is in the Job applicant arena too.
Pupils will be familiar with the Pearson Edexcel GCSE papers. Well, Pearson have a job applicant’s test too called NDIT (numerical data intepretation test). They say that “NDIT measures candidate ability to manipulate and interpret numerical information from dashboards and reports. These skills are rated as “important” for nearly 300 jobs ranging from sales managers to executives”.
The questions could range from the simple ones like this: Q18. What number must replace N to make this correct?
7N + N =88
Choice A5 B6 C8 D9
Ans D9. There is an element of reasoning in this because if the question is algebraic then the answer might be N = 11 since 8 times N would be 88. However, that’s not an available answer so it must be a simple sum of 79 + 9 = 88 so N = 9.
And then typically business oriented questions like this:
There are many different Job Application reasoning tests. Another is “EPSO” for e.g. EU applicants and a typical question is this:
Q20 .In 2012, Belgium represented 2,5% of the total EU output value of the agricultural industry. In 2013, the total EU output value is expected to grow by 15%. Given France is expected to increase its total share by 5 percentage points, what is France’s expected output value in 2013?
Ans 117,300
Belgium is 2.5% so 2012 total EU is 40 x 8500 = 340.000 France share = 85,000/340,000 = 25% in 2012 so 30% in 2013
2013 total = 340,000 x 1.15 = 391,000 So France = 0.3 x 391,000 = 117,300
And finally, GMAT the Graduate Management Admission Test
Although the test contains many conventional numerical reasoning tests it does assume quite an advanced maths knowledge such as Surds. And some follow a very specific style as follows:
Question 21: Does 2x + 8 = 12?
Then comes the standard format:
You are given two statements:
In this case the statements are::
2x + 10 = 14
3x + 8 = 14
Then choose one answer from:
Statement (1) ALONE is sufficient, but statement (2) alone is not sufficient.
Statement (2) ALONE is sufficient, but statement (1) alone is not sufficient.
BOTH statements TOGETHER are sufficient, but NEITHER statement ALONE is sufficient.
EACH statement ALONE is sufficient.
Statements (1) and (2) TOGETHER are NOT sufficient.
The answer is option 4 since in both cases x = 2, which fits the original.
Tips
Here is some advice – my top ten tips – for approaching Numerical Reasoning tests in general: first before the Test:
Know which test you are taking. This sounds obvious but this can be vital in identifying the style and typical format of the questions. Then you can hopefully find some free practice pehaps on the internet, or at worst invest a small amount of money in a license, or a book, or a little tutoring.
Practice the key topic areas outlined at the beginning such as BIDMAS and ratios – not just within your specific test but in general e.g. from past GCSE papers. Of all the techniques, probably percentage is the most important to be tight on, including for instance “10% of…” , or a “5% increase…”
Practice both mental arithmetic and calculator skills – assume you can use a calculator but if, as is likely the case you are told not to, then there are certain key operations to perfect which might be quicker in your head anyway, such as “1/2 of…” or “180 degrees of a pie chart circle….” or “50 % of…”.
Practice working at speed as this can be a key differentiator
Whether out and about or listening the news or reading newspapers, whenver a graph or data table appears then you or your children should take the opportunity to understand it
Then during the test:
Understand the question but do not over complicate or be intimidated: for instance if a column heading in a data table contains a term you are unfamilar with – let us say job title “actuary” – then don’t worry simply use the number beneath it. Look out for key words or phrases like “more than” or “cumulative” or “value”
When looking at graphs ensure you look at the units of measure carefully on the axes such as “thousands of units”
In tables of data identify the correct row and column or intersection depending on the question. Note also that in some cases some data may be irrelevant. Hence a quick look at the question before you look at the table or graph may be useful.
In multiple choice questions it is sometimes possible to eliminate obviously wrong answers. Sometimes a quick estimate will point to perhaps only two possible answers.
Work at a good pace and remember that a blank answer scores zero. Don’t get stuck on one question to the detriment of others.
And in conclusion
Numerical reasoning tests are a great leveller. In principle anyone from 9 (admitedly pretty good at maths) to 90 could take a test and get a similar score. Indeed, the same numerical reasoning question could appear in an 11 plus exam as a job application aptitude test.
The large majority of maths techniques needed to suceed are not of the “quadratic equation” type, rather the “basics” type. But you do need to be very comfortable with the basics, that is a prerequisite; however, that in itself is not enough because higher order skills are needed such as understanding the question, processing and analysing the data, determing your approach – and all very quickly.
The rise of such tests is welcome in terms of the numerical skills needeed for the future of work, – see the Barclays Life Skills video – not just in technical roles but in for example sports, managerial and military, and (it would be nice!) among local and national politicians too.
In terms of inclusion of numerical reasoning questions beginning to appear in for example GCSE exams, this is good, but it would be naïve to believe pupils are desperate for real world, wordy, problems – most simply want the most straight forward in line with their standard revision. So examiners, be kind!
Links to free tests: most of these links take you directly to free sample numerical tests, or just need you to register. They may suggest furhter acess for more questions needs a payment – if so don’t pay if you don’t want to.
The study of Business and Economics qualifications at school is growing – for instance both Economics and Business uptake at A-Level grew about 10% in a year from 2021-2022 and Business has grown 25% in four years. Many parents and pupils ponder whether to enroll in these relatively unfamiliar topics and if they do confirm, then the decision is which to take – generally its difficult to take both, because of availability or time constraints.
I tutor both of these topics academically and have a strong background in industry so perhaps I can help.
How popular?
First, what’s available and what’s the uptake.
For GCSE Economics, of the two major Boards, AQA offer Economics but Pearson Edexcel don’t, unless you can do International GCSE. Other Boards like OCR and CIE also offer GCSE Economics.
For GCSE Business (used to be called Business Studies) both AQA and Pearson Edexcel offer Business as well as other Boards.
For A Level, both Edexcel and AQA offer both Economics and Business, as do other Boards.
So essentially both topics are available at both GCSE and A-Level – if, and it’s a big if – the school has teaching capability. With fairly small cohorts of pupils, some schools may opt not to teach it.
For GCSE, around 12% of all pupils took Business, and around 2% took Economics.
This large difference is not shown at A-Level, where about 12% of all pupils took Business, and about 11% took Economics.
How does that compare to other subjects? You may be surprised to learn that this puts Business or Economics at about the same level as Physics and above Geography for A Level.
So in summary, both Business and Economics are growing in popularity; Business is taken by a reasonable proportion of the cohort at GCSE level, while at A-Level both are.
What do they cover?
First Business
Obviously A-Level is more developed than GCSE but both Business qualifications cover broadly the same themes and topics such as:
Understanding what a business is and how it operates, is organised and meets customer needs, and what characteristics its start-up entrepreneurs and leaders display, such as attitude to risk.
Both generic business aspects and also many individual businesses; for instance portfolio analysis of multinationals like Apple or Nissan, or strengths and weaknesses of smaller business.
Marketing definition, research, segmentation, planning, positioning, and strategies in a U.K, in a U.K. and global context for both niche and mainstream businesses.
Marketing mix across Product Price Place and Promotion
Sales concepts such as price elasticity of demand and sales forecasting and methods
Financial sources and planning ,managing finance, the financial ratios associated with the three key reports namely profit and loss, balance sheet and cashflow; project appraisal methods such as payback time; and external influences such as interest rate, Inflation and exchange rate.
Operational aspects such as factors and type of production, economies of scale, quality, and measures such as productivity and capacity utilisation
Business objectives and strategy – such as focus on cost or differentiation; business growth, and decision-making techniques; competitive advantage and overcoming barriers to entry
Human resources aspects such as organisation design, legal aspects and employee motivation
Then Economics, again for GCSE and A-Level
Nature of economics – the fundamental economic problem of allocating scarce resources to meet unlimited demand
Economics as a social science including both behavioural economics and balancing economic policy with moral and political concerns such as poverty and inequality
Markets – how markets are structured and governments work, why they can fail economically and what interventions can be made
The UK economy – its performance and macroeconomic aspects
Measures of economic performance like G.D.P. and economic objectives like 2% inflation
Definitions and calculations of aggregate supply and demand, and key diagrams like supply-demand graphs of price against output, and shifts, and production frontiers.
Supply-demand case studies such as for Oil, Housing and Transport
Economic philosophies such as Keynesian, Classical and Laissez-Faire free market
Mixed economy concept such as private and public sector, public and private goods, merit and de-merit goods
Macroeconomic policies such as fiscal (taxation and Government spending); and monetary policies such as interest rate
Role of bank of England, Banks and financial markets
Supply-side and demand-side initiatives such as productivity and tax-cuts.
Microeconomic aspects such as business behaviour and the labour market; business growth, objectives and revenues, costs and profits
Price, Income and cross elasticity of demand and supply
Competitive aspects such as, perfect competition, oligopolies and monopolies
Time based considerations such as short and long-run; and scale-based such as marginal versus average cost
Trade on a UK and International basis; trade bodies like E.U. and W.T.O; globalisation
What are the crossovers/similariries and what are the differences?
There are many cross-overs in topics, ranging from factors of production, employment legislation, through effect of interest rates, to membership of international trade bodies. Three of the main differences are:
– the level of detail in which a topic is approached: for instance the supply-demand equilibrium diagram is only a small part of the Business syllabus but forms a major element of Economics.
– the micro or macro perspective: the Business syllabus is much more focused upon individual company case-studies, ranging from household names down to the smallest start-up; whereas Economics is much more tuned to the aggregate of the whole economy (in our case U.K.) Another example would be the approach to a current hot-topic, electric vehicles: Economics might look at the benefits of Government subsidies to the whole industry, and whether consumers or companies as a whole would take the major share of the subsidy benefit; whereas Business would look at individual car companies like Ford or Nissan. and how EV’s fit in with their specific objectives and strategies, for instance of growth and diversification, and the implications for a new type of manufacturing.
– The type of calculation : Business requires students to perform a host of calculations for individual businesses such as profitability and liquidity ratios, project appraisals, break-even, gearing, capacity utilisation, critical path analyses, moving average sales forecast, and decision trees. Whereas with Economics, there are some calculations to do, but much more at the whole-country economy level such as the formulae for components of Aggregate Demand (the total U.K spending on goods and services); marginal propensities to consume or save; the multiplier effect; the GINI coefficient for inequality.
The Maths skills are easier than you think.
You can see above that many calculations are required. Of course you need to know and understand the formulae – they will be taught. But the actual Maths techniques are often not much more than BIDMAS and % calculations of % change and % of one quantity to another. Calculators are always allowed. There would never be a quadratic equation, or geometric proof, for instance. At A-Level you would cover standard deviation in Maths, but not in Economics, where you would think it might fit, or Business.
You do need to understand graphs, typically bar charts or line charts. The two approaches for Business and Economics are fundamentally different through. In Business, a graph will usually have a numerical scale from which a specific number can be gleaned. Whereas in Economics the graphs and diagrams are generally without a scale, since you just need to explain the overall shape or trend or shift.
How do the examiners mark exams?
There is a lot of similarity in the approaches for instance both have four “Assessment Objectives” : AO1, for Knowledge, AO2 for Application, AO3 for Analysis and AO4 for Evaluation. Both have short-sharp questions, and also longer essay questions where reasoned logic and justified conclusions are important. A slight difference is that Economics is more likely to have some multiple choice questions.
What are the alternatives and natural A-Level partners?
The beauty of both these topics is that being essentially social sciences, they could fit with Arts topics like languages; mid spectrum topics like Geography or Politics, Religious Studies or Sociology; or STEM topics like Maths or Physics. An alternative incidentally is the very new T-Level range of technical qualifications which includes Management and Administration, which is a single topic equivalent to three A-Levels as it involves a practical placement and workplace project as well as theory.
Further Education and Career prospects
Both topics have very firm University and career paths, albeit slightly different. A Business degree could lead to a Masters qualification in the famous MBA (Master of Business Administration) and a career to a senior position within a Business or starting up your own. A typical Economics Degree is with Politics and Philosophy; a career might ensue in Government, in Accountancy (with an extra qualification) or in banking or the finance or planning department of a company..
Conclusion
Both Business and Economics are growing in popularity. While not quite mainstream they are moving above niche, especially at A-Level. There are many cross-over similarities; the main differences are the types of calculations and approach to graphs, and that Economics tends towards the Macro aggregate of a country whereas Business is more Micro at the individual company level.
The topics may be the first time a student has come across them. It will help if they have a particular prior interest or future related goal but not essential. A student needs to be reasonable at both Maths and Essay writing, but not exceptional at either.
There is a very clear path to University degree choice and often rewarding career path beyond.
The International Baccalaureate (IB as it is known) is emerging from the niche into the mainstream in the U.K. It is no longer education’s “best kept secret”.
I tutor IB Maths and so I have accumulated some research into this growing option.
The IBDP (Diploma Programme) is studied by the same age group as the A-Level cohort and is taken instead of (not as well as) UK A-Levels. Although still a minority option it is a growing choice. IBDP is over 50 years-old and by 2022 UK take-up had increased to over 5,000 students (from the 170,000 worldwide). This compared to 800,000 A-Level students – so clearly A-Level is and will remain the most popular and safest choice for post GCSE study – so what attracts parents and pupils to IB? Let’s try and find out why, by describing it.
The IBDP students takeamodule from within each ofsix compulsory subject groups, namely: studies in language and literature; language acquisition; individuals and societies; sciences; mathematics; and the arts. They choose three Higher Level (HL) and three Standard Level subjects. For Maths, for example, a student chooses Analysis and Approaches (AA), or Applications and Interpretations (AI) at the HL or SL levels. At Science IB subject group. the individual subjects are biology, computer science, chemistry, design technology, physics, and sports and health (the student can choose two).
Students also study three additional topics, to encourage a more “rounded”, socially responsible approach; namely theory of knowledge; creativity, action, service; and an extended essay.
For Maths, the IB topic list and techniques for answering questions are around 95% similar to A-Level, and there are equally rigorous end-of-course exams. What’s a little different is their frequent “Investigations”, “International mindedness”, “Developing inquiry skills”, and “TOK” (Theory of Knowledge) sections, all encouraging students to creatively “look beyond” the curriculum. For instance:
Investigations; for a Pool Party Invitation, as part of Permutations and Combinations: how many different ways could three images be arranged for the invitation card? (Answer: 3! = 6)
International Mindedness: Where did Numbers come from? (Answer: many answers such as India and Sumeria and Egypt). And where does the Word Asymptote come from? Answer: the Greek word “Asymptotos” meaning “not falling together”. (Note: your author, long before being aware of IB, was including similar etymological references in my Maths tuition materials such as “al-jabr,” meaning “restoration of broken parts” the Arabic origin of algebra).
Developing Inquiry Skills. With pieces of spaghetti, construct a circle with radius one spaghetti length. What is the circumference of your circle in spaghetti units?
Theory of Knowledge TOK): Is Mathematics a Language? Why do we call Pascal’s triangle Pascal’s triangle if it was in use before he was born? Is it possible to know things about infinity, of which we have no experience? (Author’s note: this TOK is not one half of TikTok)
A good example of how IB maths is, let’s say, more intellectual, even ethereal, than A-Level Maths is that in the middle of some fairly standard A-Level fare on quadratic equations’ discriminants, there is suddenly a section on “the fundamental theory of algebra” referring to “the existence of complex zeros of a polynomial” (no me neither, at first!)
How is IB viewed at university?
Because UK Universities increasingly attract international students, they usually include IB required grades in their offers. For instance, an IB HL grade 7 is equivalent to A* in A-Level. A typical Oxbridge offer would be A*A*A or IB 42 points with grades 7,7,6 in the Higher Level choices.
Where can I study IB in the U.K.?
There are over 5000 “IB world” schools internationally, and around 100 schools in the UK offer the IB. Most but by no means all are in the UK Independent sector. They range from those offering the complete IB programme, including Year12-13 IBDP, as above, and also Primary and Middle Year IB; through to schools offering mainly A-Level but IBDP as an alternative.
There is more information in this article, in which the featured IB school is the new Fulham School, which your author was intrigued to find has opened up in the same road which our family used to live in, before moving to Twickenham. Who’d have thought!
How does Tutoring fit in?
Zoom or MIcrosoft Teams mean that tutoring doesn’t have to be local, or even national, especially since the “on-line” course text-book material is so technically advanced. Using this, I do international IB tutoring, and my approach is to pick out a few of their sample exam questions for each sub-topic which the student is currently doing – such as Binomial Expansion – and ask the student to try on their own. I then let them access official model answers, which I also supplement and add value to with my own additional workings, comments, and if necessary alternative methods and good ways of explaining.
Although my approach is fundamentally to “teach to the test”, to help the student get through their end-of-topic tests, mocks and major IB exams, I might also throw in a few challenging questions on the same topic from other advanced Entrance Boards like Cambridge TMUA or Oxford MAT; or Maths Challenges with a similar focus on “out-of-the-box” problem solving like the UKMT Senior Maths Challenge.
In summary
Although IBDP in general offers more breadth than A-Level (six subjects instead of three), it actually offers less breadth when you look at individual subjects. For instance, the IBDP in Maths has no mechanics, and less statistics; but arguably it has more depth in the subjects it does cover, and the exam questions may be fractionally harder.
Like the new technical T-levels (more on that in a future blog), the IBDP in general offers a minority but viable alternative for those who want something different out of their Sixth Form Years; namely more focus on soft skills, less specialism since both Arts and STEM subjects are compulsory, and most important I believe, it is a universally recognised qualification and comparable across multinational countries. It is suitable for those candidates who are comfortable with continuous assessment tasks, are aiming high academically across a variety of subjects, are intrigued by the philosophy as well as content of their subject and anticipate an international University placement or future career abroad.
Update after initial posting: the Economist magazine, no less, has run an article on the IB, emphasising its’ role in encouraging community service projects and keeping a spectrum of arts and STEM/sciences going through a Sixth Former’s years. It also speculates on an English Baccalaureate (but would we spoil it?!)
The 2022 GCSE are now out so what’s my take from a personal tutorial point of view, and a national perspective.
My pupils
Well first of all, let’s be relived the exams happened at all. Think back a year and some were questioning the very continuation of these qualifications.
From a personal perspective I’m very happy with the GCSE results my pupils managed. All had school interruptions during the two year programme but pulled it together for the exams. For the one who needed a top grade 9 for his new school sixth form entry – yes, he got it. For those who simply wanted high grades , several got 7’s and 8’s, one got 6’s. And for those who simply wanted a pass, and took Foundation, they got the maximum possible 5.
The exams were unusual this year – not just because they were the first to be actually sat since 2019. The syllabus was narrowed down so that pupils were given advance warning of what would and would not be in the exams. Typically about 10-15% of topics were removed. My strategy was to examine these lists in great detail and make sure that pupils revised what they needed to, and eliminated what they didn’t. And it was possible to even narrow down accurate predictions from Papers 1 to 2 for Science, and 1,2 and 3 for Maths. I issued Mocks with several typical questions per included topic and several pupils said they did indeed crop up.
I think this approach especially helped some pupils with whom I only had a few lessons from Easter onwards. If my time with a Pupil is limited, and indeed all pupils’ own time is spread amongst other topics, then focus on what’s important is crucial.
However, if we assume this advance warning is not carried through to next year, will this “focused topic” approach still be appropriate? Well, aspects of it, yes. For instance I examined past papers in detail and it was obvious that the Core Practicals formed the basis, every year, of detailed exam questions. So I found a series of excellent short videos on each, issued links, advised pupils to re-read their lab experiment books, and told them precisely what examiners wanted with the 6-mark “how would you design an experiment to…” questions. This advice will always be relevant in science. And across all my subjects – Science, Maths, Business – the fine details and nuances of what’s in Foundation, Higher, Combined, Triple, Paper 1 paper 2 , Long question etc can be so important to emphasise with pupils.
The national picture
A lot of focus is on lockdown induced grade inflation, from pre-Pandemic levels. So let us start there. For A level, the grade inflation between 2019 and 2021, coinciding mainly with teacher assessment, was around 20%. The grade A or higher numbers of entrants jumped from 26% to 45%. By 2022 this % had dropped, as expected, and by an amount that was anticipated by examiners. The A-Level inflation reduced by around half, so that the 36% for 2022 brought us almost exactly half way back to the pre-Covid levels.
For GCSE the grade inflation also fell, but in a different way. First, the inflation from 2019 to 2021 was not as high as A Level ; for instance the % of pupils getting grade 4 or above in GCSE inflated by around 10% from 67% to 77% ; in 2022 this figure was 73% , a drop of 4%, so just less than half the 10% grade inflation has been eliminated. Similarly, for the percent getting grade 7 or above, the figure jumped from 20% to 28% and back this year to 25%.
In theory, by 2023, grade boundaries and these percentages should return to pre-Pandemic i.e. 2019 levels – but who knows! First, will more unusual events happen, and second will the examiners give more time for settling down?
Other ways of looking at the results include:
the attainment gap between boys and girls continued, with girls being about 7% higher, though the gap has narrowed fractionally.
Independent and especially state selective schools as expected got the highest percentage results, though it should be noted that independents showed the highest drop of all ownership categories 2021-2022 i.e. are eliminating grade inflation fastest.
London schools continue to outperform the rest of the U.K. For instance around 32% of London pupils scored 7 or higher grade, compared to 22% in the North East.
For Maths, and Combined Science and Business, the distributions of grades was a typical normal distribution with the most common being 4 and 5, with tail-offs above and below those. But for the individual Triple sciences, all three had heavily skewed distributions towards the higher grades – almost all grades in Triple Biology, Chemistry or Physics were grade 5 and above, with very few below grade 5. So if a teacher thinks you are good enough to do Triple versus Combined, its probably the right decision
What I cant find out, and would be fascinating, is this : for those who took Foundation exam in Maths , the maximum grade is 5, a reasonable pass is 4, and below that means a re-sit; so what proportions of pupils in the end passed, or had to re-sit, and how does the re-sit figure compare to those who took Higher? This might shed light on the conundrum of which exam a pupil who is on the cusp of Higher or Foundation should take. From my own limited sample, those who opted for Foundation did indeed get grade 5.
Below are a series of graphics and infographics illustrating for GCSE the above points. Note that one good thing to emerge from the Pandemic was the use of highly visual means of displaying dull or complex statistics, particularly trend graphs. Though I say it myself, I helped start off this approach with award winning publications and software applications almost 20 years ago!
As anticipated the exam Boards such as Edexcel and AQA have published their “advance information” changes to assessment content for the 2022 exams including GCSE. If you recall, the purpose is to offset the difficulties pupils have endured due to the Covid disruptions. The indication is this is just for 2022.
I myself would have kept the content pretty much the same but made the questions easier by making them more on-syllabus, and less obtuse and wordy; but anyway we now have the Boards’ pretty specific topic list of what will or won’t be assessed, and I have taken a quick look at my specialities for Edexcel Maths and AQA Triple and Combined Science (see also web links at the end of the article which cover all subjects). I am sure teachers will be explaining these to pupils and parents alike, but here is my immediate take, initially on Higher.
Towards the end of this document, I also include a little on grade boundaries, formulae sheets and Mock exams and finish with some overall conclusions and take-aways. Also I have included an update on topic-targeted mocks I’ve created.
But let’s start with what is in (the “main focus areas”) and what is out.
Maths Edexcel
For Higher Pearson Edexcel Maths, the amount of content reduction is very low, so most topics are still in there – about 90 topics are listed as “main focus areas” i.e. are “in”. It looks like a few difficult ones like Quadratic Sequence, Completing the Square, Congruence, Volume of cone and sphere, Proofs, and Iteration are excluded from assessment now.
Sometimes there is some ambiguity: compound interest is mentioned in the formula sheet but not in the list of included assessed topics so perhaps will be needed for growth, decay, depreciation; while for Angles the easier parallel line topic seems excluded while the more difficult polygon and circle theorem topics are included.
Mostly the topic list is precise enough to revise from but not so specific so as to tell you the question – this is as it should be. But sometimes the description is so specific that you can almost anticipate the question – such as capture recapture, and equation of a tangent to a circle.
Overall the Maths changes are fair. About 90% of topics remain included. Any exclusions are spread fairly evenly across the main headings of Algebra, Geometry etc.
Ideally (like science below) a list of exclusions (as well as inclusions) would have been stated by Pearson, but hopefully my pointers above will help and no doubt teachers will firm up on these in due course. The implied exclusions will reduce revision time slightly, but note the preamble does ask teachers to teach the full content anyway.
Science AQA
For AQA science the picture is different from Edexcel Maths; from modest exclusions for Chemistry to almost the opposite for Biology i.e. very few Biology inclusions (Bizarre, I know!). Let me explain.
First Triple. For Chemistry the content at first sight seems to remain largely untouched. There are only two minor “not to be assessed” exclusions listed – nanoparticles and (strangely considering their importance) greenhouse gases.
There are a large number of topic headings listed as “main focus areas of assessment” such as Periodic Table (section 4.1.2). So far so good.
But then you think, what about 4.1.1? This is the all-important atomic and electronic structure section – which helps you understand 4.1.2 Periodic table – yet is not listed in the inclusions. Similarly, section 4.8 is not mentioned at all – Chemical analyses such as Chromatography and Flame tests – and yet the core Practical involving Flame tests IS included.
(And although I have not looked at Foundation in detail, strangely there are MORE listed topics in Foundation than Higher; so while atomic structure is not listed in Higher, it is included in Foundation. My take on that is this: in Higher there won’t be a specific question on, for example, atomic structure; but pupils would be advised to learn it anyway because it informs so many other parts of the syllabus from Periodic table onwards. I wonder if the Examiners have thought the communication of this through! I think maybe teachers will agree with me and err on the side of caution and continue to teach fundamental topics like this anyway)
I think there is some clarification needed on what needs to be revised. In the preamble to the lists (for all Sciences) the Board indicates that topics not specifically listed as “in assessment” may still be included in “low tariff or linked questions” which confirms my view that pupils should still revise most of the syllabus to be on the safe side.
On balance I think the list of Chemistry “in topics” does indeed help and is sometimes very specific , like section 4.10.4 (Haber process/NPK fertilisers – so there’s almost certainly a question on this- and it links to another inclusion on Reversible reactions) ; although sometimes less specific (like 4.4.3 Electrolysis). I think they are trying to pinpoint the particular questions likely to be asked. For all the sciences the devil may be in the detail: the specific numbered subsections may sometimes give the game away. Myself and teachers will no doubt be trying to second guess these questions!
Note that for Chemistry and all Sciences the Board emphasise that the type of question will not change and the general scientific methods including maths skills and practical experiment interpretation are still needed. The specific core practical list (a bit reduced ) is well pinpointed and I strongly recommend pupils revise the short videos available on these; high chance of specific questions on these practicals.
For Physics the list of inclusions is narrowed down considerably to essentially Particle Model, Energy, Forces, Momentum, Pressure, Waves and Space.
And unlike Chemistry above, the list of “exclusions from assessment” is very long and specific. So out go most of Electricity, most or all of Radioactivity and Atomic Structure, and Magnetism altogether. And yet there is some ambiguity to resolve. Section 4.2.4 energy transfer is included and this includes Power, Current and Voltage i.e. electrics; and yet the basics of that, namely amps, potential and circuits from 4.2.1 to 4.2.3 are specifically excluded.
Some of these exclusions are topics which have been a staple for pupils at school since Year 7 and before and it seems actually unfair on pupils to exclude the basics of electricity and magnetism which for some would have been easier than let’s say Space. I suppose you can’t have it both ways: since broad education is meant to be more important per se than the exams themselves, in a sense it does not matter if they are examined on a topic. On the other hand, to “waste” five years work with just a few month’s notice may annoy many pupils, who having already finished the topic by now and would be quite happy to be examined upon them.
For Biology triple, like Physics there are considerable reductions; the inclusions are narrowed down to Cell Structure, tissues, organ systems, diseases, antibodies, nervous systems, hormones, reproduction, parts of ecosystem.
There are a long list of exclusions, for instance the whole of staples like Evolution won’t be assessed. And again there are ambiguities: nothing from the large section on Section 4 Bioenergetics is included; and yet only a small part (4.4.2.2 Taking Exercise) is specifically excluded. Bioenergetics describes the core biology fundamentals of Photosynthesis and Respiration and pupils have learned these no doubt from year 7 and they have featured in almost every past paper. To not test pupils on this seems perverse. But since very little has been specifically excluded from section 4, should pupils after all revise it anyway? My take is that there won’t be a specific question on section 4 Bioenergetics, but it would be prudent to still revise as it infuses the remainder of the syllabus and there may be a “linked” or low tariff” question on this core topic.
Similarly, 4.5.2 Nervous System is a main focus area, but from it 4.5.1 (structure function), 4.5.2 (brain) and 4.5.3 (eye) are excluded. This is useful as it leaves only 4.5.4 (temperature), implying a specific question. But it would be unwise to ignore the introductory 4.5.1 as it informs 4.5.4.
The list of required Biology practicals, as for other sciences, is reduced but still very specific. So the staple Quadrat and Mass of Potato chips practicals are included as ever and the fact they have survived points very clearly to a question this year (as almost every year) and their video should be watched, understood and learned.
In Combined Science (Higher) the picture is similar as for Triple;
Combined Chemistry lists several very specific inclusions, similar Included content to Triple Chemistry, and almost zero exclusions mentioned.
For Combined Physics a focus on Energy and particles as with Triple, but this time including Radiation and Motor Effect and EM Waves (so Combined has more extensive content than Triple!) And again ambiguity: series and parallel circuits are excluded as an assessment topic, yet the required practical on these is Included. Similarly 6.7.2 the Motor Effect – which has its roots in magnetic fields – is included, yet 6.7.1 the basics of magnetism is excluded.
For Combined Biology, a very short specific list of inclusions and very long list of exclusions. The list of inclusions is slightly different to Triple, for instance Photosynthesis is included.
Discussion on science lists.
There is some ambiguity to be resolved, by the AQA Board or perhaps by teachers. If something is neither included in assessment, nor specifically excluded from assessment, should it still be revised, to be safe, in case “linked or low tariff” questions arise? I think in some cases a topic can be eliminated altogether, but in others it would pay to revise just in case; so some detailed analysis will be required to make that call. If the Exam Boards’ “exclusion lists” are taken too literally, some precious revision may be missed which in fact may contribute to “linked” questions.
For English, if a set book is excluded that presumably can safely be put aside. But for chemistry, if “atomic structure” is not to be assessed, then it would be a mistake to simply not revise it, because it informs so much of the surviving other topics.
Grade Boundaries The Boards have indicated that boundaries will be set somewhere between normal, and the last two years.
Mock exams Many schools have already penciled in exams for after half term in late February 2022. The dilemma for teachers is, shall we complete the syllabus testing as normal to encourage a full learning experience; or shall we adjust them to exclude the “not being assessed” topics, in order to avoid wasted revision time? No doubt teachers will be crawling through the fine detail of today’s lists, just like I have done above!
Formula sheets For Physics, as before the formulae are extensive. For Maths, intriguingly, some of the few formulae which were given last time are not this time (for spheres and cones) confirming their probable absence from assessment. While formulae like quadratic formulae and sin and cosine rule are included now, indicating their probable inclusion in assessment.
In conclusion
The Boards have rightly kept their promise to publish by February 7th
The timing of the announcement seems about right; earlier, and some topics would not have been taught at all; later and some revision time would have been wasted.
The Exam Boards in their announcements and preambles have stressed they still want as much of the content to be taught and revised as possible. But with their list of exclusions, inevitably the precious, finite teaching and revision time will not be devoted to topics on the “not to be assessed” lists. This is useful , as long as care is taken when dropping topics.
Maths is relatively untouched compared to the sciences and revision should still cover around 90% of topics. The basics are all still there and the exclusions are often niche standalones.
Chemistry has very few specific exclusions, and a broad list of main inclusions, but gaps in this list indicate some additional topics will not be assessed.
Physics and Biology have long lists of exclusions and short lists of inclusions. The topics have been considerably reduced. In my opinion reduced too much – some fundamentals have been eliminated.
But for the Sciences the sub-section numbers listed from the specification which do survive as “included” can often give very specific pointers to the content of the question
A key phrase in the Sciences preamble is “Topics not explicitly given in any (main focus) list may (still nevertheless) appear in low tariff questions or via ‘linked’ questions, (but) topics not assessed (at all) either directly or through ‘linked’ content have been listed as “not to be assessed”.
Hence there is some ambiguity to be resolved in Science in terms of what topics to revise – there are three categories: first, about 70% are essential to revise; and then (15%) topics not listed as key focus areas, yet are fundamentals so may crop up in linked or low tariff questions, and so should probably be revised anyway; and finally (15%) those definitely excluded from assessment – only these can be truly de-prioritised.
The type of science question is not altered i.e. could still include unusual applications, maths calculations, and practicals: the core practicals listed are very specific and may indicate precise questions – so have high revision priority.
I think the above lists will be communicated and ambiguities resolved for pupils in the coming weeks. If any parent or pupils have questions please don’t hesitate to ask your teachers, or myself as I believe I can help.
I have created Mock exams featuring two or more questions on every one of the Paper 1 , 2 and 3 Higher and Foundation maths Pearson Edexcel inclusion lists. Their specific topic list for each paper is very useful, for instance: in Higher Maths the highly niche topic of Capture Recapture appears only in paper 2 and likewise Frequency Polygon only Paper 3, and a quick refresh just before those exam dates would pay dividends.
I also created topic targeted Mocks for AQA Triple and, separately Combined science, and together with Maths these proved very useful to pupils in their actual Mocks especially as I added my own explanatory notes over and above the sometimes rather bare official mark schemes. I also managed to get some of the very latest exam Board questions in too.
I have also begun to research the 2022 topic lists for the specialist qualifications like Further Maths, iGCSE, and OCR FSMQ and also the Edexcel Sciences.
An unusual request came my way, to construct a slide pack drawn from the GCSE Business syllabus but focused on helping prisoners in English jail get started as business entrepreneurs on release. A fellow consultant gave me seven business themes, such as Marketing and Finance, provided by the IOEE Institute of Enterprise and Entrepreneurs, to work up into coherent multi-media lessons (and he would do the in-house training).
It was a fascinating exercise and to tackle it I had to imagine how someone with a difficult background could turn a start-up into a successful business – what sort of skills and abilities they would need, how they would obtain finance, form stakeholder relations, how they would negotiate deals – and of course which business laws are important. As well as teaching the basics, for instance financial reporting and calculations, the marketing mix, ownership options, advertising and market research techniques, organisation structure and quality and customer satisfaction.
I created a slidepack for each theme and starter, plenary and interactive quiz. In the slides I included many short case studies and enhanced these with on-line links to videos and articles. This aspect was fascinating, because with the package to be used in prison I was given a web address restriction of one source only – the BBC. But I discovered a host of great short stories on line within the BBC’s CEO secrets, their Business pages, the Dragons’s Den, and of course Bitesize.
These videos varied from business lessons from well know celebrities like Baroness Karen Brady, Levi Roots, Lord Alan Sugar to the rags to riches, start up to multinationals like Deliveroo and Brewdog; the charming story of rapper Labrinth taking two teenagers to an East End market stall to learn the art of selling; the man who converted his grandma’s jam recipe to an international business; the inspiring stories of start-ups surviving and thriving in the Pandemic and opening zero-waste Green businesses.
A selection of stills from the video links
I put a lot more time into these than the financial reward justified but as a philanthropic work it was justified and with a little alteration I’ve made the package suitable for any Business Studies student – for instance I’ve already used them to teach a Chinese business student – and made them available in my TES shop.
When I first started tutoring with simple Maths I didn’t realise the interesting avenues down which it would take me!
UKMT is the United Kingdom Maths Trust which on foundation in 1996 brought together a trio of similar pre-existing Maths challenges at three different age groups, the Junior, Intermediate and Senior tests. Dr. Tony Gardiner is the name most associated with driving these competitions forward and now tens of thousands of pupils a year take part in the three competitions, which cover Years 8 and below, Year 11 and below, and Year 13 and below.
The format is very similar in each – 25 questions of increasing difficulty each with 5 multiple choice answer options. Clearly the standard of questions increases through the age groups but not in the way you might think. I have studied the Intermediate and Senior papers in particular and the syllabuses do not vary greatly, rather it is largely the same topics, but with more challenging questions. You will see in the appendix my research, that I have collated from past UKMT papers, the GCSE and A-Level individual topics that students need as a minimum to know to have a good chance of success in the UKMT competitions..
In order of most frequent first, Geometry, Number, Algebra, Trigonometry, Statistics, Probability (counting outcomes) and finally Ratio are the topics featured. You might think that calculus is included in the Senior challenge, but no, as I say, it sticks largely to GCSE topics but with more challenging questions, and set in a particular style which after a while becomes familiar. Both competitions challenge pupils in two ways especially; working at speed and doing problem solving, which is something the UKMT wishes to encourage.
The benefits to pupils are of the following kind. Most obviously, more exposure to subjects which will feature in their GCSE and A Level exams – for instance Pythagoras and Similarity feature extensively. Second, learning to work fast in terms of reading a problem, understanding what to do and executing the solution all within a few minutes (and without a calculator, thus developing mental arithmetic skills). Third, managing an exam – how should I proceed if my answer is not listed, when guessing a wrong answer may carry penalties, and which if any questions should be missed out? Fourth, the problems help you to think in a different way about Maths, imaginatively. out of the box if you like. And lastly, especially for those who are successful, it can add to your UCAS personal statement.
Just entering shows ambition, and there are further possible rewards for high scores, such as Gold,Silver,Bronze, Kangaroo (I’ll let you research that one!), and a national olympiad. There is also a team competition, which I am pleased to say my old school Newcastle Royal Grammar School won a few years back.
Do you have to be really good at school Maths for high scores? Well it helps of course, but the questions do encourage intuition and feeling for Maths rather than (just ) rewarding technical revision.
Shown below are some typical geometry questions, then number questions, from each of the three age group competitions, showing yes the progression and but also continuity. You will see that knowing some Maths formulae and definitions is a minimum essential – but that alone does not guarantee success, as intuition and for instance ability to quickly sketch, plan solutions, create equations or compile tables is needed too.
Typical medium difficulty UKMT Geometry questions Typical medium difficulty UKMT Number questions
How do you enter? Well, the school usually helps with the administration. Remember the Junior, Intermediate and Senior competitions are typically in April, February and November respectively, with deadlines for entries a few weeks before each. A practice really is needed!
For tutors the benefit of helping pupils is that most tutors will have to stretch themselves to accurately and quickly answer the difficult questions; often there is more than one way to approach them and the challenge is to see the relative benefits of different methods; and learn to think in different ways about Maths problems beyond the confines of conventional exam requirements. My own approach to coaching UKMT is to start by going through topic by topic and set questions relevant to that subject from both UKMT and also GCSE past papers; and once any shortfalls are ironed out I begin to set full papers at first without time limits and finally within time constraints. Although model answers are available, they are sometimes a bit wordy, and I try to write out the solutions myself to force me to think through the problem and anticipate how a pupil may best understand an answer. I give tips on both managing the exam and also question-specific explanations and tips – for instance I point out that certain types of question such as circle/square combinations occur year after year.
In summary UKMT is a great initiative which encourages good Maths practices and techniques and I enjoy greatly helping pupils to become familiar with the challenging papers. More information is available through UKMT’s website
Appendix 1. List of Maths topics you need to know for Intermediate and Senior UKMT
The Extended Project (EPQ) which students can take in Years 12/13 is an opportunity to gain extra UCAS points, perhaps half a grade, and also to develop a whole new set of skills, both academic and future career related.
As a tutor I have been privileged to work recently on a fascinating EPQ and I hope played a good role in supervising and advising a student on a project related to the physics of rocket launch propulsion.
It is clear when you read the EPQ specification and marking system that approaching a half of the marks are awarded for the process of planning and executing the project, rather than purely marking the technical content. And so I bring some of my business and project management skills, as well as the academic aspect, into the mix for the student.
In choosing the title the student should do preliminary research on a topic that fascinates them and it is feasible to research and agree it with a nominated school supervisor. Begin to map out some objectives you wish to achieve and arrange them in the SMART form (specific, measurable, agreed, realistic, time-bound). The title may change a little as you go along don’t worry.
Set up a good document management system for articles you have found in the library or on the internet. Make sure you are always working on an up to date copy of your master not an out of date one. Keep notes of not just the technical content but also of the process steps you take such as how you take decisions about what to include or reject, how you avoid plagarism, how you are proceeding versus your objectives, and what you are learning; you have to complete Process Logs and these contribute to marks.
Use project management techniques such as Gant charts and stage gate control to ensure you plan out your work and use these to try and hit deadlines. Again useful to include in Process Logs.
Look at examples of projects to see how to establish a list of contents at the front, organise your paragraphs well and put a lot of work into the conclusion. A typical EPQ is 5,000 words and 25 pages. Keep structured references as you go along such as author name, article name, date. A good way of ensuring a validated paper is through Google Scholar.
You will find yourself on a technical project inevitably working way beyond A-Level syllabus. This is great!. It is introducing you to University level research and theory, and it will be a fantastic addition to your UCAS personal statement.
Do not worry if you realise that the more you uncover about your topic, the more questions emerge and you may feel your work is superficial – it is not! The writers of published Papers have years to do this, it is their job, and at the age of 17 you only have a few months on your project while focussing on A-Levels as a priority.
In summary you have to put in some extra work, but it may coincide with summer holidays anyway, and there are so many benefits ranging from UCAS points, through learning research and writing techniques in advance of a possible University dissertation, to expanding your academic and real-life knowledge.
November 14th. It is now time to end this particular blog or else it will go on forever!. Schools did indeed return in September and in my view teachers and their representatives, and pupils and parents have all done a great job in keeping the show on the road, at the time of writing, in difficult circumstances At this stage exams in England are going ahead, delayed a little to June or July, but it seems inevitable some changes such as reduced syllabus or exam questions options will be introduced. What is clear is that one aspect of education has changed forever, namely the use of on-line technology, which surely will be a permanent part of the mix even when things return to normal.
August 17th. At this stage its is likely that schools will return in September but still not certain, with Case numbers creeping up. But the real story is A- Level results and the move to stick with Teacher grades. Comparing these to previous year actual outcomes versus predictions indicates significant grade inflation will therefore take place. The infamous algorithm actually did its’ job in bringing the broad sweep of grades back to where they should be. However: two problems. First, when applying correction factors, the algorithm produced some ridiculous individual results such as fails when no exam was taken. And second, it seemed to favour smaller class sizes, which are more common in private than state schools.
July 7th Various announcements have been made that schools will indeed go back full time in September for all Years which is good news. The emphasis will be on hygiene, from washing hands to cleaning surfaces, and minimising contact through staggered timetables, one way systems etc. Rather than a strict 2m rule throughout school, though avoiding 1m still seems required. This will be difficult, but the alternative of further virtual schooling may be worse. I think it will happen, but with nuances like cutting back on aspects of the syllabus content, shorter exams and perhaps still some virtual learning (after all, some of it has been very fruitful)
One aspect of the lockdown not much talked about is the loss for Year 11 and 13 of the “going into school to get results” day, and the leaving events like Proms, and so many end-of-school holiday trips have been cancelled. It is so sad for that generation.
June 19 Primary Schools have been back since June 1, years 1 and 6 at least. Years 10 and 12 have just begun to return, a few 2-hour lessons per week on face to face, mostly focussing on core subjects. Its is a slow start but we’re getting there. Some schools are really pushing on-line work rigorously, others less so. One school I am in touch with are setting exams at end of June for Year 10’s, not far off mock GCSE standard that’s good. I can see that the on-line novelty will wear off and we need to find a way of getting children back to school, safely of course but with an attitude of “we’re gonna do this”. If not for this school year then certainly in September. I think year 10 parents are the most worried the GCSE’s will be affected and why demand for Year 10 tuition remains very high.
For year 11’s (the forgotten year) two things are happening. First, yes we know their predicted grades will be formulated into actual grades in August. Some surveys have suggested they will be half a grade higher than last year. Perhaps the final examiners will bring them back down a touch but it seems reasonable. The issue for me is that children need four go’s at really learning a topic but Year 11’s missed out on the final pre exam revision push.
So that means that the if they take a topic forward to A Level they will have missed out on that final embedding of knowledge which forms the beginning of AS Level. Which is why – the second happening – it is a great thing that schools are beginning to use the June/July hiatus for Year 11’s to begin year 12 AS Level, even if its is with videos and on-line learning. (And why I am running Maths for A Level science courses for Year 11’s! )
Today we had the publication of plans for NTP the National Tutoring Programme and it certainly seems to have had a lot of thought put into it. The website is up and running and the aims and resources are clear. I think we should wish them well in trying to do the catch up of lost time, and maybe even at the other end of the programme providing a permanent means for disadvantaged pupils to keep up.
My tuition for International students continues about the same level but there’s just a hint that some are hesitating as to whether the British international schools will be open in September. We shall see.
May 11 The beginning of the end. Or the end of the beginning. The Prime Minister announced that some restrictions will be eased and said he hoped first and last year of primary schools could open from June, with secondary perhaps seeing some face to face teaching July. But I think it will take a lot to persuade parents and teachers alike to believe it is safe. I believe it is 50:50 whether any schools reopen before September – or at least more than they are now because we shouldn’t forget technically they are open to a small number of vulnerable pupils and those of front line workers.
May 8. Still full. I lost my first Chinese pupil whose parents understandably were hesitant to continue lessons in the uncertainty about resumption. But the place was quickly filled by an extra UK lesson. Zoom works well on Waiting Room but slightly annoyingly when 1 person is Waiting and 2 are in the lesson that counts as 3, which means maximum 40 minutes so you sometimes have to restart. I have found a way of helping with student’s school web tasks but feeding the questions back into a mix of past paper questions to check they can do them without help. I’m also extending Maths for A-Level Biology to Maths for A-Level Chemistry.
Still no sign of at-school restart : safety has to be guaranteed, so if not straight after half term, that would mean end of June earliest – and what would be the point for a few weeks. Are we into Alice Cooper territory? Schools Out for Summer. Schools Out Forever? The lyrics are eerily appropriate.
April 24 The first full week after Easter and it looks like all the pupils in my schedule have returned for on-line lessons. I have adjusted Zoom to include a password and the excellent waiting room feature. For GCSE students the Maths for A Level Biology programme seems to be working well; while continuing GCSE work is useful just in case resits are needed and to keep a learning focus, I’ve offered a programme which looks forward rather than back.
Still no sign of the plans for restart: these could vary for a phased resumption before half term on geographic and yeargroup basis, to a more widespread resumption immediately after half term, to a wait till September. My instinct is for the middle option, but we shall see. Years 10 and 12 will probably be a priority.
April 3 The second week complete and all my pupils have now used Zoom with me successfully , albeit I’ll adjust some settings during Easter. Some schools now looking forward rather than back, beginning A-Level introduction early for GCSE students rather than continuing GCSE work for which there’s no exam and its now become clear today that current work will not count towards GCSE because “schools have also been told not to set extra work to inform the predictions, because young people may not be able to do themselves justice if they are incapacitated by illness or have a difficult home environment”. Likewise with some of my GCSE students I will begin “Maths for A-Level Biology” early.
March 28 The first week of shutdown has completed and Zoom is working pretty well for my remote tuition. There is a boom in Zoom round the world it seems. Schools have been using Microsoft Teams, Google Classroom, Show My Homework, Hegarty Maths, Kerboodle among others to set on-line homework tasks which vary from watching videos to answering questions and entering answers. It looks like Year 13 A-Level students’ tasks do indeed still count towards final grade; with Year 11 GCSE it is a little less clear how important their continued diligence is.
March 20: schools have shut down. Some clarity received from Government that cancelled exams will NOT mean that GCSE s and A Levels are not awarded: rather that the criteria for allocating grades will be determined by predicted grades, mocks, and coursework which teachers will collate and inform examining boards of their recommendation. These grades will be awarded earlier than usual in July and so appeals may be received and possibly an optional Autumn term exam will be arranged. What is not quite clear is whether tasks submitted on line over the next few weeks will count towards grades. Until informed otherwise we have to assume they will.
For year 10’s who are not yet taking exams the objective must be to take on- line tasks, teaching and tuition seriously and diligently to ensure the prolonged absence does not adversely affect their chances at GCSE next year
Today’s various announcements marked a Rubicon so from now I will be doing on-line tuition only till further notice, which some of my UK pupils have already started with me using Zoom. My Chinese students already do this and it works well.
March 19 : update: schools beginning to shut down and set up homework and revision material on the web systems. Some are timetabling the issue of new material to when their normal lesson times would be and some are planning to run live webinar lectures at lesson times. I am beginning to do on line tuition to UK students in the afternoon (already plenty of Chinese in the morning) and finding so far Zoom better than more well known Skype.
Still no word on decision of what might replace exams as a qualification.
March 18: update: announcement that all schools will close Friday and that exams will not take place in May/June. An announcement will be needed as to whether this means postponement till September, or waive through on Precited Grades. PM’s phrase “pupils will get qualifications” could indicate the latter. I am beginning to see how schools will keep their pupils busy: good on line portals like GCSE Pod or Show My Homework are places to set tasks.
A thought: one of the world’s most valuable Apps in moral terms is “Nextdoor” where you can find out what is happening locally, and who knows what its now worth in financial terms. Other Apps whose time has come include Zoom and Skype.
March 17 : update: Teddington has moved to closing most of the school but keeping Year 11/13 open. The reason is associated with shortage of staff, self isolating or on sickness.
Similarly Waldegrave is closing except for Year 7, 11 and 13 which remain open and Orleans Park is open for years 7,9,11,12 and 13 only.
This leaves keeps things moving for GCSE and A Level and leaves open the possibility of completing those exams but of course things are fast moving and may change.
Parents from year 10 are beginning to ask about possible extra tuition.
March 16
My personal opinion is that after this weekend the chances of UK schools having to close due to Coronavirus have moved from below 50% to over 50%. Whatever the science says, peer pressure may become irresistible. If closure happens, the length could be perhaps 4 weeks, 2 of which luckily are at Easter holiday; all the way up to 6 months including summer holidays.
With a short stop, perhaps pupils in Year 11/13 who would be most affected could receive remote schooling, reassemble for exams, and examiners might lower the grade boundaries. But for an extended outage, the question would then be, what about qualifications for 6th form and University, assuming that no exams would be possible in May unless on-line exams were mobilised quickly? I don’t believe that everyone repeating their year would be an option; firstly I do not believe pupils would want that, and second the capacity is not available unless you roll all the way back to nursery and delay the very first year of schooling.
Even a half way house of taking GCSE/A Level in September would be problematic as it would mean starting the next Year after Christmas, and requiring pupils to maintain “mental fitness” all over this summer. So an interesting alternative compromise is nearby Teddington’s plan to close the school except for Year 11/13, which at least keeps things moving.
If exams were to be cancelled altogether and yet pupils progress to the next level, that then implies that coursework and predicted grades at GCSE and A Level would come into play, as a means of determining 6th form and College admissions. But this is speculation. We shall see. Currently isolation for over 70’s seems to be the focus, but certainly schools are beginning to plan – for instance my school at Waldegrave is encouraging pupils to take more books and equipment home each day in case a sudden instruction comes.
As a tutor, whatever happens, I will offer options to parents of continuing as normal, or moving to on-line, or (and I hope not) stopping altogether. Note that better than Skype for on-line is a purpose built free programme called Zhumu, which I already use extensively with my morning Chinese students and remote Europeans and the tutoring works very well using this system. Needless to say we have already introduced handwashing.
Biology
The Biology of Coronavirus is interesting to say the least; at GCSE level we know that viruses, despite causing so much grief, are not actually living, as they do not have enough of the MRSGREN characteristics (more on that in future updates); they only live when a host is found, where they can rapidly replicate; and antibiotics do not work, instead a vaccine is needed to prevent infection rather than cure ; and at A Level you would know that the reason that soap and water is so effective is that the hydrophobic part of the soap can rupture the lipid membrane of the virus (see below)
On a lighter note
Regular readers will know that a pop song is never far away. Let’s hope the outcome is less of John Lennon’s “hold you in his armchair you can feel his disease” in Come Together, or Depeche Mode’s “you know how hard it is for me to shake the disease”; rather Paul McCartney’s “Its getting better all the time” (he always was more optimistic), a song which originated when Ringo fell ill in 1964, and was temporarily replaced with drummer Jimmy Nichol, who played five concerts before Ringo was well enough to return. During Nicol’s tenure John and Paul constantly asked him how he was coming along, to which he always replied, “It’s getting better,” In 1967 Paul made this into a song for Sergeant Pepper.
On July 20 1969 The Apollo 11 Lunar Module touched down on the surface of the moon and Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin began their walk. Many (including me) judge this to be mankind’s greatest single-event achievement so far. Outlined below are the many aspects of this story which provide learning opportunities and potential exam questions across the three GCSE Sciences, particularly Physics.
The take-off
Despite the enormous sound and visual fury of the launch, the fuel used by the Saturn rockets powering the mission was mainly not fossil fuel, rather it was a mixture of liquid oxygen and hydrogen. Normally gaseous, very low temperatures are required to liquefy them, -219 C and -253 C respectively. Being liquid rather than gas is safer, and occupies much less space because volume = mass / density and liquid density is higher. Saturn had sections which as fuel was used up were jettisoned to just leave the lunar and command modules. The enormous power was needed to enable the modules to reach the required speed to exit the earth’s atmosphere and escape the main gravitational pull.
Saturn V launches Apollo 11
The journey there
The distance from the earth to the moon is about 240,000 miles and the maximum speed was just over 24,000 miles per hour as it left earth’s orbit. So a “time = distance / speed “ calculation indicates a ten hour journey time and yet it took 3 days, so what happened to this slow-coach! Well, maximum speed does not mean average speed, and after the Saturn rockets were jettisoned, gravity slowed down the un-powered Module , as required, in order not to fly straight past the moon as it approached. Also, the journey included an orbit of the earth and several of the moon before descending to the moon so the distance was much higher.
The journey there..and back
Fuel Cells
If the rockets were jettisoned, how did the modules get to the moon without their powerful fuel? Well, once the modules were propelled out of earth’s orbit at high speed, less force was acting upon them since air resistance was zero. There was still a backwards gravitational pull of earth but it became smaller and smaller. So Newton’s Law would suggest they just carry on in the direction they were pointing, namely towards the moon, even without Saturn rockets’s major fuel source, albeit gradually decelerating from initial 24,000 mph. Small amounts of fuel were needed for lighting, communication and landing/leaving the moon, and these were a mixture of conventional fuels and fuel cells developed in Cambridge University, which were the early versions of the fuel cells we learn about in Physics GCSE. Namely hydrogen plus oxygen combining through electrodes to produce water,and release energy as electricity. The maximum power was around 2000 Watts and the water was not wasted – it was drunk by the astronauts!
A fuel cell was used on Apollo 11 mission
“In space, no one can hear you scream”
As the advert for the science fiction classic confirmed, sound cannot travel in space because the longitudinal sound waves, whose vibrations are parallel to the direction of travel, need particles such as air to vibrate – but there is no air in a vacuum. So how come we could hear the astronauts?
Sound waves don’t travel in space …but radio waves do
As David Bowie memorably told us in Space Oddity, a conversation was possible between Major Tom and Ground Control. Well, the answer is that communication was achieved by Radio waves, which are not sound waves but Electromagnetic waves which as transverse waves vibrate at right angles to the direction of travel. Just like other parts of the spectrum – like light waves from the sun – radio waves can travel through a vacuum at the speed of light namely 300 million meters per second. Since the 240,000 miles is around 360 million meters, then using time = distance / speed, the time for a radio signal to travel from the moon to the earth is only 1.2 seconds. Hence the only-slight delay between Houston asking a question and the astronauts answering.
Note however that Michael Collins, alone in the Command module while Armstrong and Aldrin walked on the moon, could not be contacted on the far side of the moon as radio contact was lost, as expected. Perhaps this was why Bowie’s Major Tom lost contact at the end of the record – “can you hear me Major Tom?”
Ground Control could hear Major Tom …at first
The physics of an orbit
When the lunar module had jettisoned its rockets it performed an orbit of the earth before heading to the moon. How does this work? If the module is set in forward motion at just the right speed then the force at right angles to its motion – namely gravity – pulls it towards earth and the net result is a bisecting direction along the path of the orbit.
The speed of the orbit remains constant at 25,000 miles an hour but the velocity is constantly changing. How can this be? Well, it’s because velocity is a vector and speed is a scalar quantity and as Vector tells Gru in Despicable Me, a vector has magnitude as well as direction. So the velocity is constantly changing because the direction in a circular path is constantly changing. When a force creates a circular motion, this is a centripetal force. (Gravity is a non-contact force while other centripetal forces are contact forces – the friction when a motor bike turns, and the tension in the spokes of the London Eye)
The diameter of the earth is about 8000 miles and the Module initially orbited the earth at around 100 miles up. So the diameter of the orbit around the centre of the earth was 8200 miles, giving a circumference of approximately 25,000 miles using Pi. At almost 25,000 miles per hour, the initial orbit took 1 hour.
The Moon Landing
When Armstrong and Aldrin’s lunar module separated from Collins’s Command Module above the moon, it reduced its speed but slightly overshot the landing site in the Sea of Tranquility in order to avoid landing in a crater. Armstrong took over control from the Module computer to achieve this ( a computer with less processing power than an I Phone incidentally). Less than 30 seconds of fuel remained, so this was where both of the astronauts’ flying experience, including dog fights with Russian MIG’s in the Korean War, proved invaluable. They stayed impossibly cool, while Houston’s control centre personnel famously were so tense they almost “turned blue”.
Armstrong’s heart beat stayed normal at 70 beats per minute, almost until the “Eagle has landed” but even he succumbed at touchdown to the fight or flight adrenaline hormone at touch down, when his heartbeat reached 150.
After Armstrong stepped down off the ladder – “one small step for man, one giant leap for mankind” – Aldrin soon followed him and began, as the Police would later sing, while Walking on the Moon, to take “giant steps” with his “feet hardly touching the ground”. Why is this? Well ,gravity there is only a sixth of the earth’s gravity ( g is 1.6 rather than 10). So it was easy to hop around. And why is the gravitational force lower? Because the force is proportional to the mass of the two objects, and the moon is lighter than the earth, even if the man has the same mass. So a person of 50 kg faces a gravitational downward force of 500 N on earth but only 80 N on the moon.
The Police …drums on the side of a Saturn
They collected rocks and when later analysed they were found
to contain the chemical lelements silicon, iron, aluminum, calcium, magnesium, titanium and oxygen. No
carbon or nitrogen, so not enough ingredients for biological life. Years
later however , hydrogen and iced water were found at the moon’s poles and this
opens the possibility, with the presence of hydrogen and oxygen, of creating
fuel cells using electrolysis which could mean that the Moon could be used as
refuelling stop on the way to Mars.
The journey back
After taking off from the moon, the lunar module docked with the orbiting Command Module and together they returned to earth. Long before the mission, Aldrin had written a thesis on docking in space based on his experience as a scientist and Air Force pilot in Korea. As the Module approached the earth atmosphere the frictional force – this time a contact force – caused the heat shield to reach high temperatures and gradually melt – as planned.
Splashdown
A parachute slowed the Module down further, with air resistance offsetting the weight of the Module, which floated down at a leisurely terminal velocity to the sea.
The crew were kept in quarantine for several days in case they had caught viruses on the moon. A virus – unlike bacteria – is counted as non-living but nevertheless can contain DNA. It is worth recalling that DNA was discovered by Watson and Crick at Cambridge University only 16 years before the Apollo 11 mission.
Further Physics
work
All of the above science should be readily understandable by anyone taking Physics or Maths GCSE – if not it’s a definite revision topic! For those carrying on with Physics, the A Level and Physics Aptitude Test for Oxford will contain more advanced Space concepts like eclipses, Kepler’s Laws for orbits and what many consider to be one of the all-time great equations; namely Newton’s formula for the Force exerted by gravity on two objects, of mass m1 and m2: F = Gm1m2/r^2 where r is the distance between the masses and G is the universal gravitational constant.
Scientists are still not sure what Gravity truly is, yet in the 1700’s Newton could already quantify it, and in a sense invented the science behind Apollo.
Did you know 2019 is the Year of the Periodic Table and its 150th birthday? Me neither! It has to be one of the least publicised “Year Of’s” and yet one of the most important. Dmitri Mendeleev’s creation attracts me in two respects, first for the science and second for the use of the highly visual illustration to simply explain it. The Table has evolved in to the colourful all-in-one-page presentation of data with shapes or pictures that I like – think Infographic, think London Tube map.
The Periodic Table is wonderful in that it answers so many questions about physical science, and if all that you know about Chemistry is the Periodic Table and the answers to the questions below, then you are well on the way to a GCSE Chemistry pass. As an adult you are welcome to this understanding but please feel free to skip to the “fascinating facts” towards the end and find Mendeleev’s position in the history and philosophy of science.
What is an element?
An element is a substance that contains only one type of atom, such as hydrogen; in contrast to a compound which contains more than one type of atom, such as H2O. A molecule contains more than one atom – of the same type such as O2, or different types such as H2O).
Some elements have an obvious single letter and some don’t; why is that?
Hydrogen and oxygen simply are called H and O whereas Magnesium is Mg and Potassium even more strangely is K (from the Latin Kalium). So there are many reasons, for instance Beryllium, Boron and Bromine couldn’t all be B.
What’s the difference between a Group and a Period?
The Groups are the downward columns and the Periods run across. Groups generally have elements of similar properties like Group 1 metals and Group 7 Halogen gases. But the properties from left to right of a Period are completely different e.g. from metallic to gaseous. The common factors in Periods is the electronic shell, so the second Period 2 is the second electronic shell.
What’s the difference between the top number and the bottom number of an element?
The top number is the atomic mass (A.M.) while the lower one is atomic number (A.N.). The atomic mass is the number of protons and neutrons while the atomic number is just the number of protons (and also electrons). So sodium has 11 protons and 11 electrons (A.N. 11) and adding in the 12 neutrons makes A.M. 23. The modern Periodic Table is in the order of atomic number; Mendeleev ordered elements by atomic weight (became mass) which in the end is very similar.
What is the order of elements?
As you go across the table left to right, the atomic number increases by 1 each element, going from Hydrogen (A.N. 1) to element 118, Oganesson (Og), formerly Ununoctium (UUO, A.N. 118). Atomic mass also increases, albeit sometimes by more than 1. Along with many elements towards the end of the table, UUO is unstable and in fact only 3 atoms of it have been produced since 2002. When Mendeleev first published his Table in 1869, he left some gaps, but made predictions of properties which in due course did fit new elements such as Group 3 Gallium.
Can we use the Periodic table to identify metals and non-metals?
Broadly the metals are on the left and in the centre while the non-metals are on the right.
The transition metals in the middle don’t seem to follow the group number pattern. Why?
At GCSE level we just mainly consider the first four periods and so for example period 2 group 1 e.g. Lithium and group 2 e.g, Beryllium then skip over the transition metals to group 3 e.g Boron and on through groups 4,5,6,7 to the final column for Nobel gases.
Why is the final group called group 8 sometimes, but also group 0 ?
This gets to the heart of the electronic structure of periodic table. The common factor of the final columns is that all the elements have stable outer electronic shell configurations which at GCSE level generally means 8 electrons in the outer shell, and so zero in electrons in the next shell.
So what other parts of the periodic table relate to electronic structure?
Sodium’s electronic shell structure
The group number determines the number of electrons in the outer shell (and vice versa). So group 1 metals have 1 electron in the outer electronic shell, and for instance sodium is A.N. 11; so its 11 electrons have configuration 2,8,1 Then group 2 elements have 2 electrons in the outer shell, and so on through group 4 with 4, and group 7 halogens with 7 in the outer shell.
Does group number determine the type of reactions elements have?
Absolutely! Group 1 elements are keen to release their single outer shell electron to go back to a stable outer shell of 8 and so react strongly to, for instance, water and acids to form ionic compounds in which the metal ion has a charge of 1+. Meanwhile group 7 halogens are adept at gaining the one electron for a stable outer shell. So Na+ and Cl- from an ionic bonded compound whereas chlorine bonds covalently with hydrogen or itself by sharing rather than exchanging an electron. Group 0 (or 8) Noble gases like argon are inert (they barely react) because they are already content with their full outer shell.
Can we predict which elements will form multiple bonds from the position in the Periodic Table?
Yes, oxygen in group 6 has 6 outer shell electrons and so needs 2 more and forms a double bond with itself or two bonds with hydrogen (which needs 1 electron) to form H2O (water). So the very familiar formula of water owes its existence to the position of hydrogen and oxygen in the Periodic Table. Nitrogen in Group 5 needs 3 more electrons so shares them with three hydrogen atoms to from the very familiar ammonia NH3. At the other end of the 2nd period, Beryllium in Group 2 cannot be bothered to gain 6 to make 8, rather it loses 2 to from the Be2+ ion, That is why group 2 metals like magnesium form 2+ ions.
Group 1 metals get more reactive as you go down the group whereas Group 7 halogens get less reactive. How does the periodic table explain this?
As you go down a group the atom gets bigger so the outer electron shell is further away from the positive nucleus. For metals such as potassium this means it is easier to prize away an electron from the claws of the nucleus than it is with the smaller lithium. On the other hand the larger iodine is less willing to accept an additional electron than chlorine, because for iodine the positive nucleus is further way from the incoming electron.
Some elements like chlorine have a decimal place in the atomic mass whereas as carbon does not. Why?
Isotopes is the answer. Chlorine has a 35 A.M. isotope and an 37 A.M. isotope in the ratio 75% : 25% and so the weighted average is 37.5. Carbon has several isotopes such as the carbon dating isotope C14 but they are in tiny proportions so the base isotope of C12 is used in the Table.
Why is Period 1 only 2 elements?
Hydrogen and Helium have respectively 1 and 2 electrons, after which the first shell is full and we move to the second shell which has the more familiar 8. Hydrogen and Helium are the main constituents of the Sun and indeed the Universe, which begs the question, are there any elements in space not in the Periodic Table? You will find the answer in the final section, Strange Facts (about the Periodic Table)
So which Periods and Groups are important for GCSE?
For the first three periods i.e from elements H to Ar you should know each element in detail and arguably be able to recite and know their properties, reactions and electronic structure. Equally Groups 1 (alkali metals), 7 (Halogens) and 8 (0) Nobel Gases (and to a lesser extent Group 2 Metals) are important to understand in detail, and for these Groups extend your knowledge to Period 4 as well, for instance down to potassium and bromine.
For transition metals in the middle you don’t have to know their groups, periods or electronic configurations, but should be aware of their names and properties. For example copper, which conducts electricity and has highly coloured compounds like its sulphate, and which features in core experiments. You do not need to know the details of radioactive elements but should understand the principles of radioactive decay.
Strange facts concerning the Periodic Table
Mendeleev’s elements – the Donald Rumsfeld of his day?
The Table has the look of a Patience card game. This is not a coincidence because Mendelev was a card player and initially sorted the elements by atomic mass, wrote them on cards, and placed them in columns of similar properties and increasing weight.
Eek! He initially missed out around a third of the elements because they had not been discovered but he was able to predict some of the missing element properties. When Mendeleev proposed his periodic table, he noted gaps in the table and predicted that then-unknown elements existed with properties appropriate to fill those gaps. He called them eka-boron, eka-aluminium, eka-silicon, and eka-manganese. Eka aluminium for instance correctly foretold the discovery later of Group 3 Gallium, with the atomic mass of 69 and density 6 times that of water – very close to what he had predicted. Eka-silicon correctly became Germanium (atomic mass 72).
On the other hand he made no space for Group 8 Nobel gases – in a sense an omission but, being inert, they hadn’t fully been discovered yet because often elements were discovered by their reactions. Another reason for omissions may have been that he was running out of time to publish, especially since other versions and lists were beginning to be circulated.
Iodine (127) has a lower atomic mass than tellurium (128). So iodine should be placed before tellurium in Mendeleev’s tables. However, since iodine has similar chemical properties to the halogens chlorine and bromine, Mendeleev swapped the positions of iodine and tellurium and made Iodine follow Tellurium, to be positioned in the right place below its halogen friends.. And in fact that’s how they appear in the modern table because of their atomic numbers (Te 52, followed by I53). Mendeleev didn’t yet know about the significance of proton-based atomic number but in a sense he was predicting it. This is one of the very few examples where the order of atomic mass is not the same as atomic number.
The 92nd element is uranium but it can transform itself into other elements like lead through radioactive decay. Elements above A.N. 92 do not actually exist – not naturally anyway – they have to be artificially created and they also radioactively decay. .
Some scientists believe that although we have reached 118 now, we could go as high as 137 – but no higher because energy levels would not permit it.
The original classical elements as proposed by among others Aristotle were earth, fire, air and water, with aether the heavenly element soon added. The alchemists began to identify more conventional elements like sulphur and mercury, so that by Mendelev’s time the modern, full set was in reach.
So one might imagine Mendeleev as Donald Rumsfeld, who famously was mocked yet admired for his “known unknowns” description of military strategy. Mendeleev’s “known unknowns” were elements like gallium, germanium and scandium whose properties and existence he predicted before discovery. His “unknown knowns” were the iodine-tellurium pair which he placed in the wrong order because he was unaware of isotopes; and his “unknown unknowns” were arguably Group 0 inert gases because, being inert, they formed no compounds; and the high atomic number elements including lanthanides, actinides and radioactive elements.
Although in GCSE exams you are given the Periodic table, so it doesn’t need to be memorised, but just in case, you may wish to consult Google and the 120,000 ways of memorising it. Including songs like this one.
Each element has a story
There are only 2 liquid elements at room temperature – bromine, and mercury the “liquid metal”. Most of the rest are solid except for around 10 gases.
The lower elements are often named after famous people (yes, there is an Einsteinium, and a Curium) and also planets (Uranium, Plutonium, Neptunium). Note that Mercury the element and planet are both named after the god.
The country Argentina is named after the element Silver(Ag). Meanwhile Gold (after the Latin word Aurum) is so precious because it does not tarnish, being so unreactive, and it is a metal, again related to its position in the Periodic Table.
Carbon is the building block of life and forms many millions of organic compounds. Because of its position in Group 4 it requires 4 electrons for stability so typically forms 4 single bonds, or 2 singles and a double, with itself or other elements like Hydrogen in Methane (CH4, Natural Gas). Yet it is also the single element in strong and precious diamond. It also forms graphite which has several layers of hexagonally arranged carbon – the graphite pencil works by a layer peeling away on to the page. Graphene is a new material – it is only one layer of graphite – so only one atom thick – yet is between 10 and 200 times as strong as steel (depending on the steel type)
A good reference for the details, pictures and uses of every element can be found in this link
Electronic structure and Heisenberg’s role in the War (possibly)
As you go across a Period, more protons and electrons are added, but the atomic radius, strangely, gets smaller. This is because the additional electrostatic attraction of more protons outweighs that of negative electrons. But when you jump to a new Period and new electronic shell comes into play. Hence as you go down Group 1 alkali metals the elements get bigger and more reactive since the outer shell electrons gets further way from the nucleus.
Mendeleev had no knowledge in 1869 of the astonishing advances in the early 1900’s of the knowledge of atomic structure, but he was on the right track with his view that the properties of elements depended on their atomic weight and hence position in the periodic table. One of these pioneers was Neils Bohr – who developed the theory of electron shells and the quantum theory in the early 1900’s and which matches the Periodic table so well – was from a footballing family – a good player himself, his brother was a Danish international. Neils, of Jewish descent, also stood out against the Nazis, whereas Heisenberg (of Uncertainty fame) was more accommodating and the two had a mysterious and fractious meeting in 1941 concerning the development of the German atomic programme. Heisenberg showed a drawing, but there was disagreement over whether it was for a bomb or reactor. There is even uncertainty (of course!) about whether Heisenberg advanced Germany’s nuclear programme after the iconic meeting, or held it in check.
The book “Periodic Table” by author Primo Levi is a collection of short stories which links his love of science with his experiences in fascist Italy and in Auschwitz.
Space exploration, the Big Bang and the rest is history
We have not so far found elements in space that are not listed not in the Periodic Table. In fact all elements are thought to have been produced from Hydrogen and Helium after the Big Bang through various processes of fusion, fission, collisions, disintegrations involving for instance supernovas and neutron stars. Many of the processes involving the protons, neutrons, and electrons of He and H began in the enormous temperatures in the first fraction of a second of the Universe, following which traces of Lithium and Beryllium, the next elements by A.N., emerged. Carbon soon followed (OK after a few million years!) and the rest is history (literally!)
Although the earth is principally solid, less than 1% of matter in the Solar System is solid. Exceptions include iron which is thought to be at the centre of all planets in our solar system.
And finally…the man himself
…more about Dmitri Ivanovich Mendeleev himself. A Russian scientist, from Siberia, one of 17 siblings. The world may have been a different place if his second fiancé had not agreed to marry him (he threatened suicide otherwise). She did marry him, a month before his divorce from his first wife (interesting timeline!). A Chemistry teacher who had just written the definitive textbook of the era, he claims to have envisaged the Periodic Table in a dream and upon awakening reproduced it.
He incorporated the periodicity of the properties of elements, and although he focused on atomic weight not number, his work seemed to hint at the future through his use of “valence” which would later evolve to reflect atomic number and electron shells. The repeating patterns had been observed a few years before by scientists like Newlands and Meyer, but as is often the case timing is everything. So it was Mendeleev that is principally remembered; not just due to luck but also because his Paper, presented to the Russian Society of Chemists, included a coherent “pull it all together” theory which included predictions of new elements.
Mendelev was all set to receive the coveted Nobel prize in 1906 but at the very last the committee changed its mind -ostensibly because of the 37 year gap, but probably because of a trivial tiff (to which scientists are not immune!) The influential scientist Ahrrenius objected to a previous criticism of one of his theories!
One of Mendeleev’s originals (notice the gaps at 68 and 72)
Mendeleev studied at St Petersberg, and helped to create the first Russian oil refinery. One of his first tables is shown above from 1871,
Also below – what is now recognised as the oldest classroom chart version, dated 1885, found in St Andrews University; and in true Antiques Roadshow style, it was found in a dusty clear-out.
Credit : ST Andrews Periodic Table
There is a crater on the moon named after him, and, as you would expect, one of the elements, mendelevium, A.N. 101.
When Mendeleev died in 1907 his Periodic Table was well on the way to international acceptance but his last words were to his Physician. “Doctor, you have science, I have faith”.
This morning on Radio 4 I heard the story of author Ian McEwan helping his son to write an English essay on one of his own books, only for a low grade to be awarded. The reason – the essay did not answer the question in the way the examiners wanted. As exam season approaches this a crucial topic – I firmly believe that knowing how to interpret questions and structure answers can add many percentage points to a score. Here are some things to look out for:
Command words. Especially on longer mark questions, certain words or phrases in the question require certain responses. For example, in Business Studies and many Humanities subjects the words “evaluate” or “assess” trigger the need to present balanced arguments with evidence and coherent analysis, followed by a conclusion with a definitive yes/no answer with justification. So, if “evaluate Brexit” (perish the thought!) came up, you would need two Leave points, two Remain points followed by your own preference with the most important point, and reason why, for instance, the economy was more important that immigration control (or vice versa). Some students miss out the conclusion, and miss almost half the available marks.
In Science, command words include “design”, or “describe an experiment”. Normally this involves a practical experiment, perhaps a core practical, and students should describe not just apparatus and substances, but also the control variables (what you keep the same), the independent variable (what you deliberately change) and dependent variable (what you measure); safety precautions; how you would present results; and how you would ensure reliability, precision and accuracy. A glossary of terms makes dull reading but is vital to understand. Practical write-ups in exercise books are well worth revisiting.
In Maths, the phrase “show that” may involve a proof or rearranging a formula to make it “look like” the required expression, while “must show your working” or “give reasons” means just that – for instance in a geometry question, you could get the right numerical answer but omit English reasons like “alternate angles rule” and fail to get full marks.
Attitude: it is tempting to answer the question you want to answer, rather than the one you have really been asked. So pupils must read questions very carefully, and as well as Command phrases pick up key words and clues in the stem of the question like “more than” or “only” or “double” – examiners have included them for a reason, not for show.
Examiners do now have the annoying habit of asking “real world” wordy questions rather than simple numerical ones. They assume pupils would prefer to answer a question like “Johnny runs part of the London marathon at 5 miles per hour, setting off from Westminster with both hands on Big Ben vertical, and traveling for 15 miles. At what time does he arrive”. Rather than simply “Speed = 5 mph. Distance = 15 miles. Set-off = 12 o’clock. When does he arrive?” Well, I know which option real-world pupils would prefer, but we just have to get used to the fact that Maths questions are increasingly “applied” rather than “pure”, obtuse not transparent, and so practice makes perfect when it comes to approaching long winded questions.
In general, the examiners and their questions are the only ones you have got, so you simply must play their game and recognise what they are after. If they insist on asking Biology questions about drunken rats (they did!) you should just go with the flow and not flounce out. What is more useful, taking to Twitter afterwards and complaining about a stupid question, or showing resilience and attempting a tough problem?
Assessment Objectives. The curious underworld (which for a time I inhabited) of examiners and their mark schemes is dominated by these “assessment objectives”. So, in Business Studies you gain marks for knowledge, analysis, application and evaluation. In Biology you can accrue marks as you mention one by one in the long questions the relevant systems and organs, processes, and substances and compounds. In Maths “method marks” may be awarded, but only under quite strict guidelines, for instance if you have correctly written a defined key step in your working. One way to find out about these is to read the publicly available mark schemes and examiners comments on the past paper web sites. In Maths, for instance reviews published by exam boards include lots of pearls of wisdom and often start with, “many pupils were let down by inability to perform basic maths” (In non-jargon, they couldn’t add up).
Examiners have hundreds of papers to mark in a short space of time, so the key is to make it easy for them to award good marks – by mentioning key words or phrases or numbers in the answer which matches their mark scheme, and by displaying well-ordered neat working. A relatively short sharp answer can out-mark a much longer one if you hit the examiners trigger points.
Know the specification. These have got more complicated, partly because of changes like “9-1”. So, for Science GCSE, there is Higher and Foundation in each of Double and Triple. It sounds obvious but revise what you have to revise, and especially if you are going to drop a topic, ignore what’s not required.
Second guessing the content. It’s a mug’s game to spend time predicting the questions, but a sure-fire topic in all three Sciences is environment and associated climate change, global warming and renewable energy. Also, after let’s say two of three Maths exams, if you have had a Box Plot and Cumulative Frequency but no Histogram, well you can guess what’s coming next. Mr Barton’s Maths website issues an annual prediction, as does Tutor2U for Business.
Structure as well as knowledge. In summary, of course revision of pure facts is important, but it only gets you so far; practicing real questions and comparing your answers to examiner’s mark schemes can get you much further. If you can’t beat examiners, then join them, play their game and give them the answers in the form they require.
Footnote: an old school-friend who read this article reminded me that our Geology teacher Dusty Rhodes (so named because he threw the blackboard duster at us for minor indiscretions – times change!) used to write “ATQ” all over our scripts before awarding marks of zero or 1/4. ATQ of course means “answer the question” – so some things don’t change. For a pupil who has revised well, not ATQ is one of the biggest remaining risks.
There is much media talk and public interest about environmental issues like climate change, renewables, air quality, plastics and pollution. There are school children marches and protests for Climate Emergency round the world. Penalties for diesel cars to discourage nitrogen dioxide and particulate emissions are being introduced, and, astonishingly, the Tesla electric car company’s market value at £40 billion has now overtaken Ford’s despite only achieving a fraction of Ford’s sales. The UK Government is phasing out petrol engine cars by 2040 in favour of electric and voted for Zero net emissions by 2050. What can we say about the inclusion of these topics in Science GCSE? Well, firstly, there are lots of examples, and “environment” is one of the few certain, banker questions in the whole of the GCSE syllabus. The first new 9-1 GCSE science papers confirmed a very large number of “environment” questions for a relatively small part of the syllabus – hence very high value revision! Secondly, examiners are looking for proof that students understand some of the technical language involved. Let’s take a look in more detail.
Questions about the environment in general have become so popular in Chemistry, Biology and Physics papers, in both combined and triple science alike, that I sometimes think you just have to mention “carbon dioxide” and you are half way to a pass ! Even if you are a climate change skeptic, suspend that view until after the GCSE’s! Certainly the payback on a relatively small amount of revision on a not-too-difficult subject is high since one or more questions will almost certainly feature – which cannot be said about all science topics. After a previous year’s “drunken rat” controversy, students tweeted that they had learned their CGP Biology guide religiously, yet so little of the syllabus cropped up.
A common fault amongst pupils is to confuse climate change and pollution, so that’s a good place to start. Students should understand the following three key points:
1. All three of the sciences begin this topic with fossil fuels, which are mainly oil, coal and gas and derivatives like petrol and diesel.
2. There are two separate consequences of fuel combustion. On the one hand, the generation of the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide as a natural but increasing product of combustion. Then on the other hand emissions of bi products such as sulphur dioxide and soot which cause pollution and smog.
3. And to counter these problems is the emergence of renewable energy sources such as solar power which reduce dependence on fossil fuel.
Candidates should ensure they understand both the advantages of fossil fuels and derivatives (fairly cheap, easily available, engines designed for them) and disadvantages (may run out, greenhouse gas generation, pollution, scars on the landscape). Similar pro and con assessments should be learned for individual, different renewables. The basic mechanics of global warming should be understood. Rays from the sun entering the earth’s atmosphere bounce off the surface , and we need this to happen to a certain extent to provide warmth yet prevent overheating; but increased CO2 concentrations in the earth’s atmosphere don’t allow enough long wavelength infrared radiation to escape, leading to a small but significant warming of the earth. (This is the way greenhouse glass works). Pupils should also know that un-combusted methane itself is a greenhouse gas and that increased world-agriculture contributes to the climate problem (and yet provides food of course)
Some effects of global warming should be learned such as polar ice-caps melting; sea levels rising and coral reefs deteriorating as ocean temperatures rise; and species migration patterns changing.
Students should be able to interpret graphs such as global temperatures rising on the y-axis – but note the typically narrowed scale – with time on the x-axis, especially since the industrial revolution. These show global average temperatures rising around 1 degree C to 14.5 degrees, which alongside CO2 atmospheric concentrations rising from 0.028% to 0.040 % seem to provide a link.
Now let us summarise what revision is needed in each of the three sciences in addition to the above, and the type of question likely to be asked. (More detail is available in my coaching card lesson plans). Each science begins with the basic assertions above, particularly the part played by carbon dioxide in global warming, then develops different angles.
Chemistry
Pupils should understand how fractional distillation of crude oil works, including generating products such as petrol and diesel fuels as described in this BBC video about Grangemouth refinery where I visited many times in my work.
Students should learn the basic word equations associated with combustion of fuels which are generally alkane hydrocarbons .
Hydrocarbon + oxygen –> carbon dioxide + water + energy released
and one example, for natural gas combustion.
CH4 + 2O2 → CO2 + 2H2O
And also the word equation for acid rain, which damages buildings and statues, especially limestone :
Sulphur Dioxide + Water -> Sulphuric Acid
Students should also know the formulae of Nitrogen Dioxides (NO and NO2) and also understand how incomplete combustion produces sooty carbon particles (turning bunsen burners yellow) and in extreme circumstances the poisonous carbon monoxide (CO). Methods of reducing emissions are important such as scrubbers at power stations and catalytic converters on cars.
(In a sense I am pleased to see nitrogen and sulphur oxides (called colloquially “NOX and SOX”) being given priority once more. As a performance analyst in BP in the 1990’s I collated the emissions data from BP Chemicals’ factories including NOX and SOX. When CO2 was suddenly elevated to a much higher importance, I always worried that focus on these polluters might be lost).
Although not in the syllabus as such, an interesting view of air quality real time results around the world, as judged by amounts of pollutants including NOX and SOX measured by detectors placed e.g. on buildings, is this web link
The alternative fuels of particular interest in Chemistry are ethanol, bio-fuels like bio-diesel, and hydrogen along of course with their pros and cons. A further branch to revise is the benefits of electric cars and the two main means of powering them namely re-chargable batteries and hydrogen fuels cells. At typical question would provide data for energy use, cost, mileage and ask you to “evaluate” the alternatives which means recommend the best with justification.
The cracking of alkanes to alkenes and subsequent polymerisation also features in this context both for the fossil fuel origin and the non biodegradable nature of plastics.
Another branch of pollution features in metals extraction and mining, with heavy metal dis-colouration of rivers a possible disadvantage as seen in this article about the Colorado river.
Exam Questions have ranged from simple (what type of reaction is burning fuel in oxygen?); to numeric (compare the parts per million figures for particulates, carbon dioxide, nitrogen dioxide for several types of fuel); to everyday experience (why do supermarkets charge for plastic bags?); to involved (describe how a fractional distillation column works).
Physics
For Physics pupils need to know more detail about individual energy sources both conventional and renewable. The energy transfer steps for several of these should be understood. So for power stations running on fossil fuels, the transfer is from chemical (in the fuel), to thermal (burning it), to kinetic (turbines and generators); to electrical (the grid).
Nuclear power involves a plentiful supply of uranium and plutonium but they are finite resources so counted as non-renewable. And of course though they have the advantage of being green in a sense – no carbon dioxide emissions – the disadvantages include waste disposal and impact of major break downs (albeit rare) like Chernobyl.
The major renewable sources to learn are: solar panels (see this video of solar powered city) and solar cells; wind turbines and wind farms; geothermal hot rocks; hydroelectric power; and tidal barriers. For each of these students should learn the energy transfer process, and advantages and disadvantages, perhaps two of each. For instance, for wind energy the transfer is from from kinetic wind energy to kinetic blade energy to electrical. The advantages include it’s renewable, and has zero carbon dioxide emissions and pollution; but it is not always available (when calm), the turbines can scar the landscape, and though costs are reducing they are expensive to build and maintain.
Typical questions have included: is global warming of 5 degrees C over the next 100 years a fact, a guess or a prediction?; why are copper pipes under a solar panel painted black?; calculate the cost of waste energy from a food processor and how it is manifested; why do chemical salts used to store solar energy need a high specific heat capacity?; explain the difference in actual versus maximum electrical output percentages for a variety of energy sources; give 2 advantages and disadvantages of running gas fired versus nuclear power stations; why are transformers used between power stations and the national grid?; and what is the payback time on a project costing £1000 yielding savings of £500 per year (answer : a 2 year payback).
It follows that students should know and be able to apply formulae around energy efficiency, power and energy transfer.
Finally, although electric cars are not specifically on-syllabus, that won’t stop AQA or Edxcel throwing in a wildcard question like “compare the advantages and disadvantages of electric cars versus conventional petrol or diesel engine cars”. Answers should include reference to easy availability of petrol (difficult for electric chargers); petrol is from fossil fuel and so contributes to global warning (electric cars do not – though the charger itself has to be charged); petrol and especially diesel cause particulate, sulphur and nitrogen dioxide pollution whereas electric cars do not; and conventional cars currently have a higher mileage range than electric.(Note that a £300m electric taxi factory is opening in Coventry – truth is stranger than fiction as 3 years ago an A Level Business Studies question case study was built around just such a possibility, Even Business Studies is not immune from our topic ! )
Biology
Photosynthesis and the carbon cycle are highly relevant in this context. This is a must for Biology exams, not just for the environment question. The word equation for photosynthesis must be learned:
(The reverse equation for respiration of course also is important)
The carbon cycle includes the absorption of carbon dioxide through photosynthesis in leaves, and the production of carbon dioxide through respiration and also decay of dead animals, which eat vegetation. This has been in balance until recently when from the industrial revolution onwards fossil fuel combustion is producing more carbon dioxide – only by a fraction but enough to mean an increase in the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, which in turn links through to the so-called greenhouse effect and global warming.
In Biology, further emphases include the generation of another greenhouse gas methane through more intensive farming, and the reduction in CO2 adsorption through Amazon rain forest depletion, in tandem with the production of CO2 from burning those forests.
Fossil fuel pollution includes damage to leaves from acid rain because their waxy layer for mineral absorption is damaged, while health is affected by carbon monoxide because in red blood cells it binds more strongly to haemoglobin than oxygen.
Further related topics include pollution caused by sewage and excess fertilisers, which can lead to eutrophication of lakes and oxygen depletion.
Typical questions include; describe the main points of the carbon cycle and the role of photosynthesis; what can we do to slow global warming?; interpret a bar chart of billions of tonnes of carbon dioxide produced at each stage of the carbon cycle.
Summary
Environment as a subject is as near to a banker question as you can get, and one of the few where parents can easily help children, especially as GCSE age is just young enough for pupils to still accept parental advice! Further, you will hear almost daily on the news stories about this topic, whose science may well feature in GCSE and so a round table discussion could follow at dinner. The key points are to start with are fossil fuels, but distinguish between carbon dioxide emissions – said to cause global warming; and sulphur and nitrogen oxides, bi product polluters causing building damage and health issues. Then candidates should be able to explain the science and list some solutions for these problems. The examiners want balanced arguments, so be prepared to list both the pros and cons for conventional and renewable energy sources.
I have just completed some Maths tutoring for two excellent students hoping to join a grammar or independent school in South West London. Their approach was exemplary, their Maths was already well in advance of Year 6, and they wanted to get even better, being prepared to work very hard in lessons and at home. One full practice paper was not enough for homework, they coped with two a week. Their parents hoped for a free or reduced fees place, but if not I have no doubt they would try to find a way to sacrifice to pay fees.
With the recent news about possible expansion of grammar schools, it made me think about what would happen if my two students did, or didn’t, make the grammar schools, and also how the various entry exams compared to each other, and to traditional year 6 SATs standards. In other words, what should pupils expect in their exam? Let’s start with this.
The entrance exam
My focus was upon my local South West London schools, 10 fee paying private independent schools and 8 free, state, selective grammar schools. I drew broad conclusions about the latest exam processes, likely to be reasonably applicable outside London too. The first thing to say is that in these 18 Schools, it is very difficult to find free sample papers or even sample questions on their websites. This is to avoid advantaged children “buying” their entrance through expensive “teaching to the test” tuition. However, for some of the Surrey schools typical common entrance papers can be purchased, some schools just outside this area do publish sample papers, and of course national publishers like CGP and Bond make practice papers available.
So you can piece together what the typical test will look like. Maths rather than English is my speciality so here are some of features of the typical Maths entrance paper.
The number of questions will be between 25 and 50, students have 45 minutes to 75 minutes to complete, so at 1.5 to 2 minutes each these are short sharp questions. But the complexity varies significantly from beginning to end, so you should expect to spend 30 seconds on the easy ones and perhaps 3 minutes on the difficult ones. The ability to work fast is almost as important as the ability to answer the question. The paper typically divides, in order of questions, into what I’ll call the four quartiles of difficulty. Remember that the higher the reputation of the school, the higher the demand for places, the higher proportion of questions in quartiles 3 and 4, as follows:
1st quartile – simple KS2 topics Number : Addition, subtraction, multiplication, division (always without calculator)
Fractions, percent and decimals, number lines 2nd quartile – tricky KS2 topics Number and measurement: clock times, square and prime numbers, ratios, units of measure Algebra: graph coordinates, sequences, simple algebra expressions, Geometry:, Angles along straight lines, at a point and in triangles, areas and perimeters of regular shapes, recognise 2D and 3D shapes, simple translation and reflections. Data : Mean (average),Tables, Pictograms, Bar Charts, Pie Charts, Line graphs Problems: Inverse Logic problems such as “what number did I start with” 3rd quartile – still KS2 but highly developed problems
Number: Factor pairs, place list of fractions and decimals in ascending order Algebra: Solving linear equations, Create equations from areas and perimeters, including odd shapes; substitution of numbers in equations Geometry: Combination of angles rules in one problem, Nets, angles round a clock-face circle Rotations, Symmetry, Mirror (e.g. what would “WINTER SALE” be on a window’s other side Problems: Speed x times = distance problems, Number reasoning, Railway timetables, Time-zones
4th quartile – Beyond KS2 to KS3 and KS4 GCSE, and Puzzles Number : Exchange rate conversions, Fibonacci sequence, Prime factor trees, Ratio problems such as cake recipe; HCF and LCM; powers. Algebra: simultaneous equations created from e.g. prices of burgers and soft drinks, Multiply double brackets using grid or FOIL Geometry Parallel line angles, enlargements and scale factors, 3-D cuboids Data: Venn diagrams, Probability, Mode, Range and Median Problems: Sudoku-like magic number puzzles, Shapes representing operations, number machines Shortest route problems such as through the streets of New York; full page multi-paragraph problems featuring combination of numeric and verbal reason logic culminating in for example, which of five children got a present, which of five animal lives on which island?
This last, 4th quartile frequently goes well beyond KS2 in two respects. Firstly, what I’ll call “puzzles” – which ironically will never resurface in secondary exams. Secondly, school syllabus content stretching well into KS3 Year 8 and 9 even in rare cases up to KS4 GCSE level (yes!). This last quartile contains the differentiator questions, the ones you have to be able to do to be really confident of gaining entry. When tutoring an 11 plus pupil followed by a GCSE pupil I sometimes find myself using the same sample questions.
Most of the school websites say, to be politically correct, that the questions should be suitable for any KS2 student (only one admitted that some questions may stretch to KS3). Parents should not be fooled. With demand outstripping supply by 4 or more to 1, the higher reputation schools do throw in the puzzles and year 7-11 level questions to identify the brightest pupils.
How many exams?
The table below shows, for the 8 grammar schools sampled in SW London, most have 2 stages, although the Sutton set start with the common SET test. The 10 independents all have just one stage except St Pauls, which starts with the common ISBE test, and most have an interview to confirm selection. Most schools feature Maths, English and either a separate verbal reasoning test or similar questions within English. What is noticeable is that Non Verbal Reasoning is becoming quite rare now (thank goodness – awfully difficult to teach!)
School
(State selective)
Maths
English
Non Verbal
Reasoning
Comments
Sample Maths available
Tiffin Boys
Y
Y
N
2 stages, and stage 1 counts 10% each Maths and English, Stage 2 counts 40% each Maths and English for entry.
No
Tiffin Girls
Y
Y
N
2 stages, and stage 1 is Maths and English OMR multi choice, passing gets you to Stage 2 Maths and English which alone determines entry
No
Below are the Sutton Grammars taking common SET
Nonsuch High for
Girls
Y
Y
N
2 stage, 1st English and Maths common SET multi choice, then joint second stage Maths and English with Wallington High School for Girls
No but SET samples can be ordered
Wallington
High for Girls
Y
Y
N
2 stage, 1st English and Maths common SET multi choice then joint second stage Maths and English with NonSuch High School for Girls
As above
Greenshaw High
Y
Y
N
1 stage only Maths and English common SET multi choice. Pass for eligibility for 60 places.
As above
Sutton Boys
Y
Y
N
2 stages, first is common SET English and Maths multi choice , to get you to second stage Sutton specific English and Maths. 1st and 2nd stage tests all affect final entry, ratio is 2:2:3:3
As above
Wallington County
Y
Y
N
1 stage only, Maths and English common SET, pass to be eligible for place
As above
Wilson’s Sutton
Y
Y
N
2 Stage , first is common SET Maths and English, second Maths and English. Count in ratio 2:4:4.
As above
School
(private)
Maths
English
Non Verbal
Reasoning
Comments
Sample Maths available
Hampton
Y
Y
N
1 stage, 3 exams : English, Words and Reasoning, Maths and an interview
A few questions
Halliford
Y
Y
Y
1 stage Maths, English, Verbal and Non Verbal reasoning
No
Lady Eleanor Holllis
Y
Y
Y
1 stage tests in Maths, English, VR, Non VR followed by Interview
No
St Catherine’s
Y
Y
N
1 Stage tests in Maths and English then interview
No
Radnor
House
Y
Y
N
1 Stage tests in Maths and English then interview. Note : it confirms some KS3 material will be tested.
Yes full paper
Surbiton
High
Y
Y
N
1 stage tests in Maths and English Plus write a personal statement
No
Kingston Grammar
Y
Y
N
1 stage English Maths and verbal reasoning followed by an interview
Yes most of a sample paper
Reeds
Y
Y
N
1 stage tests Maths English and Verbal Reasoning
No
Claremont
Fan
Y
Y
N
1 stage test Maths English and Verbal Reasoning
Yes a full paper
St Pauls
Y
Y
Y
1st stage ISBE / GL Multiple Choice in English, Maths, Verbal and non Verbal reasoning. 2nd stage is English and Maths and interview
No but ISBE sample papers can be ordered
Grammars – the pros and cons.
Through the lens of my two students, if they started Year 7 even in the best of the local state schools, they would be so far ahead that they would, to be honest, be bored and held back. Like many bright children they need the challenge. The supply of free grammar schools is limited. At many of our local grammars the ratio of applicants to places is 4 to 1 and at some even higher, where queues around the block form at the start of exam day. (Some now phase exams through the day to avoid this). In business, if supply is limited and demand is high, you increase prices or create more capacity – in this case by creating more grammar schools, because prices are fixed at zero.
However the downside is of course that if the brightest pupils are creamed off from state schools, the overall standard must surely fall. This is detrimental to the remaining pupils, who lose the chance to learn from the approach and abilities of high achieving pupils, and dispiriting for teachers who enjoy challenging them and getting a positive can-do response. Some teachers would surely jump ship. Some Headteachers have said this would recreate “secondary moderns”.
One compromise – which one of our local state schools already employs – is to offer a limited number of exam-selective places, while mainly offering free places for local pupils. The question then is, do you sprinkle the selected pupils among the classes, or “set” from the start. The problem with the first approach is that schools are constrained by the national curriculum which prescribes certain content for certain years, so the brighter pupils would be constrained by the pace of the slowest. The alternative is to “Set” from year 7 and effectively teach the top set Year 8 or 9 level content from age 11, and take all GCSE’s (not just Maths) a year early. This “grammar stream” approach is advocated by former UCAS Chief Executive Mary Curnock Cook Or go further (as my old school used to do) and identify the brightest year 7 pupils and to remove them at year end from Year 8 and place them straight into Year 9 (we were called “removes”).
Is tutoring needed? As noted above, the questions definitely stretch beyond standard KS2 (whatever schools say). The question is, how do you get access to, and practice these. In theory, purchase of Bond or CGP practice books can do the trick, but the risk is that the pupil will miss the personal explanation and without homework being set, may not practice enough, and even these excellent publications don’t include the outrageously tricky questions which do crop up. Note also that while common entrance papers like SET the Selective Eligibility Test can be purchased, frequently these are only for Stage 1 permission to sit the really challenging Stage 2 papers which are not formally available. So structured learning, and exam tips are needed over and above school provision. Parents might provide this but many would struggle with the vital end of paper questions. Extra tutoring is your insurance policy (but not a guarantee) and this can come in several forms, including private one to one, or exam centre cramming.
What is tutoring providing?
What you are trying to do is this: First make sure the basics of KS2 are in place. Second, introduce the pupil to a selection of KS3 topics which may crop up. Third, help the pupil work at speed. Fourth, teach exam techniques. Finally set a sufficient quantity and quality of challenging tasks from which gradual improvement instils confidence – the “more I practice the luckier I get”. What is difficult to teach is the natural mathematical abilities such as puzzle solving and spatial awareness, and my guess is that is why such puzzles are included – there may be disadvantaged pupils who cannot afford tutoring yet have that innate mathematical ability which money can’t buy.
In conclusion
The 11 plus is highly challenging. A good KS2 performance – an 11 plus “pass” – will probably not be enough to get through. There are many pupils and parents willing to take up that challenge, to achieve that extra level of excellence. Schools, the State and Tutors all have a part to play in meeting that demand.